


Ask the community...
One more thing to consider - make sure you're looking at the right line on your tax forms when comparing calculations. The "total tax" should be what's on line 24 of Form 1040, which is your actual federal income tax liability before any withholding or payments are applied. Sometimes people accidentally compare their "amount owed" (which is total tax minus withholding) with their actual tax liability, creating confusion. With your income level around $130K and proper withholding of over $20K, you should definitely be getting a refund if your actual tax liability is in the $18K-$19K range like the IRS calculator suggests. Also, if you're still getting different results after double-checking your entries, try using a third calculator like the one on TaxAct or FreeTaxUSA just to get another data point. If two out of three calculators agree, you'll have more confidence in the correct amount.
This is excellent advice! I think you've hit on exactly what might be confusing me. I need to make sure I'm comparing the actual tax liability (line 24) and not mixing it up with what I owe after withholding. Looking back at my situation, if my actual federal tax liability is around $18,500 like the IRS calculator shows, and I had over $20,000 withheld, then a refund of $1,500+ makes total sense. I think H&R Block might be showing me something different - maybe including estimated payments or penalties I don't actually owe. I'll definitely try a third calculator like you suggested. Having multiple data points will give me much more confidence before I file. Thanks for the clear explanation about line 24 - that distinction between tax liability and amount owed is really important!
I see you're dealing with a really frustrating discrepancy! As someone who's been through similar tax confusion, here are a few additional things that might help: **Check for duplicate entries** - Sometimes tax software accidentally double-counts income or deductions. Make sure your W-2 wages and 1099-INT interest aren't being entered multiple times in H&R Block. **Look at the actual tax calculation breakdown** - In H&R Block, there should be a detailed view showing exactly how they calculated your tax. Look for the step-by-step breakdown: Total Income β AGI β Taxable Income β Tax Before Credits β Final Tax. Compare each step to what the IRS calculator shows. **Verify your withholding amount** - Double-check that you're entering the exact amount from Box 2 of your W-2 ($20,175) in both systems. A small typo here could throw everything off. Given your income level and withholding amount, the IRS calculator result makes much more sense. With around $130K total income, roughly $115K taxable income after standard deduction, your federal tax should indeed be in the $18K-$19K range. Getting a refund with over $20K withheld is exactly what I'd expect. I'd recommend completing the return with a different software (like FreeTaxUSA) as a third comparison point before filing. The pattern should become clear when you see which calculation is the outlier.
This is such a comprehensive breakdown - thank you! I'm definitely going to go through each of these steps. The duplicate entries point is particularly interesting because I remember having to re-enter my W-2 information in H&R Block when it didn't import correctly the first time. I might have accidentally left the old entries in there. I'm feeling much more confident now that the IRS calculator is probably right. The math just makes more sense - with my income level and the amount withheld, a refund around $1,600 seems reasonable. I'll try FreeTaxUSA as you suggested to get that third data point, and then I can file with confidence knowing I've triple-checked everything. Really appreciate everyone's help in this thread - you've all saved me from potentially making a costly mistake with H&R Block!
Just want to add a helpful tip for anyone going the Solo 401k route - I set one up last year through Fidelity and it was surprisingly straightforward. The whole process took about 20 minutes online, and they walked me through exactly how to calculate my contribution limits based on my 1099 income. One thing I wish someone had told me earlier: you can actually open a Solo 401k late in the year (even December) and still make contributions for that tax year, as long as you make the contributions by the tax filing deadline (including extensions). This gave me flexibility to see how much profit my business made before deciding on contribution amounts. The combination of maxing out a Solo 401k for myself AND doing a spousal IRA for my non-working husband has been a game-changer for our retirement savings. We went from saving maybe $12,000/year to over $30,000/year in tax-advantaged accounts.
This is really helpful! I'm curious about the contribution timing - when you say you can make contributions by the tax filing deadline, does that include both the employee AND employer portions of the Solo 401k? I've heard conflicting info about whether the employer contribution has to be made by December 31st or if it also gets the extension to the filing deadline. Also, did you have to do anything special to coordinate the Solo 401k with your spousal IRA contributions to make sure you didn't accidentally over-contribute based on your total earned income?
For Solo 401k timing, both the employee and employer contributions can be made up to the tax filing deadline (including extensions). The employee portion is treated like a salary deferral and the employer portion is a business deduction, but both get the same deadline flexibility for sole proprietors and single-member LLCs. Regarding coordination with spousal IRA - you don't really need to worry about over-contributing across different account types since they have separate limits. Your Solo 401k limits are based on your self-employment income, and the spousal IRA has its own $7,000 limit. The only thing to watch is that your total earned income needs to cover all contributions combined. So if you made $50,000 self-employment income, you could potentially do a Solo 401k contribution based on that PLUS the $7,000 spousal IRA, as long as your combined contributions don't exceed your earned income.
As someone who went through this exact same situation a few years ago, I can confirm what others have said - you definitely cannot contribute to your spouse's old 401k. That was my first instinct too, but it's simply not allowed once they're no longer employed there. What worked really well for us was the combination approach: I set up a SEP IRA for my self-employment income (super easy to do) and opened a spousal IRA for my non-working partner. The SEP IRA gave me much higher contribution limits than I expected - I was able to put away about 20% of my net self-employment income, which was way more than the $7,000 IRA limit. One thing I learned the hard way: make sure you're calculating your net self-employment income correctly for the SEP IRA contribution. You have to subtract the self-employment tax deduction first, which I initially missed. The IRS has worksheets that walk through this calculation, but it's definitely worth double-checking with a tax professional or using one of the tools others mentioned here. The spousal IRA was incredibly straightforward - just opened a regular IRA in my spouse's name and contributed to it from our joint finances. Come tax time, filing jointly made it all work seamlessly.
This is exactly the kind of real-world experience I was looking for! I'm in a similar boat with self-employment income and was getting overwhelmed by all the different retirement account options. Quick question - when you say you were able to put away about 20% with the SEP IRA, was that 20% of your gross self-employment income or the net amount after the self-employment tax deduction? I want to make sure I'm estimating my potential contributions correctly when I start planning for next year. Also, did you find any particular resources or worksheets that were especially helpful for calculating the SEP IRA contribution limits? I've looked at the IRS publications but they can be pretty dense to work through.
I completely feel your frustration! This exact same thing happened to me last month - got disconnected twice right in the middle of providing my verification information after waiting over an hour each time. It's absolutely infuriating when you finally get through just to have the call drop. What eventually worked for me was calling at exactly 7:00 AM on a Tuesday. The connection seemed much more stable in the early morning, and I got through in about 40 minutes instead of the usual 2+ hour wait. When the agent picked up, I immediately asked "Can you hear me clearly and is this connection stable?" before starting any verification. I also had absolutely everything written down beforehand - SSN, last year's AGI, filing status, exact refund amount - so I could provide it all quickly without fumbling around looking for documents. The agent was able to complete my verification in just a few minutes, and she even made a note in my account about the previous disconnections. My refund was processed and deposited within about 10 days after the verification was completed. Don't give up - that $3,400 is rightfully yours! The early morning timing really does seem to make a huge difference with their system stability. Try again tomorrow morning right when they open and you should have much better luck.
This is exactly what I needed to hear! I've been so discouraged after multiple disconnections, but your success story gives me real hope. The 7 AM Tuesday timing seems to be the magic formula that everyone who actually gets through mentions. I really appreciate the tip about asking upfront if the connection is stable - that's such a simple but brilliant way to avoid wasting time on a call that's going to drop anyway. And having everything written down beforehand is definitely something I need to do better. I think part of my problem has been fumbling around looking for documents while the agent is waiting. It's so reassuring to know that your refund came through relatively quickly once verification was complete. After dealing with this for weeks, 10 days sounds amazing! I'm going to try your exact approach next week - call right at 7 AM, confirm connection stability first, have all my info ready to go, and ask them to note the previous disconnection issues. Thanks for taking the time to share what actually worked - hearing concrete success stories from people who dealt with the same nightmare really helps me believe this will eventually get resolved!
This is absolutely infuriating and I completely understand your frustration! I went through the exact same nightmare two months ago - got disconnected FOUR times during verification attempts after waiting 2+ hours each time. I was ready to give up on my $2,800 refund. What finally worked for me was calling at exactly 7:00 AM on a Wednesday morning. I got through in about 25 minutes instead of the usual marathon wait. The key things I did differently: 1) Asked immediately if the connection was stable before starting verification, 2) Had everything written down and ready (SSN, 2023 AGI, filing status, exact refund amount), and 3) Asked the agent to note in my account that I'd been disconnected multiple times previously. The agent was actually very understanding and said these disconnections happen constantly due to their outdated phone system. She made the notation, completed my verification in under 3 minutes, and my refund was deposited exactly 8 days later. The early morning timing really seems to be crucial - their system is way more stable then and there are fewer people calling. Don't give up on that $3,400! It's your money and you absolutely will get it. Try the 7 AM approach next week and I bet you'll finally get through successfully.
One more thing to consider - check if your area has any rural development grants or infrastructure improvement programs available. Many counties and states offer cost-sharing programs for rural road improvements, especially if multiple property owners participate. I found out about a USDA Rural Development grant that covered 40% of our road improvement costs when we went through a similar situation. We had to form a small road association with our neighbors and apply as a group, but it saved us thousands. The application process took about 6 months, but it was worth the wait. Also, some utility companies will contribute to road improvements if they need better access for maintenance - worth asking your electric, gas, or phone companies if they'd be interested in cost-sharing since better road access benefits their service capabilities too.
This is fantastic advice! I had no idea rural development grants were even a thing. Do you know if there's a good resource to find out what programs might be available in a specific area? I'm in a similar situation to the original poster and would love to explore grant options before moving forward with any road improvements. Also, the utility company angle is brilliant - our electric company actually had issues getting their truck up our gravel road last winter during a power outage, so they might definitely be interested in contributing to improvements.
Great question about rural road improvements! I've dealt with similar situations professionally, and there are definitely some key steps to follow. First priority is determining road ownership through your county recorder's office - this is absolutely critical before spending any money. Many rural roads exist in legal gray areas where ownership isn't clearly defined, which can create huge problems later. For tax implications, if you own the road section, the paving cost gets added to your property's tax basis (helpful when you sell), but won't give you an immediate deduction. However, there's one exception many people miss - if you use part of your property for business purposes (home office, rental, etc.), a portion of road improvements might qualify as a business expense. You'd need to work with a tax professional to calculate the business-use percentage. Also consider getting multiple quotes - $15,000 for 1/4 mile seems reasonable for basic asphalt, but prices vary wildly based on access, prep work needed, and local contractors. Some areas offer chip seal as a middle ground between gravel and full asphalt that costs about 40% less. Finally, document everything meticulously if you proceed - photos, contracts, receipts, property surveys. This documentation will be essential for tax basis calculations and potential future property disputes.
Kelsey Chin
This is actually pretty common during tax season! The IRS has specific rules about when they can release different portions of your refund. If your refund includes refundable credits like the Earned Income Credit or Additional Child Tax Credit, they're required by law to hold those portions until mid-February for additional verification - this is called the PATH Act delay. Since you filed 2 weeks ago and only received part of your refund, the missing $246 is likely related to these refundable credits. The IRS will typically release this second portion within 1-2 weeks of the first payment, assuming everything checks out during their verification process. You can check the status of your refund using the "Where's My Refund" tool on the IRS website - it should show you if there's a second payment pending. If you don't see any updates there after another week, then it might be worth calling or checking if there was an offset for past debts.
0 coins
Liam Murphy
β’This is really helpful information! I had no idea about the PATH Act delay - that explains so much about why refunds get split up. I'm dealing with a similar situation right now where I'm waiting on the second part of my refund. The "Where's My Refund" tool has been showing "processing" for over a week now. Should I be concerned if it's been longer than the 1-2 weeks you mentioned for the second payment to come through?
0 coins
Ellie Perry
β’@Liam Murphy If it s'been longer than 2 weeks since your first payment and Where "s'My Refund is" still showing processing, "that" could indicate they need additional time to verify your information. Sometimes the IRS requests extra documentation for certain credits, especially if it s'your first time claiming them or if there are any discrepancies. I d'give it another week or so before getting concerned. The IRS processing times can vary quite a bit during peak season. If it hits the 3-4 week mark with no updates, that s'when I d'consider calling their helpline or using one of those callback services others mentioned to avoid the long hold times. You can also try creating an account on the IRS website to see if there are any notices or additional information needed from your end.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
I experienced this exact same situation last year! My refund was supposed to be $523 but I only received $287 initially. I was really worried that something went wrong with my filing or that there was some kind of error. It turned out that the IRS had split my refund because part of it included the Additional Child Tax Credit, which requires extra verification time. The remaining portion ($236 in my case) arrived about 10 days later via direct deposit. The key thing is to check your tax return form to see if you claimed any refundable credits - those are usually what cause the split. Look for lines related to Earned Income Credit, Additional Child Tax Credit, or American Opportunity Tax Credit. If the missing amount roughly matches what you claimed for these credits, that's almost certainly what's happening. The IRS should send you a letter explaining the delay, but sometimes those letters arrive after the second payment does. I'd recommend checking the "Where's My Refund" tool every few days - it should update to show if there's a second payment coming.
0 coins
Justin Evans
β’This is so reassuring to hear! I'm actually in the exact same boat right now - filed about 2 weeks ago expecting $467 but only got $221. The math is really similar to your situation too. I did claim the Additional Child Tax Credit for the first time this year, so that's probably what's causing the split. It's frustrating that the IRS doesn't give you a heads up about this when you're filing - would save everyone so much stress! I'll keep checking the "Where's My Refund" tool and try to be patient for another week or so. Thanks for sharing your experience!
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
β’@Justin Evans You re'absolutely right about the IRS not giving a heads up - it would save so much anxiety! I went through the same panic when it happened to me. Since you claimed the Additional Child Tax Credit for the first time, that s'definitely what s'causing the delay. The IRS is extra careful with first-time claims to prevent fraud. One thing that helped me was setting up text alerts through the Where "s'My Refund tool" so I got notified as soon as there was an update. Also, if you have an IRS online account, sometimes the information shows up there a day or two before the refund tool updates. The second payment should hit your account within the next week based on your timeline. Hang in there!
0 coins