Back to California Unemployment

NebulaNomad

Does employer approval affect unemployment claim after quitting job audit?

Walked off a job at a logistics company eight months ago because the conditions were genuinely unsafe and HR kept stonewalling my complaints. Filed my claim right after and got through the initial EDD process fine, but now I'm seeing 'Pending' on basically every week going back two months. Got a letter saying EDD was reviewing the circumstances of my separation. No dollar amount, no explanation of what specifically they're looking at. My weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z was $390 and now nothing is moving. Here's what's confusing me: someone told me that if my former employer gives EDD the thumbs up, my claim is fine, and if they push back, I'm done. Is that actually how it works? Does employer approval affect unemployment claim after quitting job audit situations like this? Because I quit, I know EDD has to investigate whether I had good reason. But does my old company literally get to approve or deny what happens to my benefits? That feels wrong to me but I can't find a clear answer anywhere. The phone lines are impossible and I really need to understand what I'm actually up against here.

Unsafe conditions on the floor was what my DE 4800 notice was about too — the interviewer asked me specifically what I reported, to whom, and when. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I got on the phone with an EDD agent before my own interview; the agent pulled up my file and told me which weeks were still pending identity verification versus which were held for the separation question. That way I went into the interview knowing exactly what EDD was looking at. Here's the video they put out on reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent was clear that my employer's response was one piece of information EDD would weigh, not the decision itself.

0 coins

Knowing which weeks were pending for identity versus which were pending for the separation question before the interview — that's the kind of detail I'd want going in. Did the agent say anything about how long after the interview it usually takes for the pending weeks to clear?

0 coins

The agent said EDD decides after the interview and processes whatever weeks were certified once the decision is made, but wouldn't give me a timeline. Said to watch UI Online and the mail for the Notice of Determination.

0 coins

The employer's response being one piece of information and not the actual decision is the part I really needed someone to spell out. Everyone in my circle kept saying my old job could just 'block' my claim.

0 coins

Your former employer responding to EDD's Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed does not give them a vote on your benefits. That letter asks them to explain the circumstances from their side. EDD's own language is that if you quit, you need to show you had a good reason — the employer's account gets weighed alongside yours, but the decision belongs to EDD. Lost my last job in a dispute over schedule changes and my employer sent in a whole written statement against me. EDD still scheduled my interview, heard me out, and made its own call. Ended up getting a Notice of Determination in my favor.

0 coins

So the employer filing their response isn't what triggers the audit or the pending weeks — that was already going to happen because I quit? I just want to make sure I'm reading this right.

0 coins

Exactly right. Any quit or firing automatically triggers a phone interview — the pending weeks are EDD holding payments until it finishes the eligibility review. The employer's response to the DE 1101CZ just gives EDD both sides before the interview.

0 coins

An employer that doesn't respond within 10 days of EDD's notice even loses the right to appeal EDD's decision. So their silence actually works against them too.

0 coins

My cousin told me employers can just deny the claim outright and EDD rubber stamps it. That is completely wrong and it took me finding out the hard way to understand it. Got fired from a warehouse job, employer told EDD it was misconduct, I panicked assuming I was done. Turns out EDD still did its own interview with me and asked for my account of events. The burden on the employer in a firing situation is to prove misconduct — EDD's not just going to take their word for it. Decision came in my favor after the interview.

0 coins

The 'employer denies it' idea messes up so many people's understanding. Quarter of my coworkers who filed after a round of layoffs thought the company had to 'approve' the claims first.

0 coins

Yeah, that's exactly the belief I ran into. Really glad to hear it corrected here because I genuinely thought my old HR had some kind of power to shut me down.

0 coins

EDD decides is the short version everyone needs to hear before they even file. Would save a lot of panic.

0 coins

Missed my own phone interview last year because I mixed up 'phone interview' with 'appeal hearing' and thought it was optional. Ended up calling EDD the same day to explain, and they rescheduled but told me any further delay would mean EDD deciding purely on file. For anyone in an audit situation like this — the interview date and time are on the DE 4800 and also show up on the UI Online homepage. Keep your phone on and free for a window around that time because the interviewer phones at the scheduled time.

0 coins

Mine just showed up in UI Online last week. The letter hasn't arrived yet but I can already see the date. Good heads up on keeping the phone free.

0 coins

The DE 4800 also lists the specific questions they're likely to ask — it's worth reading it closely because the interview moves fast.

0 coins

Exactly, the DE 4800 lays out the topic areas in advance. Feels obvious in hindsight but I didn't realize I could basically walk in prepared.

0 coins

The mixing up of interview and appeal is so common. They're two completely different steps — the interview is EDD's fact-finding, the appeal is what you file after if you disagree with the Notice of Determination.

0 coins

Eight months of work in logistics and an unsafe conditions complaint on record — documentation you kept at the time is going to matter a lot at that interview. Emails to HR, incident reports, any written record of raising the issue before you quit. EDD asks whether you tried to fix the problem before leaving, and having paperwork that shows you did puts your account on much stronger ground than just saying so.

0 coins

Kept everything — emails, a written complaint I submitted through their internal system, and a few photos of the actual hazard. Wasn't sure if I'd ever need them but held onto them anyway.

0 coins

Photographs of the actual condition are strong. The interviewer might not ask for them in the call itself but if EDD requests anything in writing after, having them ready matters.

0 coins

HR stonewalling is itself part of the story — if you can show you escalated and they didn't act, that speaks to whether you had a real choice left. Some people quit after one conversation and that reads differently.

0 coins

PENDING PENDING PENDING for two months and no explanation is exactly what happened to me and I completely lost it. Mine turned out to be a combination of an identity verification step that hadn't cleared and the separation question open at the same time. The identity piece got resolved first after I uploaded through ID.me and EDD confirmed it. The separation question stayed open until after the phone interview. Got the Notice of Determination in the mail about three weeks after the interview and the pending weeks processed at once after that.

0 coins

Two separate issues running at the same time would explain why nothing has been moving for so long. How did you find out it was the identity piece versus the separation question? UI Online doesn't tell you which is which.

0 coins

Honestly I called EDD and got through after a lot of tries. That was before I knew there were other options. The agent walked through my file and told me both were open.

0 coins

The ID.me step trips people up because there's a whole separate process to complete — taking the photos, the video check sometimes, then ID.me confirming to EDD. If that piece stalls, everything stalls.

0 coins

Something that helped me prep for the quit interview: EDD's question isn't just 'why did you leave' — it's closer to 'why was staying not an option.' Framing your unsafe conditions story around what you tried, what the company did or didn't do, and what made the situation impossible to stay in tends to match the shape of what EDD is actually evaluating. I dealt with a constructive dismissal situation a couple of years back and once I understood the shape of EDD's question, the interview felt much less like a trap.

0 coins

Why was staying not an' option reframes the whole thing for me.'I ve been 'rehearsing I quit because of safety' hazards but that framing isbetter.

0 coins

The specific sequence matters too — you filed a complaint, you gave them time to respond, they stonewalled, then you left. That sequence is what EDD is listening for.

0 coins

Constructive dismissal cases can get complicated in the interview but the core question is the same: did the conditions make it impossible for a reasonable person to stay. Keep the facts specific and in order.

0 coins

Duplicate payment on my claim had me sitting on hold for three hours before I tried Claimyr — ended up talking to a live EDD agent who confirmed the specific certification weeks being reviewed and what was holding up the adjustment. Worth knowing when you've already exhausted the hold music.

0 coins

Three hours of hold time before finding that — yeah I've had exactly that experience. Did the agent give you any sense of the timeline for fixing the duplicate issue?

0 coins

The agent said to watch the Payments section in UI Online and that it typically updates within a few days of EDD processing the correction, but couldn't give a date.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration piece catches people off guard during an audit situation. EDD still expects you to register and post a resume in CalJOBS within 21 days of the date on your Notice of Requirement to Register for Work — the DE 8405. If that deadline passes while you're focused on the interview issue, it can create a second problem stacking on top of the first. Check your mail for that form if you haven't yet.

0 coins

Had no idea about this deadline — going to check my mail pile right now. I've been so focused on the pending weeks I may have let something important sit.

0 coins

The 21 days goes by fast when you're stressed about other things. CalJOBS is caljobs.ca.gov — registration is straightforward but the resume posting step is what most people miss.

0 coins

EDD's letter tells you whether you need to register. Some people are exempt but the letter says so. If you got the DE 8405, you need to do it.

0 coins

Watching Claim History in UI Online while everything is pending feels like watching a screen that's permanently frozen. The 'Pending' status just means EDD needs to resolve an open eligibility question — it doesn't mean denied and it doesn't mean anything is wrong with the claim. My whole claim sat in pending for six weeks after my interview and I was convinced it was over. Notice of Determination came and all those weeks processed within a few days.

0 coins

Six weeks after the interview before the notice arrived — that's the range I was afraid to ask about. Helps to know someone got through that wait and had it resolve.

0 coins

The wait is genuinely rough. Keep certifying through it because EDD can only pay the weeks you certified — if you stop certifying during the review and win, those uncertified weeks are gone.

0 coins

The 'keep certifying' rule is so important. I almost stopped because I figured nothing was going to move anyway. Really glad someone told me not to.

0 coins

Balance on my claim dropped by $780 without any explanation last winter and I had no idea how to find out why. Used Claimyr and got through to an EDD agent who looked at my claim and found that two weeks from several months back had been flagged for review — the agent explained what documentation EDD needed from me to close out the question. Sent it through UI Online messaging and the balance corrected about two weeks later.

0 coins

An unexplained drop in the balance with no notice sent is exactly the kind of thing you can't figure out from UI Online alone. The agent being able to tell you which specific weeks were flagged and what documentation they needed — that's the detail you can't get any other way.

0 coins

UI Online showed me the balance was lower but had nothing explaining the specific weeks or what triggered the review. The agent had the detail I needed.

0 coins

Former HR coordinator here, different industry but same EDD process. When a claimant says they quit for unsafe conditions, what EDD is looking for is whether the claimant took steps to address the issue before leaving — that's the 'good reason' standard, in plain terms. The employer's response to the DE 1101CZ goes into the file but EDD's interviewer reviews both accounts and makes an independent judgment. The employer cannot unilaterally block a claim. I've seen EDD approve claims where the employer filed a 20-page objection.

0 coins

That '20-page objection' detail is actually reassuring — if even that couldn't block an approval, then my old HR sending in their version of events isn't the final word.

0 coins

The key is that your version is documented and coherent. If you have a timeline with specific dates — when you first reported, what response you got, when you decided the situation was untenable — that holds up well in an interview.

0 coins

An HR coordinator's view on how EDD weighs employer responses is exactly the perspective this thread needed. The employer's objection going into the file alongside the claimant's account rather than overriding it is the part I'd never understood correctly.

0 coins

My penalty weeks situation last year started from exactly this kind of audit and I made it worse by not calling EDD the same day I missed my rescheduled interview. If something comes up and you can't make the scheduled time on the DE 4800, contact EDD at least a full day before — not day-of, not after. Missing it and doing nothing means EDD moves forward on the information it already has, and that rarely goes well when you're the one who quit.

0 coins

The 'at least one day before' part is good to know — I'd assumed I could call same-day if something came up and get it changed.

0 coins

Same-day changes aren't something EDD can accommodate for the interview — but if you do miss it without notice, calling EDD that day is still better than waiting. They note that you followed up quickly.

0 coins

EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site is worth running before the interview just so you're not caught off guard by the number on your DE 429Z. The standard base period uses your highest-paid quarter from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim started. If a big raise or high-pay quarter is too recent, it might fall outside that window and your weekly amount ends up lower than you'd expect from recent pay.

0 coins

My DE 429Z shows $390 a week which tracks for my wages but it's good to know why the number might look off to someone who just got a raise. I've seen questions about that in other threads.

0 coins

The alternate base period can kick in automatically if your wages under the standard period don't meet the minimum to file a valid claim — but it doesn't get used just to bump up a weekly amount that's already valid.

0 coins

The base period math is confusing until someone explains it once and then it clicks. The 'last five completed quarters, first four of them' logic is counterintuitive at first read.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet: EDD still expects work search activity every week you're certifying, even during a separation review. The certification question about looking for work doesn't pause because your claim is under audit. If you've been answering no to that question because you thought the audit froze everything, that's a problem worth fixing. Contact EDD through UI Online messaging or the phone line about any weeks you may have certified incorrectly.

0 coins

I've been answering honestly — yes, I've been applying places — but I hadn't thought about the work search question being active throughout the pending period. Glad you flagged it.

0 coins

Keeping a personal record of where you've applied, with dates, is a habit worth having. EDD doesn't specify a number of contacts you need but if they ever ask, having the detail there helps.

0 coins

The work search question on each certification is real — it's not suspended just because eligibility is under review. Certifying honestly each two-week period is the right move regardless of what's happening with the audit.

0 coins

Partial wages from a contract job during my UI claim got flagged in a review similar to this one. Claimyr got me to an agent who confirmed which certification period had the discrepancy and what EDD needed to verify the amounts. The agent told me to use the Report Wages section in UI Online to document the correction going forward, though weeks already certified needed to be addressed by contacting EDD directly.

0 coins

The 'Report Wages in UI Online' versus 'contact EDD directly for past weeks' distinction is the part people get wrong — the online tool doesn't go back and fix already-certified periods.

0 coins

Exactly what confused me initially. The agent was specific that Report Wages handles future weeks only and that any past week I reported incorrectly needed a separate message to EDD to trigger a review of that period.

0 coins

Went through a quit audit about two years ago, different industry, similar unsafe conditions argument. The interview took about 25 minutes and the interviewer asked me to walk through the timeline in order: when I first noticed the problem, when I reported it, what I was told, what happened after, and why I concluded it wasn't going to get better. Got the Notice of Determination about five weeks later — approved. The process works slower than anyone wants but it does reach a conclusion.

0 coins

Twenty-five minutes and walking through it in order — that matches the format I was imagining. Good to have a real example of how the conversation actually goes.

0 coins

The interviewer didn't interrupt much. Just kept asking 'and then what happened' until the whole timeline was out. Having it mentally organized beforehand made it flow easily.

0 coins

And then what' happened is basically the structure of the whole interview. The more linear and factual your account, the less the interviewer has to push forclarification.

0 coins

EDD's decision comes in the mail as a Notice of Determination, DE 1080CZ, and if it goes against you, the same envelope has an Appeal Form DE 1000M. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing. That deadline is firm — a late appeal needs you to explain why you missed it. The appeal goes first to EDD for review, then to the CUIAB if it proceeds. Keep certifying through the whole thing because back pay only covers certified weeks.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, not from when I receive it — that's the detail I'd have gotten wrong. Good to know before the notice even arrives.

0 coins

The mailing date is what the 30-day clock runs from. If the envelope gets delayed in the mail, that eats into your window, so open and read anything from EDD the day it arrives.

0 coins

The 'keep certifying through an appeal' rule saved my claim once. I stopped for three weeks thinking my pending decision would cover everything. It doesn't — only the weeks you actively certified get paid if you win.

0 coins

Benefits are federal taxable income and EDD gives you the choice to withhold 10 percent at each certification — the question shows up in the certification flow. Got caught off guard by a tax bill my first time on UI and now I always set the withholding from day one. The Form 1099G shows up in UI Online under Payments by January 31 of the following year. No California state income tax on the benefits though, just federal.

0 coins

Had not thought about the tax piece at all while stressing about the audit. The 10 percent withholding option being right there in the certification flow is good to know before the first payment actually processes.

0 coins

You can change the withholding election at any future certification if you change your mind. It's not locked in from the first time you answer.

0 coins

An employer that sends in a detailed response to EDD but then doesn't show up for the phone interview loses the ability to appeal EDD's decision afterward. Worth knowing if you're worried about your old company dragging this out post-decision. EDD's process gives both sides a chance to be heard, but there's a structure and a timeline to it that the employer has to actually follow.

0 coins

An employer blowing their own deadline to appeal because they didn't engage with EDD's process properly is satisfying information to have. Doesn't happen often probably, but good to know the door closes on them too.

0 coins

Employers routinely file a response to the DE 1101CZ but then don't show up for or participate in the interview side of things. When EDD makes a decision after that, they've missed their window to appeal.

0 coins

Months two through four of my own separation review I was absolutely convinced every pending week was money I'd never see. It wasn't. All of them processed within about a week of EDD making its decision and updating UI Online. The notice came in the mail a few days before UI Online showed anything — so if you're watching the screen obsessively, also check the actual mailbox.

0 coins

Watching both the screen and the mailbox — noted. I've been so focused on UI Online that I've been a little loose about checking mail.

0 coins

Mailing date is the legal trigger for a lot of things — the appeal window, the 30-day deadline. The notice mails before UI Online updates, at least in my experience. So the mailbox is actually the faster source of information.

0 coins

Same experience here — the Notice of Determination in the mail was two days ahead of UI Online reflecting the decision. The UI Online Claim History update followed but not instantly.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure