PA UC appeal 'quashed for monetary determination' - what does this mean for my hearing?
I'm totally confused and hoping someone can explain what's happening with my unemployment appeal. I was let go from my job at a warehouse back in January and my former employer is claiming misconduct (which isn't true - they were downsizing but didn't want to pay unemployment). I filed for benefits, got denied, and then filed an appeal. My in-person hearing is scheduled for this Tuesday, and I've been preparing my defense all weekend. But now I just checked my PA UC portal and there's an email saying my "appeal was quashed for monetary determination" - what the heck does that mean? Is my hearing canceled? Do I still need to show up on Tuesday? I've never heard the term "quashed" before and I have no idea what a "monetary determination" has to do with my wrongful termination appeal. I tried calling but of course got the busy signal over and over. Anyone deal with something like this before? I'm stressing out because I really need these benefits and don't want to miss my chance to prove my case.
22 comments


Chloe Anderson
sounds like good news actually! pretty sure quashed means dismissed or canceled. so they canceled the appeal hearing because they're approving u based on monetary eligibility. check ur dashboard for new payment info in next few days
0 coins
Omar Hassan
•Really? That would be amazing if true! But why would they suddenly decide I'm monetarily eligible when the whole issue was about whether I was fired for cause? I'm scared to get my hopes up.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The previous comment is not quite correct. "Quashed for monetary determination" typically means there was an issue with your monetary eligibility that needs to be resolved before they can proceed with the appeal about your separation reason. There are two main types of eligibility in PA UC: monetary (did you earn enough in your base year) and non-monetary (reason for separation). It sounds like they discovered a monetary issue that needs to be addressed first, as monetary eligibility must be established before they review separation issues. You should still call to confirm whether your hearing is canceled or not. Don't assume anything when it comes to appeals.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
•This happened to me in 2023!!! They found some issue with my wages that had to be fixed before they would even look at why I got fired. Took them WEEKS to sort it out and I had to submit all kinds of extra paystubs. SO FRUSTRATING!!!
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
i think u should still go to the hearing just in case. better safe than sorry right?
0 coins
Sean Doyle
PA UC Appeal Referee here. "Quashed" is a legal term meaning the appeal has been dismissed or set aside. When an appeal is "quashed for monetary determination," it means one of two things: 1. The UC office discovered you don't meet the monetary eligibility requirements (haven't earned enough in your base year), making the separation issue moot for now. 2. They discovered an error in your monetary determination that needs to be corrected before proceeding with separation issues. You should be receiving official documentation via mail explaining the specific reason and next steps. Your Tuesday hearing is almost certainly canceled, but you should still attempt to call to confirm. The appeal system and claims system sometimes don't communicate efficiently. If you disagree with the monetary determination, you can file a separate appeal specifically addressing the monetary issues once you receive the formal notice.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
•Thank you for explaining this! I just checked my mail and found a letter saying they need to recalculate my base year wages because my former employer reported different amounts than what I claimed. Looks like I need to submit my W-2 and some paystubs. So frustrating that this is happening at the last minute!
0 coins
Zara Rashid
When i had my appeal last year they did the EXACT SAME THING the day before my hearing!! Turns out my employer reported my wages wrong on purpose to try to mess up my claim. Make sure you have ALL your paystubs ready to go because they're gonna ask for them. Good luck with PA UC - the whole system is designed to trip people up IMO.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•same thing with me they "lost" my w2 information twice 🙄 almost like theyre trying to make it hard on purpose...
0 coins
Omar Hassan
UPDATE: I just got through to someone! The appeal referee was right - they found a discrepancy in my reported wages. My employer claimed I only worked there for 5 months when I was actually there for 9 months. Now I have to submit all my paystubs to prove my correct wages. The hearing is officially postponed until they resolve the monetary determination. Thanks everyone for the help!
0 coins
Diego Vargas
•Glad you got an answer! Make sure you submit those paystubs ASAP. They'll need to recalculate your financial eligibility based on your base year (the first 4 of the last 5 completed calendar quarters before you applied). Once that's done, they'll reschedule your hearing about the separation issue. Keep checking your dashboard and mail for updates.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
To answer your follow-up question: Once they have your paystubs, the monetary redetermination typically takes 2-3 weeks. You won't need to file a new appeal for the separation issue - they'll automatically reschedule your hearing once the monetary eligibility is established. Just keep an eye on both your online portal and your mail for the new hearing date. Make sure your address is current in the system!
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
•2-3 weeks??? thats crazy long when bills are due now 😫
0 coins
Sean Doyle
One more tip: When you submit your paystubs, include a cover letter that clearly lists your employment dates and weekly/monthly wages. Calculate the total base year wages yourself. This makes it easier for the examiner to verify your information and can speed up the process. Also, keep a copy of everything you submit for your records.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
•That's excellent advice - thank you! I'll definitely put together a clear summary of my wages. Should I include a copy of the W-2 as well, or just the paystubs?
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Yes, absolutely include your W-2 along with the paystubs. The more official documentation you can provide, the better. If you filed your taxes already, including a copy of your tax return (or at least the relevant pages showing your income) can also be helpful.
0 coins
Luca Romano
If you're having trouble getting specific answers about your claim status after submitting your documents, I'd recommend checking out claimyr.com to get through to PA UC directly. I used it when I had a similar wage dispute last year and it saved me weeks of waiting. Their system connects you to an actual PA UC agent so you can get real answers instead of guessing what's happening with your claim.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
•Thanks for the suggestion! If I can't get through after submitting my documents, I'll definitely look into it. Right now I'm just focusing on getting all my paystubs and documentation together.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Just wanted to add that you should also keep detailed records of when you submit everything and how you submit it (mail, fax, online upload). I learned the hard way that PA UC sometimes "loses" documents, so having proof of submission dates can be crucial if there are any delays. Also, if you're mailing documents, use certified mail with return receipt - it's worth the extra cost for the peace of mind. Good luck with getting this sorted out!
0 coins
Harper Hill
•This is such great advice! I've heard horror stories about documents getting "lost" in the system. I'm definitely going to use certified mail and keep copies of everything. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's really helpful to know what to expect going into this process.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
As someone who went through a similar wage discrepancy issue with PA UC last year, I wanted to share a few additional tips that helped speed up my process. First, when you organize your paystubs, put them in chronological order and highlight the gross pay amounts - this makes it easier for the examiner to quickly verify your earnings. Second, if you have any employment verification letters or hire/termination letters from HR, include those too as they help establish your exact employment dates. Finally, don't be surprised if they ask for additional documentation even after you submit everything - I had to provide bank deposit records showing my direct deposits matched my paystubs. It's frustrating but hang in there - once they get the monetary determination straightened out, your separation appeal will get back on track. The whole process took about 3 weeks for me from submission to new hearing date.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
•This is incredibly helpful - thank you for taking the time to share all these detailed tips! I hadn't thought about highlighting the gross pay amounts or getting employment verification letters from HR. I'm going to call my former employer's HR department tomorrow to see if they can provide documentation of my actual start and end dates. The bank deposit records tip is especially useful since I do have all my direct deposit records saved. It's reassuring to hear that even though your process took 3 weeks, you did get your hearing rescheduled. I'm trying to stay patient but it's hard when you're waiting for benefits you really need.
0 coins