


Ask the community...
Slightly different perspective - have you checked if you might qualify for the reduced 50% exclusion rather than the 100% exclusion? The rules vary based on when the stock was acquired as C corp shares. For C corp shares acquired after August 10, 1993 but before February 18, 2009, you can exclude 50% of the gain. For shares acquired after February 18, 2009 and before September 28, 2010, you can exclude 75%. And for shares acquired after September 28, 2010, you can exclude 100%. But this all depends on when the shares were acquired as C corp shares, which in your case sounds like October 2018, so you'd be in the 100% category if you met the holding period.
This is a good point, but the exclusion percentages only matter if OP meets the 5-year holding requirement first, which seems to be the main issue here. Being 2 months short of 5 years means they likely can't access any of the exclusion percentages.
I'm really sorry to hear about your situation - being just two months short of the 5-year requirement is incredibly frustrating, especially when you've been with the company since its founding. While the other commenters are correct about the general rule that C-Corp holding periods don't "tack" from previous entity types, there might be one avenue worth exploring given your specific timeline. Since your S-Corp to C-Corp conversion happened in October 2018, you should definitely investigate whether this qualified as a tax-free reorganization under Section 368 of the Internal Revenue Code. If the conversion was properly structured as a Section 368 reorganization (which many S-Corp to C-Corp conversions are), there's potentially an argument for holding period tacking under certain circumstances. This is an extremely technical area of tax law where the specific documentation and structure of your conversion matters enormously. Given the potential tax savings at stake, I'd strongly recommend consulting with a tax attorney who specializes specifically in Section 1202 and corporate reorganizations - not just a general CPA. You'll need someone who can review your conversion documents, operating agreements, and any legal opinions from 2018 to determine if there's any path forward. The fact that you were kept in the dark about sale details is also concerning from a fiduciary duty standpoint, but that's a separate issue. For now, focus on gathering all your corporate documents from the 2018 conversion and get specialized legal advice before your filing deadline.
My partner and I did this 3 years ago! One tip: consider putting only one person on the mortgage but both on the deed if your bank allows it. That way, only one person claims all the interest but both have ownership. We did this bc my credit score was way better so I got the loan alone (better rate!) but we're both on the deed. The person not on the mortgage can just transfer their share of the payment to the mortgage holder, who then makes the full payment and claims 100% of the deduction. Simplifies taxes a lot! But u need to trust each other obvs.
Isn't that technically mortgage fraud? I thought the person claiming the deduction has to be legally responsible for the debt. If only one person is on the mortgage, can they really claim 100% even if the other person is paying half?
Just a warning - I tried doing this exact arrangement and it backfired on me. When my partner and I split, I had no legal right to the mortgage interest deductions despite paying half the mortgage for years. Also created huge issues when we sold since I was on the deed but not the mortgage. Would not recommend.
Great question! I went through this exact situation two years ago when my partner and I bought our first home. Here's what I learned from working with both a tax professional and mortgage lender: Since you're both on the mortgage and splitting payments 50/50, you can each deduct your proportional share of the mortgage interest on your individual tax returns. Keep detailed records of who pays what - bank statements, cancelled checks, or electronic transfer records showing each person's contribution. One key thing to watch out for: the mortgage lender will send ONE Form 1098 (mortgage interest statement) to whoever is listed as the primary borrower. You'll need to coordinate to ensure you both get the information needed for your tax returns. Some couples scan and share the 1098, others request the lender send copies to both parties. Also, don't forget about property taxes! If you're splitting those 50/50 as well, you can each deduct your portion of property taxes paid, which also goes on Schedule A. Given your combined income of $180k and a $520k mortgage, you'll likely have enough deductions to make itemizing worthwhile. The mortgage interest alone in your first few years will probably exceed the standard deduction threshold. One last tip: consider having a tax pro review your first year's return to make sure you're handling everything correctly. It's worth the cost to get it right from the start!
When I won on a Canadian game show (different one, smaller prize), they actually withheld Canadian taxes first, then I had to report it in the US. But I got a foreign tax credit for the Canadian taxes paid, so I didn't end up paying double. Make sure your cousin keeps ALL documentation they gave her. Also, if this aired on TV, keep a copy of the episode if possible as proof if ever questioned.
Your cousin should also be prepared for this to potentially affect her state taxes in Massachusetts. Game show winnings are typically subject to state income tax as well, so she'll need to report the $25,000 on her Massachusetts return too. One more thing - if the show hasn't aired yet, she might want to consider making quarterly estimated tax payments now rather than waiting until next year's filing deadline. Owing $25k worth of additional taxable income could result in a significant tax bill, and the IRS charges underpayment penalties if you don't pay enough throughout the year. She can calculate roughly what she'll owe using her current tax bracket and make payments using Form 1040ES. The safe harbor rule is to pay at least 90% of this year's tax liability or 100% of last year's (110% if her previous year's AGI was over $150k). Since this is unexpected income, making an estimated payment could save her from penalties later.
Did you claim any credits like EIC or Child Tax Credit? Those automatically get extra scrutiny and slow down processing.
Nope, just a simple return with W2 income and standard deduction. That's why I'm confused about the delay.
I'm in a very similar situation - filed on March 8th and still getting that same "processing delayed" message with Tax Topic 152. My transcript has been completely blank for 7 weeks now. What's really frustrating is that I had a simple return too - just W2 income, standard deduction, no credits or complications. I've been checking the WMR tool almost daily and it's maddening to see the same message over and over. Like you, I'm starting to wonder if something went wrong or if my return got lost in the system somehow. The fact that the transcript shows absolutely nothing is what worries me most. Reading through these comments has been really helpful though - especially learning about ERS (Error Resolution System) from the former IRS employee. At least now I understand this is unfortunately normal for this filing season, even though it's incredibly stressful when you're waiting on your refund. I think I'm going to wait until I hit the 8-week mark before trying to call, based on the advice here. The phone situation sounds absolutely brutal right now. Has anyone had success getting through recently, or is it still basically impossible?
I'm dealing with the exact same thing! Filed March 12th and it's been 6+ weeks of that same frustrating message. The blank transcript is what gets me too - like did they even receive it? From what I've read here, it seems like this ERS queue situation is just the reality this year. I tried calling twice last week and couldn't get through after 2+ hours on hold each time. Thinking I might try that Claimyr thing people mentioned if I don't see any movement by week 8. At least knowing other people are in the same boat makes me feel less crazy for checking the WMR tool every single day š The waiting is the worst part when you have no idea what's actually happening behind the scenes.
Emma Garcia
Quick update for everyone who offered advice - I've completely revamped my study plan based on your suggestions. I'm now: 1) Taking active notes while listening to TaxMama 2) Doing 15 practice questions after each chapter 3) Using flashcards for difficult concepts 4) Joined two EA exam Facebook groups 5) Reading Circular 230 directly I'm feeling much more confident about my approach now. The tip about interleaving different study methods instead of doing them sequentially was particularly eye-opening. Thank you all so much!
0 coins
Anna Stewart
That's a fantastic study plan revision, Emma! It sounds like you've really taken the advice to heart and created a comprehensive approach. One additional tip I'd suggest - since you mentioned you're juggling this with family life, consider setting up a study tracking spreadsheet or app to monitor your progress across all these different methods. It helps you see which areas need more attention and keeps you motivated when you can visually see your improvement. Also, since you're scheduled for January 5th, make sure to take a full-length practice exam under timed conditions about 2-3 weeks before your test date. This will help you identify any remaining weak spots and get comfortable with the exam format and timing. The real exam can feel quite different from doing scattered practice questions. Best of luck with your EA journey - your dedication and willingness to adapt your approach based on feedback shows you're going to do great!
0 coins