Back to California Paid Family Leave

Omar Fawaz

Paid family leave denied self employed S corp owner appeal — what are my options?

I've been going back and forth on this for weeks now and honestly don't know what to do next. I own a small S corp, just me basically, and I pay myself a W-2 salary through the business. I had SDI withheld from every paycheck, CASDI shows up on all my stubs, so I figured I was covered. Filed a PFL bonding claim when my daughter was born in September and uploaded her birth certificate right away. Then I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail saying I was denied. The letter was pretty vague about why. I think it has something to do with how I'm classified but I genuinely don't understand what I did wrong. Has anyone here dealt with a paid family leave denied self employed S corp owner appeal situation? The DE 1000A came with the notice. I'm not sure if I should just file the appeal or if I'm missing something obvious first.

Denial came the same week my bonding claim started, and the Notice of Computation had a weekly benefit amount that looked way off compared to what I'd been paying into. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to an actual EDD agent after I'd spent three mornings getting the same recorded message. The agent pulled up my DE 429DF and told me the base period wages EDD had on file were lower than what I reported, which explained why the number looked wrong. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Every morning for two weeks I've hit that line and gotten cut off before I even get a menu option. Hard to believe anything actually gets you through to a person there, what happened when you called?

0 coins

Tried the line myself seven or eight times in one week, same dead end every time. Claimyr handled the hold, my phone rang, and an EDD agent was there. That was it.

0 coins

Used Claimyr too for my own bonding claim! The agent told me my first payment had been issued on a specific date I hadn't seen yet in SDI Online, so I knew to watch for it. Really glad I made that call when I did!

0 coins

The appeal form DE 1000A has a 30-day window from the date on that determination notice, so please don't set it aside. File it online or mail it before that deadline, even if you haven't figured out the full reason for the denial yet. You can explain more in the hearing.

0 coins

The notice is dated November 3rd, so I have until early December roughly. Is there anything I should include with the appeal form or just send it as is?

0 coins

You can write a brief statement with the form explaining your situation, the CASDI on your stubs, the W-2 wages. The hearing is where you present everything fully, but a clear statement helps.

0 coins

Does EDD tell you when the hearing will be, or do you have to ask? I'm in a similar spot and have no idea what comes next after mailing the DE 1000A.

0 coins

EDD mails a hearing notice with the date, time and instructions. Keep watching your mail and your SDI Online messages.

0 coins

S corp W-2 wages with CASDI withheld should qualify, full stop. EDD sometimes kicks these back because whoever reviewed it flagged the ownership structure without looking at the actual withholding. Appeal it and bring every pay stub you have.

0 coins

That tracks with what the denial said, it mentioned something about my relationship to the business. But the CASDI is right there on the stubs. Do they want something beyond the stubs to show the withholding is real?

0 coins

Bring the W-2 itself plus the stubs. The W-2 will show the state wages and withholding in a way that's hard to argue with.

0 coins

Heard this before. W-2 is the key doc. Stubs alone sometimes aren't enough for them.

0 coins

Worth knowing: PFL eligibility needs at least $300 in base period wages with CASDI withheld. If your W-2 wages are in that base period and the CASDI deductions show on the W-2, you have the documented proof of contributions. The denial might be an error rather than a true disqualification.

0 coins

My wages have been consistent, well over $300 in the base period. So it really might just be a review error?

0 coins

It's possible, yes. The appeal is the right move either way, and presenting the W-2 and stubs at the hearing gives EDD a clear record to look at.

0 coins

EDD makes these mistakes more than they'd like to admit. Appeal.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost the same thing, S corp, W-2, CASDI on the stubs, got denied at first. She appealed and had the determination reversed. It took a while but she got her weeks and the payments came through. Don't give up on it.

0 coins

That is genuinely encouraging, thank you. Did she have to do the hearing in person or was it over the phone?

0 coins

Hers was a phone hearing actually, the notice had the dial-in info. She said just having her paperwork organized made a big difference.

0 coins

Phone hearings are nerve-wracking, do you know if you can have someone with you on the call?

0 coins

She had a friend sit with her just for moral support, the friend wasn't speaking for her or anything, just there. I'd check the hearing notice to see if EDD says anything about it.

0 coins

Don't overthink the appeal. Fill out the DE 1000A, state you're a W-2 employee of your own S corp with CASDI withheld the whole time, attach the stubs and W-2, send it. That's your case right there.

0 coins

Direct and clear, I appreciate that. I've been making it more complicated in my head than it probably needs to be.

0 coins

That's what they do to you. Keep it simple.

0 coins

The DE 1000A, which is the Appeal Form that came with your determination, is the right document. EDD's site confirms you have 30 days from the date on the notice. Filing it doesn't cost you anything and preserves your right to a hearing. If the denial was an error, the hearing officer can overturn it.

0 coins

30 days goes fast. file it now dont wait to have everything perfect

0 coins

Exactly right. You can submit additional documents before the hearing date, so getting the appeal in on time is the priority.

0 coins

Filed the appeal online this afternoon. Felt better to just do it.

0 coins

Good move. Getting it in early is always smarter than waiting.

0 coins

Payments were coming in fine until they suddenly stopped after week three, and I couldnt figure out which weeks EDD had actually paid versus which were still pending. Spent four mornings trying that phone line, nothing but a recording. Tried Claimyr and ended up talking to an EDD rep who went through my claim week by week and told me exactly which ones had been paid out and when the next one was scheduled to process.

0 coins

Wait, what is Claimyr? I've been trying to reach EDD for two weeks about my own bonding claim.

0 coins

You hand off the hold to them, your phone rings when an EDD person picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I need to ask about the proof of relationship they're still showing as pending on my claim. Might try that.

0 coins

For documentation at the appeal, pull together: the W-2 for your base period year showing state wages and CASDI withheld, all pay stubs from that year, your S corp payroll records if you have them, and a copy of the determination notice itself. Present it in that order. Clear paper trail is everything here.

0 coins

Payroll records meaning the actual payroll register, or is the W-2 and stubs sufficient?

0 coins

W-2 and stubs usually do it. The payroll register is a backup if they push back on anything.

0 coins

Having the records ready beats scrambling for them later.

0 coins

I might be in a similar boat soon. I'm also the sole W-2 employee of my own LLC taxed as an S corp and I haven't filed yet. Should I attach anything extra when I file the original claim, to try to avoid the denial in the first place?

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online you submit the claim and your proof of relationship for bonding. If EDD needs anything else they'll ask. The key is that your wages show CASDI withheld in the base period.

0 coins

And the base period is roughly the year before I file? I'm not sure I understand how they calculate it.

0 coins

The base period looks at a 12-month stretch of four quarters, covering wages from about 5 to 18 months before your claim starts. EDD's site has a calculator that gives you the estimate based on your wages.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense, I'll check the calculator before I file.

0 coins

Appeal. Show up with the W-2. That's the whole playbook.

0 coins

Honestly that's probably the most useful summary in this thread.

0 coins

the determination letter, did it give a specific code or just say ineligible? mine said something about base period wages not meeting requirements but i had plenty of wages, turned out they had the wrong quarters

0 coins

Mine just said something about my relationship to the employing unit. No code that I could find. But the wrong quarters thing is interesting, is that something that can get fixed before the hearing or only at the hearing?

0 coins

for me it got corrected at the hearing when i showed the right stubs. took a while but it worked out

0 coins

Bring documentation covering all four quarters of the base period just in case they're pulling the wrong timeframe.

0 coins

There's a thing people mix up here that's worth clearing up. PFL pays you benefits during leave, but it doesn't protect your job on its own. That comes from CFRA or FMLA depending on your situation and your employer's size. For a solo S corp owner you'd want to look into how that applies to you separately from the EDD claim.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about the job protection piece. I'm essentially my own employer so it's less of an issue, but good to know they're separate things.

0 coins

So if someone works for an actual outside employer and takes PFL, they should ask HR about CFRA separately?

0 coins

Exactly, ask your HR about CFRA. EDD handles the benefit payments, your employer handles the job protection side under those laws.

0 coins

That distinction trips a lot of people up. PFL from EDD is the money, CFRA or FMLA is the job guarantee, and you need to handle them separately.

0 coins

DE 2500E never showed up in my SDI Online after my bonding payments started, panicked a bit and couldn't get anyone on the phone, tried a dozen times that week. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who confirmed the first electronic payment notification had been issued and explained what it meant for direct deposit timing. Ended up being fine anyway.

0 coins

Had no idea the DE 2500E was even a thing I should be watching for. Glad to know it confirms first payment info.

0 coins

What does the DE 2500E actually say, is it just a date or more than that?

0 coins

Just the first payment info basically, the date it was issued and the amount for that period. After that you track in SDI Online.

0 coins

Got it, adding that to my list of things to watch for once this appeal resolves.

0 coins

How many of the eight weeks were you using all at once or splitting them up?

0 coins

edd denied my buddy same situation s corp w2 and he appealed and won. took like two months but he got backpay for all the weeks he shouldve been paid

0 coins

Two months is a long time but backpay for the missed weeks makes it worth pushing through. That's good to know.

0 coins

yeah he said just document everything and dont miss the 30 day window

0 coins

The backpay piece matters a lot. Good reason to file the appeal even when it feels like a long shot.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, by the way! Someone told me I had to wait seven days unpaid like with disability, but that's the disability claim, not PFL. When I figured that out I stopped waiting and filed right away.

0 coins

Wait, there's really no waiting period for PFL? I was told to expect seven unpaid days at the start.

0 coins

That seven-day waiting period is for Disability Insurance, not PFL. EDD is clear that PFL has no benefit waiting period. Worth knowing before you plan your leave dates.

0 coins

Okay that changes my whole timeline, good to know before I file.

0 coins

Right? I lost almost a week just waiting for nothing! Check EDD's site on PFL basics, it's spelled out there.

0 coins

Intermittent days caught me off guard after I started taking PFL in pieces. The first two payments came fine, then the third didn't, and I couldn't tell if I'd reported my work days wrong or if EDD was still processing. I tried Claimyr after a week of getting nowhere with the phone line and got an agent who found the DE 2580GF showing which intermittent days I'd reported and which ones were still pending certification.

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment to me. EDD agents don't just pull up your paperwork like that over the phone.

0 coins

Actually had the same doubt, tried three mornings on that line myself, nothing. Went ahead with Claimyr and the agent confirmed my claim's start date and told me I still had days within my 41-day window to certify. Would not have known that otherwise.

0 coins

Alright. I'll give it a look.

0 coins

S corp owner paying yourself W-2 wages is an employee for SDI purposes as long as CASDI is being withheld. The confusion is usually on EDD's end, not yours. Document it and make them look at the actual withholding.

0 coins

That framing actually helps a lot. I've been worried I did something wrong, but if the withholding is there, the case is there.

0 coins

Exactly. The stubs and the W-2 tell the story. Let them do the work.

0 coins

One thing to watch on timing: the eight weeks of PFL has to be used within 12 months of your daughter's birth. The appeal process takes time, so if it drags past that window you'd want to flag that at the hearing. The hearing officer can speak to what happens in that situation.

0 coins

She was born in September so I have until September of next year. With any luck the appeal resolves well before that.

0 coins

That's a reasonable window. Document the appeal filing date too so you have a clear record of when you started the process.

0 coins

Went through a denial appeal myself last year, different reason but same form. The hearing was straightforward, the officer asked questions and I showed my documents. Wasn't as scary as I'd built it up to be.

0 coins

Hearing that from someone who actually did it makes it feel more manageable. Were you able to submit documents ahead of the hearing or only on the day of?

0 coins

EDD sent instructions with the hearing notice about submitting docs beforehand. I sent mine in a few days early and the officer already had them when we started.

0 coins

That's really useful to know, gives me hope for my own situation if I end up needing to appeal.

0 coins

For anyone following this, the OP did the right thing filing the appeal right away. The 30-day window is firm and there's no way to extend it once it passes. Everything else, the documents, the statement, can come together before the hearing.

0 coins

Appreciate everyone here. Appeal is in, documents are organized, now I wait. Will report back after the hearing.

0 coins

You've done everything you can do at this stage. Keep the determination notice and your appeal confirmation somewhere safe.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure