


Ask the community...
Just went through this myself last month. File today if you can - the earlier you file, the earlier your effective date starts. Even if they determine you're not eligible initially, you can appeal and if you win the appeal, you'll get backpay from your original filing date. Don't wait!
I went through something similar when I was terminated for "performance issues" after reporting wage violations to HR. My advice: file immediately and be completely honest about the safety complaints you made. NYS DOL actually protects workers who report safety violations under whistleblower laws, so mentioning that complaint could actually help your case rather than hurt it. When I filed, I included all the details about my complaint and the timeline - it showed a clear pattern of retaliation. The adjudicator sided with me because the timing was too suspicious. Also, keep records of everything related to the unsafe conditions you reported - emails, photos, witness names, dates. This documentation could be crucial if your employer contests the claim.
This is incredibly helpful advice! I hadn't thought about the whistleblower protection angle. Do you happen to know if there's a specific timeline for when retaliation cases are strongest? Like, if I was fired the day after complaining about safety issues versus a week later, does that make a difference in how NYS DOL views it? I'm trying to figure out how to present my case since there was only about 3 days between when I reported the unsafe ladder situation and when they terminated me for "performance.
I'm in a similar situation and just went through this process last month. The harsh reality is that without any work during your benefit year, you won't qualify for a new regular unemployment claim in NY. You need to have earned at least 10x your weekly benefit amount in covered employment during your base period. However, here's what I learned that might help: 1. Apply anyway - sometimes there are system glitches or overlooked wages that could work in your favor 2. If denied, you have the right to appeal within 30 days 3. Ask specifically about the 597 hardship review form when you call (as mentioned by The Boss above) 4. Start applying for emergency assistance NOW - SNAP, HEAP, emergency rental assistance through your county 5. Contact your local One-Stop Career Center - they sometimes have emergency funds or job placement programs 6. Look into temporary staffing agencies - even short-term work could help you qualify for future claims The system is absolutely broken and designed to discourage people from getting help. Don't let that stop you from fighting for what you need. Document everything, keep records of all your job applications, and don't give up. You've made it this far - you're stronger than you know.
Thank you Benjamin, this is incredibly thorough and helpful! I had no idea about the One-Stop Career Centers or that they might have emergency funds. I'm definitely going to look into that along with the 597 form. It's frustrating that these resources aren't more widely advertised - feels like you have to know someone who knows someone to find out about them. I really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and give such detailed advice. It gives me hope that there might be some options I haven't explored yet.
I went through this exact situation last year and it's absolutely terrifying when you're facing the end of benefits with no work history. The reality is NY does require wages during your benefit year to qualify for a new claim, BUT don't lose hope completely. Here's what worked for me: 1. Applied anyway (got denied as expected) 2. Immediately appealed the denial 3. During the appeal process, I got connected with a local workforce development program that helped with emergency rent assistance 4. Found a part-time gig through a temp agency - even just a few weeks of work can sometimes help establish eligibility The appeals process bought me crucial time to find other resources. Also, call 211 - they have a database of local emergency assistance programs that many people don't know about. Some churches and community organizations also have emergency funds. I know it feels hopeless right now, but there are more safety nets than it initially appears. You just have to dig deeper to find them. Don't give up - you deserve support while you keep searching for work in this brutal job market.
Moving within state is fine but PLEASE update your address immediately. I forgot to update mine when I moved and it caused a delay in my benefits because they couldn't verify my identity during a routine check.
Just went through this exact situation! Moved from Manhattan to Albany in January while on unemployment. The process is super straightforward - just log into your NY.gov account and update your address in the "Personal Information" section. I also updated it during my weekly certification just to be safe. My benefits continued without any interruption. The only thing to keep in mind is that you still need to be actively searching for work and available to accept employment, so make sure you can realistically commute to job opportunities in your field. Since you mentioned you can commute back to NYC if needed, you should be totally fine. Good luck with the move!
This is really helpful, thank you! I was getting worried about nothing. One quick question - when you say you updated it during your weekly certification "just to be safe," do you mean there's a specific section for address changes in the weekly claim form, or did you just make sure your profile was updated before filing that week?
Everyone blaming the unemployed when the real problem is how CONFUSING they make the whole tax system on purpose!! 😤
big facts. they could send clear instructions but noooo, gotta make it impossible to understand so they can collect penalties
Same thing happened to me! Got hit with a $920 bill for my 2021 benefits. I was SO confused because I swear the news made it sound like ALL unemployment was tax-free during the pandemic. Turns out it was just 2020. I ended up calling the tax department (took forever to get through) and they confirmed it's legit. The agent told me they've been getting hundreds of calls about this exact issue. I'm doing a payment plan now - $85/month for 12 months. Still sucks but at least it's manageable. Don't ignore it though, the penalties add up fast!
Tyler Lefleur
Just want to add that timing matters here too. Don't let too much time pass between when your disability ends and when you file for unemployment. There are specific timeframes you need to follow, and delays can affect your claim approval.
0 coins
Logan Scott
I went through this exact situation about 8 months ago with a knee injury. The most important thing is that you absolutely cannot collect both disability and unemployment simultaneously - it's considered fraud. You need medical clearance stating you're able to work before you can file for UI benefits. What worked for me was getting a detailed letter from my doctor specifying exactly what I could and couldn't do (like no lifting over 20 lbs, no standing for more than 2 hours, etc.). Then when my employer couldn't accommodate those restrictions, I was able to file for unemployment. Just make sure you keep all your medical documentation organized because NYS Department of Labor will likely request it during the review process.
0 coins
StarStrider
•This is exactly the kind of detailed advice I was looking for! Thank you for sharing your experience. Did you have any issues with the timing between when your disability ended and when you filed for unemployment? I'm worried about any gaps in coverage while I'm waiting for my doctor to clear me for work.
0 coins