Back to California Paid Family Leave

Nina Chan

Paid family leave overpayment — returned to work early, do I need to call?

So I took PFL bonding leave starting in October and had planned to use the full eight weeks. But my manager called and asked if I could come back after just three weeks because they were short-staffed, and honestly we needed the income so I went back full-time on November 3rd. The problem is I didn't report it to EDD right away. I think I got one more payment deposited after I had already gone back, maybe covering days I was actually working. Now I'm seeing stuff online about overpayments and I'm panicking a little. Do I actually need to call EDD about this, or is there something I can do in SDI Online? And if there is an overpayment, what happens? Do they just take it out of future payments or send me a bill or what? I still have five weeks of PFL left in my 12 months that I haven't used yet.

Reporting wages when you go back is required, and not doing it is exactly what creates an overpayment situation. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form when they know you've returned to work, but they can only do that if you've told them. The sooner you report it, the better your position if they ask about timing.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

Is there a way to report it in SDI Online, or does it have to be a phone call? I keep reading different things.

0 coins

You can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online. Pick your claim ID in myEDD and choose the request type. That creates a written record, which helps.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

ok I'm going to do that today. thank you for being specific about where to find it.

0 coins

Report it. That's the short answer. Wages even if not yet paid, you have to tell them. Don't sit on it longer than you already have.

0 coins

This. The longer you wait the messier it gets.

0 coins

Exactly. And you still have weeks left so you want to keep that clean.

0 coins

Direct deposit on my claim wasn't set up right and a payment landed somewhere unexpected, so I needed to sort out the payment method fast. I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD's PFL line on the phone, because every morning I tried I got the high-volume recording and that was it. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which account the payment had gone to and what I needed to submit to correct it. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

The direct deposit piece hits home for me. I had the same thing happen, debit card when I expected direct deposit. Used Claimyr myself actually. Once I got someone from EDD on the line I asked about a DE 2514 I'd gotten and the agent walked me through what it meant and said I had 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal if I disagreed. That was the only clear answer I got after a week of trying that line.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try before you went with Claimyr? I've been at it six days straight and the line just ends the call.

0 coins

Five days for me. The sixth morning I tried Claimyr and that afternoon I was talking to an EDD agent.

0 coins

Fine. I'll try it tonight.

0 coins

November 3rd return date, so any day on or after that would be wages to report. EDD pays one seventh of your weekly amount for each eligible day, so if a payment covered days starting November 3rd or later you'd owe back those specific days' worth, not the whole payment.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

That's actually really helpful math to understand. So it might not be the whole two-week payment, just the days I was actually working?

0 coins

Right. It depends on exactly which days the payment period covered and when in that period you returned. Your Notice of Computation shows your weekly amount and you can calculate from there.

0 coins

wait so if only part of a payment period overlaps with going back to work, only that part is the overpayment? i thought you had to give back the whole payment

0 coins

To answer that last question, yes it's the days, not the whole payment necessarily. Each eligible day is one seventh of the weekly benefit. That's how EDD breaks it down.

0 coins

ok that's a relief, i was imagining owing back hundreds more than i maybe do

0 coins

The notice they send will spell it out. Don't estimate, wait for it, then check the math yourself.

0 coins

you can also just send the request claim update in sdi online and explain what happened, you dont have to call if youre scared to, the written one works too

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

yeah I'm honestly a little scared to call and get in trouble. good to know the online option does something.

0 coins

it does, i used it when i messed up my return date and they sorted it out, took a few days but it worked

0 coins

One thing that tripped a lot of people up: EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification after you report going back. If you don't return that form, benefits stop. Since you haven't reported yet they haven't sent one, but once you do report expect that form to come and return it promptly.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

What is the Continued Claim Certification exactly? Is it a paper form in the mail?

0 coins

It's the DE 2580GF. EDD mails it. You fill it out showing your work and wages and send it back. That's how they reconcile what you were paid against what you actually earned.

0 coins

And that form is also how you'd eventually claim the remaining weeks you mentioned, if you go back out on leave later.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke. I spent nine days trying to reach anyone about my claim and kept getting the same recording about high call volume and then it just disconnects. Nine. Days.

0 coins

That line is brutal. What was the question you needed answered?

0 coins

I had a payment discrepancy and needed to know which weeks had actually posted. No way to figure it out without talking to someone.

0 coins

That's the kind of thing where SDI Online sometimes doesn't show enough detail. Hope you found a way through.

0 coins

If there's an overpayment EDD will mail you a notice. You can appeal it within 30 days of that notice using the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. Worth knowing before the letter arrives so you're not caught off guard.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

Is the appeal just for if I think they got the amount wrong, or also if I can't afford to pay it back?

0 coins

Both are reasons people appeal. What EDD does with an overpayment notice is laid out in the notice itself. Read it carefully and decide from there.

0 coins

the 30 days goes fast so open the mail the day it comes

0 coins

The receipt number on my bonding claim wasn't matching up anywhere I looked in SDI Online, which had me worried the claim hadn't gone through right. I used Claimyr to get EDD's PFL line, and the agent found it immediately, confirmed the claim was filed and active, and read me the receipt number so I could write it down correctly. Worth knowing that number is in your SDI Online account even if it's hard to spot.

0 coins

I honestly wasn't sure about Claimyr doing anything real. I've tried that PFL number so many times and nothing ever gets through. How did you even get to an actual person?

0 coins

I just ended up talking to an EDD agent, that's all I can tell you. They knew the claim, they knew the number. It was real.

0 coins

My bonding claim had a proof of relationship question too. After I finally got someone on the line the agent told me EDD had received the birth certificate and it was matched to the claim already. I'd been worried for nothing but I never would have known without that call.

0 coins

ok maybe I'll give it a shot. The line has hung up on me every day this week.

0 coins

Just to flag something for the original question: going back to work before your PFL period ends doesn't erase your remaining weeks. Those five weeks you mentioned are still in your 12-month window from the birth. If you want to use them later you'd file a new claim with the DE 2501F.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

Wait, so I'd file a whole new claim for those weeks, not just extend this one?

0 coins

If you returned full-time and want to take more leave later, yes, a new DE 2501F. EDD tracks the total weeks used within the 12 months from the birth date.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

ok this is the clearest I've understood this. so fix the overpayment situation now, then file fresh when I want those weeks. got it.

0 coins

Five weeks still available is actually great news given how stressful the rest of this sounds! Get the reporting sorted and those weeks are still yours.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

honestly yes, trying to focus on that part

0 coins

The overpayment piece is fixable. EDD deals with this more than people realize.

0 coins

Returned early, didn't report, got an extra payment. That sequence has a name and EDD knows what it looks like. Report it now and cooperate. That's the whole playbook.

0 coins

Yep. Don't overthink it. EDD's seen this before.

0 coins

They have. And cooperating early usually goes better than waiting for them to notice.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and reading this is making me nervous all over again. I went back part time, not full time, does the reporting work the same way?

0 coins

Part time is still wages, still has to be reported. EDD adjusts based on what you earned versus what you would have been paid for PFL. The key is reporting every day you work and what you earned, even if the wages haven't come in yet.

0 coins

ok and I do that in SDI Online, through the Request Claim Update?

0 coins

That, or if you get the Continued Claim Certification in the mail, fill it out and send it back. It has a spot for wages and days worked.

0 coins

Part time and intermittent is actually what PFL is built for. Report accurately and the math works out for each day.

0 coins

My cousin did something similar and the overpayment letter did come eventually, like two months later. The notice had the amount and the appeal info right on it. She wasn't expecting it and panicked but the 30 days to appeal is from the date on the letter, so she had time.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

two months later?? ok I'm definitely reporting now so I can try to get ahead of that

0 coins

Reporting proactively might affect how the notice reads. Either way, appeal window is 30 days from the notice date, that part doesn't change.

0 coins

ugh the reporting piece. I forgot to report one week when i went back intermittently and it was such a headache to untangle. anyway just report as soon as you can is the lesson i learned.

0 coins

how long did it take to sort out for you?

0 coins

few weeks of back and forth, a letter, filling out that certification form again. annoying but it did get resolved anyway.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my claim had a weekly amount that looked wrong to me, nothing matched what I'd expected from my wages. I'd heard of Claimyr and tried it to get to someone at EDD. The agent confirmed the weekly benefit amount on my record and explained which quarter of my base period they used for the calculation. I had my pay stubs in front of me and the numbers lined up once she walked me through the base period math.

0 coins

What's Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

It waits on the EDD line until a live person picks up, then your phone rings. That's about it. So instead of you dialing for the tenth morning in a row, it handles the hold.

0 coins

oh that might actually help me. I need to ask about whether my part-time wages were reported correctly on the claim and nobody picks up.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. three mornings, nothing. might look into this.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the five-week question: those weeks are in the same 12-month clock that started at the birth. The cap is eight total weeks in those 12 months across any PFL claim. Three weeks used means five left before that clock runs out.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

And the 12 months starts from the birth date, right? Not from when I filed?

0 coins

From the birth date. So figure out when that window closes and plan accordingly.

0 coins

There's a note on EDD's site about this if you want to confirm it in writing. The benefits and payments FAQ covers the 12-month window.

0 coins

Around week three of waiting to see what EDD would do about my claim, I noticed the payment history in SDI Online wasn't showing which specific weeks had posted and which were still pending. I tried Claimyr to get EDD's PFL line, and the agent told me week one and two had been paid out and week three was still processing, with the next payment due the following Friday. That was actually useful, knowing a specific date instead of just guessing.

0 coins

Got a similar answer on a call about a payment date. The agent pulled up the claim and read me the exact date the payment issued. That was more than two weeks of trying the line on my own and getting nowhere, and one morning with Claimyr.

0 coins

what did you do after they told you the date, did you just wait or did they say to do anything

0 coins

Waited. The payment showed up two days after the date they gave. Nothing else to do.

0 coins

To loop back to the original question: yes you should report, and yes you can do it in SDI Online with a Request Claim Update. Document everything, dates you returned, days worked, wages. If an overpayment notice comes, read it, check the math, and appeal within 30 days if anything looks off.

0 coins

Nina Chan

Author

Thank you, this thread genuinely helped me understand what to do. Submitting the Request Claim Update right now.

0 coins

Good. And hang onto those five remaining weeks, you have time to use them before the window closes.

0 coins

late to this but just want to say the part about appealing within 30 days of the notice, not 30 days from when you get it in the mail, actually the date printed on the notice. open it same day.

0 coins

that's a really easy thing to miss

0 coins

Correct. The appeal window runs from the notice date. The DE 1000A is the form, it's on EDD's site and usually attached to the notice itself.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure