


Ask the community...
I'm new to this community but had to jump in because your situation is almost identical to what I went through last year! The whole "rule violation" thing is definitely intimidating when you first see it, but it's really just their way of contesting your claim - not an actual determination that you did anything wrong. What really stands out to me is how your employer's story keeps evolving. Going from "different direction" to "wouldn't be against your unemployment" to suddenly discovering "rule violations" only after you filed? That's textbook bad faith behavior that UC examiners see right through. I learned the hard way that you absolutely MUST keep filing your weekly claims during this process - I almost made the mistake of stopping when I saw the contest. Also, that conversation where your boss said they "wouldn't be against" your claim is probably your strongest piece of evidence. Write down every single detail you can remember about it. One thing that really helped my case was emphasizing during the determination interview how my employer's story kept changing after I filed. The examiner took note of the inconsistency and ruled in my favor. Your situation sounds even stronger since you have that HR email essentially admitting your manager "misspoke" - that's basically confirmation that the original conversation happened and they're trying to backtrack. Don't let them intimidate you into giving up! The system is designed to protect workers from exactly this kind of post-termination story manipulation.
Thank you for sharing your experience! It's really encouraging to hear from someone who went through almost the exact same situation and came out successful. You're absolutely right about the evolving story being a major red flag - when I lay it out chronologically like that (different direction → wouldn't oppose claim → manager "misspoke" → sudden rule violations), it becomes really obvious they're just making things up as they go. I'm definitely continuing to file my weekly claims and I've been documenting everything in detail. That HR email where they admitted my manager "misspoke" really is golden evidence because it proves the conversation happened AND shows they're trying to cover their tracks after the fact. It's so helpful to hear that emphasizing the story changes during your determination interview was effective. I'm going to make sure to present a clear timeline of their contradictions to the examiner. Thanks for the reminder that this kind of employer behavior is more common than I realized - it makes me feel much more confident about fighting this!
I'm new to this community but your situation is really striking a chord with me because I just went through something very similar! The "rule violation" status is definitely scary at first, but from what I've learned, it's really just the system's way of flagging that your employer contested your claim - not an actual finding against you. What's most telling about your case is the clear timeline of your employer changing their story. They went from "going in a different direction" during termination → telling you they "wouldn't be against" your unemployment claim → HR saying the manager "misspoke" → suddenly claiming rule violations only AFTER you filed. That pattern screams bad faith contest to me. That initial conversation where your boss said they "wouldn't be against" your claim is incredibly valuable evidence. It's essentially an admission that they didn't consider your termination misconduct-related when it actually happened. Combined with shutting down your email access so quickly (looks like they're trying to prevent evidence gathering), their behavior is going to look really suspicious to the UC examiner. My advice: document every detail of that conversation with exact dates/times, keep filing your weekly claims no matter what, and don't let their intimidation tactics work. The determination interview is where you'll get to present all this evidence of their contradictory statements. You've got a really strong case here - employers who legitimately terminate for misconduct don't usually tell people they "wouldn't be against" their unemployment benefits! Stay strong and keep fighting this. The system is designed to catch exactly these kinds of post-filing story changes from employers trying to avoid their unemployment costs.
Thank you so much for laying out that timeline so clearly! Seeing it spelled out like that - "different direction" → "wouldn't be against" → "misspoke" → sudden rule violations - really drives home how obvious their bad faith is. You're absolutely right that legitimate misconduct terminations don't usually come with reassurances that they won't oppose unemployment benefits! I've been documenting everything and that conversation is definitely my strongest evidence. It happened immediately after termination in my supervisor's office when I directly asked about potential UC issues. The fact that they're now trying to walk it back through HR just makes their contest look even more desperate and fabricated. I really appreciate everyone's advice here - I'm feeling much more confident about fighting this now that I understand how common this employer tactic is and how the system is designed to protect against exactly this kind of post-filing story manipulation!
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm in a very similar situation - just got offered a part-time position (12-15 hours/week) while on UC and was really anxious about how to handle it correctly. Reading everyone's real experiences has been so much more valuable than trying to decipher the official PA UC website. The consistent advice seems to be: 1) Be completely honest when reporting ALL earnings and hours, 2) Report gross pay for the week you worked (not when paid), 3) Keep simple records (notebook or phone photos), 4) Continue job search activities, and 5) Don't stress about the math since the system calculates partial benefits automatically. What's really encouraging is hearing from multiple people that their combined income (part-time wages + reduced UC) was actually higher than UC benefits alone. That makes this transition feel much less scary financially. One quick question for those who've been through this - when you report your part-time earnings, does it affect your benefit year or the total amount you can collect over time? Or does it just reduce that week's payment while preserving your remaining benefit balance for later weeks? Thanks everyone for sharing such detailed, practical advice. This community is amazing!
Great question about how partial benefits affect your benefit year! From my experience, when you work part-time and receive reduced UC payments, it doesn't extend your benefit year or preserve unused benefits for later. Each week you file counts toward your benefit year regardless of whether you receive full, partial, or zero benefits that week. So if you're entitled to 26 weeks of benefits, working part-time for 10 weeks still uses up 10 weeks of your benefit year, even though you received smaller payments during those weeks. The upside is that you're earning more overall during those weeks with the combined income, which helps you get back on your feet faster. Just something to keep in mind as you plan your transition to full-time work!
I'm really glad I found this thread! I'm currently on UC and just got offered a part-time job that starts at 20 hours/week but will become full-time in about 6 months. After reading all these experiences, I feel so much more confident about taking the position. The consistent message seems to be that PA's partial benefit system actually works well when you're honest and organized about reporting. I especially appreciate the practical tips about keeping records - I think I'll use the phone photo method for my work schedules since I always have my phone with me anyway. It's also really encouraging to hear from multiple people that the combined income (wages + reduced UC) often ends up being more than UC alone. One thing that's been weighing on my mind is whether I should give PA UC a heads up before I start working, or if I should just wait until I have actual earnings to report on my weekly certification. Has anyone found it helpful to call ahead, or is it better to just let the weekly filing process handle everything? Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences here - this kind of real-world advice is so much more helpful than trying to figure everything out from the official websites!
From my experience, you don't need to call ahead - just report your earnings during your regular weekly certification when you actually have wages to report. The system is designed to handle this through the normal weekly filing process. When you certify for the week you worked, there will be clear questions asking if you worked and how much you earned. Just answer honestly with your gross pay for that week and let the system calculate your partial benefit automatically. Calling ahead might actually create confusion since you won't have specific earnings to report yet. The weekly certification process is really the proper channel for reporting part-time work. Save yourself the hassle of trying to get through on the phone - the online system handles it smoothly once you start earning!
This thread is absolutely incredible - such a wealth of real-world experience and practical advice! I'm actually going through something similar right now (14-week severance package, laid off last month) and this conversation has answered so many questions I didn't even know I should be asking. I especially appreciate everyone emphasizing the importance of filing immediately and keeping up with weekly certifications during the severance period. I almost made the mistake of thinking I should wait until my severance ended to file! The tips about using CareerLink resources, keeping detailed documentation, and treating the severance period as strategic career development time are game-changers. I've been feeling anxious about the long gap before UC payments start, but you've all reframed it as an opportunity to be selective and thorough in my job search. One question for those who've been through this - did any of you find that employers were understanding about the severance situation during interviews? I'm worried potential employers might think I'm not serious about finding work quickly since I have that financial cushion. Thanks to everyone for sharing such detailed, helpful experiences. This community is amazing!
I can definitely relate to your concerns about employer perceptions! When I went through my severance situation, I found that most employers were actually quite understanding - layoffs are so common these days that having severance doesn't raise red flags about your motivation to work. In fact, several hiring managers told me they appreciated that I could be thoughtful about fit rather than desperate to take anything. My advice would be to be upfront about your timeline if asked, but frame it positively. Something like "I'm fortunate to have some time to find the right opportunity where I can make a real impact" rather than focusing on the severance aspect. Most employers respect candidates who are strategic about their career moves. Also, the fact that you're actively interviewing and networking during your severance period actually demonstrates initiative - you're not just sitting around waiting for the money to run out! The 14-week cushion gives you leverage to negotiate better offers too, which is a nice position to be in. Keep that confidence up and use this time to your advantage!
This has been such an incredibly valuable thread! As a newcomer to this community and someone who might be facing a similar situation in the coming months (my company just announced "restructuring" plans), I'm amazed by how generous everyone has been with sharing their real experiences and practical advice. The consistent message about filing immediately after your last day of work, even though you won't receive payments during the severance period, seems counterintuitive but makes perfect sense once you understand the system. And the emphasis on maintaining those weekly certifications and job search requirements during the entire severance period is crucial information I never would have known otherwise. What really stands out to me is how many of you turned what could have been a stressful waiting period into productive career development time. The suggestions about using CareerLink resources, getting certifications, and being strategic about job searching rather than desperate really reframe the whole experience in a positive way. I'm definitely bookmarking this thread for future reference and will be sharing it with colleagues who might need this information. Thank you all for creating such a comprehensive resource and showing that this community truly supports each other through difficult transitions. The combination of technical knowledge and emotional support here is exactly what people need when navigating unemployment for the first time!
Welcome to the community, Paolo! Your thoughtful summary really captures how valuable this discussion has been. It's wonderful to see how people here share real experiences rather than just repeating official policy language - that's what makes the difference when you're actually going through this stressful situation. I hope the "restructuring" at your company doesn't affect you, but if it does, you're already ahead of the game by learning about the process now. The key insight that really helped me was understanding that filing immediately isn't just bureaucratic procedure - it starts your benefit year clock ticking, which is crucial for maximizing your total benefits. One thing I'd add to all the great advice here: if restructuring does happen at your company, try to get as much detail as possible about your severance package in writing before your last day. Things like payment schedule, total amount, and any conditions can affect how you report everything to PA UC. Being prepared with those details will make the initial filing much smoother. This community really is special - people genuinely want to help others navigate these challenges successfully. Best of luck with everything, and hopefully you won't need this information at all!
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now! Got laid off last week and I'm expecting my final paycheck plus some accrued vacation time payout in the next few days. Based on what everyone's saying here, it sounds like I shouldn't report either of these on my weekly certifications since the work was done before my layoff date. Is that correct? Also, does anyone know if there's a difference in how PA UC treats regular final paychecks vs. vacation/PTO payouts? I want to make sure I handle this correctly from the start to avoid any issues down the road.
Yes, you're correct! Since both your final paycheck and vacation payout are for work/benefits earned before your layoff date, you should NOT report either on your weekly certifications. PA UC treats them the same way - it's all about when you earned it, not when you received payment. Just make sure to keep records of the dates and amounts in case you ever need to reference them later. You're smart to ask upfront rather than guessing!
Just want to echo what everyone else has said - you're handling this correctly! I went through the exact same confusion when I got laid off from my job at a warehouse last year. Got my final check about 10 days after my last day and spent way too much time worrying about whether to report it. The rule is simple: if you didn't do the work during the week you're claiming benefits for, don't report it. One thing I learned the hard way though - make sure you keep a copy of that final paystub! I had an issue months later where PA UC needed documentation about my employment dates, and having that final paystub with the pay period dates really helped prove when my employment actually ended. Also, if you have any unused sick time or personal days that get paid out, same rule applies - don't report it since you "earned" those days while you were still employed. The weekly certification process gets easier once you get into the routine. Just remember to be honest about any actual work you do during each claim week going forward. Good luck with your job search!
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! That's really helpful about keeping the paystub - I wouldn't have thought about needing it later for documentation. I'll make sure to save everything. It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through the exact same situation. The whole unemployment process feels overwhelming when you're new to it, but this community has been incredibly helpful in clearing up the confusion. Really appreciate everyone taking the time to explain these details!
Miranda Singer
Congratulations Aisha! This is such amazing news! 🎉 I've been quietly following your journey and I'm so excited that everything worked out for you. Your story has been incredibly helpful for those of us who might face similar situations in the future. The way you handled everything - from asking thoughtful questions to staying on top of the reporting requirements - really shows how to navigate this process the right way. It's also wonderful to see how supportive and knowledgeable this community is. Everyone's advice about proper reporting, keeping documentation, and understanding the nuances of PA UC has been educational for all of us. Best of luck with your new position - after 8 weeks of searching, you definitely deserve this success! Thanks for keeping us updated throughout your journey.
0 coins
NeonNova
•Congratulations Aisha! I'm so happy for you! 🎉 As someone who's brand new to this community, I've been reading through this entire thread and it's been such an educational journey. Your experience really highlights how important it is to ask the right questions and get proper guidance when dealing with PA UC. The support you've received here is incredible - everyone shared such detailed, practical advice about reporting requirements, documentation, and navigating the system correctly. It gives me confidence that if I ever find myself in a similar situation, this community will be here to help. Your success after 8 weeks of searching is truly inspiring, especially in today's job market. Thank you for sharing your whole experience with us and congratulations again on the new position!
0 coins
Lucas Bey
Congratulations Aisha! This is absolutely wonderful news! 🎉 I'm so excited for you - landing a job after 8 weeks of searching is such an accomplishment, especially in today's challenging market. You've been handling this entire situation so professionally and it's clear you're going to do great in your new role. The advice you've received here about reporting the job acceptance on your weekly certification while continuing to file until your actual start date is spot on. This community really came together to help you navigate the PA UC system, and your experience will definitely help others who find themselves in similar transitions. Make sure to celebrate this win - you've earned it! Best of luck on your first day and in your new position!
0 coins