


Ask the community...
Based on the information you've provided, it sounds like you're facing a non-fraud overpayment situation. Here's the likely process you'll go through: 1. You'll receive a Notice of Potential Overpayment explaining the discrepancy 2. You'll be scheduled for a phone interview (this is why getting through to EDD is critical) 3. After the interview, you'll receive a Notice of Overpayment with the exact amount and any assessed penalties 4. You'll have options to: - Pay in full - Request a payment plan - File an appeal if you disagree - Request a waiver (difficult to get approved) For gig workers, I recommend keeping a detailed log of all work performed going forward - date of work, company, amount earned, and date paid. This helps tremendously with accurate reporting.
Thank you for breaking down the process. I'm going to take your advice about keeping better records going forward. I've already started organizing everything from those 6 months to show exactly what happened. Really appreciate everyone's help here - it's made a stressful situation a bit more manageable.
I went through something very similar with DoorDash, Instacart, and TaskRabbit income. The thing that saved me was creating a detailed timeline showing when I actually worked vs when payments were processed. Some of those apps have weird payment schedules - like DoorDash would sometimes hold payments for "quality review" or whatever. Here's what helped me during my audit: - Downloaded ALL transaction histories from each app (not just the 1099s) - Showed screenshots of the apps' payment policies explaining delays - Created a week-by-week breakdown showing the reporting confusion The EDD rep actually acknowledged that their system doesn't account for how gig payments work. I still had to pay back some money and got 4 penalty weeks, but they reduced the penalty amount by 50% because I could prove it was an honest mistake due to the complexity. Don't panic - just be super organized with your documentation. The fact that you were reporting SOME income shows you weren't trying to hide everything.
To all those having trouble reaching a human at California Unemployment. I just ran across this video that gave me a shortcut to reach a human. Hope it helps! https://youtu.be/Ize0EkN4HDI
When writing your appeal, be clear and specific about why the notice is inaccurate. Include: 1. State clearly that you disagree with the determination 2. Explain the specific facts that make the notice incorrect (dates, amounts, circumstances) 3. Attach any supporting documentation (pay stubs, work records, correspondence) 4. Request a if you want to present your case in person 5. Submit within the deadline (usually 30 days from the notice date) Keep it factual and professional. Focus on the facts that prove the determination is wrong rather than emotional appeals. The key is providing evidence that contradicts their findings. Good luck with your appeal!
This is excellent advice! I'm dealing with a similar issue and was overwhelmed about how to start my appeal. The point about being factual rather than emotional really resonates - I was getting so frustrated that I almost wrote an angry letter. Instead, I'll focus on organizing my documentation and clearly stating the facts that contradict their determination. Thank you for breaking down the key elements so clearly. Did you go through this process yourself, and if so, how long did it typically take to get a response after submitting the appeal?
I work at a community center and we get people in this situation all the time. Here are a few more resources that might help: most Starbucks and McDonald's locations have free WiFi if you need to use the UI Online messaging system from your phone. Also, many churches and community centers will let you use their phones for important calls like this - just explain your situation. If you're in a big city, some unemployment offices have walk-in hours where you can speak to someone in person about rescheduling. Don't give up - there are always options even when it feels hopeless!
Thank you so much for these additional resources! I hadn't thought about using WiFi at places like Starbucks to access the UI Online system. That's really helpful to know that community centers and churches might let us use their phones too. It's reassuring to hear from someone who works directly with people in similar situations - makes me feel less alone in this mess. Do you know if there's usually a time limit when using phones at community centers for these kinds of calls?
I went through this exact same situation last year! Here's what worked for me: I called EDD from a payphone at a gas station (yes, they still exist!) and explained the situation. The agent was actually really understanding and let me use my sister's phone number for the interview. They called her phone at the scheduled time and she just handed it to me. The whole interview took about 15 minutes. Also, if you have a smartphone but just can't afford the monthly service, you can still use apps like Google Voice or Skype with WiFi to make calls. Many libraries, coffee shops, and even some fast food places have free WiFi. Don't panic - EDD deals with people in financial hardship all the time, they're usually willing to work with you if you communicate proactively!
Have you checked if your browser is up to date? Sometimes outdated browsers don't work properly with government sites. Also make sure you're not using any auto-fill features as those can cause conflicts with the EDD site's security features. I've been on unemployment twice in the past three years and both times had technical issues that were resolved by updating my browser and disabling browser extensions. Also worth noting - if you can't get it working online, you can request a paper application by mail, though obviously that will take longer to process.
UPDATE: You all are amazing! I tried a combination of suggestions - disabled my VPN, cleared all cookies, turned off browser extensions, and waited until 1am to try again. It finally worked! Got all the way through the application process and received my confirmation number. Now fingers crossed the claim gets processed quickly. Thanks to everyone for the help!
So glad you got it working! This is such a helpful thread - I'm bookmarking it for future reference. The VPN tip especially is gold, I never would have thought of that. Hopefully your claim processes smoothly from here!
Congratulations on getting through! This whole thread is a goldmine of troubleshooting tips. I'm dealing with similar issues right now and hadn't thought about the VPN being a problem. Going to try your combination approach tonight. Quick question - how long did it take from when you submitted to getting the confirmation number? Just want to know what to expect when I finally get through!
Serene Snow
I'm so sorry this happened to you! That clerk's behavior was completely unprofessional and inexcusable. I went through a similar situation last year where I had technical difficulties during my hearing, and here's what worked for me: First, call the Appeals Board office first thing tomorrow morning at 8am sharp - they're usually less busy then. Ask to speak with a supervisor and explain exactly what happened. Be calm but firm about how the clerk's conduct prevented you from participating in your scheduled hearing. Second, write down everything you remember about the conversation - exact times, what was said, how long you waited, etc. This documentation will be crucial. Third, if you don't get satisfaction from the supervisor, you can file a formal complaint about the clerk's conduct through the EDD website. Poor customer service like this needs to be reported. The good news is that situations like this are considered "good cause" for missing a hearing, especially when it's due to staff misconduct. Don't panic - this is fixable, but you need to act quickly. Keep us updated on how it goes!
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
•Thank you so much for the encouragement and detailed advice! It really helps to hear from someone who went through something similar and came out okay. I'm feeling a bit more hopeful now after reading everyone's responses. I'll definitely call at 8am sharp tomorrow and ask for a supervisor right away. I've already started writing down everything I remember from the conversation - even though it was frustrating, I tried to pay attention to what was happening. Your point about this being "good cause" is really reassuring. I was worried they'd just automatically rule against me, but it sounds like there are protections in place for situations like this. I'll keep everyone posted on what happens tomorrow!
0 coins
Brandon Parker
I work as a paralegal at a firm that handles unemployment appeals, and this situation is unfortunately more common than it should be. Here's what you need to do immediately: 1. **Call the specific Appeals office listed on your Notice of Hearing** - not the general EDD number. Do this at exactly 8:00 AM when they open. 2. **Request an immediate reschedule due to clerk misconduct** - use those exact words. This creates a paper trail and puts them on notice that their staff acted inappropriately. 3. **File a written complaint** through the EDD website about the clerk's behavior. Include your case number, hearing date/time, and a detailed timeline of events. 4. **Check your UI Online account daily** - if a decision is issued saying you "failed to appear," you'll need to file an appeal within 20 days citing the clerk's conduct as good cause. The key legal point here is that you were present and ready to participate - the clerk's behavior prevented your participation, which is grounds for rescheduling under CUIAB regulations. Document everything and don't let them brush this off. You have rights as an appellant, and they violated them. Keep pushing - appeals can absolutely be won, even after setbacks like this. I've seen similar situations resolved in favor of the claimant when properly documented and escalated.
0 coins