Back to California Paid Family Leave

Omar Fawaz

PFL claim disqualified wages question — did I make a mistake, file new claim or appeal?

I'm kind of freaking out and not sure what to do. I filed a PFL bonding claim in SDI Online about three weeks ago when my daughter was born and got the Notice of Computation showing a weekly benefit amount that seemed way too low. When I looked more carefully I realized I might have entered something wrong about my wages during the base period, or maybe EDD pulled from the wrong quarters. Now I'm worried they disqualified part of my wages or used the wrong period entirely. My question is: if there's a mistake in how the wages were calculated, do I appeal the Notice of Computation, or do I file a completely new claim, or is there some other way to correct this? I haven't gotten an actual approval or denial letter yet, just the Notice of Computation. I really don't want to mess this up with a newborn and bills piling up.

The Notice of Computation isn't your approval, it's EDD's calculation of what your benefit could be based on the wages they have on record for your base period. If the amount looks wrong, check your base period quarters carefully in SDI Online and compare them to your pay stubs or W-2 from that time. If wages are missing or wrong, that's usually because the employer reported them differently than expected. You'd address that through an appeal once you get a determination letter, not by filing a new claim.

0 coins

So I wait for the actual determination letter before doing anything? I'm looking at SDI Online now and it shows the claim as pending still. Does that mean they haven't decided yet?

0 coins

Pending just means they're still reviewing it. The determination letter, which is the DE 2514 if they deny or limit it, comes by mail. If they approve you'll get the payment notification instead. Either way, that's when the 30-day appeal window opens.

0 coins

Thirty days from when it arrives in my mailbox, or thirty days from when they send it?

0 coins

The appeal form DE 1000A says to appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice itself, so go by that date, not the day it shows up in your mailbox.

0 coins

DE 2500E on my claim came through but the payment amount didn't match what I expected from my Notice of Computation, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which weeks had been paid and what the per-day rate was for my situation. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too, got to an agent about my own bonding claim. I'd been trying to figure out whether my start date locked in my 41-day window, and the agent told me exactly what date EDD had on file as the claim start, so I knew where I stood. Relieved to have that confirmed.

0 coins

Wait, what did they say about the 41 days specifically? Like does the clock start the day you file or the first day you're off work?

0 coins

The agent said the 41 days runs from the first day of leave, not the day you file. The filing date just needs to fall within that window. So if you started leave on a Monday, you count from that Monday.

0 coins

That part is actually relevant to me too, I wasn't sure if I'd cut it close. Good to know the leave start date is what matters.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke. Called four mornings in a row, got a recording telling me to try again and then the line just ended. Never even got to hold. For a wages dispute you absolutely need to talk to a human, not send a message through SDI Online and wait two weeks.

0 coins

Same. That line does exactly that, cuts you off before you even wait. Maddening.

0 coins

Is there an online form to dispute wages or does it have to be over the phone?

0 coins

You can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online or use Ask EDD. Those are both real options. Phone is just faster when it comes to something like a wages discrepancy where you need them to look at your specific record.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If EDD disqualified wages, does that mean the whole claim is denied or just that the benefit amount is lower? Because I thought disqualified wages just meant they didn't count certain earnings, not that you get nothing.

0 coins

That's a fair distinction. Sometimes wages are excluded from the calculation because they don't fall in the base period quarters, and that lowers the weekly benefit amount without denying the claim entirely. A full denial is a different thing. The Notice of Computation shows the amount they'd pay; a DE 2514 is what you get if they're denying or reducing eligibility itself.

0 coins

Okay so the amount being lower than expected doesn't automatically mean I'm disqualified from getting anything?

0 coins

Correct. Low benefit amount and full disqualification are two separate outcomes. Low amount means the wages they found put you at a lower rate. Disqualification means they don't think you're eligible at all.

0 coins

This actually helped me understand what I'm looking at. My claim is still pending so I haven't gotten the DE 2514, which I guess means they haven't denied me, they're still reviewing.

0 coins

Don't file a second claim. That's the one thing I'd tell anyone in your shoes. EDD sees duplicate claims and it creates a mess. Appeal the existing one once you have a determination, or call and ask them to look at the wages before it even closes.

0 coins

Filing twice is exactly the wrong move. It doesn't reset anything, it just confuses both claims.

0 coins

Yeah I had that instinct to refile but I'm glad I asked first. I'll wait for the letter.

0 coins

My coworker filed twice by accident and it took forever to sort out, lol. EDD kept asking which one was the real claim.

0 coins

you need the actual denial letter before you can appeal, they wont let you appeal a pending claim, happened to me

0 coins

That's right. The appeal window opens from the date on the determination notice. No notice, no appeal yet.

0 coins

yeah exactly, i waited around thinking i could do something sooner and there was nothing to do until the letter came

0 coins

Can I ask something slightly different? If the wages in the base period just came out low because I had a slow year, not because of any mistake, is an appeal even the right move? Or is that just what I'm stuck with?

0 coins

If the wages are accurately reported and there's no error, the calculated amount is what it is. An appeal is for when you believe the calculation is wrong or eligibility was denied unfairly. If the wages are correct but just low, the benefit amount reflects that and there isn't much to dispute.

0 coins

Okay that's what I figured but I wanted to make sure I wasn't leaving anything on the table.

0 coins

Worth double-checking the quarters EDD used though. Sometimes a quarter doesn't get counted that you'd expect, and that's worth asking about before you assume the number is final.

0 coins

Something to check before the determination arrives: pull up your earnings record in SDI Online and see which quarters show wages. The base period is four quarters from roughly five to seventeen months before your claim started. If a quarter looks empty that shouldn't be, that's your first clue that wages weren't reported to EDD by your employer.

0 coins

I went into SDI Online and found the base period section. One quarter is showing zero that I know I earned in. That has to be the problem.

0 coins

That zero quarter is likely why your Notice of Computation came out low. When the determination comes, appeal it and explain that wages were earned and withheld in that quarter. Have your pay stubs from that period ready.

0 coins

My employer switched payroll systems that year, which might explain why that quarter looks empty to EDD. I'll pull the stubs.

0 coins

Payroll system transitions do cause reporting gaps sometimes. Document everything from that quarter and keep it organized for the appeal.

0 coins

Two days a week back at the daycare since my little one hit three months, and I never got a DE 2580GF for the intermittent weeks. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to sort it out! The agent confirmed which intermittent days were still pending and told me the DE 2580GF had been generated but not yet returned, so the payments for those days were on hold.

0 coins

Posting here about intermittent days sounds like marketing for that service, I have to be honest. What does it even do?

0 coins

thought the same thing the first time i saw it mentioned. tried it myself because i was getting nowhere, and an actual EDD agent told me my payment method hadn't been set up right on my claim, which was why the first payment never came. not a pitch, just what happened.

0 coins

Alright, that's a concrete answer. I'll think about it, I've been hesitating to do anything that involves handing over my information to a third party.

0 coins

For the intermittent days question itself, you do have to return the DE 2580GF or the payments stop. The agent was clear about that.

0 coins

appeals take time. if the wages question is a reporting error by your employer, it might be faster to get the employer to correct the report with EDD directly than to wait on the full appeal process.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about going through the employer. Would that actually change what EDD has on file before the determination comes out?

0 coins

If the employer submits a corrected wage report, EDD can update their record. No guarantee of timing but it's worth asking HR while you also prepare for an appeal just in case.

0 coins

do both. don't rely on HR alone. they move slow.

0 coins

Is there any chance a mistake in the original filing, like entering wages wrong myself, can be corrected? Or is that totally on the employer side?

0 coins

The claimant doesn't enter specific wage amounts when filing in SDI Online. EDD pulls the wage data from employer reports. So if the number is wrong, it's almost certainly on the employer reporting side, not something you typed incorrectly.

0 coins

Oh I didn't realize that. I thought I had to enter my salary somewhere during the application.

0 coins

The SDI Online application asks about employment but not about your specific dollar amounts, at least not in the way you'd think. The wage pull is automatic from employer records.

0 coins

DE 2514 sitting in my mailbox was one of those moments. My care claim for my mom got partially denied and I called EDD about it through Claimyr. The agent confirmed the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination had been issued and told me which weeks were covered and which were not, so I knew exactly what to appeal.

0 coins

What did you tell them when you got on the line? Like did you need the receipt number or just the claim ID?

0 coins

Had both on hand. The agent used the claim ID to pull everything up. The receipt number wasn't needed once the claim was already in the system under my account.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. every time it cuts off before i even get a hold message. getting real tired of it.

0 coins

The appeal form itself is the DE 1000A. It comes with the denial letter, or you can get it from EDD's site. You fill it out and explain what you believe is wrong, then submit it by mail or through the instructions on the form. Keep copies of everything.

0 coins

Does the appeal have to be super detailed or can I just say the wages in quarter X are wrong?

0 coins

Be as specific as you can. Name the quarter, say what wages you believe should be there, and attach your evidence like pay stubs. The more specific, the cleaner the appeal.

0 coins

The Appeal Form DE 1000A has a section for your explanation. Keep it factual, state what the error is and what evidence you have. That's it.

0 coins

30 days goes fast. Don't sit on that letter when it comes. Gather the stubs now so you're not scrambling.

0 coins

Already started pulling them from my old email. My employer did direct deposit so the stubs are all digital at least.

0 coins

Good. Digital is fine, print them out for the appeal packet.

0 coins

Part D not" received sat on my care claim status for ten days after my'dad s doctor submitted it. Tried Claimyr to get an agent on the PFL line. Agent looked at the claim and said the Part D had been received but'wasn t matched to my claim yet, they had my receipt number wrong on thesubmission.

0 coins

I've been trying to figure out if EDD received my proof of relationship for my bonding claim. That's exactly the kind of thing I'd want an agent to confirm. Going to try Claimyr for it.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the receipt number from when you filed ready. The agent will need one or both to pull up the document status.

0 coins

Makes sense. My claim ID I have, the receipt number is in the confirmation email from when I filed in SDI Online.

0 coins

The whole wages-and-quarters thing is legitimately confusing. EDD doesn't do a great job explaining which quarters they're using. The Notice of Computation should spell it out but most people don't know how to read it.

0 coins

Is there a legend or explanation on the Notice of Computation itself, or do you have to already know what the columns mean?

0 coins

The notice shows the quarters and the wage amounts EDD has for each one. It doesn't have a detailed glossary but EDD's site has information explaining the base period, and the benefits calculator there can also help you understand the range.

0 coins

The calculator is actually useful for this. Put your quarterly wages in yourself and see what it spits out, then compare to your notice.

0 coins

I had a friend go through an appeal for exactly a missing quarter situation. It took a while but they did get the corrected amount eventually once the employer submitted the updated wage report. Wasn't fast but it worked.

0 coins

How long did the whole process take for your friend, roughly?

0 coins

Honestly I'm not sure of the exact timeline, it felt like a couple months from appeal to resolution. Not quick, but the extra weeks of benefit were worth pursuing.

0 coins

Good to hear it worked out. That's encouraging.

0 coins

Don't forget you only have 12 months from the birth to use your eight bonding weeks, anyway. So while you're sorting out the wages question, keep an eye on that window too.

0 coins

Yeah that's been in the back of my head. My daughter was born in September so I have until next September at the latest.

0 coins

Right, and the appeal doesn't pause that clock, so the sooner the wages thing gets resolved the more of those eight weeks you can actually use, anyway.

0 coins

That's a good point that I don't think enough people realize. The 12 months keeps moving whether or not your claim is pending.

0 coins

Filing a brand new claim while one is pending isn't going to fix a wage calculation issue. The new claim would pull from the same employer wage records. The fix has to happen at the source, either through the employer correcting the report or through an appeal.

0 coins

So even if I filed fresh the same quarters would show up wrong?

0 coins

Yes. The wage data EDD uses comes from employer reports, not from anything the claimant enters. Same employer, same quarters, same records.

0 coins

That settles it for me. No second claim. Wait for the determination, appeal with the stubs, and get the employer to fix the reporting too.

0 coins

Waiting period is zero for PFL by the way. I saw someone in another thread saying there's a one-week wait like disability. There isn't. Bonding benefits start from the first day of leave.

0 coins

yeah i made that mistake when i filed, was mentally subtracting a week from my payment for no reason

0 coins

Easy mistake. Disability has the seven-day wait but PFL doesn't.

0 coins

I'm glad someone said that because I was absolutely assuming there was a waiting week.

0 coins

Intermittent PFL question from the original post side: if someone is bonding but plans to go back part time, do they have to refile or just report the days they work?

0 coins

If you filed on the paper DE 2501F and answered yes to the question about working during leave with your schedule attached, you stay on the same claim and report wages. If you filed in SDI Online for a straight leave and now want intermittent, you'd contact EDD about how to adjust it.

0 coins

That makes sense. The reporting of wages part is what trips people up though, right? Not reporting is apparently how overpayments happen.

0 coins

Exactly right. Any day you work and earn wages, even if the pay hasn't come through yet, has to be reported. EDD sends the DE 2580GF to certify continuing intermittent leave and you have to return it or payments stop.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure