< Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

Can I quit a new job after 1 week and still claim PA UC benefits?

I just started a new job last Monday after being on unemployment for about 2 months. The pay seemed decent and the interview went well, but after my first week, I can tell this place is a nightmare. The manager is constantly yelling at everyone, they changed my schedule three times already, and the job duties are completely different from what was described. I'm honestly thinking about not going back on Monday. If I quit, will PA UC cut off my benefits? My original claim still has like 4 months left on it. Can I just explain that the job wasn't as described? Has anyone been through something similar? I'm really stressed about this!

BE CAREFUL!! PA unemployment will consider this voluntarily quitting without good cause and you'll lose ALL your benefits. They don't care if the job sucks, they expect you to stick it out. I quit a job after 2 weeks last year because they lied about pay and hours, and UC denied my continued claim even though I explained everything. Had to appeal and STILL lost.

0 coins

Oh no, that's exactly what I was afraid of! Did you try explaining that the job wasn't as described during your interview? I feel like that should count as good cause.

0 coins

The previous response isn't entirely accurate. PA UC does recognize certain situations as "good cause" for voluntary quit. If the job misrepresented the working conditions, hours, duties, or pay during hiring, you may be able to continue receiving benefits. You need to document exactly how the job differs from what was promised during the interview process. Save any job listings, emails, or texts that describe the original position. When you file your weekly certification, you'll need to report that you're no longer working and provide the details when prompted.

0 coins

this happened to my brother last year lol. he got a warehouse job but when he showed up they had him doing delivery driving with his own car & no gas money??? he quit after 3 days and still got his benefits when he explained it to uc

0 coins

You need to carefully document everything that's different from what was promised. PA unemployment requires you to show "good cause" for quitting, and material misrepresentation of job duties can qualify. Here's what I'd recommend: 1. Write down specifically what was promised vs. reality (hours, duties, pay, conditions) 2. If possible, try to address concerns with your employer first (they'll ask if you tried to resolve it) 3. When you quit, do it in writing and clearly state the reasons 4. File your weekly claim and honestly report that you're no longer working 5. Be prepared to provide detailed information about why you quit The UC examiner will likely contact both you and the employer to get statements before making a determination.

0 coins

Thank you for the detailed advice! I think I can definitely document the schedule changes since they sent them by text. I'm going to try talking to the manager tomorrow, but honestly I doubt anything will change based on how they treat everyone.

0 coins

jus saying itll take FOREVER to get thru to unemployment if u need to explain ur situation to them!! i had an issue last month and tried calling for TWO WEEKS straight and got nuthin but busy signals the whole time. finally got thru last friday but had to call like 57 times in a row

0 coins

I had the same problem trying to reach someone about my open issue. Ended up using this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a rep in about 20 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. They have a video demo showing how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2. Saved me so much time and frustration, especially when dealing with a complicated situation like quitting a job.

0 coins

I WENT THROUGH THIS EXACT SCENARIO IN JANUARY!!! Got hired at what seemed like a great retail position, but my first week they had me doing inventory in a freezing warehouse with no heat and I caught pneumonia! I documented everything, took pictures of the warehouse, saved texts about schedule changes, and got a doctor's note. When I quit and explained to UC, they initially denied my continued claim, but I appealed with all my evidence and WON! The key is evidence, evidence, evidence! Don't just quit - build your case first!

0 coins

That's really encouraging to hear! Did you have to go through a whole appeal hearing or did they reverse the decision before that?

0 coins

I had to go through a phone hearing with a referee. It was about 20 minutes long where they asked me questions about why I quit and what evidence I had. My former employer didn't even show up for the call. Got the decision about 10 days later saying I had good cause to quit and my benefits were reinstated with backpay!

0 coins

You got LUCKY. Most people lose these appeals. I had tons of evidence too and still lost because the referee said I "should have tried harder to resolve the issues with management" before quitting. It's a huge gamble with your benefits.

0 coins

To summarize for the original poster: 1. You CAN potentially keep your UC benefits if you quit, but only with documented good cause 2. Material differences between job as described and actual conditions can qualify as good cause 3. You must attempt to resolve issues with employer first if possible 4. Document everything thoroughly 5. Be prepared for a possible initial denial and appeal process 6. Continue filing your weekly claims during this process Each case is evaluated individually, and success depends on your specific circumstances and documentation.

0 coins

Thank you everyone for the advice! I'm going to document everything tomorrow and try talking to the manager about the issues. If nothing improves, I'll quit in writing with specific reasons and make sure to keep filing my weekly claims. Really appreciate all the help - this situation has been so stressful.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,684 users helped today