


Ask the community...
I'm a retired accountant, and I think it's absolutely reasonable to ask for citations, but there's an important distinction to make: tax professionals should know THE PRINCIPLES behind tax law and where to find citations, rather than having every code section memorized. For example, when a client asks me about the home office deduction, I should know the general rules (exclusive use, regular use, principal place of business) and be able to say "that's covered in Publication 587 and Section 280A of the tax code." I might need to look up the exact citation, but I should know where to point you. What raises red flags is when someone gets defensive or dismissive when asked for support. Good tax pros welcome these questions because they want you to understand and be comfortable with their advice.
That makes sense! So it's not that they need to have the exact code section memorized, but they should be able to tell you generally where to find the information or be willing to look it up for you. Is there a polite way to phrase this kind of request without seeming like I'm challenging their expertise?
I've found the best approach is to frame it as wanting to understand for your own knowledge rather than challenging their expertise. Try saying something like: "This is interesting - could you point me to the IRS publication or tax code section where I could read more about this? I'd like to understand the details better." Most professionals respond well to curiosity. If they still get defensive, that's actually valuable information about whether this is someone you want to work with. A good tax professional should appreciate a client who wants to be informed rather than just taking everything at face value.
Adding to this discussion - I've learned that there's a huge difference between tax preparers and actual tax attorneys when it comes to citations. Tax attorneys literally live and breathe by citations since they often have to defend positions in court or to the IRS. My regular tax preparer at H&R Block couldn't cite anything specific when I asked about some S-corp questions, but when I went to a tax attorney for a second opinion, she immediately pulled up multiple court cases and revenue rulings that addressed my situation. She even emailed me a summary with all the citations afterward.
That's because there's a HUGE difference in qualifications. H&R Block "professionals" often just take a 10-week course. Tax attorneys have law degrees plus specialized tax training. You get what you pay for.
Don't discount CPAs though - many are extremely knowledgeable about tax laws and citations, especially those who specialize in taxation. The real dividing line isn't the credential but whether they focus on compliance (just filling out forms) versus actual tax planning and strategy.
I've used TurboTax Live for 3 years now, and it's decent but has some limitations. For importing brokerage accounts - yes, they connect with major firms, but crypto transactions and more complex investments sometimes have issues. The CPAs vary wildly in quality - I've had amazing experts who found deductions I never knew about, and others who seemed barely more knowledgeable than me. Pro tip: if you don't like the expert you're matched with, you can disconnect and try again for a different one. For quarterly estimated payments, make sure you have the exact dates and amounts handy - TurboTax can be picky about matching those precisely to IRS records.
What about state taxes? I have to file in two states and always struggle with that part. Does TurboTax Live handle multi-state filing well?
TurboTax handles multi-state filing pretty well actually. I've filed in both California and Arizona for several years because of a rental property, and the software walks you through it step by step. The Live experts are particularly helpful with state-specific questions since tax laws vary so much between states. Just make sure you select the multi-state option early in the process. It costs a bit more, but it's way cheaper than having a CPA handle multiple state returns.
Has anyone used H&R Block's live tax pro option? I'm trying to decide between that and TurboTax for a similar situation (W2s, investments, home ownership).
I've used both. H&R Block's interface isn't as slick, but their tax pros seemed more experienced to me. Their import features for investments weren't as good as TurboTax though. For brokerage accounts specifically, TurboTax has better connections with more institutions.
Don't forget about self-employment taxes! For both your independent contractor work and your Etsy business, you'll need to pay self-employment tax (15.3%) on your profits in addition to regular income tax. This catches a lot of people by surprise. Each Schedule C will calculate your profit (revenue minus expenses), and then you'll complete Schedule SE to calculate your self-employment tax. The good thing is you can deduct half of your self-employment tax on your 1040, which helps offset the cost a bit. Make sure you're setting aside enough for taxes throughout the year - the rule of thumb is about 25-30% of your freelance/self-employment income for federal taxes, plus whatever your state requires.
Thanks for mentioning this! I hadn't even thought about self-employment taxes. Is there a minimum amount I need to earn before I have to pay those? My Etsy shop only made about $1,200 last year.
You're required to file Schedule SE and pay self-employment taxes if your net earnings from self-employment are $400 or more during the year. Since your Etsy shop made $1,200, you'll need to determine the profit after deducting expenses. If your profit exceeds $400, you'll need to pay self-employment tax on that amount. Even though it's a small amount, it's still important to report it correctly. The upside is that reporting this income helps you build Social Security credits, which can be important for your future benefits. Also, properly documenting even small business activities establishes a history if your business grows in future years.
Has anyone used FreeTaxUSA for multiple income sources? I'm in a similar situation with W2 job, freelance writing, and a small online shop. TurboTax wanted to charge me extra for the "self-employed" version but I'm trying to save money.
I used FreeTaxUSA last year for my W2 and two side businesses. It handled everything perfectly and was MUCH cheaper than TurboTax. The interface isn't as fancy but it asked all the right questions and let me do multiple Schedule Cs without charging extra. Federal filing was free and I only paid like $15 for state.
Another option - if you know roughly how much you earned those two days, you could always file now using your best estimate, then amend later if needed when the W-2 arrives. Not ideal but if you really need that refund ASAP it's technically an option.
Has anyone noticed that employers seem to be taking longer and longer to send W-2s each year? I swear they all wait until the absolute last minute on January 31st now, sometimes even later. Making us all wait to file is so frustrating.
Yep! And the IRS starts accepting returns usually by like Jan 23rd... so there's this awkward week where you COULD file but don't have all your docs yet. Super annoying especially if you're expecting a big refund!
Rhett Bowman
If you want a free alternative, try calling the IRS exactly at 7:00 AM Eastern when they open. That's what worked for me after weeks of failed attempts. Also, the Taxpayer Advocate Service can sometimes help with identity theft cases if you're experiencing financial hardship because of the delayed refund. And definitely check your credit reports at annualcreditreport.com to see if there are other accounts opened in your name. If someone's using your SSN for employment, they might be using it for other things too.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
ā¢I've actually tried calling right when they open multiple times with no luck! Do you know if the Taxpayer Advocate requires proof of hardship? This refund delay is definitely causing me financial problems since I was counting on that money.
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
ā¢Yes, the Taxpayer Advocate Service typically requires some documentation of hardship - things like utility disconnection notices, eviction threats, or proof that you can't meet basic living expenses without the refund. If you have any documentation showing financial strain, gather that before contacting them. They've been overwhelmed lately too, but they're often more accessible than the main IRS lines. Their criteria for accepting cases have gotten stricter because of their high case volume, but identity theft cases with hardship are generally prioritized.
0 coins
Abigail Patel
Has anyone tried going to their local IRS office in person instead of calling? I had a similar situation last year and was able to get an in-person appointment through the IRS website. Took about 3 weeks to get the appointment but they resolved everything in one visit.
0 coins
Daniel White
ā¢I second this! In-person appointments are WAY more effective. I had my identity theft issue resolved in about half the time after visiting my local office. They can verify your identity on the spot and put notes directly in the system. Just make sure to bring multiple forms of ID and copies of all your documentation.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
ā¢That's a great suggestion! I didn't even think about going in person. How did you schedule the appointment? Is there a specific section on the IRS website for that?
0 coins