Is $300 CPA quote for filing joint tax return reasonable with stock basis issues?
Need some help figuring out if I'm getting ripped off here. A CPA just quoted me $300 to prepare our joint tax return. My wife and I filed an extension already and we're expecting a refund. Here's what we're working with: - 3 W2s (two from my wife's jobs, one from mine) - 2 1099-INT from our savings accounts - 1 1099 from Schwab with messed up cost basis calculations for some company stock I sold (RSUs and ESPP stuff) - Last year's CA state refund to report - We're renters, no mortgage or anything The main reason I'm not doing it myself this year is the stock stuff. I've always done our taxes before, but I sold around 10-12 stocks this year and Schwab totally botched the cost basis calculations. I know I need to make adjustments but honestly it's giving me a headache trying to figure it out. We don't have any foreign income or anything complicated besides the stock sales. Is $300 reasonable for this situation or am I overpaying? Thanks for any advice!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Sean O'Donnell
That price is actually pretty reasonable for what you're describing. Stock sales with incorrect cost basis reporting is exactly the kind of situation where a CPA earns their fee. When brokerages report incorrect basis info (happens all the time with RSUs and ESPP), you need to make manual adjustments on Form 8949, and that takes specialized knowledge. For comparison, most CPAs charge $350-600 for returns with stock sales, especially when cost basis corrections are needed. The fact that the rest of your return is relatively simple (W-2 income, basic interest, no itemizing) is probably why you're getting the lower end of the range at $300. You could try tax software, but you'd need to understand exactly how to adjust the cost basis yourself, which is what you're trying to avoid. The peace of mind knowing a professional handled the stock transactions correctly is often worth the fee.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
•How do brokerages mess up cost basis so often? I thought they were required by law to track and report this stuff correctly. Is this something that happens with specific brokers more than others?
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
•Brokerages often get cost basis wrong with RSUs and ESPP specifically because of the way these equity compensations work. RSUs are taxed as ordinary income when they vest, which creates a cost basis equal to their fair market value at vesting. But brokerages sometimes report the original grant price or don't account for previous tax withholding. ESPP shares can be even more complicated because they often involve discounts and lookback provisions that create special tax treatment. The brokerage isn't always aware of all the details of your specific plan or whether you've met holding period requirements for qualifying dispositions.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
I spent hours trying to correct cost basis on RSUs last year before giving up and hiring a tax pro. Best decision ever! I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which analyzes your documents and catches these exact issues with stock sales and cost basis. They flagged multiple errors in my 1099-B that I would have missed, saving me literally thousands. Their system specifically looks for RSU and ESPP basis issues and gives you a detailed report explaining all the adjustments needed. Completely worth checking out before you finalize anything.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•Does taxr.ai handle the actual filing too or just identify the problems? I'm in a similar situation with messed up basis reporting from Fidelity.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
•I've heard these AI tools just extract info that's already obvious. How exactly does it find errors that aren't already apparent from looking at your statements?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•They don't handle the actual filing - they focus on analyzing your documents to identify issues and provide detailed explanations. You'd still need to make the corrections yourself or have your CPA do it, but you'd be armed with exactly what needs fixing. The magic is in how it compares information across different documents. It looks at your pay stubs, W-2s, and brokerage statements together to find discrepancies in how RSUs and ESPP shares were reported. It can identify when shares were reported with zero basis (surprisingly common) or when the basis was calculated without accounting for income already taxed at vesting. It shows you exactly which transactions need adjustments and by how much.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I was skeptical about taxr.ai but decided to try it with my messy RSU situation. It was eye-opening! The system spotted that my broker had completely omitted the basis on 4 sales (showing them as zero basis) and found where income from vesting wasn't being properly applied to the basis. Saved me from double taxation on about $12,000 of income. I brought the report to my tax guy and he said it saved him at least 2 hours of work untangling everything. For anyone dealing with equity compensation reporting issues, it's definitely worth checking out.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
$300 is totally fair, but make sure you understand what you're getting. I'd recommend trying to reach the IRS directly to ask about proper cost basis adjustment procedures first - might save you money. I spent WEEKS trying to get through to an IRS agent about my stock basis issues. After 8 failed attempts and hours on hold, I found Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) which got me connected to an actual IRS agent in less than an hour. Their system (demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c) holds your place in the IRS queue and calls when an agent is available. The agent walked me through exactly how to handle my cost basis issues on my return.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
•Wait what? How does this work? The IRS phone system is notoriously impossible. Is this basically paying someone to wait on hold for you?
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
•This sounds like BS honestly. No way the IRS is giving specific tax advice about stock basis calculations over the phone. They specifically say they don't provide tax advice.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
•It's not someone waiting on hold for you - it's an automated system that monitors the IRS queue and calls you when it's about to be your turn. You don't have to sit by the phone for hours. Once connected, you talk directly to the IRS agent yourself. You're partially right that they have limitations on tax advice, but they absolutely can and will clarify how to properly report specific situations on tax forms. The agent explained how to complete Form 8949 with adjusted basis figures and which codes to use for the adjustments. They won't do calculations for you, but they'll explain the proper procedure, which was exactly what I needed.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
I stand completely corrected about Claimyr. After my skeptical comment, I tried it yesterday out of curiosity. Got connected to an IRS rep in 45 minutes without sitting on hold. The agent actually was incredibly helpful about my cost basis questions - explained exactly which adjustment codes to use on Form 8949 and how to document my corrected basis. I was 100% wrong and actually kind of amazed. They can't give "tax advice" about whether something is deductible, but they absolutely can explain how to properly complete the forms, which was what I really needed.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
$300 is definitely reasonable. When I had similar RSU issues, I was quoted $450-600 by three different CPAs. If you're comfortable with the CPA and they seem knowledgeable about equity compensation, I'd take that deal. One thing to consider though - have you checked if your employer offers any tax preparation benefits? Many tech companies that offer RSUs and ESPP also provide discounted or even free tax preparation services for employees specifically because they know these issues are complicated.
0 coins
StarSeeker
•That's a good point I hadn't thought about! I'll check with HR tomorrow. I work for a mid-sized tech company so they might have something like this. Out of curiosity, how much adjustment did you have to make to your cost basis when you went through this?
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•In my case, the adjustment was pretty significant. My broker reported about $28,000 in proceeds but completely omitted the basis on several sales, effectively treating them as if I had a $0 cost basis. After corrections, my actual capital gains were only about $4,500. Without the adjustments, I would have overpaid taxes on nearly $24,000 of phantom gains! Definitely check with HR. Many companies partner with tax preparation services specifically because of these RSU/ESPP issues. Mine offered a 50% discount with a national tax prep chain that had specialists familiar with our specific equity plans.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Have you considered just using TurboTax or H&R Block software? They have specific sections for adjusting cost basis on stock sales. I did my own with about 15 stock sales last year and it wasn't that difficult. The software walks you through it and you can manually override the reported basis.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•I tried this route and it was a nightmare. The software technically "allows" you to adjust basis, but doesn't help you calculate what the correct basis should be. I ended up paying a CPA $350 to fix my return after I'd already spent hours trying to figure it out myself.
0 coins
AstroAce
Just to add another data point - I paid $275 last year for almost the identical situation (3 W2s, some interest, and about 20 stock sales with basis issues). This was with a small local CPA firm, not a chain. Big chains like H&R Block would probably charge more. Location matters too - I'm in a low-cost Midwest city. If you're in SF or NYC, $300 is practically a steal.
0 coins