


Ask the community...
What no one's mentioning is that this answer really depends on how much money we're talking about. If you won $100 here and there while vacationing, most accountants I've talked to say just report it in your home state and don't bother with nonresident returns. But if you're winning thousands or tens of thousands across multiple states, definitely file properly in each state. It also depends on whether you're offsetting with losses. Some states don't allow gambling loss deductions at all, while others only allow them if you itemize, and a few let you net them directly against winnings.
Do you know what the threshold amounts are for filing? Like is there a minimum amount you have to win in a state before you're required to file there? I won about $800 total across 3 different states but lost about $500 in my home state.
Each state has different filing thresholds. Generally, you need to file a nonresident return if your income from that state exceeds the standard deduction for that state, or in some cases, if your gross income exceeds a certain amount regardless of deductions. For example, New Jersey requires nonresidents to file if their income from NJ sources exceeds $1,500. Pennsylvania requires you to file if you have any PA-source income regardless of the amount. Michigan requires filing if your MI income exceeds $20,000. So for your $800 spread across 3 states, it really depends on which states they are and how much you won in each one.
I was in the same boat last year and wish someone had told me this - the apps are now reporting this data directly to states! My friend got a notice from Indiana asking why he didn't file a return there, when he had only placed a few bets while driving through the state. The betting apps are required to track your physical location for legal compliance reasons, and that data is increasingly being shared with tax authorities.
Just to add to what others have said - as a sole proprietor LLC, your business doesn't file its own tax return. Instead, you report the income and expenses on Schedule C of your personal tax return (Form 1040). And yes, the threshold is $400 net profit, not $5,000.
What's the difference between gross income and net profit for this $400 threshold? Like if I made $2,000 in sales but spent $1,700 on supplies and expenses, would I still need to file?
The $400 threshold refers to net profit, which is your gross income minus your business expenses. In your example, if you made $2,000 in sales but had $1,700 in legitimate business expenses, your net profit would be $300. Since that's below the $400 threshold, you technically wouldn't be required to file based solely on your self-employment income. However, keep in mind there might be other reasons you'd need to file a tax return, and it's generally a good practice to file anyway so you have documentation of your business activity, especially if you plan to claim business losses.
One thing nobody mentioned - even if you're under the $400 threshold, you might still want to file taxes for your business. Filing can establish your business history (helpful for loans later) and let you claim startup losses to offset future profits. My accountant had me file even when I only made $275 my first year.
I think there's still some confusion here. Let me try to clarify: 1. When you move money from Traditional IRA to Roth IRA = distribution + conversion 2. Line 4a reports the TOTAL amount distributed 3. Line 4b reports the TAXABLE portion 4. Form 8606 is required to calculate the taxable portion If your TIRA had only deductible contributions, the entire distribution is taxable. If you had non-deductible (after-tax) contributions, only part is taxable. The key is tracking your "basis" (non-deductible contributions) on Form 8606 each year!
So what if I've never filled out Form 8606 before but I've been doing backdoor Roth conversions for years? Am I in trouble? I honestly just let my tax software handle it without understanding what it was doing.
You should go back and file Form 8606 for any year you made non-deductible IRA contributions. This form is required even if you don't file a tax return, as it's how you track your basis in your Traditional IRA. If you've been doing backdoor Roth conversions through tax software, the software likely prompted you for the information and completed Form 8606 for you. Check your past returns to see if it's there. If not, you should consider filing amended returns to include Form 8606 for those years to establish your basis properly. Without this documentation, you risk being taxed twice on those contributions.
I had this exact same question last year! An IRA distribution is literally ANY money coming out of an IRA account - doesn't matter where it goes after. So yes, when u move $ from TIRA to Roth, that's a distribution. The trick is the tax treatment: - Regular withdrawal to your bank account = distribution (taxable + maybe penalties) - TIRA to Roth = distribution + conversion (taxable but no penalties) - IRA to IRA rollover = distribution but not taxable if done properly Report the whole amount on line 4a, and the taxable part on 4b. For backdoor Roth, those are usually the same number unless u had non-deductible contributions.
Does anyone know if there's a specific reason they shut down Direct Pay during that window? Seems like a weird time since many people do their taxes late at night.
I'm guessing it's for system maintenance and updates. Most big financial systems have a daily maintenance window - banks often do similar things in the middle of the night. 11:45pm-midnight ET probably affects the fewest users across all US time zones while still being overnight for the IRS east coast operations.
That makes sense about the maintenance window. Just seems poorly timed during tax season when so many of us are burning the midnight oil trying to get things filed. They should at least put a more visible warning on the site about it!
Quick question for anyone who's done this $1 extension trick - does the payment confirmation serve as proof of your extension? Like should I save that confirmation page as documentation?
Yes, absolutely save the payment confirmation as proof. Take a screenshot or save the PDF they email you. While the IRS system should automatically register your extension when you make that payment, having documentation is crucial if there's ever a question about whether you filed for an extension on time. I recommend saving it in multiple places (email, cloud storage, etc.) just to be safe. I've had clients who needed this proof years later during audits.
Thanks for confirming! I just did the $1 payment and saved both a screenshot and the PDF they sent. Feeling much better now knowing I have solid proof of the extension filing. I need the extra time to sort through some investment documents that still haven't arrived.
Lena Kowalski
One thing nobody's mentioning is that the β¬750M threshold is actually pretty high! This only affects the very largest multinational companies. Small and medium businesses (even fairly large ones by most standards) won't be directly impacted by these rules. Also worth noting that the implementation timeline keeps getting pushed back. Originally supposed to start in 2023, now many jurisdictions are talking about 2024 or even 2025 before they have local legislation in place. The US delay is particularly problematic since so many multinationals are headquartered there.
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
β’Does that β¬750M threshold apply to the global company or just operations in a specific country? Like if a company makes β¬800M worldwide but only β¬100M in France, would it still be subject to the minimum tax in France?
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
β’The β¬750M threshold applies to global consolidated revenue of the multinational group, not the revenue in each specific country. So in your example, a company with β¬800M worldwide revenue would be subject to the minimum tax rules even if they only had β¬100M in France. This is actually one of the key points of the agreement - it's designed to capture large multinationals that might have relatively small operations spread across many countries. The threshold was set to target the largest 10-15% of multinational enterprises while excluding smaller companies that would face disproportionate compliance burdens.
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
As someone who works with emerging markets, I think the impact on developing countries is being overlooked. Many use tax incentives to attract foreign investment because they can't compete with developed nations on infrastructure, workforce, etc. This agreement potentially removes one of their few competitive advantages. That's likely why Kenya and Nigeria haven't signed on. They see it as developed nations protecting their tax bases at the expense of developing economies' growth strategies. The revenue redistribution under Pillar One is supposed to address this, but the formulas tend to favor larger economies.
0 coins
SofΓa RodrΓguez
β’That's a really good point. Do you think there's any chance the OECD will modify the agreement to address these concerns? Or are developing nations just going to be left behind?
0 coins