


Ask the community...
I feel your pain! I had the same issue a few months ago and was getting nowhere with the regular phone lines. What finally saved me was contacting my local assemblyperson's office - they have a constituent services department that can sometimes help expedite unemployment issues. I called my assembly member's district office, explained the situation, and they were able to reach out to the DOL on my behalf. Got a call back from a DOL supervisor within 3 days and my payment hold was resolved that same week. You can find your assemblyperson here: https://nyassembly.gov/mem/search/ Worth a shot while you're also trying the phone strategies others mentioned. Sometimes going through an elected official's office gets better results than the regular channels. Make sure to mention that your employer is contesting and you need to provide your side of the story about the hour reduction - that shows it's not just a routine inquiry.
This is brilliant advice! I never thought about contacting my assemblyperson's office. It makes sense that they would have more direct channels to the DOL. I'm definitely going to try this alongside all the phone strategies everyone has shared. Having someone advocate on your behalf when you're dealing with a contested claim seems like it could really make a difference. Thank you for sharing this - and for including the link to find my assemblyperson!
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now - my claim has been pending for 3 weeks after my employer disputed it. Based on all the advice here, I'm going to try a combination approach: calling at 8:05am on Wednesday using the "technical support" option, and if that doesn't work within a few days, I'll contact my assemblyperson's office. For anyone else reading this thread later, it seems like the key strategies are: - Call at off-peak times (8:03-8:05am, Tuesday/Wednesday, or 1:15pm) - Try different menu options ("technical support" vs "claim status") - Use registered phone number - Have all documentation ready - Consider Claimyr service as backup - Contact assemblyperson's office for contested claims Alice, I hope you get through soon - the reduced hours situation should definitely qualify you for benefits under constructive discharge rules once you can explain it to someone. Keep us posted on what works!
This is such a helpful summary of all the strategies! I'm saving this list. It's crazy that we need this many workarounds just to reach someone who can help with our legitimate claims. I've been following this thread since Alice posted and it's both frustrating and reassuring to see how many people are dealing with the same issues. The assemblyperson contact idea seems especially smart for contested claims where you really need to speak to someone who understands the nuances. Thanks for organizing all this advice in one place - definitely going to bookmark this for future reference!
The whole unemployment tax thing is so confusing. I thought government benefits weren't supposed to be taxed? Like why do they give you money and then want some back??
Just wanted to add that you can also make estimated quarterly tax payments if you're worried about owing too much at the end of the year. Since you mentioned receiving about $8,000 in benefits, you might owe around $800-1,200 in federal taxes (depending on your tax bracket) plus whatever NY state taxes apply. If you're still collecting, definitely turn on the 10% federal withholding ASAP. And don't stress too much - this catches a lot of people off guard their first time dealing with unemployment taxes!
This is really helpful - I had no idea about the quarterly payment option! Since I'm about 4 months into collecting, would it make sense to make a quarterly payment now for what I've already received, or should I just turn on withholding going forward and deal with the tax bill when I file? Also, is there a penalty for not having taxes withheld from the beginning?
Just to add - make sure you understand the difference between state unemployment and federal unemployment taxes too. Even if you don't pay state unemployment on yourself, you still might have other tax obligations depending on your business structure and income level.
Great point about federal vs state taxes! As someone who just went through setting up my own LLC last year, I learned this the hard way. Even though I don't pay state unemployment on myself as a single-member LLC, I still had to deal with federal self-employment taxes and quarterly estimated payments. The IRS and NYS Department of Labor have completely different requirements, which adds another layer of confusion. Definitely recommend talking to a tax professional early on to avoid surprises at tax time.
This is exactly what I needed to hear! I was so focused on the unemployment insurance question that I didn't even think about the federal side of things. Did you end up having to make quarterly payments your first year, or were you able to wait until tax time? I'm trying to figure out if I need to start setting money aside now or if I have more time to get organized.
This exact thing happen to me and there was a ERROR in there system. When I finally got through to an agent (used claimyr.com) they fixed it on the spot. Turns out my employer reported my wages but they weren't showing up right in the system. Don't give up!!
Have you tried requesting your wage and benefit statement directly from the unemployment office? Sometimes there are discrepancies between what your employer reported and what shows up in their system. I had a similar issue where my wages weren't properly credited to the right quarters, and it took getting an actual person on the phone to manually review and correct it. Also, make sure they're considering ALL your employment - if you had multiple jobs or worked in different states, sometimes those wages don't get automatically included. The processing status probably means they're still reviewing your case, so don't lose hope yet!
This is really solid advice! I hadn't thought about requesting the wage statement directly. I'm definitely going to do that and also double-check if they have all my employment info correct. The fact that it's still showing "processing" online while I got a denial letter is so confusing - maybe there really is some kind of system error going on. Thanks for giving me hope that this might still work out!
I actually had a very similar situation last year where my wages weren't showing up correctly in their system even though my employer had reported everything. Turns out there was a lag in how they processed multi-employer wage reports. When I finally got through to someone (took forever!), they were able to see the wages in their back-end system but they hadn't been properly applied to my claim yet. The agent said this happens more often than people think, especially if you switched jobs recently or had overlapping employment periods. Definitely request that wage statement and don't be afraid to push back if the numbers don't match what you know you earned!
Jackie Martinez
I'm in a similar boat at week 19 and this thread is really helpful! Just want to add that I found out you can actually see your exact benefit year end date and remaining weeks when you log into your my.ny.gov account under the "View Benefit Payments" section. It shows both your monetary balance AND your week counter, which cleared up the confusion I had about whether it's the money or the weeks that matter (it's the weeks). Also, for anyone struggling with the phone system, I've had better luck calling right at 8am when they open or during lunch time around 12:30-1pm. Still takes forever but at least I don't get the busy signal immediately.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
•This is super helpful Jackie! I didn't know about the "View Benefit Payments" section showing the week counter - I've been obsessing over just the dollar amount. Going to check that out right now. And thanks for the phone tips too, I've been calling at random times and always getting busy signals. Really appreciate you sharing the specific times that work better!
0 coins
Ava Johnson
Just wanted to share my experience since I went through this exact situation last year. Hit my 26 week limit in March 2024 and benefits stopped even though I still had like $800 left in my monetary balance. That was confusing at first but the 26 week rule is firm. After my benefit year ended (the full 52 weeks from when I first filed), I was able to file a new claim since I had worked part-time for a few months and earned enough wages to qualify again. The waiting period for the new claim was shorter than my original application too. Don't panic when you hit week 26 - start planning for other income sources or assistance programs, and keep track of any work you do because it might help you qualify for a new claim later. The job market has been tough but there are resources out there if you know where to look.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
•Thank you so much for sharing your real experience Ava! This is exactly what I needed to hear. I'm at week 20 now and have been stressing about that $800+ still sitting in my balance - I had no idea it would just disappear when I hit 26 weeks. Really helpful to know that you were able to file a new claim after your benefit year ended too. Can I ask what kind of part-time work you did and roughly how much you needed to earn to qualify for the new claim? I'm wondering if I should start looking for some temporary work now even if it's just a few hours a week to build up wages for a potential future claim.
0 coins