


Ask the community...
As someone who works in college admissions, I wanted to add a few money-saving tips that might help offset some of these application costs that can't be covered by 529 funds: 1. Fee waivers - Many colleges offer application fee waivers for students who qualify based on income or participation in programs like free/reduced lunch. Don't assume you won't qualify - the income thresholds are often higher than expected. 2. Apply early decision/early action where possible - Some schools waive application fees for early applicants or offer reduced fees. 3. Visit virtual campus tours first - Most schools now offer comprehensive virtual experiences that can help you narrow down which schools are worth the expense of an in-person visit. 4. Look into SAT/ACT fee waivers - Low-income students can get up to 4 free SAT attempts plus free score reports to colleges. 5. Some schools participate in "application blitzes" or have special free application periods - usually announced on their social media or websites. While it's disappointing that 529 plans can't cover these pre-enrollment costs, there are definitely ways to reduce the financial burden. Every dollar saved on applications is more money available for actual college expenses!
This is incredibly helpful advice from an admissions perspective! I had no idea about application fee waivers or that some schools have free application periods. The virtual campus tour suggestion is especially smart - we were planning to visit 8-10 schools in person which would have been a huge expense. Do you happen to know if the fee waiver eligibility is consistent across schools, or does each college have different income requirements? Also, are there specific times of year when schools are more likely to offer those free application promotions? This could really help us strategize which schools to prioritize for visits and applications while keeping costs manageable.
Fee waiver eligibility does vary by school, but most use similar guidelines based on family income or participation in federal assistance programs. Generally, if you qualify for free/reduced lunch or have a family income under $50,000-$65,000 (depending on family size), you'll likely qualify at most institutions. Some schools are more generous and extend waivers to families earning up to $100,000. For timing, I'd recommend checking college websites in late summer/early fall when they announce their application seasons. Many schools offer free application weeks during National College Application Week (usually in October) or during their own promotional periods. Private schools sometimes waive fees during yield protection periods in late fall/winter to encourage more applications. Pro tip: if you're unsure about fee waiver eligibility, just ask! Most admissions offices are happy to work with families on application costs. The worst they can say is no, but you might be surprised how flexible they can be, especially if you're a strong candidate they want to recruit.
This thread has been incredibly informative! I'm in a similar situation with my son who's a junior, and I was definitely planning to use 529 funds for application fees before reading this. It's disappointing that these pre-enrollment costs don't qualify, but I appreciate everyone sharing their experiences and workarounds. One question I haven't seen addressed: what about test prep courses or tutoring? My son is planning to take a prep course for the SAT - would that qualify as a 529 expense since it's education-related, or does the same "pre-enrollment" rule apply? I'm assuming it doesn't qualify, but want to make sure before I budget for it separately. Also, has anyone dealt with National Merit Scholarship applications or other scholarship application fees? I'm wondering if those fall into the same non-qualified category. Thanks again to everyone who's shared their knowledge - this has saved me from making some expensive mistakes!
Unfortunately, test prep courses and tutoring also don't qualify as 529 expenses since they fall under the same "pre-enrollment" rule. The student needs to be enrolled in an eligible educational institution for the expenses to qualify, and test prep is considered preparation for enrollment rather than an actual educational expense. Same goes for scholarship application fees - they're treated the same as college application fees and aren't qualified 529 expenses. It's frustrating because these costs are all education-related, but the IRS is pretty strict about the enrollment requirement. The good news is that by planning ahead and budgeting separately for all these pre-enrollment costs (applications, test prep, scholarship fees, campus visits), you'll avoid any tax penalties and can save your 529 funds for the big expenses once your son is actually enrolled. Based on what others have shared, budgeting around $3,000-$5,000 total for the entire application process seems realistic depending on how many schools and what level of test prep you're considering.
Heads up! If your LLC elected S-Corporation status at any point, you need to file Form 1120-S instead of 1065. Made this mistake my first year and got a nasty letter from the IRS. Double check your entity classification before filing.
How would you know if your LLC has S-Corp status? We set up our LLC through LegalZoom a few years ago and I'm not sure what elections were made.
You would have had to specifically file Form 2553 (Election by a Small Business Corporation) with the IRS to obtain S-Corporation status. It doesn't happen automatically. You can confirm your entity's filing status by: 1) Looking at last year's tax return - if you filed Form 1120-S previously, you're an S-Corp. If you filed 1065, you're a partnership. 2) Calling the IRS Business line (with patience or using Claimyr) and asking them to confirm your entity's classification. 3) Checking your formation documents and any subsequent IRS correspondence. S-Corp election approval comes as a specific letter from the IRS. If you never specifically elected S-Corp status, then as a multi-member LLC you're almost certainly classified as a partnership for tax purposes and need to file Form 1065.
Just to clarify something that might be confusing from the thread - while there's no IRS filing fee for Form 1065, don't forget about your state requirements! Even with zero activity, many states still require annual filings and fees. For example, if you're in California, you'll owe the $800 minimum franchise tax even with no income. Texas has a "no tax due" report that still needs to be filed. Each state is different, so check your state's Secretary of State website or Department of Revenue. Also, since you mentioned this LLC has been inactive, you might want to consider formally dissolving it if you don't plan to use it. This could save you from ongoing state fees and annual filing requirements. You'd need to file a final Form 1065 (checking the "final return" box) and handle the state dissolution process, but it might be worth it long-term.
This is really helpful advice about state requirements! I had no idea about the California $800 fee even with zero income - that's brutal. Quick question though: if we dissolve the LLC, do we still need to file the 2024 Form 1065 first, or can we skip straight to dissolution? We're definitely not planning to use this LLC again and those ongoing state fees are exactly what I want to avoid.
This has been an incredibly thorough and helpful discussion! As someone who's been following along and learning from everyone's experiences, I wanted to add one more consideration that might be relevant for the original poster's situation. Since you mentioned this is a 28-unit apartment building with major renovations planned, you might want to look into whether any of your renovation work could qualify for the Opportunity Zone program benefits, assuming the property is located in a qualified zone. While this doesn't directly impact your passive loss situation, it could provide additional tax advantages that complement your strategy of becoming an active participant. Also, given the scale of your operation (28 units + major renovations + 500+ hours annually), you're essentially running a real estate business at this point. Have you considered whether forming a separate entity (like an LLC where you're the managing member) for your management activities might provide additional benefits? This could help clearly delineate your active role and potentially provide other business expense deductions related to your management activities. The documentation strategies everyone has shared here are gold - especially the detailed spreadsheet approach with photo references and decision documentation. It sounds like you're on the right track with your transition from passive to active participation. The fact that you'll likely have substantial income to offset those suspended losses against makes this a really smart strategic move both operationally and tax-wise. Best of luck with your renovation project! The combination of repositioning the asset while utilizing suspended passive losses should work out very well for you.
These are excellent additional points! The Opportunity Zone angle is particularly interesting - if the property is in a qualified zone, the timing could work out really well since you're doing major capital improvements anyway. The tax deferral and potential exclusion benefits could be substantial alongside the passive loss utilization strategy. Your point about forming a separate management entity is also worth exploring. I've seen some investors create management companies that they own/control to formalize their active role. This can help with documentation (management agreements, invoices for services, etc.) and might provide clearer evidence of material participation since you'd literally be running a property management business. One thing to consider with that approach - make sure any management fees paid between entities are reasonable and well-documented. The IRS scrutinizes related-party transactions, especially when there are significant tax benefits at stake. The scale of this operation really does sound more like a business than a passive investment at this point. Between the renovation project, active management of 28 units, and the strategic repositioning to increase rents by 40%, this is clearly entrepreneurial activity rather than passive investing. Thank you for such a comprehensive discussion everyone! This thread should be a great resource for anyone dealing with similar passive activity loss transitions.
This has been an incredibly educational thread! As someone new to real estate investing who's been lurking and learning, I'm amazed by the complexity of passive activity loss rules and how much strategic planning goes into managing them effectively. I'm currently considering my first real estate investment and this discussion has me thinking about the long-term implications of passive vs. active participation from day one. It sounds like if you're going to accumulate significant losses in the early years (which seems common with real estate), it's really important to have a plan for eventually becoming active so you can actually utilize those losses. A few things that stood out to me from this discussion: - The importance of documentation from day one, not just when you transition to active - How material participation is about decision-making authority, not just hours worked - The potential for substantial tax savings when you can finally use suspended losses against income - The various strategies (grouping activities, real estate professional status, etc.) that can optimize the benefits For the original poster, it sounds like you've got a great situation developing - becoming active right as your property is positioned to generate significant income to absorb those suspended losses. The timing couldn't be better! Thank you to everyone who shared their real-world experiences and detailed advice. This is exactly the kind of practical information that's so valuable for understanding how these complex tax rules work in practice.
Has anyone tried the "two-earner/multiple jobs worksheet" on the W4? My husband and I both work and I feel like we're always owing a ton at tax time despite both claiming "Single" on our W4s.
That worksheet is actually really important if you have two incomes in the household! The problem is that each employer calculates withholding as if that's your only job, so they're both using the standard deduction and lower tax brackets in their calculations. Without the multiple jobs adjustment, you'll almost always underwithhold.
I went through something similar when I switched from hourly to salary. The key thing to remember is that the W4 is just instructions to your employer - you're not changing your actual tax liability, just the timing of when you pay it. For your situation making $4,800/month, $950 in federal withholding does seem high unless you have no deductions. A few suggestions: 1. Use the IRS Withholding Estimator first - it's free and official 2. If you're single with no dependents, you might be able to increase your take-home by claiming some estimated deductions in Step 4(b) 3. Don't claim "exempt" unless you had zero tax liability last year AND expect zero this year The restaurant industry can be tricky because tip income affects your withholding calculations. Make sure you're accounting for all your income when using any calculator. And remember - it's better to owe a small amount than get a huge refund, since that's basically giving the government an interest-free loan of your money.
This is really helpful advice! I'm actually in a similar situation - just started a new job and realized I might be over-withholding. The tip about restaurant workers having tricky withholding makes a lot of sense since tip reporting can vary so much month to month. Quick question - when you mention claiming estimated deductions in Step 4(b), what kind of deductions would someone like Jade typically be able to claim? I'm thinking things like work uniforms, car expenses for work, or maybe student loan interest? Just want to make sure I understand what counts as legitimate deductions before I mess with my own W4.
Zoe Dimitriou
This is such a great question! I've been helping coordinate our local VITA program for the past three years, and we absolutely welcome high school volunteers. In fact, some of our most dedicated and tech-savvy volunteers have been teenagers. Most sites will start you in a support role - greeting taxpayers, helping with paperwork, or assisting with document organization. It's actually perfect for learning the ropes! You'll pick up so much about tax preparation just by observing and helping with the intake process. The certification process is the same for everyone, but don't let that intimidate you. The materials are designed to teach you everything from scratch. Many of our high school volunteers find the online training modules easier to navigate than some of the older volunteers do! My biggest tip: reach out to multiple VITA sites in your area. Some are more flexible with younger volunteers than others, and you want to find one that's enthusiastic about having student volunteers. Also, this experience will absolutely stand out on college applications - admissions officers love seeing practical community service that demonstrates real-world skills. Good luck with your search! Feel free to ask if you have any other questions about the volunteer experience.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
β’Thanks for sharing your experience as a coordinator! I'm really encouraged to hear that VITA sites are welcoming to high school volunteers. Do you have any recommendations for how to find and contact local VITA sites? I've been searching online but it's hard to find specific contact information for coordinators in my area. Also, when is the best time to reach out - should I wait until closer to tax season or start inquiring now?
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
β’@Carmen Vega Great question! The IRS has a VITA site locator tool on their website irs.gov (that) s'really helpful - just search for VITA "site locator and" you can find programs by ZIP code. You can also contact your local United Way, community colleges, libraries, and churches as they often host VITA sites. Now is actually the perfect time to reach out! Most coordinators start recruiting and planning in the fall for the upcoming tax season. This gives you time to complete training before the busy February-April period. Don t'wait until January - by then, most sites have already finalized their volunteer rosters. When you contact them, mention you re'a motivated high school student interested in gaining real-world experience. Many coordinators specifically value younger volunteers because you tend to be reliable and good with technology. Also ask if they have any partnerships with local high schools - some sites work directly with guidance counselors to recruit student volunteers. Pro tip: If the first site you contact isn t'accepting high school volunteers, ask them to recommend other sites in your area that might be. Coordinators usually know each other and can point you in the right direction!
0 coins
Freya Christensen
This thread has been incredibly helpful! As someone who's been thinking about volunteering with VITA myself (I'm a junior in high school), I wanted to add that I reached out to three different sites in my area last month and got very different responses. One site said they prefer volunteers 18+, another was thrilled to have high school students and immediately sent me training materials, and the third said they'd consider me for a greeter role but wanted to meet with my parents first. So definitely don't get discouraged if the first site you contact isn't enthusiastic - keep trying! I also discovered that some sites partner with high school business or accounting clubs, which might be another way to get involved. My school's FBLA chapter actually does a group volunteer project with our local VITA site each year. It's worth asking your teachers or guidance counselor if they know of any existing partnerships. The training really isn't as scary as it sounds either. I've been working through the online modules and they start with very basic concepts. Having no prior tax knowledge isn't a disadvantage - they assume you're starting from zero. Plus, YouTube has tons of supplementary videos that explain tax concepts if you get stuck on anything in the official materials.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
β’This is such valuable advice about reaching out to multiple sites! I'm a sophomore and was feeling discouraged after the first VITA coordinator I contacted said they only take college-age volunteers. Your experience shows it's really worth shopping around to find the right fit. The tip about checking with FBLA or other business clubs is brilliant - I hadn't thought of that approach. I'm going to ask my economics teacher if she knows about any school partnerships. It would be amazing to volunteer alongside classmates who are also interested in finance. Thanks for mentioning that the training starts from zero too. I was worried I'd be behind since I haven't taken any business classes yet, but it sounds like they really do teach you everything you need to know. Did you find any particular YouTube channels especially helpful for supplementing the official training materials?
0 coins