
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I've been building up a decent amount in my HSA account and plan to save receipts for qualified medical expenses that I might want to reimburse myself for years down the road. My question is pretty straightforward - is it acceptable to scan these receipts and throw away the originals? I've already got a stack of pharmacy receipts, doctor visit copays, and prescription slips that's getting unwieldy. I really don't want to keep a shoebox full of fading paper receipts for the next decade, but I also don't want to get in trouble if I ever need to prove these expenses to the IRS. Does anyone know if digital copies are sufficient for HSA reimbursement documentation?
So I screwed up last year and didn't withdraw my full Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) amount. I realized my mistake and withdrew the remaining amount in January this year, which should be within the correction window. But now I'm completely confused about how to fill out Form 5329 with these new line items. I see there's now an "a" and "b" for lines 52 and 53, and I'm trying to figure out what numbers go where: 1. For line 52a - should I enter the full RMD amount I was supposed to withdraw? Like if I needed to take out $13,500 from my IRA last year, do I put $13,500 on line 52a? 2. For line 52b - It says "from all other plans" - does this mean non-qualified plans since 52a is for qualified plans? I only have an inherited IRA and inherited Roth, which I think are qualified plans, so would this be zero? 3. For line 53a - I'm completely lost here. The old form asked for what you actually withdrew. Should I only enter what I withdrew last year? Or do I include the correction amount I took in January within the correction window? 4. For line 53b - Same confusion as 52b - is this for non-qualified plans only? Any help would be greatly appreciated! I'm trying to get this right and avoid penalties.
Thanks for this detailed thread - it's been really helpful! I'm in a similar situation but with one additional complication. I missed my RMD from an inherited traditional IRA last year, but I also have a regular traditional IRA that I did take the correct RMD from. When filling out Form 5329, do I need to include the distributions from both IRAs on line 53a, or only report the one where I had the shortfall? And should the required amount on line 52a be the combined RMD requirement from both accounts, or just the amount I was supposed to take from the inherited IRA where I missed it? I've been going in circles trying to figure out if I report everything together or handle each account separately on the form.
I missed inherited IRA RMDs for 2023 and 2024. Yesterday the IRS AI Expert Assistant explicitly stated I could sum those on a 2025 Form 5329 and report on line 52a. Today the IRS AI Expert Assistant insists separate year specific Form 5329's are required for each years missed RMD. Any clarification out there?
So I'm in a bit of a sticky situation and need to figure out what my options are. Last year I hired a tax preparer to handle my taxes - nothing too complicated, just my W-2 from my main job and some 1099 income from my side gig (about $14,000 in freelance writing). I just got a notice from the IRS saying there's a discrepancy in my return. Apparently, my tax preparer completely missed reporting one of my 1099-NECs! Now I owe about $3,200 in back taxes plus penalties. I paid this person $275 to do my taxes correctly, and they flat-out missed something major. I called the preparer's office, and they basically shrugged it off saying "clients are ultimately responsible for their returns" and offered to file an amendment for me for ANOTHER fee! This seems ridiculous. If I'm paying a professional, shouldn't they be liable for their own mistakes? Has anyone dealt with this before? Do tax preparers have any legal responsibility when they mess up? Or am I just stuck paying for their error? I'm wondering if I should file a complaint somewhere or if there's any way to get them to at least cover the penalties since it was their oversight.
Another option - file a complaint with your state's consumer protection agency. I did this when my preparer messed up my home office deduction and it was pretty effective. They contacted the preparer and suddenly they were willing to cover the penalties I had to pay. Also keep all your documentation showing you provided them with the missing 1099! That's your proof they had access to everything they needed to file correctly.
This is good advice, but how do you even prove you gave them all your documents? My preparer last year claimed I never gave them my 1099-INT forms even though I'm 100% sure I did. Should I be getting some kind of receipt for my documents??
Yes, definitely get a receipt! Any professional tax preparer should provide you with a document intake checklist or receipt showing what you provided. I learned this the hard way after a similar situation. Now I always email myself a list of what I'm bringing before my appointment, and I ask them to sign off that they received everything. Some preparers even use client portals where you can upload documents with timestamps. If they don't have a formal process, just ask them to write "Received all tax documents" on your copy of their service agreement and sign it. It's basic CYA and any legitimate preparer should be fine with this.
I went through something very similar last year and it was incredibly frustrating. One thing that helped me was documenting everything - save all your original documents, correspondence with the preparer, and the IRS notice. This creates a clear timeline showing their error. You mentioned they want to charge you another fee to fix their mistake - that's a huge red flag. A reputable preparer should fix their own errors for free. I'd definitely recommend filing complaints with both the IRS (Form 14157) and your state's consumer protection agency. Also, for future reference, always ask preparers about their errors and omissions insurance before hiring them. Good preparers carry this specifically to cover situations like yours. And consider getting a second opinion on complex returns - even a basic review by another professional can catch mistakes before filing. The "client is ultimately responsible" line is technically true, but it doesn't absolve them of professional negligence when they fail to include documents you provided. Keep pushing back and don't let them off the hook for their oversight.
@a119ed99a147 can probably give better specifics, but from my experience, I'd give them one final written demand (email works) stating clearly that they made the error and requesting they fix it at no charge and cover any penalties. Set a reasonable deadline like 10 business days. This creates a paper trail showing you tried to resolve it directly first, which strengthens your complaint case. If they refuse or ignore you, then file the complaints. The IRS does sometimes waive penalties for first-time filers or when there's clear preparer negligence, especially if you can document that you provided all necessary forms. The key is showing you relied on professional advice in good faith. I've seen people get penalty relief by explaining the situation clearly to an IRS agent - which is where something like Claimyr that others mentioned might actually be worth it to get through to someone who can note preparer error in your file. Don't waste months going back and forth with an uncooperative preparer though. The complaint process puts real pressure on them since it affects their ability to practice.
@a119ed99a147 Great question about strategy! I'd recommend giving them one final written demand (email works) stating clearly that they made the error and requesting they cover the penalties and amendment at no charge. Give them 10 business days to respond. This creates documentation of their refusal if they don't cooperate. If they refuse or ignore you, then file the complaints. Having that final written demand actually strengthens your complaint because it shows you tried to resolve it directly first. Regarding IRS penalty relief - yes, they do consider preparer error! Look into "reasonable cause" penalty relief. You'll need to demonstrate that you relied on a tax professional in good faith and provided them with all necessary documents. The IRS has specific procedures for this, and having documentation proving you gave them the missing 1099 is crucial. The key is showing you exercised "ordinary business care" by hiring a professional and providing complete information. I've seen people get penalties waived this way, especially when they can prove preparer negligence.
Just got this IRS return verification screen asking for a 14-digit control number from some notice in the mail. The screen says "Verify Your Return" and "Verify Your Notice" at the top, and asks "Did you receive an IRS return verification notice in the mail?" Never seen this before in my life. Been filing taxes for 15 years and this is new to me. I'm currently looking at a verification page on sa.www4.irs.gov that says: "Verify Your Return Verify Your Notice Did you receive an IRS return verification notice in the mail? (You will need this notice to continue with this online service. If you received a notice, but don't have it with you, please come back later.)" There are two options provided: - "Yes" - which then requires me to "Enter the 14-digit control number provided on your notice, you don't need to use spaces." - "No, please resend the notice" - with a warning that states: "(If you have filed your return within the last 7 days, please allow an additional 14 days to receive the notice in the mail before requesting another one to be sent. You can then come back and continue verifying.)" This verification step is completely throwing me off. I'm not sure if I missed something in the mail or if this is some new security feature. The page is very clear that I need this specific notice with a 14-digit control number to proceed, but I haven't received anything like this. I checked the URL and it shows I'm on sa.www4.irs.gov which seems legitimate, but I've never encountered this verification step before in all my years of filing. Do I really have no choice but to wait for something to arrive in the mail? Has anyone else run into this new verification requirement? Is this some kind of new identity theft prevention measure?
I actually went through this exact same verification process about 3 weeks ago and can confirm it's completely legitimate! The whole thing is part of the IRS's beefed-up security measures for 2025. A couple of things that might help while you're waiting: The CP01H notice they send is super plain looking - honestly looks like it could be junk mail at first glance. Mine came in a standard white envelope with just "Internal Revenue Service" in the return address. The 14-digit control number is in a clearly marked box about halfway down the page. The waiting period varies but mine took exactly 11 days from when I first hit that verification screen. I'd recommend checking your mail daily and maybe even asking neighbors if anything got misdelivered - that happened to my friend last month. Once you get the letter and enter those 14 digits (no spaces, just the numbers), the verification happens instantly and you're good to go. The system remembers you're verified so you shouldn't have to do this dance again anytime soon. The sa.www4.irs.gov domain threw me off too at first, but it's their official secure portal. I actually called the IRS to double-check (waited 2 hours on hold like an idiot) and they confirmed it was legit. Hang tight - I know the waiting sucks but the process actually works pretty smoothly once you get that magic number!
Thanks for sharing your experience! Really helps to hear from someone who just went through this. I'm at day 8 since hitting the verification screen so hopefully my notice shows up soon. Good call on checking with neighbors too - with how plain you're describing the envelope, I could totally see it getting misdelivered. At least now I know what to look for and that the whole process is worth the wait once you get that control number! ๐ค
Just want to echo what others have said - this verification process is definitely real and becoming much more common this tax season. I'm a tax preparer and have had dozens of clients hit this same CP01H verification requirement over the past few months. The timing can be frustrating, but here's what I've observed: most of my clients receive their notice between days 8-16 after hitting that verification screen. The envelope is incredibly plain - just says "Internal Revenue Service" with no special markings, so it's easy to overlook. One thing I always tell clients is to avoid the temptation to keep clicking "resend notice" if it doesn't arrive exactly when expected. The IRS system can get backed up if you request multiple notices, and it might actually delay the process. Also worth noting - if you're married filing jointly, make sure the verification notice gets sent to the primary taxpayer's name and address as listed on the return. I've seen cases where couples assumed it would go to both spouses but it only goes to whoever is listed first. The sa.www4.irs.gov domain is 100% legitimate - it's their secure access portal specifically for this type of verification. Once you complete it successfully, you'll have normal access to all IRS online services and this verification typically doesn't repeat unless there are major changes to your tax situation. Stay patient - the system works, it's just slower than we'd all like!
This is really helpful info from a tax preparer's perspective! I'm definitely going to resist the urge to keep hitting that resend button - didn't realize it could actually slow things down. Good point about the married filing jointly thing too, since my spouse and I always wonder who gets what from the IRS. I'm on day 9 now so hopefully my plain envelope shows up soon. Thanks for the reassurance that this is becoming standard practice and not just some random hassle!
AstroAlpha
This is such a smart strategy! I've been doing something similar but wasn't as organized about it. Just started using a simple folder system on Google Drive with subfolders by year, then categories like "Prescriptions," "Doctor Visits," "Dental," etc. One tip I learned from my accountant: make sure you're also keeping track of any mileage for medical appointments since that's HSA-eligible too at the current IRS rate (65.5 cents per mile for 2023). I use a simple mileage app that logs the trips automatically. Also, for anyone worried about receipt quality over time - I scan mine as soon as I get home. Some thermal paper receipts from pharmacies start fading within months, so don't wait! Better to have a clear digital copy than a blank piece of paper years later when you actually need it.
0 coins
Krishna Govinda Sinkhwal
use HSA Smart mobile app.
0 coins