


Ask the community...
Has anyone actually had the IRS audit them for this? I have a trucking company and a property management LLC. Both 100% owned by me. I've been running separate retirement plans for years with no issues.
You've been lucky so far, but this is exactly the kind of situation the IRS looks for in audits. I work for a TPA (third-party administrator) for retirement plans, and we see this scenario frequently. Once the IRS discovers this in an audit, you'd face: 1. Plan disqualification 2. Immediate taxation of all plan assets 3. Penalties and interest 4. Required retroactive contributions for excluded employees The costs can be astronomical. I'd strongly recommend getting this fixed before you're audited.
Your colleague is definitely wrong here. The controlled group rules under IRC Section 414(b) and (c) are crystal clear - if the same person owns 80% or more of multiple businesses, they form a controlled group for retirement plan purposes regardless of what industries they're in or where they're located. In your example with 100% ownership of both the dental practice and auto repair shop, these absolutely constitute a brother-sister controlled group. The owner cannot set up a retirement plan for just the auto shop without including eligible employees from the dental practice in the nondiscrimination testing. The IRS specifically designed these rules to prevent exactly what your colleague is suggesting - cherry-picking which employees to cover based on business profitability or convenience. The fact that the businesses are unrelated operationally is completely irrelevant to the controlled group determination. I'd recommend showing your colleague the actual code sections or getting a definitive ruling from a qualified ERISA attorney. This is one of those areas where being wrong can result in massive penalties and plan disqualification.
This is really helpful clarification! I'm new to business ownership and honestly had no idea these controlled group rules even existed. I was actually considering setting up a second LLC for a side consulting business and was planning to do separate retirement plans. Sounds like I need to understand these rules before I make any moves. Are there any good resources you'd recommend for learning more about controlled groups and retirement plan requirements? I want to make sure I don't accidentally create compliance issues down the road.
Has anyone successfully gotten this tax forgiven or reduced? I'm a single parent and was self-employed in 2020 during the pandemic just trying to keep my family afloat. Now they're hitting me with this huge bill for taxes I didn't even know were deferred.
Unfortunately, these deferred taxes can't be forgiven - they were just postponed, not eliminated. But you might qualify for a payment plan as others have mentioned, which could make it more manageable. Also check if you qualify for first-time penalty abatement if there are penalties attached.
I went through this exact same situation last year! As a self-employed person, you ARE responsible for paying this because when you're self-employed, you're considered both the employer and employee for tax purposes. The "employer's share" refers to the 6.2% Social Security tax that was deferred under the CARES Act. Here's what likely happened: When you (or your tax preparer) filed your 2020 taxes, the deferral was automatically applied to reduce what you owed at that time. This was actually beneficial then, but now that deferred amount is coming due. Don't panic about the 3-week deadline - you have options! You can set up a payment plan directly with the IRS online if you can't pay the full $3,800 at once. For amounts under $50,000, you can get up to 72 months to pay it off. The setup fee is only about $31 if you do it online with automatic payments. Check your 2020 tax return (specifically Schedule SE) to confirm the deferral was taken. And definitely don't ignore this - the sooner you address it, the better your options will be. Payment plans stop most penalties from accumulating, which saves you money in the long run.
I went through this exact situation with my amended return last year! The key thing to understand is that there's no separate "amended return transcript" - everything shows up on your regular Account Transcript on the IRS website. You'll want to log into irs.gov, go to "Get Transcript Online" and pull your Account Transcript for the tax year you amended (so if you amended your 2022 return, look at the 2022 Account Transcript). Look for transaction code TC 971 which means they received your amended return, and TC 977 which means it's been processed. The "Where's My Amended Return" tool is honestly pretty useless - it rarely updates and gives minimal info. Unfortunately, the processing times right now are brutal - despite the official 16-week timeline, most people are waiting 6-8 months or even longer. I know it's incredibly frustrating, especially when you're anxious about the status, but at least checking the Account Transcript will give you a clearer picture of where things actually stand in the process.
This is such a helpful breakdown, thank you! I'm dealing with the same situation and had no idea about the difference between Account Transcript vs Return Transcript. Just checked mine and found the TC 971 code from June but no TC 977 yet - at least now I know what to look for instead of just refreshing that useless "Where's My Amended Return" page every day. The 6-8 month wait time is honestly shocking though, especially when TurboTax made it seem like it would be much faster. Really glad I found this thread because the IRS website explanations are so confusing!
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! Filed my amended return through TurboTax in April and have been going crazy trying to track the status. After reading through all these responses, I finally understand that I need to check my Account Transcript on the IRS website instead of relying on that useless "Where's My Amended Return" tool. Just logged in and found the TC 971 code showing they received it, but no TC 977 yet which means it's still processing. The 6-8 month timeline everyone is mentioning is absolutely insane - I had no idea it would take this long when I filed! TurboTax definitely doesn't prepare you for the reality of amended return processing times. Thanks to everyone who explained the transaction codes - this has been way more helpful than anything I could find on the official IRS site. Guess I'll just have to be patient and keep checking that Account Transcript every few weeks. Never using TurboTax for amendments again though!
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - there are different rules if your annual business income is over $27 million (average of last 3 years). If you're over that threshold, you're considered a "tax shelter" and subject to different bonus depreciation rules. Also, the bonus depreciation rules are different depending on when you placed the properties in service. The 2017 tax reform made big changes: - 100% for property placed in service after 9/27/2017 through 2022 - 80% for 2023 - 60% for 2024 - 40% for 2025 - 20% for 2026 - 0% after 2026 Make sure your CPA considers these phase-out periods!
Lol I wish I had the problem of $27 million in annual income from my STRs! But seriously, do you know if there's any minimum property value where cost segregation makes sense? I've got a small cabin I rent out that's only worth about $175k total.
The general rule of thumb is that cost segregation starts to make financial sense when the property value is $500k or higher, but it depends on several factors. For your $175k cabin, the study itself might cost between $3k-$5k, so you'd need to weigh that against the potential tax savings. However, if you purchased the cabin recently and could do a simplified cost segregation (like with one of the AI tools mentioned above), the economics might work out even at that lower value. Look at your cabin's components - if you have a lot of specialized systems (hot tub, custom lighting, high-end appliances, extensive landscaping), you might have more segregation opportunities than a basic property. You also need to consider your tax bracket - the higher your rate, the more valuable the accelerated deductions.
Be careful with DIY cost segregation! I tried to do my own for my rental last year based on some percentages I found online, and ended up getting audited. The IRS wanted to see a formal engineering report to back up my allocations. If you're going to do this, either use one of the specialized services mentioned or get a real cost segregation study from a qualified firm. The few thousand you'll spend on proper documentation is worth it compared to dealing with an audit and potential penalties.
I'm curious about this too! Also, what kind of documentation did they specifically ask for during the audit? I'm planning to do cost segregation on a few properties I built myself and want to make sure I have everything properly documented upfront. Did you end up having to pay penalties or just back taxes?
@Keith Davidson I m'really sorry to hear about your audit situation - that sounds stressful! This is exactly the kind of scenario I m'trying to avoid. Could you share what specific red flags might have triggered the audit? Was it the amounts you claimed, the way you allocated the depreciation, or something else? Also, for those of us considering cost segregation, what would you recommend as the minimum documentation to have in place before filing? I d'rather spend a bit more upfront on proper documentation than deal with audit headaches later.
Paolo Conti
Quick tip: If you're still worried, you can also check your payment status by requesting your tax account transcript on the IRS website. It's free and usually updates within a week after a payment is processed. Just go to IRS.gov, create an account if you don't have one, and request an "account transcript" for the current tax year. The transcript will show any payments received and when they were applied to your account. Much easier than calling in most cases!
0 coins
Amina Diallo
ā¢Does the transcript show pending payments or only fully processed ones? My payment was just made yesterday.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
ā¢The transcript only shows fully processed payments, not pending ones. If you just made your payment yesterday, it probably won't appear on your transcript for at least 3-5 business days, possibly longer during the busy filing season. The account transcript is great for confirmation after the fact, but if you need immediate verification that a very recent payment is in the system, calling the IRS is usually the only option. That's why some people use services to help them get through on the phone lines during busy periods.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Just a heads up for anyone using payusatax - they charge a processing fee that's higher than some other payment options. I think it was like 1.96% when I used it. If you're paying a large amount, it might be worth looking at other IRS-approved payment methods like DirectPay (free but sometimes glitchy) or EFTPS (free but requires registration ahead of time).
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
ā¢Thanks for mentioning this! I just checked and paid an extra $75 in processing fees that I didn't notice. Are there really free options?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
ā¢Yes, there are free options! DirectPay on the IRS website is completely free for bank transfers, though as Oliver mentioned it can be buggy during peak times. EFTPS (Electronic Federal Tax Payment System) is also free but you need to enroll in advance which obviously doesn't help if you're filing last minute. For future reference, some credit card processors charge less than payusatax - I think Pay1040 was around 1.87% last time I checked. But honestly, when you're up against the deadline like the original poster, sometimes paying the processing fee is worth the peace of mind of using a reliable service that you know will get your payment through on time.
0 coins