


Ask the community...
Just a tip from someone who went through this exact situation with the Recovery Rebate Credit and CP13 notice - make sure you keep copies of EVERYTHING you send to the IRS and send it via certified mail so you have proof of delivery. The IRS is notorious for "losing" correspondence, especially with these stimulus payment disputes. Also, when you write your response letter, put your notice number, tax ID, and tax year in the subject line AND at the top of every page. Make it super obvious what your letter is about. And be really clear and direct about why you're eligible for the Recovery Rebate Credit despite being claimed as a dependent on someone's 2019 return.
Would it be better to fax the response instead of mailing it? I've heard the IRS processing centers have huge backlogs of mail but faxes get entered into their system faster.
In my experience, faxing can be faster but only if you have confirmation the fax went through successfully. The IRS fax lines are often busy or don't connect properly. I'd recommend doing both if possible - send via certified mail for your records and also try faxing. The key thing regardless of method is making your documents super clear and organized. Put your notice number, SSN (last 4 digits only for security), and tax year on every single page. The IRS processes millions of pieces of correspondence and making yours easy to identify with the right case helps tremendously.
Just a heads up that if you were claimed as a dependent on ANYONE'S 2019 return, you were technically ineligible for the first two stimulus payments as an individual. The law was written that way, even if the person who claimed you didn't receive a payment for you either. This is a really common misunderstanding about the Recovery Rebate Credit. Even if you weren't properly claimed as a dependent (like in your case where you probably didn't qualify as one), the fact that someone DID claim you is what matters to the IRS automated systems.
That doesn't sound right. If someone incorrectly claimed you as a dependent when you weren't actually qualified to be one, you should still be eligible for your own stimulus payment. The IRS even has procedures for resolving these exact situations.
I've seen this happen when students receive retroactive scholarships or when tuition credits get applied after the fact. The key boxes on 1098-T form to understand: Box 1: Payments received for qualified tuition/expenses Box 4: Adjustments made to PRIOR year scholarships Box 5: Total scholarships/grants processed Box 6: Adjustments made to PRIOR year qualified expenses The timing of when things post to the student's account vs calendar year can create weird situations. If your son got any retroactive adjustments or late scholarships that applied to previous terms, they might show up this way. Double check if he received any: - Year-end scholarships - Special graduation grants - Adjustments to previous semesters - Balance corrections from prior years
He did get a special completion grant in his final semester that wasn't expected. But it was only about $5k, nowhere near these massive amounts showing up. And nothing that would explain an extra $80k in box 5 when his actual grants were only about $22k total for the year. I'm definitely going to contact the university tomorrow. Just needed to make sure I wasn't missing something obvious about how these forms work before I start that process.
The completion grant could be part of it, but you're right that it doesn't explain the magnitude of these discrepancies. One other possibility is if there was some loan forgiveness or conversion of loans to grants. Some schools have programs where initial loans get converted to grants upon graduation or completion of certain requirements. These conversions get reported in a really confusing way on the 1098-T. Either way, it's definitely worth getting clarification from the university. Ask them for a full accounting of how they arrived at each box amount.
Make sure to file Form 8863 for the American Opportunity Credit if this is your son's 4th year of college! Many people miss this. Even with scholarships, you might qualify for up to $2,500 credit if you paid any qualified expenses out of pocket. Also, check if his scholarships were restricted (specifically designated for tuition) or unrestricted. Only unrestricted scholarships that exceed qualified educational expenses are taxable.
But wouldn't the American Opportunity Credit be unavailable if the student already claimed it for 4 years? I thought that was the maximum lifetime limit?
To answer your original question - a GOOD tax preparer should be finding you every legitimate deduction you qualify for while keeping everything accurate and documented. It's not an either/or situation. My accountant helped me deduct about $4200 more than I thought possible when I started my small business, but she also insisted on proper documentation for everything. She explained that aggressive but legitimate deductions are fine, but we need records to back everything up. The real value isn't just in finding deductions - it's in their knowledge of what's allowed, what requires special documentation, and what might trigger audits. Anyone promising huge magical deductions without talking about documentation is probably sketchy.
That's helpful, thank you. How much should I expect to pay for a quality preparer who will do both (ensure accuracy and find legitimate deductions)? I don't want to overpay, but I also understand that expertise costs money.
For a situation like yours with a home purchase and some freelance work, expect to pay somewhere between $350-600 for a quality tax preparer, depending on your location and the complexity of your freelance activities. If your freelance work is more involved with lots of expenses and equipment, it might go higher. It's an investment, but a good preparer can often find deductions that more than cover their fee. Just make sure whoever you choose is asking detailed questions about your situation rather than just collecting your W-2s and basic info. The more questions they ask, the more likely they're looking for those legitimate deductions you might qualify for.
I actually switched from a "find every deduction" guy to a more conservative preparer after getting audited three years ago. My old preparer found me tons of deductions but didn't explain what documentation I needed. When I got audited I was completely unprepared. My new accountant is super thorough and explains everything. She still finds deductions but is careful to make sure I understand what records to keep. I actually get roughly the same refund amount but with WAY less anxiety. Good tax prep isnt about being aggressive or conservative - its about being THOROUGH and KNOWLEDGEABLE. Good preparers know exactly where the lines are and help you get every benefit you're entitled to without crossing those lines.
2 Don't forget about improvements! If your aunt or you made any major improvements to the property (new roof, renovation, addition, etc.), those can be added to your basis and reduce your capital gains. You'll need receipts though!
1 I actually did replace the HVAC system about 6 months after inheriting it. Would that count? It cost around $9,000. I should have the receipt somewhere in my email.
2 Yes, that absolutely counts! A new HVAC system is considered a capital improvement, not just a repair. Make sure to add that $9,000 to your stepped-up basis. Any significant improvements that extend the life of the property or add value can be included. Just make sure you have that receipt handy in case of an audit.
3 Has anyone used a tax professional for this kind of situation? My tax software is confusing me with all these basis questions and I'm worried about making a mistake.
GalaxyGuardian
Don't forget about other deductions beyond just gas/mileage! I do Uber/Lyft part-time and was able to deduct: - Phone mount for car ($25) - Portion of cell phone bill (20% business use) - Car chargers - Dashcam - Snacks/water for passengers (I keep receipts) - Special seat covers to protect from wear and tear - Spotify subscription (for passenger entertainment) Made a big difference on my Schedule C!
0 coins
Sofia Morales
ā¢Thanks for this list! I hadn't thought about the phone mount or dashcam. Can you really deduct Spotify though? I use it while driving but isn't that kind of a gray area?
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
ā¢You can deduct Spotify if you're using it specifically for your business - like providing music for passengers as part of your service. It's considered a business expense if it's primarily for your customers' experience. If you're just listening to it yourself while doing DoorDash deliveries, that would be much harder to justify as a business expense since there are no passengers benefiting from it. It's all about whether it's necessary for your business operations versus personal enjoyment.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
Something I learned the hard way - if you choose standard mileage the first year you use your car for business, you can switch between standard and actual expenses in future years. BUT if you choose actual expenses the first year, you're STUCK with that method for the life of that vehicle in your business. Also, don't forget you can deduct business parking fees and tolls IN ADDITION to the standard mileage rate! Those aren't included in the $0.67/mile.
0 coins
Amina Toure
ā¢Yup, this is super important! I made that mistake with my first delivery car. I used actual expenses the first year when the car was new and had higher value for depreciation. When the car got older and needed fewer repairs, standard mileage would have been better but I was stuck with actual expenses. For parking and tolls - gig drivers should use apps that track these separately! I use the Stride app for mileage and the Everlance app to snap photos of parking receipts. Makes tax time way easier.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
ā¢Thanks for pointing this out! I didn't realize that choosing actual expenses would lock me in for the life of the vehicle. That's definitely something to consider since I might keep this car for several years. And I had no idea about the parking fees and tolls! I've probably spent around $200 on parking in downtown areas for pickups/deliveries. Good to know I can deduct those on top of the standard mileage.
0 coins