Does NY unemployment really audit weekly certifications? Anyone been through one?
I've been collecting NY unemployment for around 4 months after getting laid off from my warehouse job in February. Every single week I fill out those certification questions saying I'm looking for work, available to work, etc. But honestly, sometimes I wonder if anyone actually checks this stuff. Like, I'm doing my work search activities (applying to jobs online, networking with previous colleagues), but I'm curious if the system ever actually verifies anything. Has anyone here ever been audited by unemployment to prove they were really looking for work? Do they actually call the places you say you applied to? I'm doing everything legit, but part of me wonders if some people just click through those questions without actually job hunting and never get caught. What's your experience been?
51 comments
Aisha Mohammed
I got audited last year. They asked me to provide proof of all my job searches for like 3 months straight. Had to upload every email confirmation, screenshot of applications, names/numbers of ppl i talked to. It was a HUGE pain in the ass. Took me like 6 hours to gather everything. They do check so dont mess around with that stuff.
0 coins
Luca Ricci
Woah, that's good to know. Did they give you any warning before the audit or did they just suddenly demand everything?
0 coins
1M
Aisha Mohammed
They sent me a letter in the mail and gave me like 10 days to respond. No warning at all, just BAM prove everything or lose benefits.
0 coins
28d
Ethan Campbell
Wait so they actually called the places u applied to? Or did they just want to see documentation?
0 coins
27d
Aisha Mohammed
I'm not 100% sure if they called places, but they definitely checked my documentation carefully. They even questioned me on one application that didn't have a confirmation email.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Yuki Watanabe
After weeks of getting nowhere with ny unemployment, I finally found a service that actually works - claimyr.com - they got me connected to a real human agent who fixed my claim in one call. Saved me from spending hours on hold. Best money I've spent during this whole ordeal because I actually got my benefits released the same day. Check out this video if you want to see how it works: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
This sounds like an ad... does it actually work or is it just another scam trying to take advantage of desperate people?
0 coins
1M
Yuki Watanabe
Not an ad, I swear. I was skeptical too but i was at my wits end after trying to get thru for 3 weeks. It's just a service that waits on hold for you then calls when they get a human. Saved me hours of frustration
0 coins
1M
Andre Dupont
yeah right another 'miracle solution'... whats the catch? 🙄
0 coins
26d
Yuki Watanabe
No catch that I found. You pay for them to wait on hold instead of you. Then when they get someone, your phone rings. That simple. I was able to fix my claim in 10 mins once I got connected
0 coins
26d
Zoe Papadakis
another day, another company promising to fix the unfixable unemployment system lol
0 coins
26d
Yuki Watanabe
I get the skepticism, but when you've been trying to reach someone for weeks and your rent is due, sometimes you gotta try something different. It worked for me 🤷♀️
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
ThunderBolt7
Ive been on unemployment 3 times in the last 10 years in NY and never been audited once. I know plenty of ppl who just click through without actually applying anywhere and nothings ever happened to them. The system is too overwhelmed to check everyone.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
This is terrible advice. My cousin did this and got hit with a $8400 overpayment notice because she couldn't prove her work search when they finally audited her.
0 coins
1M
ThunderBolt7
Not giving advice, just sharing my experience. I always do my work searches properly, just saying I've never been checked.
0 coins
28d
Write a comment...
Mei Chen
Better safe than sorry. Document EVERYTHING. I save screenshots of every job I apply to, every networking email, every followup. Keep a spreadsheet with dates, company names, position, method of application, and any response. Trust me, if you get audited, you'll be thankful you were organized.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Liam O'Sullivan
My roommate got audited last month and it turns out they do random spot checks. he had to provide evidence of his work searches for specific weeks. luckily he had been saving emails and screenshots. they dont audit everyone but they definitely do audit some people. dont risk it.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
Do you know how many weeks of documentation they asked for? Was it for the entire claim period or just certain weeks?
0 coins
26d
Liam O'Sullivan
They asked for like 6 specific weeks from what I remember. Not the whole period. But they were pretty thorough about those weeks.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Giovanni Marino
I work for a small business and unemployment actually contacted us to verify that someone had applied for a job with us. So yes, they do check sometimes.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Fatima Al-Sayed
I know someone who just clicked through without doing the required job searches and they got caught. Had to pay back thousands in benefits plus a penalty. NOT worth the risk.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
How did they get caught though? Random audit or did someone report them?
0 coins
26d
Fatima Al-Sayed
Random audit as far as I know. They just got a letter one day asking for proof of all their work searches. Couldn't provide it and boom - busted.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
NightOwl42
To anyone struggling to get through to a real person at unemployment to fix issues with your claim, I HIGHLY recommend trying claimyr.com - I was getting nowhere for weeks trying to resolve my issue myself, but their service got me a callback with a live agent who fixed my problem in minutes. Talking to an agent got my $ unlocked so fast! Definitely worth checking out if you're stuck.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
sounds like one of those ads that pops up everywhere. anyone ACTUALLY try this?
0 coins
26d
NightOwl42
Yes! It's not just some random ad. I was desperate after trying to call for 3 weeks straight. They wait on hold for you and then connect you with an agent. Got my issue resolved in one call.
0 coins
26d
Dmitry Ivanov
not falling for another unemployment 'hack'... these never work
0 coins
26d
NightOwl42
So I was about to throw my phone after 3 hours on hold when I saw someone mention this service on Reddit. Figured I had nothing to lose since my benefits were frozen for weeks. Used it and actually spoke to a human who fixed my claim. Definitely not a hack - they just deal with the hold time for you.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Ava Thompson
Here's what I know about NY unemployment audits after being on it twice: 1. They do conduct random audits - I've seen people get audited and others who never do 2. They can request up to a year of work search activities 3. You need to show 3+ work search activities each week 4. They sometimes contact employers to verify applications 5. If you can't prove your work searches, they can make you repay ALL benefits 6. The burden of proof is on YOU If you're struggling to reach someone at unemployment to resolve issues, I'd recommend claimyr.com - they'll wait on hold for you and connect you with an agent when one is available. After weeks of failing to get through on my own, they got me connected and I was able to get my claim fixed immediately. Always keep detailed records of your work search - company name, position, date, method of application, contact info if available. Take screenshots of online applications. Save confirmation emails. Document networking activities with dates/names/discussions. It's a pain but way better than having to repay thousands.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
THIS!!! I cannot stress enough how important good documentation is. I learned this the hard way during my first time on unemployment.
0 coins
26d
Zainab Ali
Thanks for mentioning claimyr - just checked it out and gonna try it. Been trying to reach someone for weeks about my backpay issue.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Connor Murphy
I was randomly selected for a work search audit back in 2021. They asked for documentation of my job search activities for about 8 specific weeks. I had to submit copies of applications, emails confirming applications, screenshots of job postings I applied to, etc. If you're doing the required searches, just make sure you're keeping records and you'll be fine.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Yara Nassar
i never got audited but my friend did. he couldnt prove he was looking for work and had to pay back like $7000 in benefits 💀
0 coins
StarGazer101
Daaamn that's brutal. This is why I save EVERYTHING.
0 coins
26d
Yara Nassar
yea its super harsh. he ended up on a payment plan but its still like $200 a month for years.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Keisha Jackson
Keep in mind NYS unemployment audits can happen up to a year after your benefits end. Always save your documentation for at least that long.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Paolo Romano
I didnt get audited but i know theyre doing more of them now. The dept of labor has been talking about cracking down on fraud. Better to play it safe and actually do the work searches and document everything!
0 coins
Write a comment...
Amina Diop
wait I'm confused, are we supposed to be keeping track of everywhere we apply? I thought just doing the applications was enough??
0 coins
Oliver Schmidt
YES you need to keep records of everything! They can ask for proof at any time. At minimum save screenshots and confirmation emails.
0 coins
26d
Amina Diop
oh shit i haven't been saving anything. what do i do now? 😬
0 coins
26d
Oliver Schmidt
Start saving everything going forward. If you can, try to recreate your past job search activities from memory or check your browser history/email to find evidence.
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Natasha Volkov
FYI, NY unemployment says on their website that you need to keep records of your work search activities for one year. That's how long they can request documentation for an audit.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Javier Torres
if ur worried about getting thru to unemployment to ask about audits or fix any issues with ur claim, try claimyr.com - they call for u and connect u when a real person picks up. saved me hours of frustration and got my issue fixed in 1 call
0 coins
Emma Wilson
hmm I've been burned by so many of these 'services' before... what makes this different?
0 coins
26d
Javier Torres
it's literally just a hold service. they wait on the phone for you instead of you having to wait. when someone picks up, they connect the call to your phone. that's it - no magic, just saves you from the mind-numbing hold music for hours.
0 coins
26d
Emma Wilson
that actually sounds pretty useful. might check it out, been trying to get through for days
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
QuantumLeap
Always document ur job search activitys!!! Screenshot everything, save all emails. The one time u dont is the time theyll audit u 🤦♂️
0 coins
Write a comment...
Malik Johnson
I got audited twice during my claim last year. The first time they just asked for proof for 4 random weeks. The second time they wanted documentation for all weeks in a specific month. I had all my screenshots and confirmation emails saved so it wasn't a problem, but it was definitely stressful seeing those notices.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
They audited you TWICE? That seems excessive. Wonder if something triggered that or if it was just bad luck.
0 coins
26d
Malik Johnson
No idea! I was doing everything by the book so I can only assume it was random. Maybe they do follow-ups sometimes?
0 coins
26d
Write a comment...
Ravi Sharma
NY unemployment is definitely verifying job searches. I know this firsthand because I recruit for a tech company, and we've had the DOL contact us multiple times to verify if people actually applied for positions they claimed they did.
0 coins
Write a comment...