Just wanted to share my experience - I was on unemployment from Nov 2022 until March 2023. I had taxes taken out of every payment. When I did my taxes (early filer here), I definitely had to report the unemployment income and pay taxes on it. Your brother might be thinking of the special exemption they had during covid, but that's been gone for a while now.

Just to add some clarity here - I work as a tax preparer and can confirm that unemployment benefits are absolutely taxable for 2023. The COVID-era exemption (which was up to $10,200 for 2020 only) is long gone. NY takes out 10% federal withholding plus state taxes. You can opt out of withholding in your online account, but I STRONGLY advise against it unless you're setting aside money yourself. I've seen too many clients get hit with massive tax bills they couldn't afford. Better to have it taken out now and potentially get a small refund than owe thousands later. Also, if you're having trouble reaching DOL by phone, there are legitimate callback services that can help - just make sure you're using reputable ones.

Just file already! The longer you wait the more money you're losing. I've been through this process three times unfortunately and the biggest mistake is always waiting too long to file thinking you'll find work right away.

Don't stress too much about the timing - you haven't missed your chance! I went through this exact situation last year when I was laid off from my retail job. The 30-day thing your friend mentioned isn't accurate for NYS. You can file up to a year after becoming unemployed, but like others said, you only get benefits going forward from when you file. I waited about 6 weeks and kicked myself for not filing sooner. The application process on my.ny.gov is pretty straightforward - just have your employment history ready and your last employer's info. The hardest part is actually getting through to speak with someone if you need help, but the initial filing can be done online. File this week and you'll start getting benefits soon!

Just wanted to add that even if your employer claims misconduct, you should still file for benefits right away. Don't let their accusation stop you from applying. NYS Department of Labor will investigate and make their own determination based on the facts, not just what your employer says.

I went through something similar last year when I was fired from my retail job. My employer claimed misconduct but NYS Department of Labor approved my benefits after reviewing the facts. The key thing to remember is that misconduct has to be willful and work-related - being late due to circumstances beyond your control (like train delays) usually doesn't qualify. When you have your interview, be honest about what happened and explain that you had no control over the transportation issues. Also mention that you weren't given any warnings or progressive discipline. Document everything you can about the train delays from those specific dates if possible. Don't give up if they initially deny it - the appeal process exists for situations exactly like yours.

Just applied for mine yesterday for the same reason (seasonal retail). The online application asks if you expect to return to the same employer and when. I put my expected return date as March 2025. Pretty sure this helps with the job search stuff but won't know for sure until I get my determination letter.

I went through this exact same process two years ago when I was doing seasonal work at a ski resort. One thing I'd add is to keep documentation from your employer about the expected return date - like an email or letter stating when they plan to bring you back. NYS DOL sometimes requests this as proof that it's truly a temporary layoff. Also, even on standby status, you'll still need to certify weekly that you're able and available to work. The good news is seasonal layoffs are super common and the system is set up to handle them pretty smoothly once you get the initial application done.

why tf do we even need this ID.me garbage?? the normal verification system worked fine before. this is just adding unnecessary steps to an already broken system. ny unemployment just making things worse 🤡

Just went through this exact same thing last week! What finally worked for me was using a different device entirely. I kept getting stuck in loops on my laptop, but when I switched to my tablet and used the Chrome browser, everything went smoothly. Also make sure you're not using any VPN or ad blockers - those seemed to mess with the verification process. The whole thing is super frustrating but once you get through it, your payments should start up again within a few days. Hang in there!