


Ask the community...
21 Your HR department should be explaining this stuff when you onboard! The withholding system is based on allowances you claim on your W-4. When I started my job in November last year, I just put "0" allowances to be safe and got a fat refund. You can always adjust later.
8 The W-4 doesn't use allowances anymore - they changed it in 2020. Now it's a completely different system with steps for different situations. I was confused too when I started my new job because I was used to the old form.
21 You're right, I completely forgot they changed the form! Shows how long I've been at my current job. I guess the basic concept is still similar though - you give your employer information about your tax situation, and they use IRS tables to calculate the withholding. Thanks for the correction. I should probably review my own withholding sometime soon since I haven't updated my W-4 since before the change.
16 Does anyone know if there's a way to see exactly how the calculation is done? My last employer seemed to take out way more than my current one even though I'm making more money now. Makes no sense and HR just says "it's what the system calculates" which isn't helpful.
2 The actual calculation is in IRS Publication 15-T if you really want to see the math. It's pretty complicated. More likely explanation is that you filled out your W-4 differently at the two jobs, or one employer is using an older version of your W-4. Ask HR for a copy of your current W-4 on file and see if it matches what you remember filling out.
I used Jackson Hewitt online last year for my W2 and 1099-G and had a horrible experience. The interface kept glitching and wouldn't let me go back and correct information without starting over. Their customer service was basically non-existent - waited 2 hours on hold and then got disconnected. I switched to FreeTaxUSA this year and it was much better. They handle W2s and unemployment just fine, and it's cheaper than both TurboTax and Jackson Hewitt. Their interface isn't as flashy but it works smoothly and I got my refund in 12 days.
Did FreeTaxUSA handle state taxes too or just federal? And was that included in the basic price or an add-on?
FreeTaxUSA does federal returns for free and charges around $15 for state returns, which is way cheaper than most other services. The state filing is an add-on but still very affordable compared to the $40+ that TurboTax and others charge. They handle both federal and state unemployment reporting correctly, which was important for me since my state taxes unemployment a bit differently than federal.
Has anyone used the Jackson Hewitt mobile app instead of their website? I usually do everything on my phone and wondering if their app is any good for filing with W2 and unemployment?
I tried their app last year and honestly wouldn't recommend it. Super buggy and kept crashing when I tried to upload photos of my documents. Ended up having to use the website anyway. If you're set on using your phone, TaxSlayer's app worked better for me this year.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet - keep REALLY good records of everything! Date of employment, hours worked, pay received, any discussions about taxes, etc. If you ever need to file Form SS-8 (determination of employee status) or deal with tax issues later, having documentation is super important. Also, some states have specific requirements for household employees beyond federal rules. What state are you in? That might affect the specific advice people can give you.
Thanks for mentioning this! I'm in Illinois. I've actually started keeping a detailed log of my hours and payments since August (wish I had done it from the beginning). Do you know if there are any Illinois-specific requirements I should know about?
Illinois does have some specific requirements for household employers. They need to register with the Illinois Department of Employment Security if they pay $1,000 or more in a calendar quarter. They're required to pay Illinois unemployment insurance taxes. Illinois also has a Domestic Workers' Bill of Rights that provides additional protections for nannies and other household workers. Your employers should be providing you with an employment notice that outlines your wage rate, work schedule, and other employment terms. Since you're paid in cash, make sure you're getting some form of pay stub or record showing hours worked and wages paid.
Has anyone had luck using tax software like TurboTax or H&R Block for this? I'm in a similar situation and heard mixed things about how well they handle household employee situations.
I used TurboTax last year as a nanny. It worked fine for reporting my income with the W-2 my employer provided, but it doesn't help much with the situation where your employer isn't doing things correctly. If you need to file Form SS-8 or 8919, you might need to do that separately outside the software.
Just to add another perspective on prohibited transactions - if you haven't actually completed the transaction yet but are just planning it, you might want to look into requesting a Private Letter Ruling (PLR) from the IRS. It costs money (I think around $10,000 now), but they'll give you a binding determination on whether your specific transaction would be prohibited. Of course, that doesn't help if you've already done the transaction, but it's something to consider for future self-directed IRA investments if you're in a gray area.
Is a Private Letter Ruling actually worth the cost though? I've heard they take forever to get (like 6-9 months) and by then your investment opportunity might be gone. Have you actually done one yourself for an IRA transaction?
You're absolutely right about the timeframe - they typically take 6-9 months, which makes them impractical for many time-sensitive investments. I haven't personally done one, but a business partner did for a significant real estate investment he was considering through his self-directed IRA. For smaller investments, the cost usually doesn't make sense. But if you're considering a large transaction with millions at stake, or a recurring investment strategy you plan to use multiple times, it can be worth the peace of mind. In my partner's case, the PLR actually saved him from making what would have been deemed a prohibited transaction, potentially saving him hundreds of thousands in taxes and penalties.
Has anyone successfully used a roth conversion ladder after dealing with a prohibited transaction? I'm wondering if there's a strategic way to handle the taxes by converting to a Roth and spreading the tax impact.
A Roth conversion ladder won't help after a prohibited transaction has already occurred. Once the prohibited transaction happens, the IRA is immediately considered distributed as of January 1 of that year. It's no longer an IRA that can be converted to a Roth. You could potentially use the distributed funds to contribute to a new Roth IRA (subject to income limits and annual contribution caps), but you'd still owe taxes and penalties on the full distribution from the disqualified IRA first.
Sean O'Connor
I'm a little late to this thread, but I wanted to add that backslash characters are sometimes used in programming for "escaping" special characters. In your tax software, it might be a bug where the program is displaying the escape characters that should be hidden. Different tax software handles special characters differently. If you're using one of the major programs like TurboTax, H&R Block, or TaxAct, you should report this as a bug. They usually release updates throughout tax season to fix these kinds of issues.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
ā¢Is there a way to do a quick check for these hidden characters across my whole return? I'm using TaxAct and now I'm worried there might be backslashes I'm not seeing.
0 coins
Sean O'Connor
ā¢The best way to check your entire return is to create the PDF preview (usually there's a "Preview" or "Print Preview" option) and then use the search function (Ctrl+F on Windows or Command+F on Mac) to search for the backslash character. Just type \ in the search box and it will highlight any instances throughout the document. TaxAct also has a built-in error checker that runs before you file. While it might not specifically call out backslashes, it should catch most formatting issues that would cause rejection. If you're still concerned, you can also print the entire return and visually scan the fields where you entered text (like name, address, occupation) for any unexpected characters.
0 coins
Luca Conti
I'm having the exact same issue but with forward slashes (/) in my software. Anyone know if this causes the same problems? I noticed them appearing randomly in some of my address fields.
0 coins
Nia Johnson
ā¢Forward slashes can definitely cause similar problems. The IRS systems interpret them as date separators or division operators in some contexts. I'd recommend removing them from any text fields like addresses. Only use them where they're expected (like in dates formatted as MM/DD/YYYY).
0 coins