


Ask the community...
I went through this exact situation about 6 months ago! The contradictory letters are definitely a system glitch - what likely happened is that the automated system processed your childcare reason correctly for the employer notification but somehow triggered a different decision pathway for your personal letter. A few things that helped me get it resolved faster: - When you call, ask to speak specifically to a "Claims Examiner" rather than general customer service - Have your confirmation number from both letters ready when you call - Try calling right when they open (8am) - I had better luck getting through then The good news is that since you have documentation showing you were already approved (the employer letter), this should be a pretty straightforward fix once you get someone on the phone. My case got corrected within 48 hours once I reached the right person, and I received full backpay dating to my original claim date. Definitely keep that hearing appointment though - better to be safe than sorry with the NY DOL system!
This is super helpful advice! I hadn't thought about asking specifically for a Claims Examiner - I was just planning to talk to whoever answered. The 8am calling tip is great too, I'll definitely try that tomorrow morning. It's really reassuring to hear that you got it fixed so quickly once you reached the right person. Did you have to provide any additional documentation beyond the contradictory letters, or was that enough to get it sorted out?
I'm going through something very similar right now! Got my denial letter about 2 weeks ago, but when I called my former employer to ask about their side of things, they mentioned they received a letter saying I was approved for benefits due to "involuntary separation." Meanwhile, my letter says I was denied for the same reason - it makes no sense! I've been trying to get through to someone at DOL for days now. The longest I waited was 4 hours yesterday before getting disconnected. It's so frustrating when you know there's obviously just a computer error but you can't get anyone to fix it. Reading all these responses is actually really helpful though - I had no idea this was such a common problem with their system. I'm definitely going to try that Claimyr service someone mentioned, and I'll make sure to ask for a Claims Examiner specifically when I do get through. Thanks for posting about this! Sometimes it helps just knowing you're not alone in dealing with these system glitches.
Congratulations on getting it sorted out! This is such a perfect example of why the NY unemployment system is so confusing - there are these edge cases that aren't clearly explained on the website. Your situation shows exactly why sometimes you just HAVE to talk to an actual person instead of trying to figure it out online. Really glad that calling service worked for you and thanks for sharing the update. This thread will definitely help other people who find themselves in the same boat!
This whole thread is exactly why I love this community! As someone who just started navigating the NY unemployment system myself, reading through everyone's experiences and advice has been incredibly valuable. It's so frustrating how unclear the official website is about these situations. @33c9af4fbe1c thanks for sharing your update - it gives me hope that there might be solutions even when things seem hopeless. And thanks to everyone who took the time to break down the different scenarios. Bookmarking this thread for future reference!
This is such a helpful thread! I'm in a similar situation where I'm approaching the end of my 26 weeks but still have about 6 months left in my benefit year. Reading through all the responses here, it sounds like the key thing is whether you worked during your benefit year and earned enough to qualify for a new claim. @872b58869e00 your breakdown of the three scenarios is super clear - way better than anything I've found on the official NYSDOL website. And @33c9af4fbe1c congrats on getting it resolved! It's encouraging to hear that the Claimyr service actually works since I've been dreading having to call and wait on hold for hours. One question for anyone who might know - if you do qualify for a new claim within your benefit year, does it reset your 26-week counter or do you still only get whatever weeks were remaining from your original benefit year?
Great question about the 26-week counter! From what I understand (though I'm still pretty new to all this myself), when you file a new claim within your benefit year because you earned enough wages from working, it actually starts a completely NEW benefit year with a fresh 26 weeks of eligibility. So you're not limited to whatever weeks were left from your original claim. However, I'd definitely recommend confirming this with an agent when you call, since everyone's situation can be different. The whole system is so complex with all these different rules and exceptions! @33c9af4fbe1c maybe you could confirm what happened in your case? Did you get a fresh 26 weeks or just the remaining time from your original benefit year? This thread has been such a lifesaver for understanding how this all works. Really hoping my situation works out as smoothly as yours did!
Going through the exact same thing right now! I certified on Wednesday morning and it's Friday evening with absolutely nothing in my payment history. Usually it shows up within a few hours like you said. After reading all these comments, it sounds like there's definitely some kind of system-wide issue happening this week. I'm going to check my message center tomorrow morning and try calling right when they open at 7:30am. If that doesn't work, I might have to bite the bullet and try Claimyr since so many people here are saying it actually works. It's just crazy that we have to pay a service to get through to our own state agency! Really hoping this resolves for all of us soon - the stress of not knowing if your payment is coming when you have bills due is awful. Keep us updated if you hear anything!
I'm in the same exact situation! Certified Wednesday too and still nothing showing up. It's so frustrating when you're depending on that money. I've been reading through all these replies and it seems like there's definitely something going on system-wide this week. Multiple people are reporting the same delays. I'm going to try calling first thing Monday morning and also check my message center like others suggested. If all else fails, might have to look into that Claimyr service everyone keeps mentioning. Really hope this gets sorted out soon for all of us - the uncertainty is the worst part!
I'm experiencing the exact same issue! Certified on Tuesday and it's now Saturday with absolutely nothing showing in my payment history. This is really stressful because I have my electric bill due Monday and was counting on this payment. After reading through everyone's experiences here, it's somewhat reassuring to know this seems to be a widespread problem this week rather than something specific to my account. I'm going to follow the advice here and check my message center first thing Monday morning, then try calling right at 7:30am when they open. If I can't get through after a few attempts, I think I'll have to try that Claimyr service that so many people are recommending - it sounds like it actually works even though it's frustrating we have to pay extra just to reach our own state agency. Thanks to everyone sharing their experiences and solutions, it really helps to know we're not alone in this mess!
I had this same exact question when I filed my claim a couple weeks ago! Everyone's right - it's your Social Security Number. I was also confused by the vague wording "identification number" but that's just how the NY DOL system refers to your SSN. Enter just the 9 digits without any dashes, spaces, or other formatting. The system will accept it and move you to the next step. Don't worry, you're definitely not alone in finding that part of the form confusing!
I just went through this same process last month and can confirm everyone here is correct - it's your Social Security Number! The NY DOL website really should make this clearer since so many people get confused by the "identification number" wording. Just to add one more tip: make sure you have your most recent pay stub handy too, as you'll need information from it in the next few steps of the application. The whole process took me about 20 minutes once I got past that initial confusion. Good luck with your claim!
Emma Wilson
Just make sure you file soon after your job ended. There's usually a waiting period and you don't want to lose out on any weeks of benefits you're entitled to.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
I'm 58 and was in a similar situation a few months ago - lost my part-time retail job and was worried about how my early Social Security would affect unemployment. Like others mentioned, you can definitely receive both! Just wanted to add that when you file your initial claim, they'll ask about all income sources but Social Security won't disqualify you. The key thing is being honest about your work availability - I made it clear I was looking for part-time work that would work with my schedule and had no problems. Good luck Paolo, and don't wait too long to file!
0 coins
Diego Chavez
•Thanks for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same situation. Did you find it difficult to balance the job search requirements with only looking for part-time work? I'm hoping to find something similar to my previous 25 hours/week position but wasn't sure if NYS Department of Labor would consider that "actively seeking employment" or if they expect you to be open to full-time positions too.
0 coins