< Back to California Unemployment

Luca Romano

EDD Money Network card charging 20% "tip hold" - can't even buy food now

Just discovered something really frustrating with these new Money Network EDD cards. I tried to buy lunch at a fast food place yesterday (only had about $65 left on my card) and my transaction was DECLINED! When I called customer service, they told me they automatically hold 20% extra for "potential tips" even at FAST FOOD places where I wasn't even leaving a tip! So basically, if you have $65 and buy $55 worth of food, they'll actually try to hold $66 (food + 20%) and decline your purchase! They claim this money gets "returned in a few days" but meanwhile I COULDN'T EAT. This feels like a total scam to me - they're earning interest on all these holds while unemployed people go hungry. Bank of America never did this with the old EDD cards. Anyone else having issues with these ridiculous Money Network fees and holds? Between this and the ATM withdrawal fees, it feels like they're making money off our hardship.

Nia Jackson

•

You're absolutely right to be upset about this. The Money Network cards implement what's called an "authorization hold" which is common with debit/credit cards, but the 20% for restaurants is excessive. Here's what's happening: when you swipe at any restaurant (even fast food), the payment processor automatically adds 20% to account for potential tips. Since fast food rarely has tips, this is particularly frustrating. To avoid this: 1. Always keep at least 25% extra funds on your card when dining out 2. Use self-checkout at grocery stores instead of restaurants when funds are low 3. Transfer larger amounts to a personal bank account (this is fee-free) You can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) about these practices. The hold should drop off after 24-72 hours, but that doesn't help when you need to eat now.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

Thanks for explaining that. I had no idea this was even a thing! So frustrating that they don't tell us about these holds up front. Do you know if I transfer money to my bank account, is there a delay before I can use it? I'm down to my last $20 now and worried about getting through the weekend.

0 coins

OMG SAME THING!!!! I was at Chipotle and had $43 and tried to buy a $35 bowl and got declined!!!! The cashier looked at me like I was trying to scam them and I was soooo embarrassed I wanted to DIE. Like we're already struggling with unemployment and now we gotta deal with this??? smh

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

That's exactly what happened to me! So humiliating standing there with people behind you in line. Did you ever get an explanation from Money Network about it?

0 coins

CosmicCruiser

•

they do this at ALL restaurants not just fast food. its a preauthorization hold for tips. bank of america cards did this too but maybe not as much. the money comes back but u need to wait 3-4 days usually. i think its normal but SUPER annoying when ur on UI and every dollar counts. i just transfer all my $ to my credit union account as soon as i get paid now avoid the whole mess

0 coins

BOA never did this to me!!! Not once in 2 years of having unemployment during the pandemic. This is new and it suuuuuucks

0 coins

Aisha Khan

•

This is actually a standard practice with nearly all debit and credit cards at restaurants - it's not unique to Money Network. The difference is that Bank of America's system would often approve the transaction anyway if you were just slightly over your available balance, while Money Network strictly enforces the authorization hold. The best solution is to transfer your EDD funds to your personal bank account as soon as they arrive. You can do this for free through the Money Network app or website. For those who don't have a bank account, consider opening one - many credit unions offer free checking accounts with no minimum balance requirements. Until then, carry a small cash reserve for food purchases when your balance is low. And yes, these holds typically clear in 1-3 business days, but that doesn't help when you need to eat today.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

I didn't realize BOA was more flexible - that explains why I never had this problem before! I'll definitely start transferring to my bank account right away. Thanks for the advice.

0 coins

Ethan Taylor

•

has anyone else noticed they also charge ATM fees now?? i swear they're just trying to squeeze every penny out of people who are already struggling. its criminal if you ask me...

0 coins

Yuki Ito

•

Yes! $3.00 per withdrawal at non-MoneyPass ATMs, plus whatever the ATM owner charges. Ridiculous. You get two free ATM withdrawals per month at MoneyPass ATMs but good luck finding one nearby when you need cash. I've been trying to reach EDD for days to complain about these Money Network cards but can't get through to anyone. Has anyone had success getting through to a live person at EDD lately?

0 coins

Yuki Ito

•

I've been having nightmares with these Money Network cards too. Been trying to reach EDD for days to complain but can't get through their phone system. Always "too many callers, try again later" then disconnects. Has anyone found a reliable way to actually speak to an EDD representative about these card issues? I found a service called Claimyr that helps you get through to EDD agents - used it last week and finally spoke to someone after weeks of trying. They connect you to the actual EDD line (not a third party) and notify you when it's your turn. Saved me hours of redial frustration. Their video demo shows how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. Their site is claimyr.com if anyone needs to actually talk to EDD about these card issues.

0 coins

does that actually work? im desperate to talk to someone about my card issues but i keep getting hung up on by the stupid robot voice!

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

This entire Money Network card situation is one more example of the state cutting corners at claimants' expense. They switched from BofA to save money, but passed all the costs to us. Consider this: the state SAVES money while unemployed people pay fees to access their own benefits. It's disgusting. I've contacted my state representative about these predatory practices. The more people who complain, the more likely something will change. These authorization holds aren't illegal, but they're certainly predatory when applied to unemployment benefits cards where people are already financially vulnerable.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

You're right - it's a terrible system. I'm going to contact my representative too. Do you have a specific email or office you contacted? I'd like to make sure my complaint gets to the right place.

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

Pro tip for everyone: Transfer your full benefit payment to your personal bank account IMMEDIATELY when it hits your Money Network card. You can set up automatic transfers in the Money Network app. No fees for transfers, and then you avoid all these restaurant holds and ATM fees. Been doing this since they switched from BofA and haven't had a single issue since. Another workaround for restaurant purchases: if you know you're running low on funds, ask the cashier to process it as a final sale with no tip option. Many places can do this if you explain the situation. Doesn't always work, but worth trying.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

Thank you! Just set up automatic transfers in the app. Appreciate the restaurant tip too - I'll definitely try asking for a final sale with no tip option next time.

0 coins

Paolo Longo

•

This is absolutely infuriating! As someone who just started dealing with these Money Network cards after being on the old BofA system, I had no idea about these authorization holds. It's unconscionable that they're essentially holding our own money hostage when we're already struggling financially. I've been reading through everyone's suggestions and it sounds like the immediate transfer to a personal bank account is the way to go. But what about people who don't have bank accounts? Are there any other options for them, or are they just stuck dealing with these predatory practices? Also, has anyone tried disputing these holds directly with Money Network? I'm wondering if there's any way to get them to adjust their policy for unemployment benefit cards specifically, since this isn't regular spending money - it's government assistance that people depend on for basic necessities.

0 coins

Great questions! For people without bank accounts, I'd recommend looking into prepaid cards from credit unions or even opening a basic checking account - many have no minimum balance requirements. Some credit unions specifically serve low-income members and offer free accounts. As for disputing with Money Network directly, I haven't had luck there. They claim it's "industry standard" but that doesn't help when you can't buy groceries. The authorization holds are technically legal, but applying them to government benefit cards feels predatory. I think the real solution has to come from EDD changing their contract requirements with Money Network, which is why contacting state reps is so important. We need to make enough noise that they realize this is hurting the people these benefits are supposed to help.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today