


Ask the community...
My tax preparer told me that if your businesses are in the same "general field" you can file them together, but if they're completely different, you should file separately. She gave the example that her client who has a therapy practice and also does public speaking about mental health files on one Schedule C because they're in the same field. But her client who is both a dentist and owns a car wash files two separate Schedule Cs because those are totally unrelated businesses.
The "general field" rule that Emily mentioned is a good way to think about it. Your guitar performance and repair work definitely fall into the same general field of music/instruments, so you're absolutely fine continuing with one Schedule C. I'm a tax preparer and see this situation a lot. The IRS isn't going to split hairs over whether playing guitar and fixing guitars are "different enough" to require separate filings - they're clearly related activities that complement each other. One thing to consider is keeping internal records that separate the income and expenses for each activity, even if you're filing them together. This makes it easier if you ever need to analyze the profitability of each service or if the IRS has questions during an audit. You can do this with something as simple as different categories in your accounting software. The fact that you've been filing this way for years without any issues from the IRS is a good sign that your approach is reasonable and defensible.
This is really reassuring to hear from an actual tax preparer! I've been keeping pretty detailed records in QuickBooks with different categories for performance income vs repair income, so it sounds like I'm already doing what you recommend. One quick follow-up question - when you mention keeping internal records separated, do you mean I should also track mileage separately for each activity? Right now I just lump all my business driving together since I'm often doing both activities on the same trip (like picking up a guitar for repair on my way to a gig).
One thing nobody has mentioned: KDP (kindle direct publishing) and other platforms will send a 1099-K if your husband makes over $600, and that gets reported to the IRS. they expect to see that income on your return somewhere. If you report as hobby, make sure you list "self-published book" in the description so it matches the 1099. Nothing triggers audits faster than income reported to IRS that doesn't show up on your return!
As someone who went through this exact decision last year with my husband's self-published poetry collection, I'd strongly recommend going with Schedule C from the start. Here's what I learned: Even though we had minimal expenses (just some basic editing software and a simple book cover), treating it as a business allowed us to deduct a portion of our home office, internet costs, and even mileage to a local bookstore event. These small deductions added up. The record-keeping really isn't as scary as it seems - I just use a simple Excel spreadsheet with columns for date, description, amount, and category. Takes maybe 10 minutes a month to update. Most importantly, starting with Schedule C gives you flexibility. If your husband's book takes off and he decides to write more, you're already set up properly. If it stays small, no harm done - you're just getting legitimate tax benefits you'd miss with hobby classification. The key is showing profit motive, which it sounds like you have - he completed and published the book with the intent to sell it. That's business activity, not just a hobby. Don't overthink it!
This is really helpful! I'm completely new to all of this and feeling overwhelmed by the business vs. hobby decision. Your point about showing profit motive makes sense - my husband did put effort into making the book professionally presentable and we definitely hope it sells. I'm curious about the home office deduction you mentioned. We don't have a dedicated office space, but he does have a corner of our bedroom where he does his writing. Would that still qualify, or does it need to be a completely separate room? And how do you calculate what portion of internet costs are deductible? Also, when you say "no harm done" if it stays small - are there any downsides to filing Schedule C for a very small income? Like does it increase audit risk or anything like that?
Don't forget you can deduct expenses even for those small gigs! I did face painting at birthday parties last year - all under $600 per client - and was able to deduct all my supplies, travel costs to events, and even a portion of my phone bill for taking bookings. It actually made a big difference and almost cancelled out the taxes I would have owed on that income!
what software did you use to file? i tried using [popular tax software] last year and got super confused about where to put all my little odd jobs.
The $600 threshold is actually just an administrative rule for businesses - it determines when they have to send YOU a 1099 and report the payment to the IRS. But you're absolutely correct that you still need to report ALL income regardless of whether you get a form or not. Here's what I do to stay organized: I created a simple spreadsheet with columns for date, client/company name, description of work, and amount paid. I also keep screenshots of payment confirmations (Venmo, PayPal, Zelle, etc.) and any invoices I send. This creates a paper trail that satisfies the IRS if they ever ask questions. The key thing to remember is that unreported income can come back to bite you later. Even though the company didn't send you a 1099, they might still deduct that payment as a business expense on their taxes, which could create a mismatch if you don't report it as income on yours. Also, once your total self-employment income hits $400 (from all sources combined), you'll need to pay self-employment tax on it, so it's worth tracking everything carefully even if individual payments seem small.
This is really helpful! I'm new to all this tax stuff and was wondering - when you mention that companies might deduct payments as business expenses even if they don't send a 1099, does that mean the IRS could potentially flag me if there's a mismatch? Like if Company X deducts $400 they paid me but I "forgot" to report it as income, would that automatically trigger some kind of audit or investigation? Also, do you happen to know if there's a statute of limitations on this kind of thing? I'm worried I might have missed reporting some small payments from 2024 that I honestly just forgot about until reading this thread.
Does anyone know if TurboTax handles the backdoor Roth contribution/conversion correctly? I've heard horror stories about tax software messing this up and people getting unexpected tax bills.
Thanks! That's helpful. I contributed and converted on the same day, so I think there weren't any earnings. But I'll check my statements just to be sure. Do you happen to know which section in TurboTax I need to go to? I've been poking around but can't seem to find where to enter the non-deductible contribution specifically.
In TurboTax, you'll want to look for the "Retirement Plans and Social Security" section, then select "IRA, 401(k), Pension Plan Withdrawals (1099-R)". When you enter your Roth conversion there, it should also prompt you about whether you made any traditional IRA contributions during the year. Alternatively, you can go to "Deductions & Credits" and look for "Retirement Plans" or "IRA Deduction" - this is where you can specifically indicate that you made a non-deductible traditional IRA contribution. Make sure to answer "No" when it asks if you want to deduct the contribution, and "Yes" when it asks if you made the contribution with after-tax dollars. The key is making sure both transactions (the non-deductible contribution AND the conversion) are properly recorded so Form 8606 gets completed accurately.
Great question! I went through this exact same confusion when I first started doing backdoor Roth conversions. Your traditional IRA basis should indeed be $0 at the end of each tax year since you're converting the entire contribution amount. Here's what's happening: You make a $6,500 non-deductible contribution (this creates basis), then immediately convert that $6,500 to Roth (this removes the basis from your traditional IRA and moves it to your Roth). So while you temporarily have basis when you make the contribution, it gets zeroed out when you do the conversion. The important thing is to file Form 8606 each year to document both the non-deductible contribution and the conversion. This creates a proper paper trail for the IRS. In TurboTax, make sure you enter both transactions - the non-deductible IRA contribution AND the Roth conversion separately. The software should automatically generate the Form 8606 for you. Keep copies of your Form 8606 for each year, along with your IRA statements showing the contributions and conversions. This documentation will be crucial if you ever get audited or have questions down the road.
This is really helpful! I'm new to the backdoor Roth strategy and was getting confused by all the basis terminology. So if I understand correctly, the basis is kind of like a "temporary" thing that exists just during the tax year between when you make the contribution and when you convert it? Also, when you mention keeping copies of Form 8606 - should I be keeping these indefinitely, or is there a certain number of years that's sufficient for IRS purposes?
Zoe Dimitriou
Has anyone tried using QuickBooks for self-managed HOA accounting? We're in the same situation and trying to figure out the best way to track the reserve contributions separately from regular expenses.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
ā¢We've been using QuickBooks for our self-managed HOA for about 3 years now. It works pretty well if you set up separate accounts for operating and reserves. We created an equity account called "Reserve Fund" and when we transfer money to reserves, we record it as a transfer, not an expense. This keeps everything clear for tax purposes. Make sure to also create separate bank accounts (operating vs reserve) to maintain the proper separation of funds. This makes it much easier when you need to demonstrate to the IRS that the reserves are properly designated through member approval.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
ā¢Thanks for the tip about setting up a separate equity account! That makes a lot of sense. Do you also track future reserve expenses somehow? Like we know we'll need a new roof in about 5 years, so I'm wondering if there's a way to plan for that in the system.
0 coins
Aria Washington
For future reserve expense planning in QuickBooks, I recommend creating a simple spreadsheet outside of QB to track your long-term capital projects and their estimated costs/timelines. We maintain a "Reserve Study" spreadsheet that lists each major component (roof, HVAC, pavement, etc.), estimated replacement costs, and target dates. In QuickBooks itself, we just track the actual reserve transfers as equity movements like @QuantumQuest mentioned. When it's time to actually spend the reserve money (like for that roof replacement), you'd record it as a regular expense and transfer the funds back from the reserve equity account to operating. This approach keeps your QB records clean for tax purposes while still giving you visibility into whether you're saving enough for future needs. The key is making sure your annual member vote to transfer excess funds to reserves is properly documented in your meeting minutes - that's what satisfies the IRS requirements regardless of how you track it in your accounting software.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
ā¢This is really helpful! I'm new to managing HOA finances and the spreadsheet idea makes perfect sense for long-term planning. Quick question - when you do the annual member vote to transfer excess funds to reserves, do you need a specific percentage of homeowners to approve it, or is a simple majority sufficient? Our HOA bylaws don't specifically address reserve fund votes, so I want to make sure we're doing this correctly from both a legal and tax perspective.
0 coins