Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

Caesar Grant

PA UC benefits and turning down job offers with much lower salaries - will I be disqualified?

Hi everyone, I'm in a bit of a dilemma with my PA unemployment situation. I lost my job about 10 days ago and just filed my initial UC claim (still under review). I've started job hunting but I'm noticing a concerning trend - many positions in my field are advertising salaries WAY below what I was making, and many job postings don't list compensation at all. My big worry is: If I get an interview and receive a job offer that pays significantly less than my previous salary, what happens with my UC benefits if I turn it down? Will PA UC consider this refusing suitable work and disqualify me? I'm hesitant to even apply for positions without salary info because I'm afraid of getting caught in this trap. I can manage financially for a few weeks, but not long-term without either a properly paying job OR my unemployment benefits. Does anyone know what Pennsylvania considers a "suitable" salary offer relative to previous income? Is there a percentage threshold where I can decline without penalty?

This is actually a good question that many people don't think about until they're in that situation. PA UC has guidelines about what constitutes "suitable work" that you can refuse without losing benefits. In the first several weeks of your claim, you generally have more flexibility to turn down jobs that pay significantly less than your previous position. The rule of thumb is that during the first 13 weeks, you can decline jobs that pay less than 80% of your previous wage without penalty. After that initial period, the threshold drops to around 70% of your previous wage. Make sure you document everything if you do decline an offer - the salary offered, job duties, and why it wasn't suitable compared to your previous position. PA UC may request this information if the employer reports that you turned down work.

0 coins

Thank you SO much for this information! That 80% guideline is super helpful. Do you know if I need to specifically tell UC about offers I've declined, or only if they ask? And would I include this on my weekly certification somehow?

0 coins

im in the same boat! got laid off from a $32/hr job and seeing postings for $19-22/hr with same requirements. its depressing and i dont understand how they expect ppl to survive on these wages with inflation the way it is!!! dont even get me started on the rent prices rn

0 coins

The market is totally screwed right now. I'm seeing the same thing in my industry too. Companies are trying to hire skilled workers at 2018 salary levels while everything costs 30% more. Then they complain about "labor shortages" when nobody wants the job. 🙄 The system is rigged against us. Good luck out there.

0 coins

You need to report any job offers you decline on your bi-weekly certification. There's a specific question that asks if you refused any work - you MUST answer honestly or you could face fraud charges later. When you answer yes, you'll get a questionnaire to explain why you declined. But here's where you need to be careful: UC might still investigate even if the salary was below that 80% threshold. They might consider other factors like commute distance, your skills, the job duties, etc. It's not just about salary. I had a friend who declined a job that paid 75% of her previous salary, but UC initially denied her benefits anyway because the position was in her field. She had to appeal and eventually won, but it was stressful and her payments were delayed for weeks while it got sorted out.

0 coins

That's really concerning. So even if I'm within that 80% guideline, they might still disqualify me? I definitely don't want to commit fraud, but the thought of having my benefits suddenly cut off is terrifying. How detailed do I need to be when explaining why I declined a job offer?

0 coins

Honestly the whole system is a mess!!! My brother got his bennies cut last year becuz he turned down a job that woulda been a 90 min commute EACH WAY. They said he refused suitable work even tho he wouldve spent like $300/month on gas!!! PA unemployment dosent care about us, they just want us off the rolls asap. Be careful what u apply for is all im saying

0 coins

Yep happened to me too but with salary instead of commute. They expected me to take a job paying $16/hr when I was making $28/hr before. How am I supposed to pay my mortgage with that??? The appeal process took FOREVER and I almost lost my house waiting.

0 coins

If your really worried about this, I would suggest applying mainly for jobs that match your previous salary range for the first few weeks. No point creating problems for yourself! Once your past the 13 week mark when the suitable work requirements get stricter, then u can broaden your search. Thats what I did during my unemployment period last year and it worked out fine. Just my 2 cents!

0 coins

That's a smart approach! I'll focus my applications on positions that are closer to my previous salary range for now. Hopefully something comes through in the next few weeks anyway.

0 coins

While everyone's giving you advice on how to handle job offers, don't forget that your claim is still under review right now. That's a whole different issue that might need your attention. If you get stuck with an "open issue" status or can't get through to someone about your claim, check out Claimyr (claimyr.com). They connect you directly to a UC agent instead of waiting through busy signals for days. Saved me 3 weeks of stress when my claim had verification issues. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2 As for your original question - document EVERYTHING if you turn down a job. Save emails with the salary offer, write down who you spoke with, when, and what was discussed. You'll need this if they challenge your benefits.

0 coins

I second the Claimyr recommendation! Used it last month when my claim was stuck for no reason and got through to a real person in minutes after trying for days on my own. And yeah, DOCUMENT EVERYTHING with any job offers - screenshots, emails, names, dates. PA UC will want all of it if they investigate.

0 coins

To answer your follow-up question: You must report any rejected job offers on your weekly certification. When it asks if you refused any work, select "Yes" and then you'll be prompted to provide details. Be specific about: - The exact salary offered and how it compares to your previous wage (calculate the percentage) - Your previous job title and the offered job title - Any significant differences in job duties or required skills - Any other factors (shift hours, commute distance, etc.) After you report this, a UC examiner may contact you for more information. They might also contact the employer. As long as you're within that 80% guideline for the first 13 weeks and you have documentation to back it up, you should be okay - but be prepared for some potential delays while they review your case.

0 coins

what if the employer offers u something verbaly different than whats in the writtten offer? happened to my cousin where they said one salary on phone but offer letter was way lower!!! how do u prove that??

0 coins

One more thing to consider - when you're applying for jobs, make sure you're completing the required number of work search activities each week (2 per week for PA UC). Even if you're being selective about where you apply based on salary, you still need to meet this requirement. You can use job interviews, submitting applications, attending job fairs, etc. Just make sure you're documenting everything properly for your weekly certification. The last thing you want is to get disqualified for not meeting the work search requirements while you're trying to be strategic about the salary issue.

0 coins

Yes, I've been keeping track of my work search activities in a spreadsheet with all the details they ask for. I'm definitely doing more than the minimum 2 per week, so that shouldn't be an issue. Thanks for the reminder though!

0 coins

Just wanted to add my experience from when I was unemployed in PA last year - I actually called the UC office directly to ask about this exact situation before I started declining offers. The representative told me that as long as the offer is below 80% of my previous wage in the first 13 weeks, I could decline without penalty. BUT she also emphasized that I needed to keep detailed records of every offer and why I declined it. What really helped me was creating a simple spreadsheet tracking: company name, position title, salary offered, percentage of my previous wage, date of offer, and reason for declining. When UC did follow up about one declined offer (the employer must have reported it), I had everything organized and ready to send them. My benefits weren't interrupted at all. Also - don't let the horror stories scare you too much. Yes, some people have issues, but if you follow the guidelines and document properly, you should be fine. The key is being proactive and honest about everything.

0 coins

Pennsylvania Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure