Back to California Paid Family Leave

Keisha Williams

Can employer require paid family leave to run with paid parental leave at the same time?

My company just told me that my California PFL and my company's paid parental leave have to run at the same time, so I'd only get eight weeks total instead of eight weeks of each. I always assumed they were separate things. I'm taking leave starting in January after my wife gives birth and I'm trying to plan our finances. Is this actually legal? Can employer require paid family leave to run with paid parental leave like that? I'm not sure if EDD controls this or if it's entirely up to my employer. Really anxious about this because we were counting on more time.

The Notice of Computation came in and I realized I had a question about how my weekly benefit amount was calculated, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach EDD's PFL line and spoke with an agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my DE 429DF and confirmed the base period quarters they used and what the weekly figure came to. What I found out that may matter here: EDD controls PFL benefit payments, but how your employer's own parental leave policy layers on top is entirely your employer's call. EDD doesn't set rules about whether company parental leave and PFL run at the same time.

0 coins

The payment date question is what brought me to try Claimyr too, and I'm glad I did. The agent told me my first payment had been issued and gave me the exact date it was processed. After that I went back to my employer to sort out how their own leave policy lined up with PFL days, and it became a lot clearer once I had EDD's side confirmed.

0 coins

So EDD really has nothing to say about whether they run together? That's all the employer?

0 coins

From what the agent explained, yes. EDD pays the PFL benefit regardless. The concurrency question is entirely your company's leave policy, not EDD's.

0 coins

Wait so EDD just pays whatever it pays and my employer decides whether to also pay their own benefit on top, or instead? I'm confused about how the money actually works when both are running.

0 coins

Your employer can absolutely require them to run at the same time, and a lot of companies do. It's pretty common. EDD sends you the PFL benefit and your employer pays their own parental leave, and if they're running together the weeks count down together. So you'd use up your eight PFL weeks and your company leave weeks at the same pace.

0 coins

So I'd just get the eight weeks and both payments come in during those eight weeks, not sixteen total?

0 coins

Exactly. The employer is using their parental leave to supplement PFL, not add extra time on top. At least that's how every job I've heard of does it.

0 coins

That's the most common setup, yeah. Though some employers do give their leave on top of PFL. Worth checking your HR documents carefully.

0 coins

EDD doesn't tell your boss how to run their parental leave. That's internal policy. What EDD controls is your PFL payment amount and how many weeks you get from them, which is up to eight. Your company can stack their leave on top or run it at the same time. Your HR handbook should spell it out.

0 coins

I did read the handbook and it says they run concurrently but I guess I was hoping that wasn't actually allowed. So there's no law stopping them?

0 coins

Not that EDD enforces. If there's a job protection angle, that's a CFRA or FMLA question for your employer's HR, not EDD.

0 coins

Worth pointing out that PFL itself doesn't protect your job anyway. EDD says it pays benefits but doesn't cover job protection. That comes from CFRA or FMLA and is completely separate from what EDD does.

0 coins

EDD's PFL line is a nightmare to reach if you actually want to verify any of this for yourself. I spent three mornings hitting redial before 8am and still got the busy recording every time.

0 coins

same here, four tries last week, nothing

0 coins

And it's not like you can even leave a message. The line just ends.

0 coins

I finally got through on a Thursday, no idea if that's just luck.

0 coins

The rule that surprised me when I went through this last year: PFL has no waiting period at all. I had assumed there were seven unpaid days at the start like disability has, so I was budgeting wrong. When I called EDD, the agent confirmed the first day of my leave was also the first day that counted for PFL.

0 coins

Wait, no waiting period at all? So day one of my leave is day one EDD might pay?

0 coins

That's correct. PFL doesn't have the seven-day wait that Disability Insurance has. Different program, different rules.

0 coins

That part is actually good news for my situation. I had the same wrong assumption.

0 coins

My sister told me she got sixteen weeks because her company leave was on top of PFL, not concurrent with it. So it really does depend on the employer's own policy, not any state rule.

0 coins

That tracks. Some employers are generous, most aren't.

0 coins

my company does concurrent too, so it was 8 weeks total, anyway employer controls that piece not edd

0 coins

About a week into my PFL bonding claim the SDI Online payment history wasn't showing what I expected, so I tried Claimyr to reach a live EDD agent. The agent looked up my claim and went through which weeks had been paid and confirmed when the next payment was due. Knowing that cleared up whether my employer's concurrent leave schedule matched what EDD was actually processing on their end.

0 coins

I'll be honest, that sounds too convenient. I tried that PFL line about six times across two weeks and got nothing but the recording. How did you actually get through?

0 coins

Claimyr holds the line for you, basically. You don't sit on hold yourself, you just get a ring once an EDD agent picks up. That's how I got through. It's not a trick, it just waits so you don't have to.

0 coins

Tried it myself when my claim wasn't showing payment info. Agent confirmed four weeks were left in my 12-month window. That's all I needed to know to plan the rest of my leave.

0 coins

Alright, might be worth a shot. I need to know the same kind of thing for my claim.

0 coins

To add some clarity on the CFRA side: it provides job-protected leave, which PFL doesn't. Whether CFRA applies to your situation, how many weeks it covers and whether your employer is covered depends on your employer and those specific laws, not EDD. The person to ask is HR. EDD handles the payment side, full stop.

0 coins

So CFRA is the job protection piece and PFL is the money piece. Those are always separate?

0 coins

Always administered separately. EDD pays PFL. CFRA is enforced by the Civil Rights Department. Your employer may run them at the same time, but they're distinct.

0 coins

This is the part that confuses me most. So I could have PFL payment running and CFRA protection running and employer parental leave all at the same time and they all count down their weeks simultaneously?

0 coins

That's often how it works, yes. Which is exactly why you end up with less total time off than people expect. The weeks overlap rather than stack.

0 coins

yeah my job did concurrent too and i didnt know until week 3, would have been nice to know before i took the leave

0 coins

That's really frustrating, especially with a newborn.

0 coins

yeah but nothing i could do about it after the fact

0 coins

Concurrent is the default for most employers. If they offer anything on top, it'll be in writing somewhere. If it's not in writing, assume concurrent.

0 coins

Checked again and it's definitely concurrent. I guess I just have to plan around eight weeks.

0 coins

Eight weeks and whatever your partner can take. Split it if you haven't already.

0 coins

Both parents can file their own PFL bonding claim, right? So if your wife files her own and you file yours, you each get up to eight weeks from EDD! That could help with total time covered even if each of your employers runs their leave concurrently.

0 coins

Correct, each parent files their own separate PFL claim. The eight-week limit is per claimant, not per household.

0 coins

Oh that's something I hadn't thought about. She'll be on a disability claim first for the pregnancy but then she files a separate PFL bonding claim after?

0 coins

Yes, once her Disability Insurance for the pregnancy ends she gets a form from EDD, the DE 2501FP, to start her PFL bonding claim. And you file your own PFL claim separately through SDI Online. Two separate claims.

0 coins

we did exactly this, staggered them so one of us was always getting pfl while the other was back at work, anyway it stretched things out nicely

0 coins

The DE 2500E question came up on my own bonding claim, so I ended up trying Claimyr to get an answer. The agent confirmed my Electronic Benefit Payment Notification had been issued and walked me through what it meant for the first payment on my claim.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on EDD's phone line in your place, so when an agent at EDD picks up, your phone rings and you're the one talking to them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

My situation is that my employer is requiring concurrent leave and I want to confirm with EDD exactly when my PFL starts so I can coordinate. That sounds like exactly what I'd bring up.

0 coins

Eight weeks is the ceiling from EDD no matter what. Your employer cannot give you more PFL weeks than EDD allows, and your employer is not adding to that eight weeks by offering parental leave. They're just topping up the payment amount during those same weeks, or not.

0 coins

That's the key point. EDD controls the PFL weeks. Employer controls whether their own leave is on top or alongside.

0 coins

Most employers aren't topping up anything. They just call it concurrent so it looks like they're giving you something extra.

0 coins

Can my employer actually require me to use vacation or sick days at the same time as PFL? Someone at work told me I had to burn through all my PTO first before PFL would kick in.

0 coins

PTO running alongside PFL is a thing but it doesn't delay PFL. PFL doesn't have a waiting period to begin with. What EDD says is that any wages plus your PFL can't be more than your normal wages. So your employer might require PTO to run with it, and that affects your total pay, but it doesn't push PFL back.

0 coins

The rule is that sick leave, vacation or other paid time off can be combined with PFL, but wages plus PFL can't exceed your regular wages. How your employer actually applies that is their own policy, so HR is the right place to confirm.

0 coins

So PTO running at the same time doesn't delay PFL, it just changes how much total money comes in? That's less bad than I thought.

0 coins

if anyone here has been trying that phone line for days and getting nowhere, the 1-877-238-4373 number at least gets you into the queue but i swear it disconnects before anyone answers half the time

0 coins

every morning this week for me, same result

0 coins

It's genuinely one of the more frustrating systems I've dealt with and I've been dealing with EDD since my kid was born in 2023.

0 coins

Intermittent PFL was something I didn't fully understand until after I'd already filed, so I ended up trying Claimyr to reach an agent about reporting my intermittent days on the DE 2580GF. Agent told me EDD had sent the Continued Claim Certification and that I needed to return it or payments would stop. Glad I called when I did.

0 coins

Did the agent say what happened if you hadn't returned it in time?

0 coins

They said benefits stop if the DE 2580GF isn't returned. They didn't give a specific cutoff date beyond telling me to get it in as soon as possible. I sent it in the next day.

0 coins

That form is easy to miss if nobody tells you to expect it. Good catch.

0 coins

worth knowing you can split the 8 weeks up too if your employer allows intermittent leave on their end, so you dont have to take it all at once, anyway edd allows that

0 coins

If I took two days a week would I still need to report those to EDD?

0 coins

yeah you report any work and wages to edd, they send a continued claim form and you return it or payments stop, anyway dont skip that step

0 coins

To add to that: on the paper claim form, the DE 2501F, you answer yes to the question about working during leave and attach the schedule of days and hours. EDD takes it from there.

0 coins

PFL pays whether the leave is concurrent or not. The number of weeks from EDD is still up to eight. What changes with concurrent leave is how your employer's pay and PFL layer together during those weeks, and that is 100 percent between you and your employer.

0 coins

Is it worth negotiating with HR on this or is it usually take it or leave it?

0 coins

Depends on your employer. Some have flexibility, most treat it as a fixed policy. Worth asking in writing.

0 coins

I already asked and they said the policy is firm. At least now I understand what it actually means financially.

0 coins

One thing I'd double check: the total PFL weeks available across all leave types in a 12-month period is still eight, shared across bonding, care and military assist. So if you used some weeks for another reason in the same 12 months, those count against the same pool.

0 coins

That's an important one that trips people up. Some assume bonding and care claims each have their own eight weeks. They share the same eight.

0 coins

I haven't used any PFL in the past year so I should have the full eight available. Good to confirm though.

0 coins

If you're ever unsure how many weeks remain in your 12-month window, the agent can look it up on your claim directly.

0 coins

Your employer can require it. EDD doesn't stop them. That's the short answer.

0 coins

Yeah I've come to terms with that. Eight weeks it is. At least now I know what I'm actually working with.

0 coins

Plan around eight, stagger with your partner if you can, and confirm PTO rules with HR in writing before leave starts.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure