


Ask the community...
I went through the EDD appeals process in December and won my case! I was in almost the exact same situation - employer claimed I quit when they actually cut my hours from 35 to 8 per week. Here's what really helped me prepare: **Documentation is everything:** I gathered pay stubs showing the hour reduction, screenshots of my work schedule changes, and text messages where I asked my supervisor about getting more hours. The judge specifically asked about my attempts to address the situation with my employer first. **Practice your timeline:** I wrote out a simple chronology - when I was hired, what my original hours were, when they got cut, what I did to try to fix it, and when I finally had to leave. Having this clear narrative really helped during the hearing. **The hearing itself:** It was less intimidating than I expected. The judge asked me to explain what happened, then asked my employer questions. When they claimed the hour reduction was "temporary," the judge asked them to specify how long and what the plan was to restore hours. They couldn't give a clear answer, which really helped my case. Your situation with 40 hours dropping to 12 is even more dramatic than mine was. That's a 70% reduction in income - no reasonable person could be expected to survive on that. Make sure to emphasize the financial impact and that you tried to work with them before leaving. The whole process took about a month from hearing to decision, but getting that approval letter made all the stress worth it. You've got a strong case - stay organized and confident!
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! It's really reassuring to hear from someone who had such a similar situation and won their appeal. The 70% income reduction you mentioned really puts it in perspective - I keep second-guessing myself wondering if I should have just tried to make it work somehow, but you're absolutely right that no reasonable person could survive on that. I'm definitely going to practice my timeline like you suggested. Having that clear narrative seems super important, especially when I'm nervous and might forget key details. Did you find the judge was understanding about the financial impact, or did they focus more on the technical aspects of whether you "quit" vs were "forced out"? Also, when your employer claimed the reduction was "temporary" but couldn't give specifics, did that pretty much seal the deal for your case? I'm wondering if my employer will try the same defense. Your success story is giving me so much hope - thank you for taking the time to share all these details!
The judge was definitely understanding about the financial impact - she asked specific questions about my monthly expenses and how the reduced hours affected my ability to pay rent and bills. But she also focused heavily on the legal standard for constructive discharge, asking whether I had tried to work with my employer before leaving and if the conditions would force a reasonable person to quit. When my employer couldn't give specifics about when the "temporary" reduction would end, that was definitely a turning point. The judge asked them three times for a timeline or restoration plan, and they kept giving vague answers like "when business picks up." The judge seemed frustrated with their lack of concrete information, and I could tell it was hurting their credibility. Your employer might try the same defense, so be ready to counter it. If they say it was temporary, you can point out that without a clear timeline or plan to restore hours, "temporary" could mean indefinitely. A 70% pay cut with no end date isn't something anyone should have to accept while hoping it gets better eventually. You're going to do great - just stay calm and stick to the facts about how their actions made continuing employment unreasonable. The financial documentation you have sounds really solid!
I went through a very similar appeal process in late 2024 and won! My employer also tried to claim I quit voluntarily when they actually made my position untenable by cutting my hours from 32 to 10 per week. Here's what really helped me succeed: **Strong documentation:** Like others mentioned, I had pay stubs clearly showing the dramatic hour reduction, plus email exchanges where I asked HR about the situation and expressed that the reduced hours weren't sustainable. **Clear financial impact:** I calculated exactly what the income loss meant - in my case it was about 69% reduction in weekly pay. I presented this to the judge as "no reasonable person could accept a 69% pay cut indefinitely without a clear restoration plan." **Stayed professional:** Even when my employer's rep made false claims about my "performance issues," I stuck to facts and didn't get defensive. The judge seemed to appreciate my measured responses. **Prepared for common defenses:** My employer tried claiming the cuts were "due to slow business" but when the judge asked why other employees weren't similarly affected and what their plan was to restore hours, they had no good answers. The hearing took about 35 minutes and I got my decision letter two weeks later. Your case with 40 hours down to 12 hours is even stronger than mine was - that's a textbook constructive discharge situation. The fact that you have documentation showing you asked for more hours and explained the financial hardship is huge. Don't let them intimidate you with that $4,800 repayment demand - you don't owe anything until the appeals process is complete, and if you win (which sounds likely), that goes away entirely. You've got this!
I'm in almost the exact same boat! Got married 6 weeks ago, updated with SSA right away, and submitted my name change request to EDD about 12 days ago. Still showing "pending review" and I have certification coming up this Friday. Based on all the responses here, sounds like I need to stick with my maiden name for certification until I get that official confirmation email. It's really frustrating that it takes so long when other agencies can process name changes much faster, but at least now I know what to expect timeline-wise. Has anyone noticed if submitting on certain days of the week makes a difference in processing time? I submitted mine on a Wednesday afternoon and wondering if that affects anything. Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences - this thread has been incredibly helpful! I was starting to worry something was wrong with my submission.
Hey Carmen! I don't think the day of the week you submit makes any difference - it seems like EDD just has a consistent backlog that takes 2-3 weeks to work through regardless of when you submit. I submitted mine on a Monday and others here have mentioned various days, but everyone's getting similar timeframes. Definitely certify with your maiden name on Friday - that seems to be the unanimous advice from everyone who's been through this! The waiting is nerve-wracking but sounds like it's totally normal. At least we know we're not alone in dealing with this slow process!
I went through this exact same process last year! It took about 19 business days for my name change to be approved after I submitted my marriage certificate. The "pending review" status is completely normal and unfortunately doesn't give you any updates until it's fully processed. Definitely keep certifying with your maiden name until you get the official confirmation email - I cannot stress this enough! I saw someone else mention they tried using their new name too early and it caused major delays. One tip that helped me: I set a calendar reminder for 3 weeks out from my submission date to call that identity verification number (866-401-2849) if I hadn't heard anything by then. Thankfully I got my confirmation email at day 19, so I didn't need to call. Also, once you do get approved, make sure to update your direct deposit info if your bank account is under your new name. The systems don't always sync that automatically. Good luck and congrats on the marriage!
Thanks Javier! This is really reassuring - 19 days is right in that 2-3 week range everyone's been mentioning. I like your idea about setting a calendar reminder for the 3-week mark to call if needed. I'm definitely going to stick with my maiden name for certifications based on everyone's advice here. I already updated my bank account when I changed my name with SSA, so hopefully that part will be smooth once EDD approves the change. Really appreciate you sharing your timeline and the specific phone number!
Hey Javier! I went through a similar situation about 6 months ago when I was laid off from my tech job. You'll definitely get multiple pieces of mail from EDD - the approval letter, your customer account number, and the paper certification forms (DE 2063). Mine took about 7-8 days to arrive. For certification without internet, I'd strongly recommend the phone option (telecert) over mail. I used it for almost 2 months when I moved and didn't have reliable internet set up yet. The automated system at 1-866-333-4606 is actually pretty intuitive - it asks the same basic questions as online like whether you worked, looked for work, were available for work, etc. You just press numbers to respond. The key thing is you MUST have your EDD Customer Account Number to use telecert - write it down as soon as you get that letter! Also, make sure to certify during your designated 2-week period regardless of which method you use. Phone certification processes payments just as fast as online (usually 1-2 business days), while mail can take a week or more. One tip: if you're worried about deadlines, you can call the general EDD number to confirm your certification dates once you're in the system. Better to be safe than sorry!
Thanks Ian! This is exactly the kind of detailed info I was hoping for. It's really helpful to know the timeline for receiving all the different documents - 7-8 days sounds reasonable. I'm definitely leaning toward the phone certification option now based on everyone's feedback. Question though - when you call that general EDD number to confirm certification dates, is that the same 1-866-333-4606 number or a different one? I want to make sure I have the right contact info ready. Also, did you ever run into any issues with the automated system not recognizing your responses or anything like that?
I'm in a very similar situation right now! Filed my claim about 2 weeks ago and still waiting for my phone interview. This thread is super helpful - I had no idea there were so many different documents they send out. Quick question for everyone: if I end up getting my interview next week, should I expect the same timeline (5-8 days) for receiving the approval letter and other paperwork? Also, has anyone tried using the EDD mobile app or does that have the same internet connectivity issues as the regular website? My phone data is more reliable than my home wifi right now, so wondering if that might be a backup option for certification if needed.
I'm new here but this thread has been absolutely incredible to find! I've been struggling with this exact ID.me issue for the past two weeks - my account is showing some mysterious @outlook.com email that I've never seen before, and I can't get past the identity verification to file my unemployment claim. Reading through everyone's experiences has given me so much hope and practical advice. I had no idea there was actually a working phone number for ID.me! I've been going in circles with their chat bot and online support forms getting nowhere. I'm definitely going to try the 8 AM calling strategy that so many people have had success with. Already setting my alarm and gathering all my documents (driver's license, SSN card, recent bank statement, birth certificate). I'm also writing down those key phrases like "search for duplicate accounts under this SSN" and "identity resolution team" that multiple people mentioned. What's really eye-opening is learning how these mystery accounts can come from tax preparation services, previous employers, or other government agencies creating ID.me accounts without us knowing. I used TurboTax a few years ago and now I'm wondering if that's where this phantom account came from! Thank you everyone for sharing such detailed experiences and advice. This community support is honestly keeping me sane through this frustrating process. Really hoping to join the success stories soon! 🤞 @Zainab Ibrahim please keep us posted on how your nephew's call goes tomorrow - we're all rooting for you both!
@Jean Claude Welcome to this amazing support thread! I m'also pretty new here but have been following all the incredible advice everyone s'been sharing. It s'so frustrating that we re'all dealing with this same ID.me nightmare, but at least we ve'found each other to figure out solutions together! Your TurboTax theory could totally be right - @QuantumQuasar mentioned that their mystery account came from FreeTaxUSA creating an ID.me account back in 2022 without them knowing. It seems like these tax services are quietly integrating with ID.me and creating accounts using our info without making it clear to users. I m'also planning to call at 8 AM sharp tomorrow based on all the success stories here. The consistency of that timing advice across so many different people really seems to be the magic formula. I love that you re'preparing everything tonight - seems like having all documents ready is what separates the quick fixes from the endless runarounds. This thread has honestly become like a lifeline for all of us stuck in this bureaucratic mess. Fingers crossed we all get good news from our calls tomorrow! Let s'definitely keep each other updated on how it goes. @Zainab Ibrahim we re all'eagerly waiting to hear how your nephew s call'goes - sending good vibes for a quick resolution! 🙏
I'm new to this community but found this thread while desperately searching for help with my own ID.me nightmare! My unemployment claim has been stuck for 8 days because ID.me is showing some random @yahoo.com email I've never created or used. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been such a relief - I genuinely thought I was the only one dealing with this! The consistent advice about calling 866-775-4363 at exactly 8:00 AM EST seems to be the golden solution that actually works. I'm particularly grateful for the detailed breakdowns from @QuantumQuasar, @Oliver Weber, and others about what to expect during the call. The fact that these mystery accounts can come from tax preparation services, previous employers, or other government agencies without our knowledge is both infuriating and enlightening. Now I'm wondering if my phantom account traces back to when I used H&R Block a couple years ago. Already have my alarm set for tomorrow morning and all my documents organized (driver's license, SSN card, utility bill, birth certificate). I'm also noting down those key phrases about "duplicate accounts under SSN" and "identity resolution team" that multiple people have mentioned as helpful. This thread has transformed what felt like an impossible bureaucratic nightmare into something that actually seems solvable with the right approach. Thank you everyone for sharing such detailed experiences and creating this supportive community! @Zainab Ibrahim really hoping your nephew's call goes smoothly tomorrow - please keep us posted! We're all in this together! 💪
Chloe Harris
I ran into this exact same issue a few months ago! What finally worked for me was creating a completely new account using a different email address, then calling SDI to have them merge my old claims history with the new account. It took about 2 weeks to get sorted out, but the rep was able to transfer everything over. Make sure you have your old claim numbers handy when you call - that speeds up the process significantly. Good luck, and don't give up! The system is frustrating but it can be fixed.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
•This is really helpful! I'm dealing with a similar situation right now. When you called SDI to merge the accounts, did you have to provide any specific documentation or was having the old claim numbers enough? Also, did you run into any issues with the new account not recognizing your employment history initially?
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
•@Chloe Harris This sounds like exactly what I need to do! Just to clarify - when you created the new account with a different email, were you able to use the same SSN and driver s'license info? I m'worried the system might still flag it as a duplicate even with a new email address. Also, do you remember roughly how long the phone call took to get the accounts merged? I want to set aside enough time when I finally get through to someone. Thanks so much for sharing your experience!
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
I had this exact same problem when trying to file for bonding leave earlier this year! The "already linked to an account" error is super common. What worked for me was going directly to the SDI office in person with all my documents. I know it's a pain, but the in-person staff were able to access the backend system and unlink my old account on the spot. It took about 45 minutes total including wait time. Bring your driver's license, social security card, and any previous claim documentation you have. Way faster than trying to get through on the phone! Hope this helps and congrats on the new addition to your family! 🍼
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
•Thanks for sharing your experience! Going in person sounds way more efficient than the phone runaround. Quick question - do you remember which SDI office you went to? I'm trying to figure out if I need to go to a specific location or if any office can handle account linking issues. Also, did they require an appointment or was it walk-in? Really appreciate the tip about bringing all the documentation - I'll make sure to have everything ready!
0 coins