PFL overpayment notice while also repaying unemployment overpayment — anyone dealt with both at once?
So I'm in a situation I didn't expect and honestly don't fully understand. I took PFL bonding leave earlier this year after my daughter was born, eight weeks total. The problem is I had also been collecting unemployment for a few weeks before she arrived — I'd been laid off and was job hunting — and apparently some of those days overlapped with days EDD later decided counted as PFL days. Now I have an overpayment notice for PFL on top of an unemployment overpayment I'm already paying back from a separate issue. I'm not sure if these are handled together or completely separately. I'm also not sure if I should appeal the PFL one or just start paying it back. The appeal form came with the notice but I don't even know if I have grounds to appeal or if I just made an honest mistake and owe it. Has anyone dealt with two different EDD overpayments at once? Do they set up separate repayment plans or combine them?
80 comments

Nina Chan
Two separate programs, two separate overpayment accounts. EDD doesn't combine them into one repayment plan. You'll handle the PFL overpayment through the SDI side and the unemployment one through the UI side. Keep your payment confirmations for both.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorGot it, thanks. Does appealing the PFL one pause the repayment clock or do I still owe it even while the appeal is pending?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Filing an appeal doesn't suspend the overpayment itself. EDD's position is that the amount is owed unless the appeal reverses it, so payments may still be expected. The notice should spell out the repayment terms. Reading it closely before the 30 days run out is important.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
The overlap between unemployment and PFL is exactly what triggered yours. EDD pays one at a time — you can't receive both for the same days. If the PFL claim covered days when unemployment was already paid, that's a real overpayment on the PFL side even if the mistake was accidental.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorYeah, I figured that was it. I didn't realize the dates would conflict when I filed the bonding claim.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Honestly the overlap thing catches so many people off guard because the two programs feel totally separate when you're filing. You're not the first person in this situation, not by a long shot.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
EDD will catch it. They compare the dates. Appeal if something looks wrong in the dates they used, but if it's accurate, you owe it.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
November 4th showed as the issue date on my payment but SDI Online said "pending" for another three days after that, so I phoned EDD to find out what was actually happening with that disbursement. I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after trying the PFL line several mornings and getting the same recorded message every time. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the payment had been issued on the 4th and told me which bank processing date to expect. On the overpayment question here: check whether the dates EDD used on the PFL notice actually match the UI payment dates exactly. If EDD counted a day as both, the overlap has to be day-for-day, not approximate.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Claimyr worked well for me on a similar timing question. The agent I reached confirmed which weeks on my bonding claim had been paid and told me when the next payment was scheduled to go out — that was the piece I needed because SDI Online just showed a lump of pending days with no breakdown. To answer the question someone may have: yes, the agent could see individual week statuses, not just the overall claim status.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Wait, what exactly did the agent tell you about the week breakdown? I have a bonding claim right now and I can't tell from SDI Online which weeks are paid and which are still pending.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
She went through each week by its start date and told me which ones showed as paid, which were still processing, and what the next scheduled date was. I had my receipt number ready and she found everything from that.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorThe day-for-day point is helpful. The notice I got does list specific dates so I can compare them to my UI payment history.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
EDD sent me an overpayment notice once and the dates were flat out wrong — they had me overlapping by four days when the UI payments had stopped before my PFL claim even started. Appealed it and won. So yes, check the dates carefully.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorThat's encouraging, actually. How hard was the appeal to file?
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Not hard at all. The DE 1000A form came with the notice. I wrote a paragraph explaining the date error, attached my UI payment history printout, and mailed it. Heard back eventually.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
30 days from the notice date. After that you can't appeal it.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
both overpayments at once sounds awful im sorry. def check the dates tho because sometimes edd just gets them wrong
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorYeah it's a lot to juggle with a baby at home too.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
You'll get through it. Focus on the 30-day appeal window first, everything else can wait a few days.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A and it comes attached to the overpayment notice. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to submit it, online or by mail. For a PFL overpayment the appeal goes to the SDI program. Appealing doesn't guarantee a reversal but if the dates EDD used are genuinely wrong, that's a strong basis.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorThank you. I'm going to pull out both notices and compare every date they used against my actual UI payment records before I decide.
0 coins
Emma Morales
That's exactly the right move! Document everything before you file anything.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Keep copies of everything you send in too.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Five weeks of bonding leave used, then a care claim two months later — I needed to know how many of my eight PFL weeks were still available before filing the second one. Ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr after the hold recording cut me off three times before 9 a.m. The agent looked at my claim history and confirmed I had three weeks remaining in my 12-month period and that the care claim start date would need to fall within that same window. That eight-week total across bonding and care in the same 12 months is something a lot of people don't realize is one shared limit.
0 coins
Donna Cline
Sounds like a marketing pitch to me. How does some service get you through to EDD when nobody else can?
0 coins
Harper Collins
I thought the same thing when I saw it mentioned somewhere. Tried it anyway because I'd been at it for a week. The agent told me my DE 2500E had been generated and gave me the date it was issued — I hadn't seen it in SDI Online yet. It's just a service that sits on hold with EDD so you don't have to, then your phone rings when a person picks up. Nothing fancy.
0 coins
Donna Cline
Fine. If I can't get through by Friday I'll give it a shot.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorThe shared eight-week limit is something I had no idea about either. Good to know for the future.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Two overpayment letters, two programs, two sets of paperwork. Welcome to EDD. Keep them completely separate in your files and don't mix up which form goes where.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorSeparating the files is a good idea, I've been keeping them in the same folder which is probably a mess.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Label everything with the program and date. UI on one side, PFL on the other. Makes it easier if you have to show anything later.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Can I ask a related question? If someone collected PFL bonding leave and also had a few days of their pregnancy disability overlapping — not unemployment but disability — does that cause the same kind of overpayment situation?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Disability Insurance and PFL are both paid one at a time. A birth mother's disability claim has to end before the PFL bonding claim starts. If the dates overlapped EDD would catch it the same way. The switch happens when disability ends and bonding begins.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Okay so as long as the disability end date and the PFL start date don't actually land on the same day it should be fine?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
The dates need to be sequential, not overlapping. The PFL bonding claim starts the day after the disability claim ends. If you have both running into the same day, that day would be the issue.
0 coins
Nina Chan
The DE 2501FP that new mothers get for bonding even has a field for the disability end date specifically so EDD can line them up correctly.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Okay so just to make sure I understand — the 30-day window to appeal, does that run from when you receive the notice or from the date printed on it? Because mail can be slow and I'd hate to lose two or three days on that anyway.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
The 30 days run from the date printed on the notice, not from when it arrives in your mailbox. So open it immediately when it comes and get the appeal in well before that date.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Noted, filing early then.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
The online appeal goes through SDI Online. Faster than mail if you're close to the deadline.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
My cousin went through something similar with an overpayment notice and said the hardest part was getting EDD on the phone to ask questions before she decided whether to appeal. She spent days trying. The online Request Claim Update in SDI Online was what ended up working for her — she sent her question through there and got a response that helped her figure out the dates.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorI didn't know you could use Request Claim Update for an overpayment question. I'll try that.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
It's under your claim in SDI Online. Pick the request type that fits — something like a general claim question — and write out what you need. It's not instant but it does get a response.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
On the UI side of your overpayment, that program's contacts and appeals are completely separate from EDD's SDI division. The overpayment notice for unemployment will have its own appeal instructions and address. Don't send a UI appeal to the SDI address or it'll get lost.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorReally glad you mentioned that. I almost assumed I'd file one appeal for both.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Completely different systems. Even the phone numbers are different. EDD runs both but they don't cross-reference your appeals.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
My bonding claim start date got entered wrong when I first filed, which meant EDD's 41-day window calculation was off. I called the PFL line through Claimyr to sort it out because I'd tried the number three times before 8:30 and each time it told me to call during business hours even though it was 8:15 a.m. The agent confirmed the actual start date in the system and what that meant for the 41-day filing deadline. Turned out the date was correct after all, but the agent also noted that if it had been wrong I could have asked for a correction through SDI Online with supporting documents.
0 coins
Nina Chan
What did you have ready when the agent answered? I want to make sure I have everything in front of me if I try phoning.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
My claim receipt number, the date I stopped working, and the date I'd written on my original filing. Having the receipt number was the most important part — she pulled everything from that.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
been trying that line since tuesday. four mornings, same recording every time. good to know something actually works
0 coins
Donna Cline
You mentioned an honest mistake. EDD doesn't usually care about intent on overpayments — the money was paid for days when another benefit was running and they want it back. The appeal matters if the facts are wrong, not if you just didn't know the rules.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorThat's a hard truth but I appreciate the bluntness.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
He's right. Check your dates. If they match what EDD has, pay it back. If they don't match, appeal it.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Something worth knowing: when you do repay a PFL overpayment, the amount comes off what EDD says you were paid, which can affect how the 1099-G reads come January. EDD sends the 1099-G for whatever benefits were actually paid in that calendar year. For the tax details a tax professional is better than guessing.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorHadn't even thought about the 1099-G angle. Noted.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
EDD does send one for PFL in January. The 1099-G reflects what was paid in the year, so if repayment happens in a different year it may not adjust the form for the original year. A tax professional can sort out the specifics.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
EDD's tax information page on edd.ca.gov has some guidance on PFL and the 1099-G. Worth reading before you talk to anyone.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
wait so pfl and unemployment literally cant both pay at the same time? i thought they were just different programs not like mutually exclusive
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Yep, one at a time. EDD won't pay two of them for the same day. PFL, unemployment, disability — they're all separate but they don't stack.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
ok that makes way more sense now thanks
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
That's why the overlap created the overpayment in the first place. Filed for both, same days, EDD caught it after.
0 coins
Emma Morales
My bonding claim actually required me to upload the birth certificate before anything moved, and I remember being so confused about what came next! For anyone wondering, once EDD has the proof of relationship and processes it, the claim status usually updates within a few days.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
How long did it take for yours to show as processed after you uploaded it?
0 coins
Emma Morales
About five days for mine! But I've seen people say two weeks, so it really varies.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
If it's been more than 14 days with no movement, the Request Claim Update in SDI Online is the way to ask.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Pay the unemployment overpayment on schedule regardless of what's happening with the PFL appeal. Stopping payments on one while fighting the other is a separate problem you don't need.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
AuthorYeah I wasn't planning to stop. Just wanted to understand how they interact.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Keeping both on schedule while appealing the PFL one is exactly right. An appeal doesn't freeze the repayment obligation.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
If you do end up appealing and it gets reversed, does EDD refund what you already repaid while the appeal was pending?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
If an appeal reversal finds you didn't owe the amount, EDD should address the repaid amounts as part of the determination. The notice that comes with the appeal decision would explain it. Worth reading that notice carefully when it arrives.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Or you could ask EDD directly through SDI Online what happens to payments made during an open appeal. That's exactly what Request Claim Update is for.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Does any of this affect the job protection side? Like if someone is in the middle of an overpayment dispute, does that change anything about CFRA or going back to work?
0 coins
Nina Chan
PFL and job protection are completely separate. PFL pays benefits but EDD itself says it doesn't protect the job. CFRA is handled by your employer and those laws, not by EDD. An overpayment dispute on the PFL side has no bearing on CFRA.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Got it, different track entirely. Thanks.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
I always get those two mixed up. PFL pays you but doesn't save your job, CFRA saves the job but doesn't pay you — that's the right way to think about it?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
That's essentially it. Whether CFRA applies depends on your employer and your situation, so HR is the place to ask about the job protection piece. EDD handles only the benefit payments.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
Coming back to update: I went through both notices side by side last night. The PFL overpayment dates line up exactly with two UI payment dates, so it's a real overlap and I do owe it. I'm not going to appeal because the facts are right. I'm going to set up repayment on the PFL side and keep going on the UI side separately. Thanks everyone for helping me understand how this works.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Glad you got clarity on it. Two repayments at once isn't fun but at least you know exactly what you're dealing with now.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Clean outcome. Knowing you owe it is better than months of uncertainty.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Set a reminder so you don't miss a payment on either one. That's the only thing left to worry about.
0 coins