


Ask the community...
Good luck! These hearings are stressful but totally winnable if you have your documentation together.
I just went through this process a few months ago and won my case! Here's what really helped me: 1) Practice explaining your case out loud beforehand - you'll be nervous and it helps to have rehearsed your key points. 2) Have a simple outline written down with your main arguments and the order you want to present them. 3) When they ask about the "misconduct," focus on the specific policy they claim you violated and whether you actually received proper training or warning about it. 4) Most importantly for retaliation cases - be very clear about the exact dates. When did you file the safety complaint vs when did disciplinary actions start? That timeline gap is crucial evidence. The hearing officers are actually pretty fair in my experience, they just want to understand what really happened.
This is incredibly helpful advice, thank you! I'm definitely going to practice explaining my case out loud - you're right that nerves will probably make me stumble over my words. Quick question about the timeline: my safety complaint was filed on March 15th and they started giving me "performance issues" write-ups starting March 22nd, then terminated me April 3rd. Does that one week gap seem like strong evidence of retaliation? Also, did you have a lawyer or represent yourself?
Just wanted to give an update - my PayPal deposit came through this morning around 8:30am! So it was about 14 hours later than my usual Chime timing, but not too bad for the first payment to a new account. Thanks everyone for the reassurance and info, this thread was super helpful when I was stressing yesterday. For anyone else switching to PayPal, seems like Tuesday morning is pretty common based on what people shared here.
That's great to hear! I'm actually considering switching from my regular bank to PayPal for unemployment deposits since Tuesday mornings sound way more predictable than the random Wednesday/Thursday timing I get now. Did you notice if PayPal sends you a notification right when it hits your account?
I've been using PayPal for NY unemployment for about 6 months now and it's pretty consistent. Usually get mine between 6-8am on Tuesday mornings, but like others mentioned, the first deposit to a new account can be delayed. PayPal seems to do some extra verification on the first government deposit which can add 12-24 hours. After that it should settle into a regular pattern. One tip - make sure your PayPal account is fully verified (bank account linked, identity confirmed, etc.) before the deposit comes through, otherwise they might hold it longer for security reasons.
Really good point about the verification! I learned this the hard way when I first started using PayPal for direct deposits from my employer - they held my first payment for 3 days until I completed identity verification. Definitely get all that sorted before your deposit is supposed to come through. Also, just to add - I've noticed PayPal's deposit timing can vary slightly during holiday weeks or if there are banking delays, but it's still more predictable than most traditional banks I've used for unemployment.
Thanks for the detailed info about PayPal verification! I'm actually thinking of switching from Chime myself since I keep seeing people say PayPal is more reliable. Quick question - do you know if PayPal charges any fees for receiving unemployment deposits? I know some prepaid cards do but wasn't sure about PayPal.
Just want to add that if you're in a job training program through Workforce Development, some of those programs might have their own requirements, but that's separate from your basic UI eligibility. The NYS Department of Labor website has info about job search requirements but I don't remember seeing anything about drug testing there.
Thanks everyone for the helpful responses! I was really worried about this since I've heard so many conflicting stories. It's good to know that NYS Department of Labor doesn't require drug testing for regular unemployment benefits. I was laid off due to company downsizing, so it sounds like I should be fine to file my claim without worrying about any testing requirements. Really appreciate the clarification about it only being an issue if you were fired for failing a workplace drug test - that definitely doesn't apply to my situation.
Glad this thread helped clear things up for you! Layoffs due to company downsizing are pretty straightforward cases - you should definitely be eligible for benefits without any drug testing concerns. Just make sure you have all your employment documentation ready when you file. The process can be a bit overwhelming at first but it sounds like you're in a good position to get approved. Good luck with your claim!
I'm currently dealing with this exact same issue! Changed my bank info from Chase to Ally Bank 9 days ago and my payment shows "paid" but hasn't arrived anywhere. Reading through everyone's experiences here is honestly such a relief - I was starting to think my claim was somehow messed up or that I'd lost the money completely. It's absolutely ridiculous that NYSDOL doesn't give any warning about verification delays or explain that payments might switch to paper checks during this process. I've been checking both my old and new accounts multiple times a day and obsessively checking my mailbox. Based on what everyone's sharing, it sounds like this 1-3 week limbo period is unfortunately normal. I'm definitely going to try the Claimyr service if nothing shows up by early next week. Thank you all for sharing your stories and solutions - this community is way more helpful than anything on the official NYSDOL website!
You're definitely not alone in this frustrating situation! I went through something very similar about 6 months ago when I switched from Wells Fargo to a local credit union. Like you, I was checking my accounts constantly and getting more stressed each day. What really helped me was keeping a detailed log of dates - when I made the change, when payments showed as "paid," etc. This made it easier when I finally got through to an agent to explain the timeline. Also, don't forget to keep certifying for your weekly benefits even while this banking mess sorts itself out - that was something I almost missed because I was so focused on the payment issue. The Claimyr service really does seem to be the best way to actually reach a human based on everyone's experiences here. Hang in there!
I'm going through this exact same nightmare right now! Changed my direct deposit from Wells Fargo to Credit Union about 6 days ago and my payment shows "paid" but is nowhere to be found. I've been losing sleep over this because I have rent due next week. Reading through everyone's experiences here is honestly the first time I've felt any relief - I had no idea this verification limbo period was so common! The NYSDOL website gives zero indication that this could happen when you change banks. I've called probably 15 times and can't get past the automated system. Definitely going to try that Claimyr service everyone mentioned. Thank you all for sharing your stories - it's so frustrating that we have to rely on community forums to understand what's actually happening with our benefits instead of getting clear information from the state!
I completely understand that stress about rent! I went through this exact same situation about 3 months ago when I switched from Bank of America to my local credit union. Like you, I had no idea this verification limbo was even a thing until I found threads like this one. The anxiety of not knowing where your money went is terrible. What really helped me was documenting everything - screenshots of the "paid" status, dates, etc. When I finally got through via Claimyr (which really does work!), having all that info ready made the call go much smoother. The agent was able to see immediately that my payment was stuck in verification and released it same day. Also check your mail religiously - sometimes they default to paper checks during this period without telling you. You're going to get through this! The money isn't lost, it's just trapped in their slow verification system.
Lucy Taylor
I'm in the same boat and it's incredibly frustrating! I've been dealing with a similar issue for about 2 weeks now. One thing I discovered is that you can try using the "Contact Us" form on the NYS DOL website - it's buried in the menu but sometimes they actually respond to written inquiries faster than phone calls. Also, I heard that some people have had luck calling the technical support line instead of the main unemployment line when it's specifically a website/certification error. The number is different and sometimes has shorter wait times. Has anyone else tried that approach?
0 coins
Miguel Silva
•That's a great tip about the technical support line! I didn't even know there was a separate number for website issues. Do you happen to have that technical support number handy? I'm definitely going to try that since my problem seems to be specifically with the online certification system rather than my actual claim status. The "Contact Us" form idea is smart too - I'll give that a shot while I'm waiting to get through by phone. Thanks for sharing what's worked for you so far!
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
Have you tried contacting your local state senator's office in addition to your assembly member? I had a nightmare situation with my unemployment benefits last year where I couldn't get through for over a month. My state senator's office has a constituent services department that actually reached out directly to the Department of Labor on my behalf. They were able to get my case reviewed and resolved within a week. You can find your representatives on the NY State Senate website by entering your zip code. Also, make sure you have your Social Security number, claim confirmation number, and any reference numbers from error messages ready when you do finally get through to someone - it speeds up the process significantly.
0 coins