Back to California Disability

Paolo Conti

How long does SDI appeal process take after denial in California EDD?

Got a denial notice from EDD last week for my disability claim, I had a back injury that kept me out of work for about two months, and the Notice of Determination said I didn't meet the medical eligibility requirements. I'm honestly not sure if my doctor submitted something wrong or if EDD just decided the injury wasn't severe enough. The notice has an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) attached and says I have 30 days from the date on the letter. I'm planning to appeal but I have no idea how long does SDI appeal process take after denial, like are we talking weeks or months? I'm already stressed about money and I don't know if I should be lining up other options or just waiting to hear back. I keep second-guessing myself about whether the appeal is even worth trying or if I should just accept it. Any experience with this?

Thirty days from the date printed on the notice is your window to file. Send the DE 1000A with as detailed an explanation as you can write, and attach anything from your doctor that speaks to why you couldn't do your regular work. The timeline after that varies quite a bit, but appeals go to an administrative law judge and the process can take several months. Keep copies of everything you mail.

0 coins

My injury was pretty well-documented but I'm not sure my doctor's notes said exactly that I couldn't do my regular job. Should I get a letter from him specifically saying that before I send the appeal?

0 coins

A letter from your provider that speaks directly to your work limitations would strengthen the appeal. Send the DE 1000A before the 30 days are up regardless, then get the supporting documentation to the address on the notice as soon as you have it.

0 coins

Appeals took about four months for my neighbor. Just flagging that it can be a long wait.

0 coins

DE 2525XX had been sitting with my doctor's office for two weeks and nobody had submitted it. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent since the phone line was eating my mornings, and the agent told me EDD had not received the form yet. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Gave the office a nudge that same afternoon and they got it in the next day.

0 coins

Eight mornings I tried that line before 9 and got the busy signal or a hang-up every time. Hard to believe anything actually gets you to a person there.

0 coins

Understandable. The agent I spoke with pulled up my claim right there and confirmed the form hadn't come in yet, so it was clearly an actual EDD employee, not a recording.

0 coins

Payment method question for my claim, I had the wrong account on file, and an agent sorted it out on the same call. Actually ended up talking to someone. Anyway, the extension situation is exactly what I'd have panicked about too.

0 coins

Glad the extension got sorted. I'm wondering if my situation is different since I already got a denial, not just a pending.

0 coins

Month three of my appeal right now, no hearing date yet. Called the number on the notice once and sat on hold so long my phone died. The 30-day deadline is firm though, so get that form in the mail today if you haven't already.

0 coins

Three months and still no date? That's rough. How did you send it, certified mail?

0 coins

Certified, return receipt. I'd do it that way every time just so there's no argument about whether they got it.

0 coins

Sending certified mail is a good call, I hadn't thought of that. Going to do that for sure.

0 coins

EDD's appeals page says to send the DE 1000A to the return address on the denial notice, not to EDD's general address. Mailing it to the wrong place is one of the more common mistakes people make and it can cost you the deadline.

0 coins

Wait, so the address on the form itself might be different from the address on the notice? I want to make sure I understand because I just got a denial too and I'm panicking a little.

0 coins

The notice has its own return address printed on it, and that's the one to use. The DE 1000A is the form but the notice tells you exactly where to send it.

0 coins

Didn't know this until I read it here. Good to know.

0 coins

Heard four to six months thrown around a lot. Mine was closer to five. Mostly waiting.

0 coins

Five months is brutal when you're not getting paid.

0 coins

Yeah. I had to work part time during it. EDD still decided what they decided, eventually.

0 coins

Claim start date on my denial didn't match the date my provider put on the certification, which is apparently why EDD flagged it. Talked to an agent through Claimyr about it and they confirmed the dates were misaligned on my claim. Filed the appeal with a corrected statement from my doctor explaining the actual first day I couldn't work.

0 coins

Wait, what's Claimyr? Is that an app or something?

0 coins

It keeps you on the line with EDD while you do other things, and your phone rings when an actual EDD agent picks up. Saved me from burning another morning on hold.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful, lol. I want to ask about whether my partial weeks got counted right. Might try that.

0 coins

date mismatch is what got me too, my doctor put the wrong start day and edd denied the whole thing

0 coins

A date mismatch is something I hadn't considered. Going to double check what my provider put versus what I listed on my claim.

0 coins

Worth knowing that if you miss the 30-day window you can still appeal but you have to explain the reason for the delay to the administrative law judge. It doesn't automatically disqualify you but it adds a hurdle. File on time if at all possible.

0 coins

Is the 30 days from when the notice was issued or from when I actually received it in the mail? Mine took five days to arrive.

0 coins

The 30 days run from the date printed on the notice, not the day it arrived. So if yours took five days to get to you, you effectively have 25 days left from today.

0 coins

Oh that's stressful. Filing mine this week then.

0 coins

Judge's calendar is backed up, that's the honest answer. You're in line behind everybody else who filed before you. File the appeal, document your medical situation clearly, and then wait. Nothing else you can do to speed it up.

0 coins

That's pretty much it. I appealed a workers' comp thing once and the wait was similar.

0 coins

Different program but same basic idea, government calendar moves slow.

0 coins

My denial came down to EDD saying my provider wasn't on their list of people who could certify. Turns out my physical therapist had submitted the medical certification, which I didn't even realize wasn't allowed. Had to get my actual doctor to certify and start the whole appeal with the correct paperwork.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's approved list of certifying providers. The medical certification has to come from a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, chiropractor, or a few other specific types. Worth checking which provider submitted yours.

0 coins

I assumed any healthcare provider could certify. Good thing I found out before I filed my appeal.

0 coins

Nobody told me the list existed. I just handed the form to whoever was treating me most often at the time.

0 coins

The provider list being so specific trips people up all the time. Glad your doctor stepped in.

0 coins

DE 1000A deadline passed on my first appeal because I misread the date, so I had to explain the delay to the judge. The judge accepted it but I added a couple more months to the whole process. Date on the notice matters, don't go by the postmark.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of thing I would do. Setting a calendar reminder today.

0 coins

My notice date and the postmark were three days apart, so I'm glad you mentioned this.

0 coins

Notice of Computation numbers on my denial looked off so I used Claimyr to get an agent and ask about it. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the base period quarter EDD used wasn't the highest-earning one, it was the quarter before. Had to figure out from there whether to appeal on the benefit amount or the eligibility denial separately.

0 coins

DE 2517 on my claim had a Notice of Determination I didn't understand, so I called EDD and got an agent who walked me through which weeks they had marked ineligible. Glad I called when I did.

0 coins

What did you do after the agent told you that?

0 coins

Agent said EDD would mail an updated notice and to appeal within 30 days if I disagreed, so I waited for the mail and then filed.

0 coins

The base period thing is easy to miss on the Notice of Computation. If the quarter they used wasn't your highest, that's worth raising in the appeal explanation.

0 coins

been waiting four months already, no hearing yet. just sit tight is the only advice i have.

0 coins

Four months is about what I keep hearing from people. At least it's consistent.

0 coins

consistent in being slow, yeah

0 coins

Appeals with a lot of medical documentation tend to move a little smoother at the hearing stage, from what I've seen friends go through. The judge wants to see that your provider actually put in writing why you couldn't do your job, not just that you were treated.

0 coins

That framing really helps me think about what I need to gather. My doctor's notes say what treatment he gave but I'm not sure they say what I couldn't do.

0 coins

Ask your provider to write a short statement specifically about work capacity, something like whether you could stand, lift, or do whatever your regular job requires. That's the piece that helps.

0 coins

edd denied me said i didnt have enough wages in my base period but i did, took like six months for the appeal and judge agreed with me so dont give up

0 coins

Six months is a long time but that's actually encouraging that the judge sided with you.

0 coins

yeah gather everything, pay stubs bank statements whatever you got

0 coins

The appeal form asks for a detailed explanation. That doesn't mean a paragraph, it means as much as you need to say. Judges see these all day, so being specific about dates and what your provider told you about your condition carries more weight than general statements.

0 coins

Specific dates and the exact language your provider used about your limitations, those two things matter more than length.

0 coins

Exactly. 'I could not stand for more than ten minutes without pain as of this date' beats 'my back was really bad' every single time.

0 coins

Five months for my sister's appeal and it got overturned! So it can go your way. She kept every single piece of paper EDD ever sent her and brought copies to the hearing.

0 coins

Keeping every notice is smart. I lost one and had to request a copy.

0 coins

I've been saving everything in a folder since the denial came. Good to know that habit helps.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD picks up and nobody answers Ask EDD fast enough when you're watching a 30-day deadline. If your denial has anything confusing on it, try to get a person before you file so you're not guessing about what they actually denied you for.

0 coins

Agreed. Know what they denied you for before you write the appeal explanation.

0 coins

Exactly. Appealing the wrong thing because you misread the denial is a waste of months.

0 coins

Filed mine, got a hearing date about five months out, then the hearing itself was 20 minutes. Anyway the wait is the main thing, the actual hearing isn't long.

0 coins

Twenty minutes after five months of waiting is kind of wild but good to know what to expect when you get there.

0 coins

Bring your documents, speak to your dates and your provider's findings, and it goes quick.

0 coins

If the DE 1000A form from the notice is lost or damaged, EDD says you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the address on the notice. The form is preferred but a letter works if you explain the delay or the missing form. Don't skip filing because you misplaced the form.

0 coins

I didn't know a letter was an option. I was worried mine had an ink smear over part of the form.

0 coins

A letter that includes all the same information works. Just make sure it's detailed and mailed before the 30 days are up.

0 coins

Medical records from every provider you saw during the disability period, any notes about work restrictions, your job description if you have one in writing. Bring copies of everything to the hearing, don't hand over your only set.

0 coins

Copies only, good rule. Keep the originals at home.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way on something else years ago. Never give anybody the last copy of anything.

0 coins

Thank you all, this has been really helpful. I'm going to get the DE 1000A certified-mailed by end of this week, ask my doctor for a specific work-restriction letter, and then just be prepared to wait several months. If anything weird comes up with the paperwork I'll try the EDD phone line. Appreciate everyone who shared their timeline.

0 coins

That plan is solid. Keep a copy of the appeal form before it goes in the mail.

0 coins

Sounds like you've got it organized. The wait is the hard part but you're doing the right things.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure