


Ask the community...
Has anyone compared FreeTaxUSA vs TaxHawk for 2024? I know they're owned by the same company but sometimes their features differ slightly.
They're basically identical in terms of features and forms they support. The biggest difference is just branding and sometimes minor UI elements. I've used both and ended up with the exact same refund amount. One small difference is that TaxHawk sometimes offers slightly different promotional discounts, but the base prices are the same. I think FreeTaxUSA has more name recognition though, which is why I stick with it.
Thanks for the heads up! I've been procrastinating on getting my tax stuff organized, so having FreeTaxUSA available early is perfect timing. I switched to them two years ago after getting fed up with TurboTax's pricing and haven't looked back. One thing I love about being able to access it this early is that I can play around with different scenarios - like seeing how much extra I might owe if I do some Roth conversions before year-end, or what my refund would look like if I max out my HSA contributions. Really helps with year-end tax planning instead of just scrambling to file in February. Has anyone noticed if they've added any new features for 2024, or is it pretty much the same interface as last year?
I'm new to FreeTaxUSA but this early access feature sounds really useful! I've been using TurboTax for years but their prices keep going up every season. Can you walk me through what the interface is like compared to TurboTax? I'm a bit nervous about switching but the cost savings seem worth it. Also, when you mention playing around with different scenarios - does FreeTaxUSA let you save multiple versions or do you have to keep re-entering information to test different situations?
Has anyone used TurboTax to prepare their S-Corp return with K-1? I'm in the same boat as OP and wondering if the software walks you through this properly or if I should use something else?
I tried using TurboTax Business for my S-Corp last year and found it pretty confusing for a first-timer. Switched to TaxAct which was actually much better for S-Corp returns in my opinion - more straightforward questions and better guidance for the K-1 part.
Just wanted to add my experience as someone who went through this exact situation last year. The key thing to remember is that even though you had no revenue/expenses, you still need to properly complete the K-1 because it establishes important records for future years. A few specific tips for your zero-activity K-1: - Box 1 (Ordinary business income/loss): Enter "0" not blank - Box 16 (Foreign transactions): Enter "N/A" if no foreign activity - Make sure to include your beginning and ending capital account balances Also, keep detailed records of any startup costs you personally paid for - these might not affect this year's return but could be important for future deductions. The IRS likes to see consistency in how S-Corps report, even in dormant years. Good luck with your first S-Corp filing! The learning curve is steep but gets easier each year.
This is really helpful, especially the specific box guidance! I'm curious about the startup costs you mentioned - if I personally paid for things like state filing fees or legal costs to set up the S-Corp before it was officially formed, how do I track those? Do they go on this year's return or get carried forward somehow? I want to make sure I'm documenting everything properly from the start.
This is such a common confusion! You're definitely not responsible for paying her taxes - that's entirely her obligation as the service provider. However, you absolutely need proper documentation to claim the Child Care Tax Credit. Here's what you need to do immediately: Start keeping detailed records of every payment (date, amount, method). Since you've been paying cash, ask your provider for a year-end summary showing total payments made, along with her Tax ID number (either SSN or EIN). You'll need this information to complete Form 2441 when filing your taxes. The fact that you're paying $225 weekly means you're spending about $11,700 annually on childcare, which could qualify you for a significant tax credit! Don't let poor documentation cost you hundreds or thousands in legitimate tax savings. If she's reluctant to provide her Tax ID or proper receipts, that's a red flag. Legitimate childcare providers understand they need to provide this documentation to parents. You might want to start looking for alternative arrangements if she continues to be uncooperative about basic tax requirements.
This is really helpful! I'm in a similar situation and had no idea about Form 2441. Quick question - if I've been paying cash all year without keeping receipts, is it too late to start documenting now? Should I ask my provider for a summary of what I've paid so far this year, or just start fresh with better record-keeping going forward? Also, do you know if there's a minimum amount you need to spend to qualify for the Child Care Tax Credit? I'm only paying about $150/week so I want to make sure it's worth the hassle of getting all this documentation.
It's definitely not too late to start documenting now! I'd recommend doing both - ask your provider for a summary of payments made so far this year, and start keeping detailed records going forward. Even if she can't provide exact amounts from earlier in the year, having partial documentation is better than none. Regarding the minimum amount - there's no specific minimum to qualify for the Child Care Tax Credit, but at $150/week ($7,800 annually), you're definitely spending enough to make it worthwhile. The credit can be up to 35% of your expenses depending on your income, so you could potentially get back $2,730 or more. That's definitely worth the effort of getting proper documentation! The key thing is making sure your provider gives you her Tax ID number. Without that, you can't claim the credit regardless of how much you spend. Start the conversation with her soon so you have time to find alternative arrangements if she's not cooperative.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! My in-home provider has been great with care but terrible with documentation. What I've learned is that you're absolutely not responsible for her taxes - that's entirely her business obligation as a service provider. However, you MUST get proper documentation to claim the Child Care Tax Credit, and at $225/week, you're looking at almost $12,000 annually that could qualify for a significant credit. Here's what I did to solve this: 1. I started keeping my own detailed payment log immediately (date, amount, payment method) 2. I had a direct conversation with my provider explaining that I legally need her Tax ID number and year-end payment summary for my taxes 3. I switched from cash to Venmo so there's an automatic record of every payment If she pushes back on providing her Tax ID, that's a major red flag that she may not be reporting her income properly. A legitimate childcare business understands these are standard requirements. You might need to start looking for alternative arrangements if she won't cooperate, because without that documentation, you'll lose out on potentially thousands in tax credits you're entitled to claim. Don't let poor record-keeping cost you money you've already earned through legitimate childcare expenses!
This is such great practical advice! I'm curious about switching to Venmo - does that create any issues with the provider potentially raising red flags about reporting income? I've heard some cash-only providers specifically avoid digital payments because they leave a paper trail. Also, when you had that conversation about needing the Tax ID, did you give them any kind of deadline? I'm worried about being too pushy since good childcare is so hard to find, but I also don't want to wait until December and then be scrambling.
Don't forget that if you absolutely cannot get your W-2, you can still file your taxes using Form 4852 (Substitute for W-2). You'll need to estimate your wages and withholding as accurately as possible. Your last paystub of the year is super helpful for this if you have it. The IRS might follow up to verify the information, but at least you can get your filing done and avoid more late penalties. Just be honest about why you're using the substitute form.
I went through something very similar a few years back when I needed old W-2s from a restaurant job. Here's what worked for me: First, definitely try the IRS wage transcript route that Omar mentioned - it's free and often the fastest option. You can get it instantly online if you can verify your identity through their system. But also don't give up on contacting the employer directly. Even if that specific Chick-fil-A location closed, the franchise owner likely had to transfer employee records to their accountant or another location. Try calling other Chick-fil-A locations in the area and ask if they can help you get in touch with the franchise owner or their HR department. One thing that helped me was explaining that I needed it for back taxes - most employers are pretty understanding about that situation and will make an effort to help since they know how important those documents are. If all else fails, the Form 4852 substitute that Nia mentioned is a valid option, but definitely exhaust the other routes first since having the actual W-2 data from the IRS transcript will be much more accurate than trying to estimate from memory. Good luck getting caught up on those taxes! Don't stress too much - the IRS is generally pretty reasonable when you're making a good faith effort to get compliant.
This is really helpful advice! I'm actually in a similar boat - worked at a small retail chain that went out of business and I'm missing my 2020 W-2. I never thought about contacting other locations to track down the franchise owner. That's a smart approach. One question though - when you say the IRS is "generally pretty reasonable," did you face any penalties for filing late? I'm worried about what kind of fees I might be looking at for being this far behind on my taxes.
Mateo Rodriguez
I'm dealing with a very similar RSU tax situation right now! My employer also liquidated some of my vested shares and I'm getting that same confusing 1099-B with no cost basis reported. It's so frustrating because it makes it look like I owe taxes on gains I never actually realized. From what I've been reading in the IRS publications, you're absolutely right that the vesting date FMV should be your cost basis. The key thing is that when RSUs vest, that fair market value gets added to your W-2 income, so you've already been taxed on that amount. Your actual capital gain or loss is just the difference between what the shares were worth when they vested versus what they sold for. One thing I learned is to make sure you save all your documentation - not just the CSV from your brokerage, but also any supplemental tax documents your employer provided about the RSU transactions. Some companies send additional forms or statements that help clarify the cost basis calculations. Have you checked if your employer's HR or benefits team has any resources to help with this? Mine had a tax guide specifically for RSU reporting that I found really helpful.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
β’Thanks for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to know I'm not the only one dealing with this confusing situation. I actually haven't checked with HR yet about additional tax resources - that's a great suggestion. I'll reach out to them tomorrow to see if they have any supplemental documentation or guides. You're right about keeping all the documentation. I've been printing everything out and keeping both digital and physical copies just in case. The whole thing is so unnecessarily complicated when you think about it - we're basically having to prove we don't owe taxes on money we already paid taxes on! Did you end up using any specific tax software or tools to handle all the calculations, or are you doing it manually?
0 coins
Daryl Bright
I'm going through something very similar with my RSUs from last year! The 1099-B situation is so confusing when there's no cost basis reported. One thing I learned after talking to a tax professional is that you should definitely double-check that your employer actually included the RSU income on your W-2. Sometimes there can be timing differences - like if the shares vested in December but were sold in January, the income might show up on different tax years' W-2s. Also, if you're using tax software, make sure it properly handles the adjustment. I initially tried doing it myself in TurboTax and almost made a huge mistake because I didn't realize I needed to manually override the cost basis field. The good news is once you figure out the right process, it's pretty straightforward for future years. Just make sure to keep detailed records of all your vesting dates and fair market values - it makes everything much easier come tax time.
0 coins
Zara Khan
β’That's a really important point about checking the W-2 timing! I hadn't thought about the possibility of timing differences between vesting and sale dates affecting which tax year the income appears on. I'll definitely double-check my W-2 to make sure the RSU income is actually reflected there for the same year as the sales. The tax software issue you mentioned is exactly what I'm worried about. It seems like these programs aren't always set up to handle the nuances of RSU reporting correctly. Did you end up going with a tax professional in the end, or were you able to get TurboTax to work properly once you figured out the manual override? Thanks for the heads up about keeping better records going forward too. I'm definitely going to be more organized about tracking all the vesting details from now on!
0 coins