Back to California Paid Family Leave

Freya Thomsen

UI claim no base period wages after SDI and PFL — does anyone qualify?

So I'm in a weird spot and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I took PFL to bond with my daughter earlier this year, and before that I was on pregnancy disability through SDI. By the time both of those ended I had basically been out of work for the better part of the year. Now I'm laid off and I filed a UI claim, but EDD is saying there are no base period wages. The thing is I was getting SDI and PFL payments during that whole stretch — does EDD not count those? I thought maybe they'd use an alternate base period or something? I had a decent salary before the disability started and I really can't believe none of that counts. Has anyone dealt with this after coming off SDI and PFL back-to-back?

Ended up in almost the same situation after my PFL ran out last spring and went back part-time before the full bonding period was done. Figuring out which days to report got confusing and I kept second-guessing the DE 2580GF, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone about it. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which weeks still had certified days pending and which ones had already been paid, so I knew exactly where I stood before I went back full-time. For the UI base period question though — EDD has an alternate base period option, so definitely ask them whether your wages from before the disability started fall into it.

0 coins

EDD's PFL line actually picked up for you? I've called that number six or seven mornings in a row and either get a busy signal or it disconnects after the menu.

0 coins

Every time I called on my own it was the same wall of noise. Claimyr just handled the hold for me and my phone rang when an agent was on. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Had a payment method question on my own bonding claim and tried Claimyr the same way — the agent told me my direct deposit was already on file from SDI Online and the first PFL payment would go there automatically. Anyway, the UI base period thing is real, the alternate period saved a coworker of mine who'd been out on disability for months.

0 coins

The base period for a UI claim typically looks at wages earned roughly 12 to 18 months before you file, and SDI or PFL payments are not counted as wages in that window. What California does allow, however, is an alternative base period that looks at your most recent four quarters, and there is also a provision specifically for people who were disabled: if you were receiving SDI during the standard base period, EDD can substitute the quarters you were disabled with earlier quarters when you actually had wages. It is called the disability base period substitution and it is worth asking EDD about directly.

0 coins

Wait, so EDD can actually go back further than the normal base period if I was on SDI? I had no idea that was even a thing. Where would I find that on my claim?

0 coins

You would need to contact EDD directly and ask them to apply it. It is not automatic from what I understand — you have to let them know you were receiving SDI during the base period and ask them to look at earlier quarters.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. The substitution exists but it won't happen unless you ask. And you'd want to have your SDI claim dates handy when you call so they can see exactly which quarters to swap out.

0 coins

Got hit with a DE 2514 denial notice on my own PFL care claim and had no clue what it meant at first — the letter was vague about why. Spent three weeks trying to reach someone at 1-877-238-4373 and got nowhere, mornings, afternoons, didn't matter. Eventually I went through Claimyr and an agent picked up. The agent told me the denial was because Part D hadn't been received within the 41-day window, and that I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed. For the UI base period issue, the disability substitution the person above mentioned is real — I went through something similar and it made a big difference which quarters EDD looked at.

0 coins

What's Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned. My bonding claim has been pending for two weeks and I need to find out if the birth certificate even made it to EDD.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD so you don't have to — when a live agent picks up, your phone rings and you're the one talking to them. That's basically it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. I'd want to ask whether EDD received the birth certificate I uploaded, because SDI Online just says pending and I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar boat and I'm scared I'm going to end up with nothing. I was on PFL bonding for eight weeks and before that my wife was the one on the pregnancy disability claim, not me. I went back to work after my PFL ended but then got laid off two months later. EDD sent me a notice saying my UI base period had no wages. I think I might be misunderstanding something but I genuinely don't know what to do next.

0 coins

Your base period for UI looks at wages you personally earned, not your spouse's. If your PFL bonding claim took up a big chunk of the standard base period and you didn't have enough wages in those quarters, you'd want to ask EDD about the disability substitution — it may let them use quarters before your PFL started when you were actually working.

0 coins

So my wife's SDI wouldn't help my UI claim at all? I figured since we filed together — wait, we didn't file together, hers was her own claim. I'm confusing myself. I'll ask EDD about the substitution.

0 coins

Each person files their own claim, yeah. Your wages are what count for your UI. The substitution for the quarters you were on PFL is the right thing to ask about.

0 coins

Tried calling EDD about my UI base period after six weeks of back-to-back SDI and PFL. The line disconnected four times before I got through. Eventually it worked out — the disability substitution covered it.

0 coins

How long before they sorted the base period out for you?

0 coins

About two weeks after I requested it. Came by mail.

0 coins

edd doesnt count pfl payments as wages i found that out the hard way. the base period thing is brutal when youve been out that long. alternate base period saved me tho ask about it

0 coins

Did you have to do anything special to request the alternate base period or did EDD offer it?

0 coins

i had to ask. called in and told them i was on pfl and sdi and they looked at earlier quarters. wasnt automatic at all

0 coins

PFL pay isn't the same as wages. EDD knows you were collecting it but it doesn't count toward the base period for UI. That's just how the two programs work. You need actual wages in those quarters.

0 coins

Right. It's the SDI withholding on your paychecks that funded PFL in the first place, but the PFL benefit itself isn't wages. Two different things.

0 coins

Exactly. And you can't be on PFL and UI at the same time either. EDD won't pay both for the same days.

0 coins

For reference on the base period: the standard UI base period looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. If you were on SDI starting, say, January, your Q4 from the prior year and Q1 and Q2 of this year might all show zero wages. That's when the disability substitution matters — you ask EDD to swap those quarters out for ones where you actually had earnings.

0 coins

So if I had good wages in the year before the pregnancy disability started, those quarters might be usable? That would actually cover me because I was working full-time for two years before all this.

0 coins

Exactly. That's the scenario where the substitution helps. Have the dates your SDI started and ended ready when you contact EDD — they'll need to know which quarters were affected.

0 coins

Worth double-checking by using the UI benefits calculator on EDD's site first, just to see if the alternate base period alone gets you there before you have to ask about the substitution.

0 coins

Birth certificate on my bonding claim sat unmatched for almost three weeks after I uploaded it. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask what was going on. The agent found it had been received but wasn't linked to the claim yet — they said to allow a couple more business days and to check SDI Online after that. The claim moved to approved the following week.

0 coins

Used Claimyr on my own claim too — the agent confirmed the receipt number on file matched what I had from the confirmation page, which I'd been second-guessing. Good to have it verified. Anyway.

0 coins

What did you tell the agent when you got them? Like did you just give the claim number and ask about the document status?

0 coins

Gave the receipt number and said the status hadn't changed in weeks. Agent found the document and confirmed the match. That's all it took.

0 coins

PFL and UI can't overlap for the same days, right? Like if someone still had PFL weeks left and filed for UI, EDD would just not pay the PFL days?

0 coins

Correct. EDD won't pay PFL benefits and UI benefits for the same period. If the PFL claim is finished and the UI claim is for a different period after returning to work, there's no conflict.

0 coins

Got it, so the question is really just whether her base period has enough wages in it after being out so long.

0 coins

The alternate base period for UI uses the four most recently completed calendar quarters — you can find it described in EDD's UI guide. The disability substitution is a separate provision specifically for claimants who were receiving SDI during the standard base period quarters. They are two different tools and you may need to ask about both.

0 coins

Are both things you have to ask EDD about manually or does the UI claim form have a place to flag it?

0 coins

From what I've read, the form does have a question about whether you received SDI during the base period. But I'd still follow up directly with EDD to make sure it was flagged, because a checkbox on a form doesn't guarantee someone acted on it.

0 coins

Agreed. Contacting EDD directly after filing is the safest step. Mail or SDI Online won't cover a UI question — that's a separate line.

0 coins

been trying that 877 number for two weeks. either busy or drops. frustrating when you just need a straight answer about which quarters they're looking at.

0 coins

Two weeks of that line is exhausting. I had the same run of dropped calls before the care claim denial situation finally got sorted.

0 coins

at least good to know im not the only one. i'll try in the morning again i guess.

0 coins

The disability substitution really does exist and it saved my UI claim after I came off SDI! I was absolutely convinced I had no wages in the base period and then an EDD rep pointed me to it. Have you filed the UI claim already or are you still trying to figure out if it's worth it?

0 coins

Already filed and got the no base period wages notice. So now I'm trying to figure out what to do next.

0 coins

Call EDD's UI line and tell them exactly what you told us — you were on SDI and then PFL and want them to check whether the disability base period substitution applies. They can look at your quarters right there.

0 coins

And don't wait too long. If EDD issued a determination you have 30 days to appeal, so check the date on whatever notice they sent.

0 coins

PFL benefits aren't wages. SDI benefits aren't wages either. Neither counts in a UI base period. The substitution exists to handle exactly this — quarters wiped out by disability get replaced by earlier quarters. Ask EDD about it.

0 coins

Does the substitution cover PFL quarters too or just SDI?

0 coins

I'd ask EDD directly on that. SDI is the clearer case since it's a disability benefit. PFL is different. Don't assume — ask.

0 coins

That's actually a good point. The provision I've seen referenced is specifically tied to disability, so PFL bonding weeks might be treated differently. EDD would know how your specific quarters line up.

0 coins

Came back to say my bonding claim finally approved after three weeks pending. EDD sent the Notice of Computation and the first payment is processing. The birth certificate did make it in, just took a while to match. Anyway hope the UI base period thing gets sorted for the original poster.

0 coins

Glad yours came through! Gives me some hope at least.

0 coins

Good news. Those pending weeks feel long.

0 coins

If the determination notice has already been issued, the appeal deadline is 30 days from that date. File the DE 1000A before that window closes regardless of whether the substitution question gets resolved — you can still work with EDD on the base period while the appeal is on file.

0 coins

Is there a way to file the appeal online or does it have to be mailed?

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be filed online or by mail. The notice itself should say where to send it. Online is faster.

0 coins

You can also check edd.ca.gov for the appeals process. The important thing is not to miss the 30-day window while waiting for EDD to review the substitution question.

0 coins

Two things can happen at once here — you ask EDD to review the base period with the substitution, and you file the appeal within 30 days just in case. You don't have to pick one or the other.

0 coins

I didn't realize you could do both at the same time. That's actually reassuring.

0 coins

Yeah. The appeal protects the deadline. The substitution request is a separate conversation with EDD. Neither cancels the other.

0 coins

also just to say — edd wont pay ui and pfl for the same days at all so if any pfl weeks are still open from bonding you cant collect ui on those days. gotta be fully off pfl first

0 coins

That's right. Once PFL is closed and the person is unemployed and looking for work, the UI claim is a separate matter.

0 coins

So basically finish the PFL period completely before expecting UI to kick in for any of those same days. Makes sense.

0 coins

Update from me: I called EDD's UI line this morning and asked specifically about the disability base period substitution. The rep confirmed my SDI quarters were flagged and said to watch for a new determination in the mail. I also filed the DE 1000A appeal online just in case since the 30-day window was coming up. Really glad I found this thread — I had no idea the substitution even existed.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move filing the appeal and asking about the substitution at the same time!

0 coins

Well done. Keeping the appeal on file while EDD reviews is exactly the right approach. Watch for the notice and if it's in your favor the appeal becomes moot.

0 coins

Good to hear. If the new determination still shows an issue, the appeal is already in. You're covered either way.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up — I thought PFL had a waiting period like disability does, those seven unpaid days. Filed expecting to lose the first week. Turned out PFL has no waiting period at all, every eligible day pays. EDD didn't volunteer that info, I just stumbled onto it.

0 coins

Correct. No waiting period for PFL. The seven-day unpaid period is for Disability Insurance only. Different program.

0 coins

I told my client the wrong thing about this last year lol. Good catch, good to have it said clearly here.

0 coins

I genuinely would have made that same mistake. I assumed they worked the same way.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure