


Ask the community...
Be careful with the terminology here. In a C Corp, technically you don't take "draws" like you would in an LLC or partnership. You take either salary (through payroll) or dividends (distributions of profit). The IRS is very particular about C Corp owners taking reasonable compensation through payroll before taking dividends. This is because they want to collect those FICA taxes. If you try to bypass this by taking only dividends, they can reclassify those payments and hit you with penalties. Also, distributing invested capital back to shareholders is a whole different issue - that's actually a return of capital and has different tax implications than either salary or dividends. You should definitely talk to a CPA about this specific situation.
Thanks for pointing this out. I think I've been using the wrong terminology which probably contributed to my confusion. So if we're using investment money to pay ourselves, that's not technically a "draw" or even a dividend, right?
That's exactly right. In a C Corp, there's no such thing as an "owner's draw" like there would be in an LLC or partnership. When you take money out of a C Corp, it has to be classified as either salary, dividends, a loan to shareholder, or return of capital. If you're using investment money to pay yourselves, the proper way to do this is typically through salary via payroll. This is especially true if you're actively working in the business. The corporation can deduct this as a business expense, and you'll pay income and payroll taxes on it. Taking investment money and distributing it directly as dividends or return of capital could potentially create issues with both the IRS and your investors, as that money was invested for business operations, not personal distributions. This is why setting up proper payroll is really the safest approach.
This is a great discussion and really highlights the complexity of C Corp compensation rules. I'm glad you updated your post to mention setting up proper payroll - that's absolutely the right approach. One additional point I'd add is that the IRS has specific guidelines for what constitutes "reasonable compensation" that go beyond just market rates. They look at factors like the company's financial condition, your role and responsibilities, time devoted to the business, and the company's dividend history. For pre-revenue startups, this often means you can justify below-market salaries, but you still need to document your reasoning. Also, regarding the investment capital distribution issue - it's worth noting that many investment agreements actually include provisions about founder compensation. Some investors expect founders to take reasonable salaries as part of the investment structure, while others prefer founders to have more "skin in the game" with lower compensation. Always check your investment docs before making these decisions. The key takeaway is that the IRS wants to see active shareholders receiving W-2 wages before taking any distributions. Even if it means higher payroll costs in the short term, it protects you from much bigger problems down the road.
This is really helpful information, especially about the IRS guidelines for reasonable compensation. I'm curious about the documentation aspect you mentioned - what kind of records should we be keeping to justify our salary decisions? Is it enough to just document comparable salaries in our industry, or do we need more formal documentation like board resolutions or compensation studies? Also, for a pre-revenue startup, how do we balance the need for reasonable compensation with conserving cash flow? Any specific percentage of funding or revenue benchmarks that are commonly used?
One thing nobody's mentioned - check if your state offers income tax deductions or credits for 529 contributions! In our state, we get a deduction up to $10k annually for contributions to our state's 529 plan, which saves us about $700 in state taxes each year.
Great question! You're smart to think through the gift tax implications upfront. The key thing to understand is that for married couples filing jointly, you can absolutely contribute the full $34k from a single account (whether joint or individual) and still stay within the gift tax exemption limits. Here's what you need to know: Each spouse gets their own $17,000 annual exclusion per beneficiary, so together you can gift $34,000 to your son without triggering gift tax. The IRS doesn't care which specific account the money comes from - what matters is that you properly document the gift as coming from both spouses. If you fund the entire amount from one account, you'll need to file Form 709 (Gift Tax Return) to elect "gift splitting." This form tells the IRS that both you and your wife are treating the $34k as two separate $17k gifts, even though the money came from one source. Both spouses need to sign this form. The good news is there's no actual tax owed - you're just documenting that you're using both of your annual exclusions. This is a common scenario and the IRS handles it routinely.
This is exactly the clarity I was looking for! Just to make sure I understand correctly - even though we file jointly, we still need to file the Form 709 to document the gift splitting? I was hoping the joint filing status would automatically handle this, but it sounds like the gift splitting election is a separate step that requires its own paperwork. Also, do you know if there's a deadline for filing Form 709? Is it due with our regular tax return or does it have its own filing date?
I work at a public library and can confirm we're a great option for printing tax documents! A few things that might help put your mind at ease: **Privacy protections we have:** - All print jobs are automatically deleted from our system after 24 hours (most are deleted immediately after printing) - Our computers have privacy screens and are positioned so other patrons can't easily see your screen - We have a "secure print" option where documents only print when you enter your code at the printer - Staff are trained on privacy protocols and won't look at your documents unless you specifically ask for help **Practical tips:** - Bring your documents on a USB drive rather than emailing them to yourself - Our color printing is $0.25/page, black & white is $0.10/page - much cheaper than commercial options - Call ahead to make sure our printers are working and ask about busy times to avoid - You'll need a library card, but they're free with proof of address **What you actually need to print:** Most people over-print their tax documents! You typically only need to print forms that require original signatures (like your 1040 and any schedules with signature lines). Supporting documents and worksheets can usually stay digital. We see people printing tax documents all the time, especially this time of year, so you won't stand out at all. The whole process is very routine and private. Good luck getting everything filed on time!
Thank you so much for the insider perspective! As someone who's been stressing about this for days, it's really reassuring to hear from someone who actually works at a library and sees this situation all the time. The secure print option sounds perfect - I had no idea that was even a thing libraries offered. Your point about over-printing is spot on too. I was definitely planning to print my entire 35-page tax package when I probably only need like 5-6 forms with actual signature requirements. That alone will save me a few dollars and reduce the amount of sensitive paperwork I'm carrying around. One quick question - do most libraries have the same privacy protocols you mentioned, or should I specifically ask about secure printing when I call? I want to make sure I'm not assuming every library has the same setup as yours. Thanks again for taking the time to explain everything! This has definitely moved the library to the top of my list over the commercial printing options.
@81d616e4ce14 You should definitely ask about secure printing specifically when you call ahead! Not all library systems have the same setup. Some smaller libraries might just have basic networked printers without the secure release feature. From my experience visiting different libraries, most larger public library systems do have secure printing options, but the exact process can vary. Some use codes you enter at the printer, others use your library card number, and a few still use the older "print immediately" system. The good news is that even libraries without secure printing still have good privacy practices - staff training on confidentiality is pretty standard. But if you want that extra layer of security where your documents don't print until you're physically at the machine, it's worth asking about when you call. Also, if your local library doesn't have secure printing, try calling a few others in your area. Many library systems are interconnected, so your library card might work at multiple locations, giving you options to find the setup you're most comfortable with.
Just wanted to add one more option that saved me last year - **hospital business centers**! I know it sounds weird, but many larger hospitals have business centers or "family resource centers" that offer printing services for patients and families who need to handle paperwork while dealing with medical situations. I discovered this when I was visiting a family member and desperately needed to print my tax forms. The staff was incredibly understanding and professional - they're used to handling sensitive documents all day (medical records, insurance forms, etc.) so tax documents didn't faze them at all. **Benefits:** - Usually very quiet and private - Staff are trained on confidentiality - Often available 24/7 or extended hours - Typically charge reasonable rates (mine was $0.15/page) - Less crowded than libraries or UPS stores **Things to consider:** - Call ahead to confirm they allow non-patient printing - Some might require you to be visiting someone or have a medical appointment - May have limited hours on weekends It's definitely not the first option most people think of, but if you're near a large medical center and other options aren't working out, it might be worth a call. The privacy and professionalism were honestly better than any commercial printing service I've used. Hope you get everything sorted before the deadline!
Warning from someone who messed this up! If your illustration work involves you physically being in the US at any point (like for meetings, reference gathering, etc.), the rules are COMPLETELY different! I had a US magazine gig that required a 2-day visit to their office, and I didn't realize this meant I couldn't use the standard W-8BEN approach. Had to file actual US taxes and everything was a nightmare. Just make sure you're doing 100% of the work from the UK and never step foot in the US for any part of this project!
Omg that sounds awful! How did you end up resolving it? Did you have to get an accountant involved?
As someone who's helped several UK freelancers with W-8BEN forms, I'd recommend double-checking one thing that hasn't been mentioned yet - make sure your illustration work actually qualifies as "royalties" under Article 12 rather than "business profits" under Article 7. If you're creating custom illustrations specifically for this magazine (like commissioned artwork), it might technically fall under business profits rather than royalties. True royalties are typically for licensing existing copyrighted material. The good news is that both articles generally result in 0% withholding for UK residents, so the practical outcome is the same. But it's worth being precise about which treaty provision you're claiming. Also, keep detailed records of all your communications and the work you're doing from the UK - this documentation can be helpful if there are ever any questions about your tax status down the line. The advice about leaving Section 5 blank is absolutely correct for your situation. Don't stress about it - thousands of UK freelancers successfully complete these forms every year!
This is such a helpful distinction! I'm actually doing commissioned artwork specifically for this magazine (they gave me a brief and everything), so it sounds like Article 7 might be more accurate for my situation. Should I be worried about getting this wrong? Like if I put Article 12 instead of Article 7, could that cause problems later on? Since you mentioned both result in 0% withholding anyway, I'm wondering if it's worth overthinking this detail or if I should just pick one and move forward. Also, what kind of documentation should I be keeping? Just emails with the client, or do I need anything more formal?
Amelia Dietrich
Just to add some additional information that might be helpful: if you're concerned about the offset amount, you can request an offset trace by calling the Treasury Offset Program at 1-800-304-3107. They can tell you exactly how much will be taken and for what debt. I was so frustrated when this happened to me last year! Also, if you filed jointly and the student loan belongs only to your spouse, you might qualify for injured spouse relief (Form 8379) which could protect your portion of the refund from the offset. It's too late for this year since you've already filed, but something to consider for next year.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
I went through this exact situation last year with my spouse's old student loan debt. Here's what actually happened in my case: The IRS processed our joint refund of $5,200. Republic Bank got their $2,000 advance payment first, then Treasury Offset took $2,800 for the student loans, and I received the remaining $400 via direct deposit to the same account I originally specified when filing. One thing that really helped was setting up an account on studentaid.gov to see the exact offset amount ahead of time. The Treasury Offset Program also sent a notice about 30 days before they actually took the money, which gave me time to mentally prepare for how much I'd actually receive. The whole process took about 3 weeks from when my return was accepted to when I got the final deposit. Republic Bank was actually pretty transparent about the timeline when I called them directly - they have a specific department that handles these offset situations since they're so common with tax advances. Just hang in there - the system works, it's just nerve-wracking when you're waiting and don't know exactly what to expect!
0 coins
StormChaser
ā¢This is super helpful! I didn't know about studentaid.gov showing offset amounts ahead of time. That would definitely help with planning. Quick question - when you called Republic Bank's offset department, did they charge any additional fees for handling the offset situation, or was it just the standard advance fees you already knew about?
0 coins