Can I get unemployment if fired but employer gave reasons - Washington ESD question
So my employer let me go last Tuesday and they were very specific about why - wrote it all out in a termination letter, cited three separate incidents, the whole thing. HR even had me sign a form acknowledging the reasons. I always thought getting fired meant you were automatically out of luck with unemployment, but my neighbor said that's not always true? I've been at this warehouse job for about two years, nothing like this has ever happened before on my record. The first incident they listed was a no-call no-show back in March, which honestly I contest because I did text my supervisor that morning - I have the texts. The other two reasons were about productivity metrics that I genuinely didn't know I was falling short on because nobody ever showed me any written warning about numbers. I filed my claim online through the Washington ESD portal two days ago and now I'm just sitting here wondering if having documented reasons from my employer means I'm automatically disqualified or if there's actually a process where I get to explain my side. Anyone been through this?
70 comments

Oliver Schulz
Filing your weekly claims while this gets sorted is the first thing I'd do in your shoes - don't skip a week thinking the whole thing is on hold. The way Washington ESD works with employer-disputed terminations is they open an adjudication period where both you AND your employer get to submit information. Having documented reasons from your employer doesn't automatically disqualify you. What actually matters is whether what you did rises to the level of 'misconduct' under their definition - which is basically did you intentionally or repeatedly ignore known workplace rules. The texts you have proving you notified your supervisor? That directly contradicts the no-call no-show. Gather everything - texts, any emails, the termination letter itself, and think about whether you ever received anything in writing about those productivity metrics.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorOkay that's a relief to hear about the weekly claims - I almost didn't file one this week because I figured the whole claim was frozen. So I do still need to do that even during adjudication?
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Yes, every week without exception. Missing a week means missing that week's payment permanently, adjudication or not. The system holds the funds until the determination comes through, then releases them retroactively if you're approved.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
This happened to me too and I had no idea about the weekly claims thing until way too late. Lost two weeks of payments because nobody tells you this upfront.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
The termination letter with specific reasons actually works in your favor in a weird way - it pins down exactly what the employer is claiming, which means you know exactly what you need to rebut. Vague firings are sometimes harder to fight. What you're going to get is a questionnaire from Washington ESD asking for your version of events, and that's your opportunity to explain the text message situation and the fact that you had no documented warnings about productivity.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorMy ESD portal is showing 'pending adjudication' right now. Is there a separate questionnaire that comes through or does it show up on the portal?
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Both, usually. Watch for a message in your SecureAccess Washington portal AND keep an eye on your physical mail. Sometimes the questionnaire only comes by mail and people miss the deadline waiting for it online.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
ALWAYS check actual mail during adjudication. I almost missed my questionnaire because i kept checking the portal only. paper letter with like a 10 day deadline to respond
0 coins
Emma Wilson
The portal messaging system and postal mail run separately and ESD uses both inconsistently depending on the case type. Set a reminder to check your mailbox daily.
0 coins
Malik Davis
When my claim was stuck in adjudication after my termination last year I was going absolutely insane trying to reach anyone at Washington ESD to find out what was happening. Calling them directly was a nightmare - I'd be on hold for over an hour and then get cut off. Someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr and it genuinely changed things for me. You go to claimyr.com and they basically navigate the phone system and hold your place until an actual ESD agent picks up, then connect you. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ - worth watching before your adjudication drags on too long. Being able to actually talk to someone helped me understand exactly what documentation they needed from me.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorHad no idea something like that existed. The phone situation is brutal - tried calling yesterday morning and gave up after 45 minutes.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
claimyr worked for me too, though I was skeptical at first. Actually got to talk through my specific situation with an agent instead of just guessing what they needed
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
gonna look into this. been trying to reach ESD for a week about my adjudication and getting nowhere
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Misconduct under Washington unemployment law isn't just 'you did something wrong at work.' What I'd look at first if I were you is whether those productivity issues were ever communicated to you formally - because the standard requires that you knowingly violated a rule. If your employer never showed you in writing that your numbers were below threshold and never gave you a formal warning, that's a real argument that you didn't knowingly violate anything. The no-call situation with the texts is your strongest point though - document that exchange carefully and reference the specific date and time in your questionnaire response.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorJust pulled up my texts and I have the message I sent my supervisor at 6:47am that day saying I was sick, with his read receipt showing he saw it. That's pretty solid evidence right?
0 coins
GalacticGuru
That's genuinely strong. A read receipt showing your supervisor saw your message before your shift started directly contradicts a no-call no-show claim. Screenshot it, note the timestamps, and reference it explicitly in your response to ESD. If the case goes to a hearing that evidence would be significant.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
read receipts have been accepted as evidence in ESD hearings before. Former HR person here and that kind of documentation absolutely matters in these determinations.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
my buddy got fired for attendance and still got unemployment approved in washington. the employer claimed misconduct but ESD sided with him because he had proof he followed the callout procedure. your text situation sounds similar tbh
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorGood to hear actual examples of this working out. Did he have to go through a full hearing or did it get resolved at the adjudication stage?
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
adjudication stage, never went to a hearing. took about 3 weeks total
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Three things worth knowing about how Washington ESD evaluates fired claimants: First thing I'd do in your position is write a detailed personal timeline of every interaction you had with management about performance - dates, what was said, who was present. The adjudication reviewer looks at whether warnings were progressive and whether you had a genuine chance to correct the behavior. Second, your acknowledgment signature on the termination form just means you received it - it does NOT mean you agreed with the reasons. Third, if adjudication comes back against you, you have 30 days to appeal and request a hearing where you can present your texts and argue your case to an administrative law judge.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorThe 30 day appeal window is really useful to know. I'll start that timeline you mentioned - I genuinely cannot think of a single formal written warning about productivity before this.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Keep that timeline somewhere safe and date it today so you have a record of when you documented everything. Memory fades fast and having contemporaneous notes matters if this escalates.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The signing thing tripped me up too - I thought signing the termination paperwork meant I was agreeing I deserved to be fired and that it would hurt my claim. Nope, it's just acknowledgment of receipt.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Just want to add - if adjudication takes longer than expected and you need to actually speak with someone about where your case stands, Claimyr is a genuinely useful tool for getting through to Washington ESD. I used it when my own fired-for-cause claim was sitting in adjudication with no movement for nearly a month. The agent I reached was actually able to flag that my employer had submitted documentation and my response window was about to close - information that was NOT visible anywhere on my portal. Website is claimyr.com.
0 coins
StarStrider
wait the portal doesn't always show when your response window is closing?? that is terrifying honestly
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
In my experience the portal status was just 'adjudication in progress' the entire time with zero indication of deadlines. The agent told me I had 4 days left to respond. Would have missed it entirely.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
This is why calling them even just once during adjudication is worth doing. That kind of deadline info not being shown clearly on the portal is a real problem.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
employers give reasons for termination all the time and ESD still approves claims regularly. the bar for 'misconduct' that actually disqualifies you is higher than most people think. your situation with the disputed no-call and no written productivity warnings sounds like it has a decent shot
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorEvery response in this thread has made me feel significantly less panicked. Thank you for that.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
file your weeklies, respond to that questionnaire fast and thoroughly, and keep those texts ready. that's really all you can do from here
0 coins
Luca Romano
Went through almost this exact thing - fired with a detailed termination letter citing specific incidents. The adjudication questionnaire they sent me was about 8 questions long and I basically wrote a paragraph responding to each point, attaching my evidence. Got approved after 19 days. When I was waiting and couldn't get anyone on the phone, I found Claimyr through someone's recommendation - claimyr.com - and finally reached an ESD agent who confirmed my response had been received and was under review. That peace of mind alone was worth it. Demo video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you want to see how the process works before trying it.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Author19 days and approved - that's genuinely encouraging. How detailed did you get in your questionnaire responses? Like did you attach actual screenshots or just describe the evidence?
0 coins
Luca Romano
Attached the screenshots AND described them in the text response. Belt and suspenders approach. The questions asked if I had supporting documentation and I sent everything I had. Don't hold anything back thinking you'll save it for an appeal.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
the attach everything approach is the right call. reviewers aren't going to dig for evidence you didn't send, they evaluate what's in front of them
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
FIRED WITH DOCUMENTED REASONS IS NOT THE SAME AS AUTOMATICALLY DISQUALIFIED. I cannot stress this enough because I see people assume this all the time and give up before they even try. Washington ESD makes their own independent determination. Your employer's version is their version. Yours is yours. The reviewer reads both.
0 coins
StarStrider
This should be pinned at the top of every unemployment thread honestly
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Every person who gives up on a valid claim because they assume documented termination = no benefits is leaving money on the table they were entitled to.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Something most people don't know: Washington ESD adjudicators are specifically trained to distinguish between poor performance and misconduct. Performance issues - like not hitting productivity numbers - generally don't qualify as misconduct even if they're the documented reason for firing. Misconduct requires something more like intentional rule-breaking or gross negligence. Missing numbers on metrics you were never formally told you were failing? That's performance, not misconduct, in most determinations I've seen.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorThat distinction between performance and misconduct is really helpful. I genuinely didn't know my numbers were that far off - my manager never said anything directly to me about it.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Document that too. If you can say 'I was never informed verbally or in writing that my productivity was below acceptable levels prior to termination' that's a meaningful statement for the record.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
This performance vs misconduct line is where a lot of employer-disputed claims get approved. Employers often frame performance problems as misconduct because they don't understand the legal distinction either.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
been through this twice with washington esd (different jobs, different situations) and both times i was fired with reasons given and both times i got approved. first time took 4 weeks, second time only 12 days. just be thorough with the questionnaire and don't panic
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Twice approved after documented terminations is actually really reassuring to read. What industries were those if you don't mind?
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
retail first time, logistics second time. different circumstances but similar process both times
0 coins
StarStrider
Does anyone know what happens if the employer submits a LOT of documentation vs just a letter? Like does the volume of paperwork from the employer affect the adjudication outcome or does it still come down to the same misconduct standard?
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Volume alone doesn't decide it - the standard is still the same legal test regardless of how much paper the employer submits. A hundred pages of documentation still has to show intentional, knowing rule violations to constitute misconduct. Quality of evidence matters more than quantity.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Agreed. I've seen cases where employers submitted extensive documentation and still lost because none of it demonstrated the claimant knowingly broke a rule. The adjudicator is applying a specific legal standard, not just judging whose stack of paper is taller.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Just to cover the practical side - once your adjudication is complete, whatever the determination is, you'll get a written decision mailed to you and it'll appear in your portal. If it's a denial, the clock on your 30-day appeal window starts from the date on that letter, not from when you receive it. So if mail is slow don't assume you have the full 30 days from when it shows up in your mailbox.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorThe appeal clock starting from the letter date not receipt date is a critical detail. How do people even find out about stuff like this?
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Hard experience mostly. The fine print on the determination letter itself does say this but most people are upset when they read it and miss the detail.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
always photograph or scan any letter from ESD the day it arrives so you have a record of when you actually received it, even if the clock starts earlier
0 coins
Nia Jackson
your situation honestly sounds better than average for employer-disputed claims. two of the three cited reasons have genuine counterarguments - the texts for the no-call and no prior warnings for the productivity metrics. the third reason they listed, what was it?
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorThe third was an incident where I apparently left my shift 20 minutes early without approval back in April. I honestly forgot about that one. I did leave early that day because I had a family emergency but I didn't formally tell anyone, just left.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
family emergency without formal notice is tougher but still arguable as a one-time isolated incident rather than a pattern. your overall record being clean for 2 years helps contextualize it.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Single incidents with mitigating circumstances rarely constitute misconduct on their own. The pattern and notice question matters a lot - did they ever warn you formally after that April incident?
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
the anxiety of waiting during adjudication is real. i'm in week two of mine right now and the not knowing is worse than the actual financial stress almost
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorCompletely. The portal just sitting there saying 'adjudication in progress' with no progress bar or estimated timeline is genuinely stressful.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
i made a list of every piece of evidence i have ready to submit if they ask for more. having the list makes me feel slightly more in control
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
Calling Washington ESD during adjudication is worth trying for exactly this reason. I used Claimyr to actually get through after a week of failed attempts - they handle the hold time and connect you when an agent is available. Getting even a basic status update from a real person makes the wait more tolerable. claimyr.com has the info if you want to try it.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
One more practical note on the questionnaire: answer every single question even if it feels redundant or you think the answer is obvious. Blank fields or one-word responses leave the door open for the reviewer to make assumptions. Write your responses as if the person reading them knows absolutely nothing about your workplace, your role, or your history with the company.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
AuthorTreating the reviewer as having zero context is a really useful framing. I was going to be pretty brief in some answers assuming they'd have my employment file, but I should probably explain everything explicitly?
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Exactly. They have what you submit and what your employer submits. They don't have your mental model of your job. Explicit is always better.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
something nobody mentioned yet - if your employer contests the claim during adjudication and you lose, that decision only covers the disputed period. sometimes people get a partial approval for weeks before the contested date. worth asking about if the determination comes back mixed
0 coins
StarStrider
I didn't know partial approvals were even a thing. So they can approve some weeks and deny others?
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
yes, particularly if the dispute is about a specific incident date. the weeks before that date might have different eligibility than the weeks after
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Partial determinations happen and are worth understanding before you receive yours. If it comes back partial, the same 30-day appeal window applies to the denied portion.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
reading through this whole thread because I'm in a similar boat - fired last week with a written performance improvement plan that I never actually got to try because they fired me the same day they handed it to me. is that relevant to misconduct determination?
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Handing someone a PIP and terminating them simultaneously is actually a known situation in ESD determinations - the argument being you were never given an opportunity to correct the behavior, which undermines the misconduct case. Document the date you received the PIP and the date of termination being the same day.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Same-day PIP and termination is worth flagging explicitly in your questionnaire. It goes directly to whether you had genuine knowledge of the problem and a reasonable opportunity to fix it - both relevant to whether the misconduct standard is met.
0 coins