


Ask the community...
The system is so rigged in favor of employers. They know most people can't afford lawyers to fight back so they just lie with impunity. Even if you win your unemployment case, there's rarely any consequences for them providing false information. It's infuriating but that's the reality.
If you have clear documentation showing they told you it was performance-related and now they're claiming misconduct, that's strong evidence of inconsistent statements. Document everything - save those emails, keep copies of your termination paperwork, and write down dates and details of any conversations you remember. During the adjudication process, present this evidence clearly and chronologically. While suing for defamation is theoretically possible, it's expensive and hard to prove damages beyond the unemployment benefits. Your best bet is to focus on winning the unemployment case first - if you can show their story changed, the adjudicator will likely rule in your favor.
This is really helpful advice. I'm wondering though - if I do win the unemployment case and can clearly prove they lied, would that strengthen any potential defamation case? It seems like having an official ruling that their statements were false might make it easier to prove they knowingly provided incorrect information.
also dont forget to certify every week going forward, not just the back weeks. i think the deadline is sunday but check your account
Just went through this exact same process last month! A few tips that helped me: 1) You can definitely claim all 6 weeks retroactively - that's what the system is designed for. 2) When you're filling out the weekly certifications, take your time with each one because you can't go back and edit them once submitted. 3) For the work search requirement, even if you didn't keep perfect records during adjudication, be honest about what you remember doing - checking job boards, updating your resume, etc. all count. 4) The first payment usually takes about 2-3 business days after you certify, but subsequent weeks are faster. Don't panic if there's a slight delay on the first one. You've got this!
I went through this exact situation when I moved from NY to PA about 8 months ago. Here's what actually happened: You cannot transfer benefits between states - you'll need to file a completely new claim in PA once you establish residency there. The good news is that PA will use your NY work history to calculate your benefits, but the bad news is their weekly benefit amounts are typically lower than NY's. Make sure you do a few things before you move: 1) Report your address change to NY unemployment immediately through your online account, 2) Complete your final weekly certification in NY, and 3) Apply for PA benefits as soon as you're eligible (usually after establishing residency). There will likely be a gap in payments - mine was about 3 weeks. PA's system is slower than NY's (if you can believe that). Also, be prepared for PA to have different job search requirements than what you're used to in NY. One last tip - if you're having trouble reaching NY unemployment by phone to properly close out your claim, I had success using a callback service that eliminated the endless hold times. It's worth it to make sure everything is handled correctly to avoid any fraud issues later.
This is super helpful, thank you! 3 weeks gap is rough but at least I know what to expect now. When you say "callback service" - are you talking about that claimyr thing other people mentioned? I'm willing to try anything at this point to avoid the phone runaround.
Yes, exactly - I used claimyr.com when I needed to reach NY unemployment to close my claim properly. It was honestly a lifesaver because I was getting nowhere calling on my own. They handle the waiting on hold part and then connect you when an agent picks up. Definitely worth it to make sure your transition is handled correctly and avoid any potential issues down the line.
I'm going through a similar situation right now - just started the process of moving from NY to PA while on unemployment. From what I've researched and heard from others here, you definitely can't transfer benefits directly between states. Each state has its own system and rules. What I'm planning to do: 1) Call NY unemployment ASAP to report my move (using that claimyr service everyone's mentioning since I can't get through either), 2) File for PA benefits as soon as I establish residency there, and 3) prepare financially for a gap in payments. One thing I learned from reading through these comments - make sure you're crystal clear about your availability for work when talking to NY unemployment. If you can still commute back to NY for jobs, there might be interstate benefit options, but if you're moving too far into PA, you'll need to start fresh with their system. The IP address flagging thing someone mentioned is scary - definitely don't want to get accused of fraud on top of everything else. Going to make sure I handle the transition properly even if it means a few weeks without income. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences, this thread has been incredibly helpful!
This is such a helpful summary of everything! I'm in the exact same boat and was feeling overwhelmed by all the conflicting info online. The IP address fraud thing is definitely something I wouldn't have thought of - glad people are mentioning that. I'm also going to try that claimyr service since it seems like multiple people here have had success with it. Better to pay a small fee than waste weeks trying to get through on my own. Thanks for putting together such a clear action plan!
Final update for anyone who finds this post later: My claim was approved! It took 5 days, not the 2-3 the agent initially said, but that's still way better than waiting for weeks. I got the determination letter today and my first payment should be processed next week. The key really was talking to an actual person who could understand my specific situation. Thanks everyone for your help and advice!
Congratulations on getting approved! This thread is super helpful for anyone dealing with the furlough-to-termination situation. I'm bookmarking this for future reference. It's crazy how the system can be so inconsistent - some people wait weeks while others get approved in days. Really shows the importance of getting the right agent who understands these edge cases. Thanks for sharing your updates throughout the process!
This thread has been so educational! I'm currently on furlough myself and have been dreading the possibility of getting that termination letter. It's reassuring to know that there are provisions for our situation, even though the process seems so inconsistent. The fact that @CosmicVoyager got approved gives me hope. I'm definitely saving the info about Claimyr too - seems like having an actual agent who understands these edge cases makes all the difference. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences here!
Freya Pedersen
just file asap and see what you get! took me 3 weeks to get my first payment but it was worth the wait. make sure you do your weekly claims every sunday
0 coins
StarStrider
One thing to keep in mind is that you'll need to report any severance pay you received when you file - that can delay when your benefits start. Also, if you're planning to do any freelance or part-time work while collecting, you need to report those earnings each week. They'll reduce your benefit amount dollar-for-dollar after the first $143 you earn in a week. The whole process can be confusing but definitely file sooner rather than later since there's usually a waiting period.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Great point about the severance pay! I actually did get a small severance package - about 2 weeks worth. Does anyone know if that completely blocks benefits until it's "used up" or if it just delays the start date? I'm trying to figure out my timeline here since I need to start looking for work but also want to make sure I don't mess up the unemployment process.
0 coins