Can I collect Social Security disability while already receiving retirement benefits and have AFLAC coverage for knee surgery?
I'm 64 and started collecting my Social Security retirement last year but I'm still working part-time (20 hours/week) at a warehouse. I need to get knee replacement surgery and my doctor says I'll be off work for at least 4 months for recovery. I pay for AFLAC disability insurance through my job, but I'm confused about whether I can also apply for Social Security disability while I'm already collecting retirement benefits? Would this be considered short-term or long-term disability? Has anyone navigated this situation before? I'm trying to figure out my income options during recovery since my retirement benefit alone won't cover all my expenses.
19 comments
Skylar Neal
No, you can't collect Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) if you're already collecting Social Security retirement benefits. They essentially come from the same pot. Once you've started collecting retirement, you can't switch to disability. Your AFLAC policy should provide some coverage during your recovery period though - that's exactly what it's designed for. Check your specific policy for details on how much and how long they'll pay.
0 coins
Brady Clean
•Thanks for the quick answer. That's disappointing but makes sense. Do you know if AFLAC typically covers the full 4 months? I need to dig up my policy details.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
The previous commenter is correct - you can't receive both SSDI and retirement at the same time. However, there's more to consider. If your disability started before your full retirement age (FRA) and you took early retirement, you might have been eligible for higher disability payments instead. But since you're already collecting retirement, that ship has sailed. Regarding AFLAC, carefully read your policy. Some AFLAC policies only cover specific events or have waiting periods. The key is whether you have their short-term disability policy specifically, not just their accident or hospital policies.
0 coins
Brady Clean
•I'm pretty sure I have their short-term disability policy. I think my FRA is 66 and 8 months, so I did take early retirement at 63. Sounds like I missed out on potentially higher payments if I had applied for disability instead?
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
I went thru similiar last year with my hip replacement!!! AFLAC was a LIFESAVER but they only covered me for 12 weeks. Check ur policy!!!! I had the short term disability one. They dont pay much but it helped with bills when i was out.
0 coins
Brady Clean
•Thanks for sharing your experience! 12 weeks would cover most of my recovery time but not all of it. Did you have any issues with the claims process? How quickly did they start sending payments?
0 coins
Norah Quay
I think your mixing up SSA disability with private disability insurance which are TOTALLY different things. Social Security Disability is for ppl who cant work AT ALL for at least 12 months or have a terminal condition. Knee surgery doesnt qualify unless there's major complications. Your AFLAC is short term private insurance and thats what you need to use here. But be warned they might try to deny your claim - they did with my husband's back surgery! Fight it if they do!
0 coins
Brady Clean
•You're right, I was definitely confusing the two types. I didn't realize SSDI was only for long-term or permanent disabilities. Sorry to hear about your husband's claim issues - did you eventually get it approved?
0 coins
Leo McDonald
This is a common confusion, so don't feel bad. To clarify the rules: 1. Once you elect to receive Social Security retirement benefits, you cannot switch to SSDI 2. SSDI requires a disability expected to last at least 12 months or result in death 3. SSDI also has a 5-month waiting period before benefits begin For your 4-month recovery, AFLAC should provide coverage if you have their short-term disability policy. Have you contacted your AFLAC representative directly? They can review your specific policy and explain exactly what you'll receive. Also, check if your employer offers any paid medical leave or if you qualify for state disability benefits, depending on where you live.
0 coins
Brady Clean
•Thanks for breaking it down so clearly. I haven't contacted my AFLAC rep yet - was trying to get clear on all my options first. I'm in Florida, so I don't think we have state disability benefits, but I'll double check.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
I was in a similar situation last year and tried calling SSA directly to ask about this exact scenario. Spent THREE HOURS on hold before getting disconnected. Tried again the next day and same thing happened! Absolutely maddening when you're just trying to plan your finances for a surgery.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
•I had the same problem with the SSA phone lines until I found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com). They get you connected to a real SSA agent usually within 20 minutes instead of waiting for hours. Saved me so much frustration when I was trying to sort out my wife's spousal benefits. They have a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU - it's definitely worth it when you need to get specific answers about your situation.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
One more thing to consider: if your AFLAC policy doesn't cover the full recovery period, you might want to look into whether you've worked long enough to qualify for FMLA job protection (12 weeks) and if you have any paid time off you can use to supplement your income during recovery. Also, some knee replacements now have shorter recovery periods - maybe get a second opinion to see if there are any minimally invasive options that might reduce your time away from work?
0 coins
Brady Clean
•Good suggestion on the FMLA - I believe I qualify since I've been at this job for over 5 years. I hadn't considered a second opinion, but that's smart. I'll ask my primary care doctor if there are specialists who focus on minimally invasive techniques.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
U should talk to your HR dept too!!!! Mine had some kind of salary continuation plan I didnt even know about. Got 60% of my pay for 6 weeks before AFLAC kicked in!!!
0 coins
Brady Clean
•That's a great tip! I'll check with HR tomorrow. I work for a smaller company but maybe they have something similar I don't know about.
0 coins
Norah Quay
The whole system is SO CONFUSING on purpose they want people to give up trying to get benefits they deserve!!!! When I called SSA about my retirement they couldn't even explain my own benefits clearly and gave different answers everytime I called!!!! Good luck with your surgery though knee replacements are much better now than they used to be my uncle was walking in 6 weeks
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
To address your original question from another angle: if you hadn't started collecting retirement benefits yet, and your disability was expected to last 12+ months, applying for SSDI might have made financial sense. SSDI payments are roughly equivalent to your full retirement age benefit, even if you're not at FRA yet. For example, if your full retirement age benefit would be $2,000 at age 67, but you took early retirement at 63 receiving perhaps $1,600, SSDI would have paid closer to the $2,000 amount. For future reference for others reading this thread: it's sometimes advantageous to apply for SSDI rather than taking early retirement if you have a qualifying disability.
0 coins
Brady Clean
•That's really helpful information. I wish I had known this before taking early retirement. My monthly benefit is about $1,750 now, but would have been around $2,200 at my FRA. I'll make sure to share this knowledge with my friends who haven't claimed benefits yet.
0 coins