Social Security online account shows my husband's email already exists - how to recover access?

This happened to me too! Turned out I actually HAD created an account like 5 years ago when they first started the online system and completely forgot about it. Try the "forgot password" option and see if they send a reset link. If that works, someone didn't steal his identity - he just created one previously and forgot.

check your spam folder!! the ssa emails ALWAYS go to my spam

I ran into this same problem last year and it was incredibly frustrating. After several failed attempts online, I discovered there are two possible causes: 1. Someone else may have accidentally used your husband's email (maybe a typo when they entered their own) 2. There could be a duplicate email issue in the SSA system itself Unfortunately, this cannot be resolved online. Your husband will need to either: - Visit a local Social Security office in person (make an appointment first!) - Call the national number at 1-800-772-1213 Bring/have ready his ID, Social Security card, and proof of address. They'll need to verify his identity before helping with the account issue. In my case, they had to manually remove the email from their system so I could create a new account.

I've helped dozens of clients with this exact issue! It's surprisingly common. Here's what's likely happening: 1) Either your husband created an account years ago and forgot about it (most common) 2) SSA has linked his email to someone else's account by mistake (less common but happens) 3) Someone else used his email by mistake when creating their own account The solution requires SSA to verify his identity and either recover the existing account or clear the email from their system. Online account access is critical for monitoring benefits, so it's worth resolving now before he starts receiving payments. The fastest way to fix this is calling SSA at 1-800-772-1213, but you'll need to get through to a representative who has access to the online account system (not all do). April is one of the busiest months for SSA calls, so expect significant wait times.

I ran into this exact issue when helping my father set up his account. After multiple failed attempts to get through on the 800 number, I discovered a service called Claimyr that got us connected to a Social Security representative in under 20 minutes instead of the usual hours-long wait. They called SSA on our behalf and then connected us once they reached an agent. I was skeptical but it worked perfectly - the agent was able to reset his account access right away. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU or just go to claimyr.com. Saved us a 45-minute drive to the SSA office and hours of waiting.

my wife had same problm but worse... someone used her email AND social!! we had to go to the office in person with ID birth certificate and everything. big hassle but fixed it.

Maybe he already has his own my Social Security account set up??!! I would log into the existing account using his email and the "forgot password" link. If he gets a reset email then BOOOM problem solved!!!

Update us once you get this resolved! I'm curious which of these solutions works for you. Online account access is really important for monitoring benefits and tax documents, so definitely worth getting fixed before he starts collecting benefits.