
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm trying to figure out the tax advantages between classifying my beach house as a rental property versus a vacation home. Just purchased this place in Naples last December for $435,000 and I'm torn on how to proceed for next year's taxes. If I classify it as a rental property, I know I can deduct expenses, depreciation, etc. But we plan to use it ourselves for about 4 weeks spread throughout the year. The rest of the time we'd rent it out on Airbnb/VRBO. If we go with vacation home classification, I understand the mortgage interest would be deductible as a second home, but I'd lose the ability to deduct maintenance costs, HOA fees ($850/month), and property management (about 15% of rental income). My CPA gave me some information, but I'd love to hear from people who've actually done both approaches. What's the better tax strategy long-term? Are there specific IRS rules about minimum rental days I need to hit to qualify for rental property treatment? We expect to generate about $65,000 in rental income next year.
I got Letter 12C dated Feb. 14, 2023 (reference number 0426527365) from the IRS about my 2022 Form 1040 return asking for W2 verification. The letter I received states: "IRS Department Internal Revenue of the Treasury Service AUSC SAO OMB Clearance No.: 1545-0074 AUSTIN 02 TX 73301-0034 In reply refer to: 0426527365 Feb. 14, 2023 LTR 12C 0 R ***-**-8076 202212 30 Input Op: 0426827365 00003253 BODC: SB 108 76063 Social Security number: 76221-427-25810-3 Dear Taxpayer: We received Dec. 31, 2022, Form 1040 federal individual income tax return, but we need more information to process your return accurately. Unless required otherwise, send us your reply within the 20 days from the date of this letter. Enclose only the information we requested and any forms, schedules, or other information required to support your entries and a copy of this letter. Don't send a copy of your return unless we ask you to do so. Don't respond with a Form 1040-X, Amended U.S. Individual Income Tax Return. We'll issue any refund due to you in 6 to 8 weeks from the time we receive your response. If we don't receive a response from you, we may have to increase the tax you owe or reduce your refund." Specifically, they need documentation to support the wage/withholding entry of $8,560.00 that I reported on line 25d of Form 1040. The letter continues: "To support the amount of wage or withholding entry of $8,560.00 on line 25d of Form 1040 submit: - Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement - Form W-2G, Certain Gambling Winnings - Form 1099-R, Distributions from Pensions, Annuities, Retirement or Profit Sharing Plans, IRAs, Insurance Contracts, etc. - Other forms reporting wage or withholding If you don't have the form you need, contact the issuer of the income statement for a copy and send it with a copy of this letter. Otherwise, send us the information in some substitute form. For example, you can send an earnings statement or paystub from your employer which shows year-to-date totals." The letter also mentioned that I could fax my information to 844-254-2836 using either a fax machine or an online fax service. It warned me to protect myself when sending digital data by understanding the fax service's privacy and security policies. Due to high volume, they can't acknowledge receipt of my fax, and my faxed signatures will become a permanent part of my filing. I faxed all my documents to their number 844-254-2836 on February 20th, but my transcripts still show N/A when I check. I'm getting worried since the letter explicitly states they'll issue any refund due "in 6 to 8 weeks from the time we receive your response." Has anyone dealt with this verification process before? I'm getting anxious since it's been a while and still no updates showing in my transcript. I'm concerned because the letter sent from "AUSTIN 02 TX 73301-0034" clearly warned that if they don't receive a response, they may increase the tax I owe or reduce my refund.
Quick tip: Their fax system is garbage. I had better luck using an online fax service like FaxZero or HelloFax. At least u get confirmation it went through.
4 weeks is still within the normal processing timeframe, though I understand the anxiety. The N/A status on your transcript is expected during verification - it means they've pulled your return for manual review. A few things to keep in mind: - The 6-8 week timeframe starts from when they actually process your faxed documents, not when you sent them - February is peak tax season, so processing delays are common - As long as you responded within the 20-day window (which you did), you're in compliance I'd recommend waiting the full 8 weeks before taking any action. If you still see no movement after that, then consider calling the number on your original letter. Keep your fax confirmation if you have one - that's your proof of timely response. The key is patience during tax season. Your refund is likely just sitting in the verification queue waiting to be processed.
So I'm basically kicking myself right now because I had to file my taxes by paper this year and the IRS website STILL doesn't show they've received them. Back in February my laptop decided to completely die on me - of course it had all my previous tax info that I needed to e-file through TurboTax. Just my luck. I mailed my 2024 tax return via certified mail about 2 months ago and got the delivery confirmation showing it was delivered to the IRS processing center. But when I check "Where's My Refund" or try to get any info online, it says they have no record of my return. I'm starting to get really worried since I'm expecting a decent refund this year. I've tried calling the IRS directly but we all know how that goes - endless hold times and then disconnected calls. Does anyone know how long it typically takes for the IRS to process paper returns these days? Or should I be concerned that something happened to my return after delivery? Really don't want to have to refile everything if I can avoid it.
Has anyone had success calling the IRS Taxpayer Advocate Service instead of the main number? I heard they might be able to help with returns that seem lost after delivery.
The Taxpayer Advocate Service is overloaded too and they generally won't help with a case that's just slow processing. They're focused on hardship cases (like you'll be evicted without your refund) or returns that are significantly outside normal processing times (like 6+ months for paper returns). Two months for a paper return isn't going to qualify for their help yet.
I went through this exact same situation three years ago and it was incredibly stressful! Paper returns really do take that long unfortunately. I mailed mine in March and didn't see it show up in the system until late August. The certified mail receipt saved me because when I finally got through to someone at the IRS, that tracking number was all they needed to confirm I had filed on time. One thing that helped me was keeping a detailed log of when I mailed it, the tracking number, delivery date, and every time I checked the IRS website. That way when I eventually did speak to someone, I had all the information ready. Also, make sure you keep copies of everything you mailed - if for some reason they do lose it, you'll need to send everything again. The waiting is the worst part, but you're definitely not alone in this. Two months is still well within their processing timeframe for paper returns, even though it feels like forever.
I'm planning to move my checking and savings balances from Chase to a local credit union that has better interest rates. I've heard there are certain thresholds where banks have to report large deposits to the IRS. Does this reporting requirement still apply when I'm just transferring my own money between banks? I don't want to accidentally create tax issues or trigger unnecessary scrutiny. Are wire transfers viewed differently than regular deposits for reporting purposes? And what exactly are the dollar thresholds that trigger this IRS reporting? I'm moving around $15,000 from checking and another $32,000 from my savings, if that matters. Just trying to make sure I do this right and don't create headaches for myself at tax time. Thanks for any insight!
I've done large transfers between banks several times and never had any issues. The real concern isn't about transfers between your own accounts but CASH deposits/withdrawals. The $10,000 cash reporting is what triggers CTRs (Currency Transaction Reports). Also be aware of "structuring" - intentionally breaking up cash transactions to avoid the $10,000 reporting threshold. That's actually illegal and can raise red flags. But again, that's for CASH, not electronic transfers between accounts with your name on them.
This is the correct answer. Electronic transfers between your own accounts aren't reportable as income because it's not new money - you already paid taxes when you initially earned it. The $10k reporting is specifically for cash transactions under the Bank Secrecy Act, not for moving your own money electronically. I work at a credit union and people get confused about this all the time. We file CTRs for cash transactions over $10k, but not for incoming wires or ACH transfers.
The amounts you're moving ($15k and $32k) are well within normal ranges for account transfers and won't trigger any special IRS reporting since you're moving your own money between accounts in your name. One practical tip: Consider doing a small test transfer first (maybe $1000) to make sure everything goes smoothly with your new credit union's systems before moving the larger amounts. This can help you avoid any potential delays or holds that some banks place on large incoming transfers from new customers. Also, keep documentation of these transfers (screenshots, confirmation emails, etc.) for your records. While they won't create tax implications, having clear records showing the money came from your own accounts can be helpful if you ever need to explain the source of funds for any reason. The interest rate upgrade sounds like a smart financial move - just make sure you understand any account minimums or fees at the new credit union so you don't get surprised later.
I'm trying to figure out the tax situation for my dad who recently became a dual citizen. He's been a US citizen for over 30 years after being born in the Philippines, but just finalized his Philippine dual citizenship last year. He sold some land that had been in our family for generations, and we've already paid all the required taxes in the Philippines including capital gains tax, documentary stamps, and agent commissions. My main concern is what happens when we transfer that money back to his US accounts. Will he get hit with additional taxes here? I remember hearing something about a tax treaty between the US and Philippines to prevent double taxation on the same income, but I'm not sure if that's still in effect or how it applies to property sales specifically. Any advice would be greatly appreciated since we're talking about a significant amount of money (about $175,000) and I don't want him to be surprised with a huge tax bill from the IRS after already paying taxes in the Philippines.
Has anyone dealt with transferring large amounts from Philippines banks to US accounts? My cousin got hit with ridiculous fees - almost 3% between the sending bank, receiving bank and terrible exchange rates. Any recommendations for cheaper options?
Just wanted to add another important consideration - make sure your father reports this on Form 8938 (FATCA) if his foreign financial assets exceed the threshold. Since he's filing as a US resident, the threshold is $50,000 on the last day of the year or $75,000 at any point during the year. With $175,000 from the property sale sitting in a Philippine account, this definitely applies. Form 8938 is filed with your regular tax return (unlike FBAR which goes to FinCEN). The penalties for not filing can be substantial - starting at $10,000 and going up from there. It's separate from but related to the FBAR requirement, so you'll likely need to file both if the money stays in the Philippine account for any length of time. Also, since this involves both dual citizenship issues and significant foreign assets, I'd strongly recommend getting professional help from a CPA who specializes in international tax matters. The foreign tax credit calculations can get complex, especially when you factor in currency fluctuations over the years of property ownership.
Brianna Schmidt
Has anyone used TurboTax for rental property reporting? I'm trying to decide if I should use that or hire a CPA this year for my new beach house.
0 coins
Alexis Renard
I used TurboTax last year for my rental property and it was ok for basic stuff. But when I got into depreciation recapture and passive activity loss limitations, I felt like I was missing opportunities. Ended up hiring a CPA mid-year and he found about $3,400 in deductions I'd missed. For complicated rental situations, I'd recommend a professional.
0 coins
Brianna Schmidt
Thanks for sharing your experience. $3,400 in missed deductions is significant! I think I'll go with a CPA for the first year at least to make sure everything is set up correctly. Better to spend a bit on professional help than miss out on legitimate deductions.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
@Sophia Long - Based on your numbers, you're looking at a significant tax decision. With $65K expected rental income and only 28 personal use days, you're right on the borderline for optimal treatment. Here's what I'd focus on: You need at least 280 rental days to stay under the 10% personal use threshold for full rental property treatment. That's very doable with short-term rentals in Naples - the season runs almost year-round there. Key considerations: 1. Track every single day meticulously - personal use includes ANY day you, family, or friends use it (even partial days count as full days) 2. Days spent doing maintenance/repairs don't count as personal use if that's the primary purpose 3. With your $850/month HOA fees alone ($10,200/year), plus property management at 15% of $65K (~$9,750), you're looking at nearly $20K in expenses before even counting mortgage interest, insurance, utilities, and maintenance If you can hit that 280+ rental day threshold, you'll save thousands compared to mixed-use treatment. The depreciation deduction alone on a $435K property (minus land value) will be substantial - probably around $12-15K annually. Have you calculated what your actual rental days will realistically be? That's the make-or-break number for your strategy.
0 coins