


Ask the community...
wait so if employers pay for unemployment insurance, why do some people act like unemployed people are freeloaders? they literally paid into this system through their work
This is such an important distinction to understand! I work in HR and I see this confusion all the time. Another way to think about it: when you look at your paystub, you'll see Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA) being deducted from YOUR paycheck - that's what funds Social Security. But you won't see unemployment insurance deductions from your pay because that's paid entirely by your employer as a separate business expense. NYS Department of Labor gets funding from these employer contributions, not from Social Security. So you're absolutely not touching your retirement benefits by collecting unemployment - you're using a benefit that was already paid for on your behalf while you were working.
If they determine it's an overpayment, make sure to request a financial hardship reduction in the recoupment rate if you need it. You'll need to provide documentation showing your expenses and income, but they can reduce the percentage they take out each week if repaying at the standard rate would cause severe financial hardship. This request needs to be made promptly after receiving the determination notice.
I went through something similar a few months ago. They kept my claim active and took out about 22% each week until the overpayment was cleared. The whole process took about 8 weeks for me since I owed around $1200. One tip - when you get the official determination letter, read it very carefully because it will tell you exactly how much they're taking out each week and for how long. You can also call and ask them to spread it out over more weeks if the current rate would cause real hardship, though you'd end up paying back over a longer period. The important thing is that your current claim should stay active as long as you keep certifying properly.
Hey Samantha! You're definitely not too late - NY gives you a full year from your layoff date to file, so you still have until October to apply. I went through something similar last year and the stress is real, but you haven't missed your window! File online at labor.ny.gov as soon as you can. You'll need your Social Security number, driver's license, and employment info from your last job (dates, employer contact info, reason for separation). While you can't get benefits for the weeks you didn't file, getting started now will help with those bills going forward. The weekly benefit amount is based on your past wages, so even starting late you should still get a decent amount. Don't let the regret about waiting stop you from getting help now - just focus on moving forward and getting that claim filed today if possible!
This is such great advice! I'm in a similar boat - lost my job in November and kept putting off filing because I was embarrassed about being unemployed. Reading everyone's responses here really helped me realize I need to stop procrastinating and just do it. Going to file my claim right after I finish reading this thread. Thanks for breaking down exactly what documents are needed too, that makes it feel way less overwhelming.
I was in almost the exact same situation as you! Got laid off in September and waited until December to file because I kept thinking I'd find something soon. The regret about those missed months was eating at me, but honestly once I got my first unemployment payment it was such a relief to finally have some income coming in. The online application at labor.ny.gov is pretty straightforward - took me about 20 minutes. Make sure you have your last employer's info handy and be prepared to do weekly certifications every Sunday. Also, start keeping a log of your job search activities right away because they require proof that you're actively looking. I used a simple spreadsheet with company names, positions applied for, and dates. The weekly benefit really does help with bills even if it's not your full salary. Don't wait any longer - file today!
The weekly certification is actually pretty simple once you get used to it! It's just a few yes/no questions about whether you worked that week, if you were able and available for work, and if you looked for jobs. The system walks you through it step by step. The hardest part for me was remembering to do it every Sunday - I set a phone reminder because if you miss a week you have to call to get it straightened out and that's a huge hassle. You've got this! The first one might feel a bit nerve-wracking but after that it becomes routine.
The weekly certification is actually pretty easy once you get used to it! It's just a few basic questions each week - did you work, did you look for work, are you able and available, etc. Takes maybe 5 minutes. The most important thing is to be consistent about doing it every week and keep good records of your job search activities. I made the mistake of not tracking my applications properly at first and had to scramble to recreate my search log when they asked for it. But honestly, the relief of having that weekly payment coming in makes it all worth it. You've got this - don't let the regret about waiting hold you back from getting the help you need now!
just curious what was your appeal about? i might need to file one too but not sure if its worth the hassle
I went through this exact same situation about 8 months ago. My appeal decision took 6 weeks after the hearing, which sounds pretty typical based on what others are saying here. I know the waiting is incredibly stressful when you're running out of money - I had to borrow from family just to get by during that period. One thing that helped me was calling my local assembly member's office. They have constituent services that can sometimes help expedite things or at least get you a real status update. Also make sure you're checking your online account regularly since sometimes the decision shows up there before the mail arrives. Stay strong, most appeals do get resolved eventually!
Miguel Ortiz
my cousin said in some states they give more than 26 weeks automatically but NY is strict about it... I think Massachusttes gives like 30 weeks or something? but NY is always exactly 26 unless theres some special extension program happening
0 coins
NebulaKnight
•That's correct. Massachusetts does provide up to 30 weeks of regular UI benefits in comparison to New York's 26 weeks. Each state sets its own maximum duration for benefits, with most states offering 26 weeks. During economic downturns, additional federal programs might be activated, but these are separate from the regular state UI system.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Welcome to the unemployment system! I went through this exact same confusion when I first got approved. The $16,250 maximum is indeed your total pot of money for the benefit year, and yes, it typically lasts 26 weeks at your $625 weekly rate. A few things I wish someone had told me when I started: 1. Download the NY DOL mobile app - it makes checking your balance and certifying much easier than the website 2. Keep detailed records of every job application, interview, and work search activity. They can audit your work search requirements at any time 3. Set up direct deposit if you haven't already - paper checks can get delayed 4. If you do any freelance or part-time work, report it honestly. The penalties for not reporting income are severe The good news is that NY's weekly benefit amount is pretty decent compared to other states. The bad news is that 26 weeks goes by faster than you think. Start networking and applying aggressively from day one - don't wait until you're close to exhausting benefits. Good luck with your job search!
0 coins