NY unemployment denied me after waiting 3 months - now facing eviction with family
Just got the dreaded determination letter from unemployment after waiting for almost 3 months. They're saying I'm not eligible for benefits. No explanation, just a flat denial. I've been counting on this money since I lost my job in February when our company downsized. Rent is already 45 days past due, and my landlord won't wait any longer. My wife, our 5-year-old daughter and I are probably going to have to look into family shelters next week if something doesn't change. I've been applying everywhere but the job market is terrible right now. Called the unemployment office over 20 times and never got through to anyone who could help. What are my options? Can I appeal this? Anyone else been through this nightmare?
40 comments
Yara Assad
Definitely appeal!!!! You have 30 days from the date on the determination letter. Don't wait - do it right away and make copies of EVERYTHING you submit. Sometimes they deny people for stupid reasons and an appeal fixes it. I got denied for "voluntarily quitting" when I was actually laid off, appealed with proof and won.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
Thanks, I'm definitely going to appeal. Did you have to wait long for the appeal to go through? My biggest concern is how to survive until then.
0 coins
1M
Yara Assad
My appeal took about 6 weeks. Not fast, but faster than the initial claim. In the meantime, call 211 for emergency rent assistance. Some counties have programs for exactly your situation.
0 coins
28d
Olivia Clark
Not to be a downer but my appeal took 4 MONTHS. the system is totally broken. try to get thru to an actual person on the phone, that's what finally fixed it for me.
0 coins
27d
Write a comment...
Javier Morales
After 6 weeks of calling and getting nowhere, I used a service called claimyr.com and got a callback with an actual agent within an hour. It was the best money I've ever spent - the agent fixed my issue right away and my payments started flowing. Totally saved me from getting evicted. Check out this video too: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Natasha Petrov
wait is this for real?? sounds too good to be true honestly 🤔
0 coins
1M
Javier Morales
100% real. I was desperate after trying for weeks. The service just keeps calling for you and then connects you when they get a human. Saved me days of waiting on hold.
0 coins
27d
Connor O'Brien
another miracle solution that probably doesnt work... these pop up all the time since the pandemic
0 coins
25d
Javier Morales
I get the skepticism, I was too. But it actually worked. I talked to an agent who fixed my backpay issue. Got $4800 deposited two days later after waiting 8 weeks with nothing.
0 coins
25d
Amina Diallo
I just tried this claimyr thing and got through in like 45 minutes after trying for WEEKS on my own. Maybe there's hope after all 😭
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
GamerGirl99
Same thing happnd to me last year. Appeal it ASAP. Dont throw away the letter. Do it online. Also contact your state senator/assembly person - they can sometimes intervene. Worth a shot.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Hiroshi Nakamura
Have you checked eligibility requirements? There are a bunch of reasons they can deny you: - Not enough work history in your base period - Fired for misconduct - Not available for work - Not enough income in previous quarters - Didn't register for work search Knowing exactly why they denied you is key to a successful appeal. You can call and ask for specifics - but good luck getting through. I had to call 72 times before connecting to someone who could actually explain my issue.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
The letter just says "not eligible based on information provided" - super vague. I worked full-time for 3 years before being laid off and have been documenting all my job searches.
0 coins
1M
Hiroshi Nakamura
That's weird. Sounds like they might have messed up. Could be they think you quit or something. Definitely appeal and clearly state you were laid off due to downsizing. Include any layoff documentation from your employer if you have it.
0 coins
27d
Write a comment...
Isabella Costa
The ny unemployment system is TRASH 🗑️ I've been fighting with them since January. You absolutely need to talk to a live agent but GOOD LUCK with that. I spent HOURS on hold every day for weeks!!! Try calling right when they open at 8am, sometimes that works.
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
Try 7:55am and be ready to dial. I got through that way after days of trying. Also try the call back feature if they offer it to you.
0 coins
1M
Isabella Costa
I tried that trick too but it's hit or miss. Some days the system is just down or overwhelmed. It's almost like they don't WANT to help us 🙄
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Freya Andersen
Apply for emergency assistance programs ASAP while appealing: 1. Contact your county Department of Social Services about emergency housing assistance 2. Apply for SNAP benefits if you haven't already 3. Call 211 to find local charities and orgs that provide rental assistance 4. Check with local churches - many have emergency funds 5. Contact local tenant advocacy groups who might help with your landlord Whatever you do, DON'T wait until you're actually evicted to start looking for help. The system is broken, but there are resources. I went through similar hell last summer and eventually got everything sorted, but only because I was aggressive about finding help. Also, you absolutely need to talk to a live person at unemployment. Regular calling rarely works - I finally got through using claimyr.com after weeks of trying. It's a service that gets you connected to an agent without the hours on hold. The agent I spoke with immediately saw the error in my file and fixed it. Worth every penny since I got thousands in back benefits.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
Thank you for this detailed advice. I'm going to try 211 today. I hadn't heard about claimyr before but at this point I'll try anything.
0 coins
26d
Eduardo Silva
211 helped me get $1200 emergency rent assistance last year. Definitely worth calling them!
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Leila Haddad
im so tired of seeing these posts. the system is broken by DESIGN. they know exactly what theyre doing making it impossible to get through and denying people for no reason! they WANT you to give up!
0 coins
Write a comment...
Emma Johnson
OP: immediately contact your state assembly person and senator. do not delay. I know this sounds weird but their office has special contacts at unemployment. My cousin works for a state rep and helped multiple people fix unemployment issues that were "impossible" to fix through normal channels 👀
0 coins
Ravi Patel
YES THIS!!! My assemblyperson's office fixed my unemployment issue in 48 hours after I spent 2 months getting nowhere. They have direct lines to the decision makers.
0 coins
25d
Paolo Bianchi
I didn't even think of this. Going to look up my rep right now. Thank you!
0 coins
25d
Astrid Bergström
Make sure you give them all your info - claim ID, SSN (last 4 digits), full contact details, and a clear explanation of what happened. The more info you provide upfront, the faster they can help.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
PixelPrincess
Not to be that guy but check if ur application had errors. I got denied bcuz I accidentally put the wrong last day of work (was off by ONE day) and they used that as reason to deny me. Had to appeal and wait another 7 weeks 🤦♂️
0 coins
Write a comment...
Omar Farouk
The only way I finally got my unemployment issues fixed was by getting through to an actual human on the phone. After trying for literally weeks (like 30-40 calls per day), I found this service called claimyr.com that connected me with an agent. Expensive but worth it - agent fixed my issue in 10 minutes and my backpay came through 3 days later.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
How does that even work? They just call for you?
0 coins
27d
Omar Farouk
Yeah basically they use some system to keep calling and navigate the phone tree, then when they actually get a human on the line, they call you and connect you. Saved me from spending another month on hold. My benefits got unlocked right away after I talked to someone.
0 coins
25d
Diego Fernández
sounds like another scam targeting desperate people. does it actually work?
0 coins
25d
Omar Farouk
Not a scam - I used it and it worked exactly as advertised. Got connected to an agent who helped me. I was skeptical too but it was either that or keep calling myself for weeks.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Anastasia Kuznetsov
Look into whether you qualify for the ERAP program (Emergency Rental Assistance) - it can cover up to 12 months of back rent and 3 months future rent in some cases. Saved my family when we were in a similar situation with unemployment.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Sean Fitzgerald
call your LANDLORD immediately!!! don't just disappear. most landlords would rather work something out than have you go to a shelter. my landlord let me do a payment plan when I was 2 months behind.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
We've been talking with them for weeks. They've been patient so far but they're also struggling financially and need the rent. Can't blame them honestly.
0 coins
25d
Sean Fitzgerald
Ask if they'd accept partial payment for now while you sort things out. Also, in NY there are some strong eviction protections - they can't just kick you out without going through the courts. That process takes time.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Zara Khan
Does the letter give ANY reason at all? Even a code or section number? Look that up online. Sometimes its something simple you can fix by uploading a document or making a phone call to clarify something.
0 coins
Paolo Bianchi
There's a reference to Section 590.10 but no specific explanation beyond that.
0 coins
25d
Zara Khan
That section is about insufficient work history/wages in your base period. Did you work all 4 quarters before applying? If you started your job less than 18 months ago, that could be the issue.
0 coins
25d
Paolo Bianchi
I worked at the same place for over 3 years before the layoff, so that definitely shouldn't be the issue. Must be a mistake.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
MoonlightSonata
This is why I hate the ny unemployment system so much. They deny people for no reason hoping they wont appeal, and make it IMPOSSIBLE to talk to anyone. It's cruel and designed to prevent people from getting benefits they deserve. 😡
0 coins
Write a comment...