Back to California Unemployment

Omar Hassan

Can overpayment happen for previous benefit year after refiling new claim?

Okay so I just reopened my UI claim after going back to work for about five months and then getting laid off again. The new claim started processing fine and I got my DE 429Z showing my weekly amount. But now I'm seeing some weird stuff in my Claim History from the old benefit year showing weeks still marked Pending, and someone told me EDD can go back and decide you were overpaid on a closed year even after you've already filed a new claim. Is that actually true? Like can EDD reach back into a previous benefit year that already ended and hit you with an overpayment notice while you're actively collecting on a new claim? I reported all my wages correctly when I certified back then, never missed reporting a week of part-time work, so I'm not sure what would trigger something like that. But those old Pending weeks are really freaking me out now that I have a new active claim running. Anyone dealt with this?

DE 1080CZ showed up in my mailbox about four months after my benefit year closed, right in the middle of a new job. The notice said there was a question about wages I'd reported during weeks 14 through 18 of the old claim. EDD absolutely can go back and audit a prior benefit year even after you've filed a new one — the two claims exist independently but EDD can still review earnings from the old period. If the old weeks were showing Pending back then and you never got a determination, those can still be decided now. The pending status doesn't just expire because the benefit year ended.

0 coins

Those old weeks being unresolved is exactly what's worrying me. So EDD can just sit on a Pending decision for months and then issue it after a new claim starts?

0 coins

Happened to me too. Got a determination letter on a week from like a year before, completely out of the blue. EDD moves slowly on these things.

0 coins

Yeah, the determination came when it came. No warning, no heads-up. When EDD finally decided those weeks, the notice included the appeal deadline from the mailing date, so make sure you read that carefully if one arrives.

0 coins

Pending from a prior year showing up in Claim History while a new claim is active — that's usually a sign the old issue was never fully adjudicated. EDD doesn't just wipe unresolved eligibility questions when a new claim files. What can happen: EDD issues a Notice of Determination on the old weeks, finds you were overpaid, and then starts collecting from your current payments. They can deduct from future benefit payments, including ones on the brand new claim. That's the part that catches people off guard.

0 coins

Wait they can actually deduct from my current payments for something from the old benefit year? Even before I've appealed anything?

0 coins

They can, yes. If a Notice of Overpayment is issued and you don't appeal within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice, collection can start. The appeal window is on the notice itself — don't miss it.

0 coins

This is the part EDD doesn't explain clearly anywhere. The two claims feel separate but overpayment collection absolutely crosses between them.

0 coins

ugh this is terrifying to read. i thought once a benefit year ended everything was just done

0 coins

Prior benefit year left me with four unresolved weeks after I went back to work and stopped certifying — I didn't think anything of it until a DE 1080CZ landed about six months later saying I owed back roughly $1,180. By that point I had already reopened my claim after another layoff. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent after the hold times were eating my whole morning. There's a video about reaching a live person at EDD if you want to know what that looks like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up both my old and new claims and confirmed the pending weeks from the prior year were still flagged for an earnings review — they hadn't been decided yet, so no overpayment had actually been issued, but one could come. She told me to watch for the DE 1080CZ and that I'd have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal if I disagreed. Knowing exactly where it stood on both claims was way more useful than staring at Claim History wondering.

0 coins

So the agent could actually see both claims at the same time and tell you what was still open? That's really useful to know, I'd want to ask the same thing about my situation.

0 coins

Those hold times are brutal, I've been disconnected twice already trying to reach EDD about something similar.

0 coins

The agent had the full picture — both claim years, which weeks were still flagged, what was pending a decision. Much clearer than anything UI Online showed me.

0 coins

Something people get wrong here: an overpayment from a prior year doesn't automatically mean fraud. EDD distinguishes between fraud and non-fraud overpayments. If you reported everything correctly and EDD later decides your wages were counted differently, that's a non-fraud overpayment — you'd still owe it back but there's no penalty. Fraud is when EDD finds you gave false info or held something back on purpose, and that adds a 30 percent penalty on top. The notice will say which one it is.

0 coins

That distinction matters a lot to me. I reported every dollar I earned during those weeks so I'd be in the non-fraud category even if EDD recalculates something.

0 coins

i thought any overpayment automatically got reported to like credit bureaus or something, is that true

0 coins

EDD can record a lien or pursue a court judgment if an overpayment goes unpaid, but EDD's own pages don't say anything about credit bureaus. The collection tools they use are deductions from future UI, disability or PFL payments, and offsets against state tax refunds and lottery winnings.

0 coins

The non-fraud vs fraud breakdown is something I wish someone had told me before I got my notice. Makes a huge difference in how you respond.

0 coins

Filed a new claim back in March after my old benefit year ended in December. Couple weeks in, those same old Pending weeks the original poster is describing — four of them from last spring — finally got decided. EDD sent a DE 1080CZ saying I owed $870 for two of those weeks because of a part-time gig I'd had. I had reported the work but EDD's calculation of the gross wages was different from what I'd entered. Appealed within the 30 days using the DE 1000M that came attached to the notice, explained the discrepancy with my pay stubs.

0 coins

Did you keep certifying on the new claim while the appeal was going? I'd be scared to stop certifying but also worried about it getting complicated.

0 coins

Kept certifying the whole time. That part's important — if you stop certifying during an appeal and you win, EDD can only pay weeks that were actually certified. Don't stop.

0 coins

The DE 1000M attached to the notice is easy to miss honestly. It's on the back page and looks like a form continuation.

0 coins

FOUR MONTHS waiting on those old pending weeks and EDD never once sent me anything, no letter, nothing. Then bam notice arrives right when my new claim payments start hitting my Money Network card. Timing felt almost intentional lol. I know it's not but EDD has a talent for stacking bad news.

0 coins

That timing sounds absolutely miserable. Did the new claim payments pause while EDD sorted the overpayment out or did both things happen in parallel?

0 coins

Both in parallel. New claim payments kept coming while I dealt with the old overpayment notice. But they warned me in the notice that collection from the new claim payments could start if I didn't respond.

0 coins

the timing being right after new payments hit is wild. feel like EDD watches for that moment specifically

0 coins

The waiver option is worth knowing about if the old-year overpayment turns out to be legit. If it wasn't your fault and wasn't fraud, you can ask EDD to waive repayment by filing the Application for Overpayment Waiver — it's the DE 1446UI. EDD looks at whether paying it back would be an extraordinary hardship. No guarantee they approve it, but the option exists and most people don't know to ask.

0 coins

Where does the DE 1446UI come from, is it attached to the overpayment notice or do you have to request it separately?

0 coins

You'd want to contact EDD to request it — the DE 1080CZ overpayment notice doesn't automatically include it, at least in my experience. Ask EDD through your UI Online account message is probably the cleanest way.

0 coins

Seconding the waiver. It got denied in my case but I wish I'd known to try earlier instead of just panicking and trying to figure out payment arrangements.

0 coins

Pension situation from my prior benefit year created a pending issue I didn't know about — EDD had questions about whether my retirement income should have reduced my weekly payments. Those weeks sat in Claim History as Pending when my new claim started. Ended up spending a morning using Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because the phone line kept cutting out before anyone answered. The agent told me the pension review was still open on three weeks from the old claim and that EDD would mail a Notice of Determination once the review was complete. She confirmed my new claim wasn't being held because of it, which was the main thing I needed to know.

0 coins

Good to hear the new claim can still move forward even while old-year stuff is under review. That's actually reassuring.

0 coins

Pension affecting UI is something I hadn't even thought about. So EDD can go back and decide pension income should have reduced payments from the prior year?

0 coins

That's what the agent indicated — the review was about whether the pension offset should have applied to those specific weeks. EDD decides how much, if anything, it reduces. I hadn't listed it wrong, EDD just flagged it for review later.

0 coins

The fact that a pending review from a totally different income question can sit open across a benefit year change is genuinely wild. Had no idea that was possible.

0 coins

My situation was slightly different — I'd been collecting and then took a freelance project during the old benefit year, reported the income as instructed using Report Wages in UI Online before certifying those weeks. EDD still flagged two of the weeks and eventually issued a determination saying my self-employment income calculation was off. The determination came eight months after the old claim ended. By then I had a new W-2 job so it didn't affect a new claim, but the overpayment notice still had to be dealt with.

0 coins

Eight months after the old claim ended is a long time. So there's really no statute of limitations window where EDD just moves on?

0 coins

Not one that kicks in after just eight months, apparently. EDD sent the notice, I appealed, and the administrative law judge held the hearing. The process works, it just takes time.

0 coins

self-employment income during a UI claim is such a gray area, glad you appealed

0 coins

Appeals across both a prior and current claim at the same time can get confusing. The hearing for the old-year overpayment is a separate proceeding from anything on the new claim. Each has its own Notice of Determination, its own 30-day window, its own DE 1000M. Keep them completely separate in your paperwork and in your head or you'll mix up the deadlines.

0 coins

Are the appeal hearings handled by the same administrative law judge or could they be totally different judges?

0 coins

CUIAB assigns judges independently. You'd likely have different judges for different issues. Each one reviews only what's in front of them.

0 coins

Keeping the paperwork separate is real advice. I mixed up the mailing dates on two different notices once and almost missed the appeal window on one of them.

0 coins

Wages used for the base period on a new claim come from the standard base period of that new claim, not from the prior one. So refiling doesn't somehow mix the wage quarters together. But if EDD later determines you were overpaid in the prior year, that's about eligibility and earnings in those specific old weeks — a separate question from how your new weekly benefit amount was calculated.

0 coins

That's actually the clearest explanation I've seen of why these are separate. The base period calculation for the new claim isn't what's under review — it's the specific old weeks.

0 coins

People get this tangled up all the time. New claim, new base period, new weekly amount — the old overpayment question is about those old weeks specifically.

0 coins

wait so the new claim's weekly amount isn't affected even if EDD finds an overpayment on the old claim? the two amounts are totally separate?

0 coins

Correct. The overpayment on old weeks doesn't change what the new claim pays per week. It becomes a separate debt EDD can collect from those new payments, but the weekly amount calculation itself stays what the DE 429Z says.

0 coins

Prior benefit year issue that turned into a bigger headache than I expected — EDD flagged four weeks from almost 18 months ago after I reopened a claim. Used Claimyr when the hold time hit over an hour and I had to pick up my kid from school. The EDD agent confirmed the flagged weeks were tied to severance pay I'd reported and that EDD was reviewing whether it should have been treated differently during those weeks. No determination had been issued yet, so she said to watch for the DE 1080CZ in the mail and to read the mailing date carefully for the appeal deadline if one came.

0 coins

Severance affecting old weeks is another thing I hadn't thought about. I had a small severance payout at the start of my original claim, did you end up getting a Notice of Determination?

0 coins

DE 1080CZ came about three weeks after that call. I appealed using the form attached, laid out exactly when the severance was paid and how I'd reported it. Still waiting on the hearing date.

0 coins

severance creating a pending flag months later is so stressful, especially when you're already dealing with a new claim on top of it

0 coins

Adjudication on old weeks can sit open longer than most people expect, especially if EDD was backlogged during the period your original claim ran. What happens when EDD finally closes those weeks and finds no overpayment: you typically see the Pending status update in Claim History and that's about it. No letter when it goes in your favor, usually. The letter — the DE 1080CZ — is what comes when EDD decides there was an overpayment.

0 coins

So no news might actually be good news in this case? If I never get a DE 1080CZ the old weeks presumably got resolved without an overpayment?

0 coins

Generally yes. The absence of a notice isn't guaranteed closure, but EDD sends the DE 1080CZ specifically when they're saying you owe something. Silence is usually better than a letter in this case.

0 coins

This is actually a useful way to think about it. I spent weeks expecting a 'you're all good' letter that never came and panicked. Eventually realized no letter meant it had been resolved okay.

0 coins

does anyone know if the pending weeks from the old claim showing up affects the new claim approval timeline?? like will EDD hold up the new payments until they deal with the old pending stuff first

0 coins

Not necessarily. A new claim processes on its own timeline. Old pending issues can slow things down sometimes, but EDD doesn't automatically freeze new claim payments just because prior weeks are still unresolved.

0 coins

ok phew because i'm already 3 weeks into my new claim and can't afford to have it held up

0 coins

If the new claim payments are coming through and UI Online shows them as paid, you're likely fine. Old year pending is a separate track in most cases.

0 coins

When I had a similar overlap — new claim active, old year with open weeks — the thing that helped me most was sending a message through UI Online asking EDD directly which weeks from the prior claim were still unresolved and why. Took about two weeks to get a response, which isn't fast, but the reply gave me a specific list of the weeks and what EDD was looking at. Way less stressful than just watching Claim History.

0 coins

Two weeks for a response isn't great but at least you got a written answer with specifics. I might try that approach before the phone line.

0 coins

The written response also becomes part of your record, which is helpful if you end up appealing anything. You can reference what EDD told you in writing.

0 coins

the UI Online message system is so underrated for this kind of stuff. slower than a phone call but you have something to point to later

0 coins

Something I ran into: EDD recalculated my prior year base period wages after my new claim filed because additional employer wage reports came in late. The recalculation changed what I'd actually been eligible for in some of those weeks. Had nothing to do with anything I'd done wrong — my employer just filed their wage reports late. Still resulted in a DE 1080CZ for a non-fraud overpayment.

0 coins

Your employer filing late causing you to get an overpayment notice feels extremely unfair. Were you able to dispute that at the hearing?

0 coins

Appealed it and the administrative law judge heard both sides. I brought documentation showing I'd reported my wages correctly when I certified. The hearing was straightforward, the wait for the written decision was not.

0 coins

Late employer wage reports creating overpayments for claimants is a real issue and not talked about enough. The claimant did nothing wrong but still gets the notice.

0 coins

my old claim had two pending weeks for over a year and i never got any notice at all, positive or negative. just disappeared from my claim history one day. called EDD and they said those weeks had been decided and no overpayment was found. so sometimes it really does just quietly resolve

0 coins

That's actually the best possible outcome and gives me some hope. Did those weeks show up anywhere with a resolved status or they just stopped showing as Pending?

0 coins

they just stopped being listed, basically. UI Online didn't give me a 'resolved' badge or anything. i only found out by calling.

0 coins

ok this is genuinely the best thing i've read in this thread

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window on the DE 1080CZ is not 30 business days, it's 30 calendar days from the mailing date printed on the notice. That date is not the date you receive it. If the letter sat in a slow mail route for a week, your window is shorter than you think. I'd file the appeal the day I got the notice.

0 coins

Calendar days from the mailing date on the letter — not from when it arrived. Got it. That's a critical distinction.

0 coins

The mailing date vs receipt date thing tripped up my neighbor. She thought she had more time than she did because she counted from when she got the letter.

0 coins

A late appeal can still be submitted with an explanation of why it was late, but EDD and the CUIAB don't have to accept it. Way easier to just file fast.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the waiver process — the DE 1446UI asks for a pretty detailed financial picture. Income, expenses, assets. EDD uses it to judge whether repaying would be an extraordinary hardship. It doesn't ask about whether you made a mistake, only about your financial situation now. So don't conflate 'it wasn't my fault' with 'the waiver will be approved' — fault matters for the non-fraud classification but hardship is what EDD weighs for the waiver itself.

0 coins

So you can be a non-fraud overpayment case and still have the waiver denied if EDD thinks you have enough to repay?

0 coins

Exactly. Non-fraud means no penalty but you still owe it unless the waiver comes through. EDD looks at hardship separately.

0 coins

That's the part the DE 1446UI instructions don't spell out super clearly. Worth reading those instructions carefully before you fill it out.

0 coins

Went through almost exactly this scenario — reopened a claim after seven months back at work, then got a DE 1080CZ four weeks later for the prior benefit year. The overpayment was about $640 tied to vacation payout I'd reported but that EDD later said should have been counted differently. Because I had reported it, it was non-fraud. Appealed it anyway on the grounds that I'd done what EDD's own certification instructions said. The hearing was done by phone with the administrative law judge, lasted maybe 20 minutes.

0 coins

How long did it take from filing the DE 1000M to actually getting a hearing date and then the written decision?

0 coins

About eleven weeks from filing the appeal to getting the hearing notice, then another three to four weeks for the written decision after the hearing. The whole thing was around four months start to finish.

0 coins

Four months is pretty typical from what I've seen others report. The CUIAB moves at its own pace.

0 coins

vacation payout being recategorized after the fact is exactly the kind of thing that makes people not trust the system. glad you appealed.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure