Are social security and medicare taxes deducted from paid family leave benefits in California?
I've been going back and forth on this and can't get a straight answer anywhere. I took PFL bonding leave starting about three weeks ago after my daughter was born, and I'm trying to figure out the tax situation before my first payment lands. I know California doesn't tax PFL, which I found on EDD's site, but what about the federal side? Like are social security and medicare taxes deducted from paid family leave benefits before EDD sends them? My regular paycheck has FICA taken out every time and I wasn't sure if the same thing happens with PFL payments. I'm trying to plan my budget while I'm out and not knowing whether the amount I see on my Notice of Computation is what I'll actually get is stressing me out a little.
72 comments

Benjamin Carter
December 3rd is when my first PFL payment showed up, and I went back to compare it with my Notice of Computation. The amount matched exactly, no FICA deductions taken out. EDD doesn't withhold Social Security or Medicare taxes from PFL payments. What you see on the Notice of Computation is what gets deposited.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorThat's really reassuring, the notice amount being what actually deposits. Did you have state income tax taken out or nothing at all?
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
Nothing withheld on mine. California doesn't tax PFL, and EDD doesn't take anything else out automatically. You can request voluntary federal withholding but that's a separate step if you want it.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorWait, voluntary federal withholding? I didn't know that was an option. How do I do that?
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
EDD has a form for it, DE 4S I believe. But honestly I'd talk to a tax professional about whether you even need it before you fill anything out.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
Payments on my bonding claim started coming in and I wanted to know exactly which weeks EDD had paid and when the next one would hit. Spent two mornings trying that phone line and it cut off on me both times. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me weeks one through two were paid out on November 18th and that weeks three and four were processing. No FICA or state taxes were taken from either payment.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Sounds like a marketing pitch to me. I've been dialing that 1-877 number since 7am three days running and nothing gets through, so forgive me if I'm not jumping at whatever this Claimyr thing is.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
I had the exact same reaction, thought it was some kind of ad. Then I finally tried it because I'd been at it for two weeks and my care claim for my dad had been sitting there with no update. Claimyr put me through and the agent told me I had three weeks left in my 12-month window, which I hadn't even thought to track. So it's real.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Three weeks left and you didn't know, that would've been bad to miss. Fine, I'll give it a shot tomorrow morning.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
The 1099-G that EDD mails each January shows the full amount of PFL benefits paid during that year. No Social Security or Medicare is withheld from the payments themselves. Whether any portion is federally taxable is something a tax professional should sort out for your situation, since EDD's guidance on that points you elsewhere.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorSo EDD sends a 1099-G and I take that to whoever does my taxes. That part I can handle.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Exactly right. Keep it with your year-end documents when it arrives in January.
0 coins
KhalilStar
fica doesnt come out of pfl. edd sends you the full amount and you deal with taxes yourself at the end of the year if you need to
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
But wait, I thought any income-type payment had withholding? I'm filing my first PFL claim and this is confusing me.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
PFL isn't wages paid by your employer, so the employer's obligation to withhold FICA doesn't apply. EDD sends the gross benefit amount and issues a 1099-G. Federal tax treatment is worth confirming with a tax pro because EDD's own page points you there rather than stating a flat rule.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Ok that distinction makes sense, it's coming from EDD not my employer. Thank you.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
My client was asking me this exact thing last week while I was doing her color! I told her what I knew, which is that EDD doesn't take Social Security or Medicare out, but I also told her to double-check the federal side with her accountant because honestly I didn't want to steer her wrong on the tax stuff.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Good call on sending her to an accountant. The California side is clear but the federal piece is the one people should actually verify for their own situation.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Exactly, I know the basics but I'm not about to tell someone how much they owe the IRS, lol.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
FICA won't touch your PFL. The Notice of Computation amount is your payment amount.
0 coins
Madison King
Short and to the point. Confirmed this matches what I got on my own claim.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Nobody told me this when I filed for bonding with my second kid. I assumed the payment would be docked for taxes and planned around a lower number. Nope, full notice amount came through, anyway just confirming what others are saying here.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorPlanning around the wrong number would've been rough. I'm glad I asked before my payment came through.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Exactly why I'm saying it. Plan for the full notice amount and then figure out the federal tax question separately before you file your return.
0 coins
Ella Knight
DE 2500E came through on mine and I wanted to know what exactly it was confirming and what the payment method on file was. Tried EDD's line a few times over two days and kept hitting a dead end. Used Claimyr and talked to an agent who confirmed my payment method was direct deposit and the DE 2500E was the electronic benefit payment notification for my first week. No Social Security or Medicare was deducted from that first payment.
0 coins
William Schwarz
What specifically did you ask the agent when you got through, was it just about the DE 2500E or did you ask about the tax piece too?
0 coins
Ella Knight
Mostly the DE 2500E and the payment method. The tax thing came up because I asked why the deposit matched the notice exactly and the agent said nothing is withheld, it goes out as shown.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
been trying that line for four days. four. good to know something actually works
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
Worth clarifying one thing that tripped up a friend of mine: the SDI withholding on your regular paycheck, the CASDI line, that's the premium you pay into the program, not a tax on PFL benefits. The two things are separate. You paid in through your wages, now you're drawing from it. No FICA on the way out.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
I had thought CASDI and FICA were somehow connected. So CASDI is just what funds the program, not a tax that keeps getting taken out.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
Right. CASDI on your stub is your SDI contribution. Once you're on PFL, EDD pays you from that pool and doesn't turn around and take FICA back out.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorThis actually clarified something I'd been fuzzy on. I kept looking at my CASDI line and wondering if it meant something for my PFL payment.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
my coworker thought she was going to get like a reduced check because of taxes and was surprised when the full amount hit her account. edd doesnt deduct fica, the notice amount is what you get
0 coins
Madison King
Same thing happened to me, expected less and got the full notice amount.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
yeah it's a nice surprise honestly. just make sure you know the federal tax situation before april lol
0 coins
Caleb Stone
PFL payments go out without Social Security or Medicare deducted. California doesn't tax it either. Set aside time before you file your return to look at the federal question with a tax professional.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorPractical and clear. That's exactly what I needed to hear.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Keep your 1099-G when it comes in January and you'll have everything you need.
0 coins
Daniel Price
Intermittent days threw me off on my care claim. I went back part-time to the office and wasn't sure how to report the days or what the DE 2580GF was asking. Tried phoning EDD but couldn't get through on two different mornings. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who confirmed which intermittent days were still pending and explained I needed to return the DE 2580GF to keep payments going.
0 coins
Noah Irving
My bonding claim has been going fine but I want to know whether I can switch to intermittent days now that I'm back part-time. I'll try Claimyr for that one.
0 coins
Daniel Price
Have your claim ID and the specific days you've worked ready. The agent can look right at what's pending and tell you what EDD has on file.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Let me add something that confused me for a while: PFL has no waiting period, unlike Disability Insurance which has the first seven days unpaid. Someone told me PFL worked the same way and I almost planned my budget wrong. It doesn't. No waiting week, no FICA deducted, what your notice says is what you get.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
I made the same mistake. Thought I'd lose the first week. Good that someone said it.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
yeah my buddy warned me about the waiting week thing and he was thinking of disability not pfl, almost had me worried for nothing
0 coins
Connor Murphy
That distinction matters for budgeting. Disability Insurance has the unpaid waiting period; PFL does not. EDD's own page says PFL has no benefit waiting period.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Just got my Notice of Computation last week and I was so relieved to understand it's the actual payment amount and nothing gets skimmed off for FICA before it hits! Made planning my leave so much easier.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Same result here, notice matched the deposit exactly.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
And California not taxing it either is a real help. Just need to sort out the federal side with my accountant before spring!
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
EDD's tax information page lays it out: California does not withhold state income tax from PFL, and Social Security and Medicare are not deducted from benefit payments. EDD sends a 1099-G at the end of the year. The federal taxability question is the one that needs a tax professional or EDD's federal tax guidance, not a forum.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Is the 1099-G separate from any other forms EDD sends, or is it the same thing as the Notice of Computation?
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Separate documents. The Notice of Computation comes early in your claim and shows your potential weekly benefit amount. The 1099-G comes the following January and shows total benefits paid during the tax year.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Got it, so I keep both but they're for different purposes. That makes sense now.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
The 1099-G is the one you hand to your tax person. The Notice of Computation is just for knowing what your weekly payment will be.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
no fica on pfl. edd sends the full amount. learned this after my first payment landed and i thought the system had made an error because it matched my notice exactly
0 coins
KhalilStar
lol same, i thought something was off because there were no deductions
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
right it looks almost too clean but thats just how it works
0 coins
William Schwarz
People also sometimes think bonding and care claims each get their own eight weeks. They don't. It's eight weeks total across all PFL claim types within a 12-month period. Use five weeks bonding and you have three left for a care claim in that same window.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
I told my brother bonding and care were separate eight-week banks and he almost filed a care claim thinking he had a full eight weeks left. Glad someone said this.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
This is the one I see misunderstood most often. Eight weeks is the ceiling for all of it combined in any 12-month stretch.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorI hadn't even thought about this yet. I'm only taking bonding leave now but good to know if something comes up with family later in the year.
0 coins
Noah Irving
My PFL payment for bonding landed this week and it was exactly what the Notice of Computation said, no FICA, no state tax, nothing taken out. First time I've been pleasantly not-surprised by a government payment in a while.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Ha, I know the feeling. EDD gets a lot of grief but on this one the payments came through cleanly.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Filing in SDI Online and having the direct deposit set up made it pretty straightforward once I got past the pending stage.
0 coins
Ella Knight
If anyone is still unsure about the weekly amount, EDD has a benefits calculator on their site that lets you estimate before the Notice of Computation arrives. Then when the notice comes you can compare. Neither the site number nor the notice includes any FICA because there is none.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorI did use the calculator before filing and it was pretty close to my notice. Helpful for initial planning.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Good. Use the actual notice number for your budget once you have it, not the estimate.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
For the person asking about the waiting period earlier in this thread, one more clarification: the seven unpaid days at the start apply to Disability Insurance claims, not PFL. A birth mother filing PFL bonding after her pregnancy disability claim ends would have already seen that waiting period on the disability side. PFL itself starts paying from day one of the bonding leave.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorI'm a dad so I went straight to PFL with no prior disability claim. This tells me I didn't miss anything.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Correct. No waiting period for you. Your bonding claim starts from your first day of leave and that's what EDD goes by.
0 coins
KhalilStar
edd doesnt touch your fica thats between you and the irs at tax time. notice amount is your check amount
0 coins
Madison King
Confirmed. Mine matched.
0 coins
KhalilStar
yeah pretty much everyone in this thread is saying the same thing so at least its consistent
0 coins