Social Security retirement-to-survivor benefits switch at FRA - can I apply online now and convert later?
I'm a 62-year-old widow trying to navigate the best Social Security strategy. My husband passed away in 2010 when he was 44 years old. I've done quite a bit of research and calculations regarding my benefits and have determined that taking my own retirement benefits now at the reduced rate and then switching to survivor benefits when I reach my full retirement age (67) will maximize my lifetime payout. This makes sense in my case since my husband was a higher earner than me. I'm ready to apply for my own retirement benefits now, but I'm confused about the process for later switching to survivor benefits. Can I just apply online for my retirement benefits right now, and then make an appointment to switch to survivor benefits when I turn 67? Do I need to do anything specific NOW to ensure that the switch goes smoothly in 5 years? I know the rules are different if you take survivor benefits first and then switch to your own, but I can't find clear information about doing it the other way around. Should I skip the online application and just make an in-person appointment now to discuss this whole plan? I want to make sure I don't miss anything important that might affect my ability to switch benefits later.
21 comments
Join the conversation
Jibriel Kohn
You're on the right track with your strategy! Yes, you can definitely apply for your own retirement benefits online now, and then switch to survivor benefits when you reach your FRA. There's no special action you need to take now to "reserve" your right to switch later - that option will still be available to you. However, I would recommend calling the SSA directly before you submit your online application to confirm this is documented in your record. This way, there's a note in your file about your intention to switch to survivor benefits at FRA. When my sister did this last year, having that note saved her a lot of hassle later. The SSA phone lines are absolutely terrible though - I spent 3+ hours on hold multiple times. I finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a representative in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU. Totally worth it to avoid the frustration of endless hold times.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•Thank you so much for this information! I was worried there might be some special form or declaration I needed to file now. That's a great tip about calling SSA to have them make a note in my record - I wouldn't have thought of that. Those hold times sound horrible! I'll check out that Claimyr service if I can't get through. Did your sister have any issues when she actually made the switch to survivor benefits?
0 coins
Edison Estevez
your doin it all wrong!!! you should ALWAYS take the higest benefit FIRST. my neighbor took lower benefit first and now shes STUCK with it forever. the ssa people NEVER tell you the truth about this stuff!!!
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
•That's not accurate information. The strategy of taking reduced retirement benefits first and then switching to unreduced survivor benefits at FRA is perfectly valid and often optimal when the survivor benefit would be higher than your own retirement benefit at FRA. The situation you're describing about being "stuck" applies to retirement benefits (which are permanently reduced if taken early), but survivor benefits are different - they can be taken at full amount at FRA regardless of whether you took your own retirement early. This is why the OP's strategy makes sense in her situation.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
•I had the same confusion when planning my benefits! The rules ARE different for retirement vs. survivor benefits. With survivor benefits, you can take them at their full amount at your FRA even if you took your own retirement early. Your neighbor might be thinking of a different situation. Though I would suggest the OP verify her husband had enough work credits for her to qualify for survivor benefits. Since he passed at 44, it's likely he did, but worth confirming when she calls.
0 coins
James Johnson
When I applied for benefits last year, I found it MUCH better to make an appointment. The online system doesn't handle nuanced situations well, and your strategy definitely qualifies as nuanced. The representatives I met with in person were able to look at all angles of my situation and document everything properly in their system. Also, make sure you bring your husband's death certificate and your marriage certificate to any appointment, even if you think they already have these documents on file. I had to reschedule because I forgot mine, which delayed my benefits by almost a month.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•Thank you for sharing your experience. I was leaning toward making an appointment for exactly the reason you mentioned - I'm worried the online application doesn't allow for noting my future plans. I'll definitely bring all my documentation when I go. Did you have to wait long for an appointment?
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
I did exactly what you're planning to do! Took my retirement at 62 and will switch to my husband's higher survivor benefit when I hit my FRA next year. It's working out great. The only hiccup I had was that I needed to provide proof that we were married for at least 9 months before my husband's passing. The online application didn't prompt me for this, but they sent a letter requesting it later. Delayed things by a few weeks.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•It's so reassuring to hear from someone who's used this exact strategy! We were married for 15 years before my husband passed, so hopefully that documentation is already in their system somewhere. Did you apply online or in person initially? And did you already arrange for how you'll make the switch next year?
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
•I applied online initially, but I've already made an appointment for next year (3 months before my birthday) to process the switch. The rep told me it's best to do the survivor switch in person because the online system isn't really set up for it. Even though they had our marriage cert on file, they still needed me to bring it again for the retirement benefit application, so keep that handy!
0 coins
Mia Green
Make sure you're accounting for the COLA increases when you run your numbers. The survivor benefit will increase with COLA adjustments between now and when you reach FRA, which could make the difference even more significant in your favor. Also, be aware that if you're still working while collecting your reduced retirement benefit before FRA, you'll be subject to the earnings limit ($22,320 in 2025 before your benefits start getting reduced). This earnings limit won't affect you after you reach FRA though.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•That's a great point about the COLA increases - I hadn't factored those in! That will definitely boost the survivor benefit even more by the time I reach 67. I've already retired from my full-time job, but I do some occasional consulting work. I'll make sure to keep my earnings under that limit. Does Social Security automatically track my earnings or do I need to report them somewhere?
0 coins
Mia Green
•Social Security gets earnings information from your tax returns, but the timing can be off. I recommend proactively reporting anticipated earnings to avoid any surprise overpayments. You can estimate your earnings for the year on the SSA website once you have an account set up, or tell them during your application process. Better to be proactive than have to pay back benefits later!
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
sorry for your loss. my husband died to but i got confused about all this and took the survivor benifits right away. now im stuck with lower amount forever they say... wish i had done more reserch like you
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•I'm sorry for your loss as well, and I'm sorry you weren't given better guidance on your options. It's so confusing, and I've been researching this for months. Have you checked if there's any way to modify your benefits now? Maybe talking to a Social Security representative could help - sometimes there are options that aren't obvious.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
One other important tip: when you apply for your retirement benefits, make sure the SSA representative understands you are NOT applying for survivor benefits at this time. There have been cases where people accidentally get processed for both simultaneously. I recommend explicitly stating in writing (in the remarks section of the application) that you are ONLY applying for retirement benefits on your own record, and that you plan to apply for survivor benefits when you reach your FRA at 67. This creates a paper trail of your intentions.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•This is extremely helpful! I would never have thought to specify this in the remarks section. I can see how confusing it might be for them since I am eligible for both types of benefits right now. I'll definitely make this crystal clear in my application and any conversations with SSA.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
This all sounds complicated! Wouldnt it be easier just to take the survivor benifits now? Why wait?
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
•It might be simpler, but it wouldn't maximize her lifetime benefits. By taking her own reduced retirement benefits now and switching to full survivor benefits at FRA, she'll get some income now PLUS the maximum survivor benefit later. If she took survivor benefits now, they would be permanently reduced. In her specific situation (where her husband was the higher earner), this strategy often results in tens of thousands of dollars more over her lifetime. The exact difference depends on benefit amounts and life expectancy, but it's usually significant enough to justify the more complex approach.
0 coins
James Johnson
When you do make the switch at 67, start the process at least 3 months before your birthday. I waited until the month of my FRA to switch strategies, and there was a gap in my payments that created some financial stress. The SSA backdated everything eventually, but I went almost 2 months without any benefits while they processed the change. Just something to plan for.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•Thank you for this practical advice! I'll definitely start the process early. Did you have to complete a whole new application when you made the switch, or was it a simpler process since you were already in their system?
0 coins