Got monetary determination letter but confusing wording about ny unemployment eligibility?
Just received my monetary benefit determination letter yesterday showing I would get $423 weekly. However, there's this confusing statement on there saying 'This is not a decision on your eligibility for Unemployment Insurance benefits. This notice tells you what employment and wage information we have on file for you in the State of New York.' I'm totally puzzled now. Does this mean I'm approved or not? Will I start getting payments soon or is there another step? Has anyone else gone through this and eventually got approved or denied after getting this notice?
37 comments
Chloe Green
That's actually normal! I got the same letter in August. It's just confirming your wage/employment history and calculating your benefit amount. There's still a separate decision coming about whether you qualify for benefits (like if you quit vs laid off, etc). Mine took about 3 weeks after that letter to get the final decision and start payments.
0 coins
Logan Scott
•Oh thank god! I was freaking out thinking something was wrong. Did you have to do anything else after getting this letter?
0 coins
Chloe Green
•Just keep certifying weekly! Don't miss those or you'll have to backdate later. Also make sure your direct deposit info is correct in the system.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
•This is a big relief to hear cos I got the same letter two weeks ago and was confused af ✌️
0 coins
Harper Hill
I was stuck at this exact step for weeks! Ended up using a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to a real person at unemployment. Talking to an agent got my benefits released within days after sitting in limbo for over a month. Seriously was the only way I could talk to someone instead of endless automated messages. They have a good walkthrough video too: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
•Is this actually real? Sounds too good to be true tbh
0 coins
Harper Hill
•100% worked for me. I was super skeptical too but was desperate after not being able to get through for weeks. My claim moved from pending to paid literally the day after I talked to someone.
0 coins
Avery Flores
•seems like another scam looking to prey on desperate ppl...
0 coins
Harper Hill
•Not a scam at all - they don't ask for any personal info or claim info. They just connect your call to an agent when they reach one. You deal directly with NY unemployment.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
•How long did it take to get someone on the phone with this?
0 coins
Harper Hill
•I got a callback in about 2 hrs. Way better than the days I spent trying to get through myself.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Yes! This is just step 1 - they're saying "based on your work history, this is what you WOULD get IF you're approved" but they still need to verify reason for separation, etc. Keep doing your weekly certifications even while waiting.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
That monetary determination letter is just telling you what your benefit AMOUNT would be based on your past wages. They still have to determine if you're eligible based on the reason you're unemployed. Were you laid off? Fired? Quit? That's what they're deciding next.
0 coins
Logan Scott
•I was laid off due to budget cuts. My employer confirmed this in writing.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
•Then you should be good. Layoffs are pretty straightforward approvals. Just be patient and keep certifying weekly!
0 coins
Aaron Lee
This system is such a mess. I got that letter and then nothing for 6 weeks 😡 had to call daily. ny unemployment needs to get their act together...
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
•same here! the whole system feels designed to make us give up sometimes
0 coins
Michael Adams
Here's my experience after getting that letter: First, yes, this is normal - virtually everyone gets it. It's basically telling you what your weekly benefit rate would be IF you qualify, based on your employment history. What happens next depends on your situation. If your case is straightforward (clear layoff with employer confirmation), you might be approved quickly - within 1-2 weeks. If there are any complications (you quit, were fired, have multiple employers, worked in different states, etc.), it could take much longer. While waiting, you MUST continue to certify weekly even though you're not getting paid yet. When you're finally approved, you'll get backpay for all properly certified weeks. If it takes longer than 3 weeks after this letter, you should start calling. The phone system is absolute hell, so I recommend using claimyr.com - it's the only service that actually got me through to a real person after weeks of trying. One conversation with a live agent resolved my issues and my payments started flowing including all my backpay. Also check your online account regularly - sometimes notices appear there that don't get mailed. Don't lose hope - the process is frustrating but persistence eventually pays off!
0 coins
Natalie Wang
•This is super helpful. Thank you for laying it all out so clearly!
0 coins
Logan Scott
•Thanks for the detailed breakdown! Did they eventually send you another letter with the final decision or did it just start paying?
0 coins
Michael Adams
•For me, I got an email notification that there was a new message in my online account. When I logged in, there was a message saying I was approved, and the payment hit my account 2 days later.
0 coins
Noah Torres
everybody gets this letter, don't stress. it's just telling u how much you'll get IF ur approved. Keep an eye on your online account for updates and make sure u do the weekly certifications
0 coins
Samantha Hall
The entire NY unemployment system runs on confusion and anxiety 🤦♀️ That letter is normal but expect to wait another 2-8 weeks for an actual decision lol
0 coins
Ryan Young
•2-8 weeks??? omg I can't wait that long, my rent is due
0 coins
Samantha Hall
•I know, it's brutal. Try calling if you're in a desperate situation - they can sometimes expedite for hardship cases.
0 coins
Ryan Young
•I tried calling like 50 times and can never get through!
0 coins
Sophia Clark
•Try claimyr.com - I was in the same situation and it was the only way I finally got someone on the phone.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Yep, got the same notice in September. It took another 3 weeks before I got the final approval. They're backlogged AF right now.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Got the same letter last month, ended up getting approved but took forever. Pro tip: if u need $ fast and cant wait for them to decide, look into emergency assistance thru HRA or local charities. Some can help w rent while ur waiting
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Catholic Charities helped me with a month's rent while waiting on unemployment. Def worth checking out.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Totally normal but KEEP CERTIFYING weekly! I've seen so many people mess this up and then they have to go through a whole backdate request process 🤦♂️
0 coins
Logan Scott
•Thanks for the tip. I've been certifying even though I'm not getting paid yet. Good to know I'm doing something right!
0 coins
Emily Parker
that letter is the equivalent of them saying "IF we approve you, this is what you'll get" but they still need to decide if ur eligible based on why u lost ur job
0 coins
Ezra Collins
whatever you do, DON'T STOP CERTIFYING while you wait for approval! biggest mistake people make
0 coins
Victoria Scott
I just went thru this whole process. That letter is normal, but what they don't tell you is that somebody still has to manually review your case. Some lucky ppl get approved automatically but most of us end up in this weird limbo where we're technically "pending" for weeks or months. I couldn't get anyone on the phone until I used claimyr.com - totally worth it to finally get a human who could actually fix my issues.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
•how long were you pending before you called?
0 coins
Victoria Scott
•Almost 6 weeks of pure stress! Was down to my last few hundred $ when I finally got through.
0 coins