Back to California Disability

Omar Fawaz

Can SDI use a different base period quarter for benefits if your highest earnings aren't recent?

So I filed my SDI claim last month after a back injury kept me from my job at the dental office. When the Notice of Computation came in I was kind of shocked because the weekly amount seemed really low compared to what I've been earning lately. I think I figured out why though. I had a gap in work about two years ago for personal reasons and my earnings were all over the place depending on the quarter. What I don't understand is how EDD picks which quarter or which chunk of time they look at. Can SDI use a different base period quarter for benefits if the one they picked isn't my highest? Like is there any flexibility in how they calculate it, or is whatever shows on the Notice of Computation basically locked in? I tried messaging through SDI Online but haven't heard anything and I honestly have no idea if I'm even asking the right question.

The question to put to EDD is whether the base period they used was the standard one or whether an alternate calculation might apply to your situation. The way it works is EDD looks at a 12-month base period made up of four quarters, and your benefit amount comes from whichever of those quarters had your highest wages. So if your highest-earning quarter falls outside that standard window because of when you filed, the amount on your Notice of Computation might look lower than you expected.

0 coins

SDI Online doesn't show me which quarter they actually used. Is that on the Notice of Computation somewhere or do I have to ask EDD directly?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly benefit and maximum, but to see the specific quarter they pulled from you'd want to contact EDD and ask them to walk through the base period dates on your claim.

0 coins

EDD's site has a benefit calculator that lets you enter wages by quarter so you can run your own estimate. Worth doing before you call, so you know going in what the numbers should look like.

0 coins

Filed date matters a lot here. The base period runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim starts, so depending on exactly when you filed your injury claim, a quarter where you earned well might fall just outside the window. August 2026 filing date, for example, puts the base period back to roughly the second quarter of 2025 through the first quarter of 2024.

0 coins

Mine was filed in October so I'm going to try to map that out. That gap I had might be landing right in the middle of my base period, which would explain everything.

0 coins

Run those four quarters against your pay records. If October is your start, the highest-wage quarter inside that window is what drives the number on your Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Does EDD ever shift the window if you had a disability or leave that knocked out your earnings in that period? I've seen something mentioned about alternate base periods but couldn't find anything specific for SDI.

0 coins

The base period runs 5 to 18 months before the claim and uses the highest quarter inside it. For anything beyond that you'd really need to ask EDD directly about your specific filing dates, since I haven't seen a clear written rule about alternate periods for SDI the way some unemployment programs have.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim was showing wrong in SDI Online and I couldn't get anyone on the phone for three weeks straight. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the payment had actually issued two days earlier than the portal was showing. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Told me to check my Money Network card balance directly since the portal sometimes lags behind.

0 coins

The base period quarter question is exactly what I need answered on my own claim and the phone line has been impossible. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific quarters you think should be counted. The agent can pull the base period dates right off your claim.

0 coins

Three weeks of that line and nothing, I know that feeling. Hope you get through quickly.

0 coins

Two weeks of mornings wasted here. Every single time it's the same recording and then it cuts off. Glad the payment thing got sorted at least.

0 coins

Whatever the Notice of Computation shows is based on wages EDD has on file. If your employer was late reporting a quarter, the number might be off for that reason too, not just the base period window.

0 coins

Hadn't even considered that. My employer is pretty small so I'm going to double-check that all my quarters actually got reported before I assume it's a base period problem.

0 coins

Worth ruling out. If wages are missing from EDD's records that's a separate fix from the base period question.

0 coins

My cousin went through something really similar after taking time off between jobs and her weekly amount looked way off. She kept asking EDD to explain the quarters and eventually got a clearer breakdown. Don't give up pushing for an explanation.

0 coins

Good to know I'm not the only one confused by this. Did she end up getting it corrected or was the amount just what it was?

0 coins

From what she said the number stayed the same once they explained which quarter they'd used, but at least she understood why. Knowing the reason made it easier to accept.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared my calculation is off too. I switched jobs in the middle of last year and my wages in the base period are all over the place. Not sure how EDD handles that or if the quarter they pick is ever wrong.

0 coins

EDD takes your highest single quarter of wages inside the base period window, so switching jobs mid-year can actually work in your favor if one quarter had strong combined earnings from both. Use the calculator on EDD's site to run your own estimate.

0 coins

edd just picks whatever quarter was highest right, like you dont get to choose

0 coins

Correct, EDD selects the highest-earning quarter within the standard base period automatically. You don't choose it, but you can verify which one they used by contacting EDD if the number on your notice doesn't match what you expected.

0 coins

ok so if your highest quarter falls outside that window youre just stuck with the lower one

0 coins

DE 2593 came in the mail after my tenth week of benefits and I almost missed the 20-day return window. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask whether they'd received it since I'd mailed it and nothing updated in SDI Online. The agent confirmed they had it and that my payments were still running.

0 coins

DE 2593 was the same thing that caught me off guard on my claim. I've used Claimyr too, and once the agent confirmed the form was in I asked about which weeks had actually been marked paid versus which were still showing pending. Turned out two weeks had processed that same morning.

0 coins

been trying that phone number every day this week and it just cuts me off every time

0 coins

It was rough before I found another way in. Hope it clears up for you.

0 coins

Twenty days goes fast when you're dealing with everything else. Good heads up anyway.

0 coins

The piece that often surprises people is that the base period looks back further than you might think. The quarter you just finished working in before your disability started usually isn't inside the window at all. That 5-to-18-month lookback is designed to use wages that were already reported and verified, not your most recent pay.

0 coins

That actually explains a lot. My highest earnings were in the last few months before my injury and those are probably outside the base period entirely.

0 coins

Almost certainly. The most recent quarter is typically excluded. So if you had strong earnings right before you got hurt, those wages might not count at all in the standard base period.

0 coins

So the quarter that just ended right before you file might not even be used? That seems really unfair if someone just got a raise or switched to a higher-paying job.

0 coins

It can feel that way. It's how EDD's system is built to work with the wage reporting cycle. The benefit estimate tool on EDD's site will show you pretty clearly which quarters fall in versus out for your specific filing date.

0 coins

Went through a back injury claim two years ago and the first Notice of Computation I got looked wrong to me too. Turned out one of my quarters was underreported. Called EDD, they found the discrepancy, and an updated notice came about two weeks later with the corrected amount. Worth verifying your wage history if anything looks off.

0 coins

Updated notice is something I didn't know was possible. If my wages were actually reported wrong that could change everything.

0 coins

Ask EDD to confirm what wage amounts they have on file for each quarter in your base period. If something doesn't match your pay records, that's the angle to push.

0 coins

This is the most useful thing in this thread for the original question honestly. Missing or underreported wages are easier to correct than arguing about which quarter gets used.

0 coins

The EDD phone line might as well not exist some days. Tried ten mornings in a row for my own notice question and either got the full busy signal or it disconnected me after the menu. How is anyone supposed to sort out a base period dispute like this if you can't reach a person.

0 coins

EDD's online contact form exists. Takes longer than a call but you at least get a written response.

0 coins

Tried that too. Response came back two weeks later and didn't actually answer what I asked. Just said to review my Notice of Computation.

0 coins

For anything specific to your wage records it really does take a live agent. The online form responses tend to be generic.

0 coins

My sister used to work in payroll and she always said the quarterly wage reporting system is one of the main reasons SDI amounts surprise people! Employers submit wages by quarter to EDD and there can be timing gaps that affect what shows in your base period. Definitely worth asking EDD to confirm what's on file!

0 coins

Payroll reporting timing is real. I've seen a quarter show up late in EDD's records because the employer filed on the last day of the reporting period, which pushed it outside the base period window for someone who filed their claim early.

0 coins

Exactly that kind of thing! And most people have no idea it can even happen until they see a Notice of Computation that looks way too low.

0 coins

Not sure if this is related but I also didn't understand the difference between the base period and the waiting period when I first filed. I thought the seven days was something about how they calculate wages and I was confused for like a week. Turns out those are completely separate things.

0 coins

The first seven days of a new claim are a non-payable waiting period, meaning no benefits for those days regardless of what the base period calculation shows. The base period is only about figuring out the weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I eventually figured out. I wish the SDI Online filing screens made that clearer.

0 coins

I made a similar mistake honestly. I kept thinking my payment was being delayed because of some calculation they were still running.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in after my claim got denied and I had no idea what the appeal window was or whether the information in the letter was even accurate. Used Claimyr to get a live person at EDD and they told me the determination had been issued nine days earlier and that I had until 30 days from that date to appeal. Turned out the specific reason on mine was a question about my medical certification timing.

0 coins

Honestly every time someone says they got through to EDD on the phone I wonder if they're just saying that because nothing has worked for me in four tries over three mornings. The line literally ends the call without even a hold option.

0 coins

I had the same experience for the first week. The call with the agent was real, the person confirmed when my determination was issued and read me the reason code. That's how I knew the certification timing was the issue.

0 coins

Phoned about which quarter of the base period applied to my current claim and the agent confirmed it was the third quarter of last year. That matched my pay records so I knew the amount on my Notice of Computation was calculated right.

0 coins

Fine, maybe I'll give it a go. Still not sure but I've got nothing left to try at this point. My question is about the waiting period on mine.

0 coins

Appeal window was something I had no idea about either. Good to know it's 30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it.

0 coins

Appeal rights on a Notice of Determination are time-sensitive. If the amount on your Notice of Computation looks wrong and EDD issued a determination about it, 30 days from the date on that notice is what you're working with. File the appeal with the form they include, or a detailed letter if the form is gone, to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

I haven't received a determination, just the Notice of Computation. Does that mean I should still appeal or just contact EDD to ask about the base period?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation alone isn't a denial. Contact EDD to verify the wage amounts and quarters they used. An appeal would come into play only if EDD issued a determination and you disagreed with it.

0 coins

Exactly right. The Notice of Computation is not an approval or denial, it just shows the potential benefit amount based on what EDD has on file. Questioning the base period at this stage is just a matter of verifying wage records.

0 coins

My claim was for a knee thing and EDD had me in the right quarter but the wage amount for that quarter was lower than my actual pay stubs showed. Asked them to look at it again and they found one pay period that hadn't posted yet. The updated amount was closer to what I expected.

0 coins

Pay stubs versus what EDD has on file is exactly what I should be checking. I haven't actually pulled my stubs and compared them to the quarters in my base period.

0 coins

Pull every stub from the quarters in your base period and add them up by quarter. If EDD's number for even one of them is off, that could explain the whole gap.

0 coins

Patients sometimes ask me about SDI during recovery and the base period confusion comes up a lot. The simplest framing is that EDD is using wages from before your most recent work, not your current paycheck, and your highest quarter inside that window sets the weekly benefit. If the amount still looks off after you check your pay records, ask EDD to confirm the specific quarter they used.

0 coins

The framing of it as before your most recent work is actually really helpful. I kept thinking they should be using what I made right before my claim.

0 coins

That's the most common misconception. The most recent months of your earnings almost never fall inside the base period window.

0 coins

Is there any form you fill out to dispute the base period or is it all just calling EDD and hoping anyway.

0 coins

No specific form for disputing the base period calculation. You contact EDD, ask them to confirm the wage amounts on file for each quarter in your base period, and if the amounts differ from your records you work with them to correct the wage reporting. It's usually an issue to take up with both EDD and your employer if wages were underreported.

0 coins

So employer might have to fix something on their end too, got it.

0 coins

Low benefit amounts frustrate a lot of people but most of the time it's the base period window working as designed, not an error. Worth verifying wages before assuming something went wrong.

0 coins

Cold comfort when the amount is half what you need to cover rent.

0 coins

Fair. Still better to know the reason so you can plan.

0 coins

been dealing with this for my shoulder claim. notice of computation came in and i just accepted it without really checking. now reading this thread and thinking i probably should have looked closer at which quarter they used.

0 coins

Even now it's worth contacting EDD to ask which quarter they used. If wages look off you can still raise it.

0 coins

ok might do that. i still have all my pay stubs from last year so at least i have something to compare against

0 coins

My claim went through pretty smoothly but I did check my Notice of Computation against EDD's benefit calculator before accepting the number. Plugging in the wages by quarter showed the same result, so I knew the base period was being applied correctly. If the calculator estimate doesn't match your notice, that's a signal to dig into the specific quarters.

0 coins

Going to do exactly this. I just need to figure out which four quarters actually fall in my base period given when I filed.

0 coins

Filing date is the starting point. Work backward from there and map your quarters, then run them through the calculator.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site is surprisingly straightforward once you know which quarters to plug in.

0 coins

If your employer is small there's also a chance they filed quarterly wages late and EDD processed your base period without that quarter. In my experience with the warehouse the quarterly deadlines get missed sometimes. Something to ask your HR about before you even call EDD.

0 coins

My office only has about six people. I genuinely don't know how on top of quarterly reporting they are. I'll ask the office manager before I do anything else.

0 coins

Good call. If the wages weren't filed on time by the employer, EDD wouldn't have them available when they calculated your base period. That's a gap that can be corrected but takes time.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure