


Ask the community...
anyone else think its ridiculous that we pay taxes for decades and then when we need help they make it nearly impossible to actually get benefits? the whole system is designed to discourage people from collecting what they're owed. smh
It's by design. They make it hard so fewer people collect. Saves the state money.
Unemployment insurance is actually paid by employers not by your taxes directly. But I agree the system is intentionally frustrating.
Having effective days is definitely a positive sign - it means they've calculated your weekly benefit amount and determined you're monetarily eligible. The "pending" status is normal for first-time payments and usually clears within 3-5 business days after certification. However, there can still be non-monetary issues (like identity verification or employer response delays) that aren't always visible on the website. If it stays pending beyond a week, definitely try calling early morning around 8am or consider using one of those callback services people mentioned. The system is frustrating but hang in there - once the first payment goes through, subsequent ones are usually much smoother!
This is super helpful, thank you! I'm feeling a bit more optimistic now. I certified on Monday so I guess I'll wait until early next week before panicking. Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences - makes me feel less alone in this nightmare system 😅
yeah the job search thing is annoying but not hard to do. just apply to jobs online and log them in your weekly claim. took me like 10 minutes each week
Another thing to keep in mind is that your weekly benefit amount might be subject to federal taxes. NYS Department of Labor gives you the option to have 10% withheld for federal taxes when you certify each week, which can save you from owing a big chunk at tax time. I learned this the hard way my first time on unemployment - ended up owing about $1,200 in taxes because I didn't have anything withheld. The gross benefit amount stays the same but it's something to consider for your budgeting.
That's really helpful advice about the tax withholding! I hadn't even thought about that aspect. With my income level, I'm definitely going to opt for the 10% federal withholding to avoid any surprises come tax season. Better to get a smaller weekly amount than owe a bunch later. Thanks for sharing your experience - probably saved me from making the same mistake!
mine was only like 4 weeks but that was during the summer when things might have been slower
I went through this same situation last year and it's incredibly frustrating. My audit took about 10 weeks total. What helped me was keeping detailed records of every interaction and continuing to file weekly claims like others mentioned. One thing I learned is that sometimes audits get delayed because they're waiting on responses from your former employer - that was the case with mine. The system doesn't always tell you this is happening though. Hang in there, most people do eventually get their back pay once the audit clears. In the meantime, see if you qualify for any emergency assistance programs in your area to help with bills.
I went through this whole mess last year. Here's what I learned: Sometimes you exhaust regular UI but automatically qualify for other programs based on your situation. The system is terrible at communicating this though. When I finally got through to an agent (took forever), they told me I was eligible for an extension I didn't even know existed. Those 88 days might actually be usable!
This is such a frustrating situation! I went through something similar last year where I had exhausted my regular 26 weeks but kept seeing effective days in my account. Turns out I was eligible for Extended Benefits but the system doesn't automatically enroll you - you have to specifically ask about it when you talk to an agent. The 88 days you're seeing could potentially be real benefits if you qualify for certain programs, but the only way to know for sure is to get through to someone at the unemployment office. I know everyone's mentioning different ways to reach them, but definitely don't stop certifying weekly while you figure this out. The system penalizes you if there are gaps in your certifications even if you weren't sure you'd get paid. Hope you get some answers soon!
This is really helpful info! I'm in a similar boat - exhausted my regular benefits but seeing effective days. Did you have to do anything special to apply for Extended Benefits or did the agent just activate it for you once you spoke with them? Also wondering how long it took for payments to start coming through after they confirmed you were eligible?
Liam O'Reilly
I was in your exact shoes 2 months ago with NY unemployment. Here's what I learned: For some reason, getting clear info about what to do when benefits run out is nearly impossible on their website or through the automated systems. The ONLY way to get accurate info about your specific situation is to talk to a live representative. But as we all know, getting through to NY unemployment by phone is like winning the lottery. I spent DAYS trying to get through with no luck. I finally broke down and used claimyr.com which basically automated the calling process for me. They kept dialing until they got through, then connected me to the agent. Once I got an actual human on the phone, they told me exactly what to do for my situation (which turned out to be different than what their website implied). It was worth every penny to finally get clear answers and get my new claim properly filed. Don't waste time trying to figure it out from their website - the info there is vague at best and misleading at worst. Talk to a human ASAP.
0 coins
Ava Harris
•not falling for another unemployment 'hack'... these never work
0 coins
Liam O'Reilly
•Think what you want, but when you've been on hold for 6+ hours over multiple days you might change your mind. Not everyone has unlimited time to waste on hold.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
I was in almost the exact same situation last year - hotel industry layoffs hit hard and the job market has been absolutely brutal. Here's what I wish someone had told me: you need to figure out if your benefit year is ending soon or if you've just exhausted your weekly allotment. If your benefit year still has months left but you're out of weeks, you're unfortunately stuck in a gap until the year ends. But if your benefit year is ending soon, you can file a new claim right away. The website makes this distinction super unclear on purpose it seems. Also, keep certifying every week even if you're not getting paid - this helps with backdating later. I know everyone's saying call them but honestly after trying for weeks, I ended up using one of those callback services people mentioned and finally got through to someone who explained my options. Don't panic too much - there are usually more options than their terrible website makes it seem like, but you need to talk to an actual person to find out what applies to your specific situation.
0 coins