NY unemployment claim shows pending for 5 weeks without payment - what's wrong?
I've been filing my NY unemployment claims weekly since I lost my job in February. The first 3 payments came through fine (about $540 each), but now my claim has been stuck as 'pending' for FIVE WEEKS with zero explanation! I've tried calling the NYSDOL hotline literally 47 times but it either disconnects or says 'all representatives are busy.' My rent is due in 4 days and I'm getting desperate. Has anyone else had their NY unemployment payments suddenly stop like this? What caused it to get fixed? The online dashboard just shows 'pending review' but doesn't explain WHY or give any timeline.
24 comments
Keisha Taylor
This is actually pretty common right now with NY unemployment. There are a few possible reasons for the pending status: 1. Identity verification issue - They might need additional documentation to verify your identity 2. Work search requirement problems - Make sure you're documenting your work search activities properly 3. System flag for earnings - Did you report any part-time or gig income in recent certifications? 4. Random quarterly review - NYSDOL does random claim reviews, especially around quarter changes The most important thing is to actually speak with an agent. Keep trying different times of day - early morning (7:30am) and late afternoon (3:30pm) tend to have slightly better odds.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Thanks for this info. I haven't reported any income because I haven't had any. And I've been doing all my work searches (3 per week) and documenting them. Could it be because my former employer disputed something? How would I even know? I've tried calling at 8am, 10am, 12pm, 2pm... different times each day with no luck 😞
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Paolo Longo
same thing happend to me last month. didnt get paid for like 4 weeks then suddenly all the money showed up at once with no explanation. the system is broken af
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Did you do anything special to make the payments start again? Or did you just keep certifying and wait it out?
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Amina Bah
I was in your exact situation back in January. Five weeks of pending claims and couldn't reach anyone. Finally used a service called Claimyr that got me through to an actual person at NYSDOL. Cost money but was worth it because my case got resolved that same day - turned out they had flagged my account for a routine review but nobody had actually reviewed it. 🙄 The agent released all my back payments once I got through. You can see how it works in their demo video: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE or just go to claimyr.com
0 coins
Oliver Becker
Is that service actually legit?? Sounds kinda sketchy to pay something just to talk to unemployment...
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
CosmicCowboy
I think its a systematic issue in their computer system. My roommate had her unemployment stopped for 6 weeks then suddenly fixed. She called everyday, same as you getting nowhere. Then I had the same thing happen to me 3 weeks later! The trick is you need to keep certifying every week even when its pending so when they finally fix it you'll get all the backpay at once.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
This is excellent advice. Definitely continue certifying weekly without fail, even when payments are pending. Many people make the mistake of stopping their certifications when they don't see payments, which only compounds the problem.
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Amina Bah
@anonymous8 It's actually legit - they just connect you through their system to skip the wait. The unemployment office still answers, you just don't have to spend days trying to get through. They don't access your unemployment account or anything like that.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
I might try this if I can't get through in the next couple days. My landlord is already bugging me about rent and I'm getting really desperate.
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Natasha Orlova
LISTEN THIS HAPPENED TO ME TOO!! It's because they do these stupid "quarterly reviews" where they check if youre still eligible. The most ABSURD part is they don't tell you they're doing it!!! You just stop getting money with NO EXPLANATION! I was literally about to be evicted when my payments suddenly started again. The whole NY unemployment system is designed to frustrate people into giving up on benefits they DESERVE. Keep calling, keep certifying, and document EVERYTHING.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
This makes me so angry! Why wouldn't they at least notify us when they're doing a review? It's cruel to just cut people off without explanation when we're already struggling.
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Javier Cruz
The pending status often indicates one of two things: either there's a quarterly review happening (as others mentioned) or there's an eligibility issue that needs manual review. Here's what I recommend: 1. Log into your NY.gov account and check your messages folder - sometimes notices are sent there rather than by mail 2. Check if you've received any physical mail from NYSDOL that might explain the hold 3. Continue weekly certifications without fail 4. Try calling right when they open (7:30am) as that's when the queue is shortest If your employer filed any dispute or if there was any question about your eligibility, NYSDOL is required to send you written notice with appeal rights.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
the message system is useless tho. i had no messages the entire time my claim was pending and then after it was fixed i got like 3 messages all at once that were dated weeks earlier. its ridiculous
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Oliver Becker
I used that Claimyr thing last month and it worked for me too. Felt weird paying to talk to unemployment but I got through in like 20 minutes when I had been trying for days with no luck. Agent told me my account had some kind of fraud flag on it for no reason, and she removed it while I was on the phone.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Thanks for sharing your experience. At this point I'm willing to try almost anything. Did they explain why you got flagged for fraud?
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Oliver Becker
They said something about my IP address changing because I certified from my sister's house one week when I was staying with her. So stupid.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO ME TOO!!! I certified from my parents house ONE TIME and boom - account review that took 6 weeks to clear!!! They never even told me that was the reason until I finally got through to someone!
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Keisha Taylor
Just want to add one important tip - while your claim is pending, make sure you're keeping detailed records of your work search activities. If your claim gets manually reviewed, they might ask for this documentation going back several weeks. For each job application, save: - Company name - Position applied for - Date of application - Contact method (website, email, in-person) - Contact person's name if available - Any response received This level of documentation will help protect your benefits if there's any question about your work search efforts.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Thank you, I've been keeping a spreadsheet with most of this info but I'll make sure to add any missing details. I'm applying to at least 4-5 jobs every week even though they only require 3.
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
CosmicCowboy
has anyone tried the online message system? sometimes u can get answers there faster than calling
0 coins
Javier Cruz
The online message system typically takes 5-7 business days for a response, which isn't ideal for urgent payment issues. In my experience, a phone call is still the most effective way to resolve payment holds, even though it's frustratingly difficult to get through.
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...
Yara Khoury
UPDATE: I finally got through to someone at NYSDOL this morning! Called right at 7:30am and waited on hold for 1.5 hours. Turns out my account was flagged for a "quarterly review" like some of you mentioned AND because I had logged in from a different device (my tablet instead of my laptop). The agent cleared both flags and said all my pending payments should process within 3 business days. Will update again when/if I get paid. Thanks everyone for your help and suggestions!
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
That's great news! And unfortunately a very common situation. The system flags accounts for security reasons but then there aren't enough staff to promptly review the flagged accounts. Glad you finally got through and got it resolved!
0 coins
3d
Write a comment...