< Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

Anastasia Romanov

Will taking a job with 15-day probation period jeopardize my PA UC benefits if it doesn't work out?

Hey everyone, need some quick advice about PA unemployment benefits. After 9 months at my manufacturing job, I got let go due to 'restructuring' in July. Been collecting UC benefits since then while job hunting like crazy. Yesterday I got a weird job offer that's making me nervous about my benefits. A recruiter emailed me last week about an administrative position, ran a background check, and today just offered me the job WITHOUT an interview! The position has a 15-day probation/training period and starts this Thursday. Pay is decent ($22/hr) - better than my UC payments for sure. My concern: If I take this job and either I quit during probation or they let me go after the 15 days, will I lose my current UC benefits? I can't afford any more benefit disruptions! Already had an issue where PA UC claimed an 'overpayment' of $780 because I visited my sister in Ohio for a weekend (they said I was 'unavailable for work' those days). Had to pay it all back before getting more payments! Has anyone taken a short-term or probationary job while on PA unemployment? What happened to your benefits afterward? I'm so stressed about this - I need income but can't risk losing my UC safety net if this sketchy job falls through. Thanks!

StellarSurfer

•

You should be okay taking the job. According to PA UC rules, if you accept suitable work and it doesn't work out through no fault of your own (like if they terminate you during probation), you can resume your previous claim as long as you're still in the same benefit year. Just make sure you report the work and earnings for the weeks you do work. The key phrase here is "through no fault of your own" - so if they let you go during/after probation because it's not a good fit, you're generally fine. If you quit without good cause, that could potentially disqualify you.

0 coins

Thank you! Do you know if I need to file a new claim or can I just restart my existing claim if things don't work out? And should I call UC to let them know I'm starting this job, or just report it on my weekly certifications?

0 coins

Sean Kelly

•

just take the job n see how it goes lol. better to have a job then be on uc anyway. if it doesntt work out just apply again. thats what I did

0 coins

Zara Malik

•

That's terrible advice. It's not always that simple to "just apply again." The PA UC system is extremely finicky and they can deny you for all kinds of reasons if you don't handle things correctly.

0 coins

Luca Greco

•

I was in a nearly identical situation in January. Got laid off from sales job after 5 years, was on UC for a few months, then took a job with a 30-day probation period. The new company let me go after 20 days saying I "wasn't catching on fast enough." Here's what you need to know: 1) You must report that you've found work on your weekly certification 2) You don't file a new claim when the job ends - you reopen your existing claim 3) When reopening, you'll need to explain why the job ended 4) Keep documentation of everything! Save the offer letter showing the probation period 5) If they let you go, request something in writing about why In my case, I was able to resume my previous claim without issues. They even automatically calculated the remaining balance and benefit weeks correctly. Just be 100% accurate with your dates of employment and earnings when you reopen. One thing though - that job offer does sound a bit suspicious. No interview at all? Just be careful it's not some kind of scam.

0 coins

Thank you SO much for this detailed info - especially from someone who went through it! This makes me feel better. I'll definitely keep all documentation and be super careful about reporting everything correctly. And yeah, the no-interview thing is weird, but I checked out the company and they seem legitimate (physical office, LinkedIn presence, etc). Still, I'll proceed with caution.

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

NEVER TRUST THE PA UC SYSTEM!!! I did EXACTLY what you're thinking about doing last year and it was a COMPLETE NIGHTMARE!!! Took a job with a 3-week training period, got let go because the company had "overhired" (their words, not mine), and then PA UC denied my reopened claim saying I didn't earn enough at the new job to qualify for a new claim BUT also said I couldn't go back to my old claim!!! Was without ANY income for 7 WEEKS while fighting with them!!! The system is BROKEN and they will use ANY excuse to deny benefits! That "overpayment" situation you mentioned is EXACTLY the kind of garbage they pull!!! They're looking for ANY reason to not pay you!!!

0 coins

I understand your frustration, but your situation sounds different. If you were let go because of "overhiring," that's clearly not your fault and should qualify for continued benefits. Did you appeal their decision? The rules are pretty clear that if you're still in the same benefit year, you should be able to reopen your claim if the job doesn't work out through no fault of your own.

0 coins

Aisha Hussain

•

Anyone else noticing how impossible it is to actually reach someone at PA UC to get answers to questions like this? I've been trying for TWO WEEKS to talk to someone about my claim issues. All I get is busy signals or that automated message saying they're experiencing high call volume. I've called literally 60+ times on some days and can never get through. So frustrating when you need actual answers from a human being!

0 coins

I had the same problem until I found Claimyr. It's a service that basically waits on hold with the PA UC office for you and calls you when they get a representative on the line. Saved me hours of frustration. They have a video that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2 I was skeptical at first, but it worked perfectly when I needed to resolve an open issue on my claim last month. You can check them out at claimyr.com - so much better than dealing with those endless busy signals.

0 coins

Zara Malik

•

One thing nobody's mentioned yet - make sure this job isn't paying you as a 1099 contractor during the "probationary period." I've seen companies try this trick where they bring you on as a "contractor" for the first few weeks, then transition you to W-2 if they like you. This matters because if you're categorized as self-employed (1099) rather than an employee (W-2), it can complicate your unemployment situation if the job ends. PA UC has different rules for how they handle self-employment income versus regular employment.

0 coins

I didn't even think about this! Just double-checked the offer letter and it does say W-2 employment from day one, thankfully. But really good point to watch out for.

0 coins

Sean Kelly

•

my cousin took job last mnth and got fired after 2 weeks, got his benifits back no problem just had to do the weekly filing thing again and say he got laid off

0 coins

Luca Greco

•

One more thing to be aware of - when you restart your claim after the job ends (if it does), there can sometimes be a 1-2 week processing delay before payments resume. Make sure you have some emergency funds set aside if possible to cover that gap. Also, continue filing your weekly certifications without interruption if the job ends. Report your last day of work accurately, and report any earnings for that week. The system will automatically adjust your benefit amount for the week based on your earnings. Finally, if your claim gets flagged for any reason when you reopen it, and you can't resolve it through the online portal, calling first thing Monday morning (right when they open at 8am) is usually the best time to get through to a representative.

0 coins

This is super helpful information! I'll make sure to keep filing without any gaps if the job doesn't work out. And good tip about calling early Monday morning - I'll remember that if I run into issues.

0 coins

when I moved from philly to pittsburgh last year I had a whole thing with unemployment where they kept saying I wasn't looking for work even though I was applying to like 5 jobs a week and eventually I just gave up fighting with them and took a job at target that I hated and paid way less than my old job just because dealing with PA UC was so stressful lol anyway this doesn't really answer your question but just wanted to say I feel your pain with how annoying the system is!! good luck!!

0 coins

StellarSurfer

•

To answer your follow-up question: You don't need to call UC specifically to tell them you're starting a job. Just report it accurately on your weekly certification. When you answer "Yes" to the question about whether you worked or earned wages, you'll be prompted to enter the employer information and your earnings for that week. If the job doesn't work out, you'll need to reopen your existing claim (not file a new one). You can do this online through your PA UC dashboard. There will be questions about why the job ended - be honest and straightforward. If they terminated you during the probationary period, that should be considered "not your fault" and your previous claim should continue. Just remember that any earnings will need to be reported for the weeks you work, and those earnings may reduce or eliminate your benefit payment for those specific weeks, depending on how much you earn.

0 coins

Thank you for this clarity! That makes the process much clearer. I'm going to accept the offer and hope for the best, but at least now I understand how to handle the UC situation regardless of the outcome.

0 coins

Ella Cofer

•

Just wanted to add one more consideration that might be helpful - since you mentioned this offer came without an interview and seems a bit rushed, make sure you get everything in writing before you start. Get a clear job description, the exact probation period terms, and what the evaluation criteria are for the probation period. Also, document your first day of work carefully because PA UC will want exact dates when you report your employment. Take a photo of your first paycheck stub too - it'll have your start date and employer info that UC might ask for later. I know the offer seems sketchy, but $22/hr is definitely better than UC payments, and from what others have shared here, it sounds like you should be able to resume your benefits if things don't work out. The fact that you're being proactive about understanding the rules puts you in a much better position than most people. Good luck with whatever you decide!

0 coins

This is really solid advice! I hadn't thought about getting the evaluation criteria in writing, but that's smart - especially if they do let me go, having clear documentation of what they expected during probation could help if UC asks questions. And yes, definitely taking photos of everything for my records. Thanks for the encouragement too - this whole situation has been so stressful but everyone's advice here is making me feel more confident about moving forward!

0 coins

Mikayla Brown

•

I've been through something similar! Last fall I took a temp-to-perm position that had a 3-week trial period while I was on UC. The job ended up being a disaster (they had me doing completely different work than advertised), and I was let go after 2 weeks. Here's what I learned: Keep ALL your paperwork from this job offer - the email from the recruiter, any offer letter, documentation about the 15-day probation period, everything. When I reopened my claim, PA UC asked for specific details about why the job ended and having that documentation made the process much smoother. Also, when you report your work on the weekly certification, be super precise with your dates and earnings. I made the mistake of estimating my hours the first week and it caused a flag on my account that took forever to resolve. One last thing - trust your gut about this job seeming sketchy. Even if it doesn't work out, at least you'll have tried, and based on what others are saying here, you should be able to get back on your original claim. The fact that you're asking these questions ahead of time shows you're being smart about it. Most people just wing it and end up in trouble later!

0 coins

Miguel Harvey

•

This is exactly the kind of detailed advice I was hoping to get! Thank you for sharing your experience. I'll definitely keep everything documented - already started a folder with the recruiter emails and I'll make sure to get any formal offer paperwork too. Good point about being precise with dates and earnings on the weekly certifications - I can see how even small mistakes could cause big headaches with the system. It's reassuring to hear from someone who actually went through this process successfully, even when the job didn't work out. I think I'm going to go ahead and take the position, but now I feel much more prepared to handle things correctly regardless of how it goes!

0 coins

Pennsylvania Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today