
New York Unemployment
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I just got approved for unemployment after being laid off from my warehouse job last month. My weekly benefit amount is $387 and I'm really grateful for the help right now. But my coworker who also got laid off keeps telling me that unemployment is just a loan and I'll have to pay it all back eventually. Is this true? Do you have to payback unemployment benefits that NYS Department of Labor gives you? I'm worried about taking money I'll owe later when I'm already struggling with bills.
I'm really nervous about this and can't find a clear answer anywhere. If I start working while collecting unemployment benefits, does NYS Department of Labor automatically know when you start working? Like do they have access to payroll systems or get notified by employers somehow? I'm not trying to commit fraud or anything - I just want to understand how the system works so I can report everything correctly. I've heard conflicting things about whether they can see your employment status in real time or if they only find out when you file your taxes. Can someone explain how this actually works?
just be honest about everything and you'll be fine, the system is set up to catch people who try to cheat but if you report your work they usually just reduce your benefits for that week
Just to add to what others have said - NYS Department of Labor also receives data from the State Directory of New Hires, which employers must report to within 20 days of hiring someone. They also do periodic cross-matches with Social Security Administration records and state tax databases. The bottom line is they have multiple ways to detect unreported work, so transparency is definitely your best policy. When you certify for benefits each week, report ANY work you did during that week, even if it was just a few hours or you haven't been paid yet. It's much better to have your benefits reduced correctly than to face fraud charges later.
I'm really worried because I think I messed up big time. I was getting unemployment benefits for about 6 weeks earlier this year, and during that time I picked up some part-time work at a restaurant. I reported the hours on my weekly claims like I thought I was supposed to, but now I'm getting conflicting information about whether I should have been claiming at all while working. My friend says the NYS Department of Labor considers any work as disqualifying you completely, but that doesn't make sense because they ask about earnings on the weekly claim form. Can someone explain what actually happens if you claim unemployment while working? Am I going to get in trouble for fraud or something?
Wait, I'm confused now. I thought if you worked ANY hours you couldn't claim that week? I've been skipping my weekly claims whenever I pick up shifts at my retail job. Have I been losing money I was entitled to?
I went through something similar and had to learn the hard way that NYS allows part-time work while collecting unemployment - it's actually encouraged! The key things to remember: 1) You must work less than 4 days per week, 2) You must report ALL earnings and hours worked on your weekly claim, and 3) Your benefits get reduced based on a formula, but you don't lose eligibility entirely. I was terrified I'd committed fraud too, but as long as you're honest on your weekly certifications, you're following the rules. The Department of Labor website has a worksheet that shows exactly how they calculate partial benefits - it helped me understand that working part-time wasn't cheating the system, it was exactly what they expect people to do while job searching.
I've been trying to get through to someone at NY unemployment for THREE WEEKS now and I'm about to lose my mind. My benefits suddenly stopped in February with no explanation, and I need to speak with an actual human to figure out what's going on. I've tried calling the main number literally 50+ times, always get the 'high call volume' message and then disconnected. I've tried emailing through the portal but just get automated responses. I've even tried calling right when they open at 8am and still nothing! Does anyone know any tricks or secret numbers to reach a live person at NY unemployment? I'm getting desperate - rent is due next week and I have no idea why my payments stopped.
Congratulations on getting through! This is such a helpful thread - I've been having the same issue with my benefits being suspended after I started part-time work last month. The 8:07am tip with the 1-4-2 sequence is gold. I'm definitely going to try this tomorrow morning. It's so frustrating that the system can't handle part-time work reporting smoothly, but at least now I know what to ask for when I finally get through. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and tips!
This thread has been a goldmine of information! I'm dealing with a similar issue - my benefits were cut off about 2 weeks ago after I started working part-time at a local bookstore. I've been calling constantly with zero luck, just getting that same "high call volume" message every single time. The system is absolutely maddening! I'm really encouraged by all the success stories here, especially the detailed tips from Connor who worked at NYSDOL. The 8:07am timing with the 1-4-2 sequence seems to be the golden ticket based on multiple people's experiences. I love that we have such specific, actionable advice rather than just the usual "keep calling" suggestions you see everywhere else. One thing I want to add for anyone else reading this - I've been keeping a detailed log of every call attempt (time, date, which menu options I tried) and it's been really helpful for my own sanity to see the patterns. Plus I figure it might be useful information if I need to escalate to my assembly member like GalaxyGuardian suggested. Going to set my alarm for 8:05am tomorrow and give the proven method a shot. Will definitely report back with results. Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences - this community support means everything when dealing with such a frustrating system!
Miguel, keeping that detailed call log is such a smart idea! I wish I had thought of that when I was going through this nightmare a few months ago. It would have been really helpful to track patterns and also have documentation if I needed to escalate things further. The bookstore part-time work situation sounds very similar to what several others here have dealt with - it seems like any kind of part-time employment change triggers these system flags. Based on what Connor explained about wage discrepancy reviews, you'll probably want to have your pay stubs and work schedule ready when you call, especially if your hours vary week to week. I'm rooting for your 8:05am attempt tomorrow! The fact that this 8:07am / 1-4-2 method has worked for multiple people in this thread gives me so much confidence that there's actually a reliable way to break through the system. Make sure you have your NY.gov ID and claim information handy too - from what others have shared, the reps can work pretty quickly once you're connected if you have everything ready. Good luck and please do update us with how it goes!
Hi everyone, I'm super confused about my NY unemployment status. Yesterday I received an email from NYSDOL saying "your claim can now be paid" but I'm not sure if that means I'm actually approved? I've been waiting for 3 weeks since I filed. The email doesn't explicitly say "approved" anywhere. Does this "can now be paid" message mean I'm good to go? When should I expect to actually see money in my account? Do I need to do something else to trigger payment? First time applying so I'm completely lost.
I just wanted to chime in as someone who went through this exact same confusion about 6 weeks ago! That "claim can now be paid" email is definitely their approval notification - I know the wording is super confusing because it doesn't actually say "approved" anywhere. From reading all these responses, it sounds like you're in great shape! One thing I learned that might help future people reading this thread is that you can actually see more detailed status information if you log into your NY.gov account and look under "Claim Summary" - it will show your claim status as "Active" once you're approved, and you can see your weekly benefit amount there too. Also, don't stress if the first payment seems to take forever - mine took 9 days but after that, weekly payments were super consistent and came like clockwork every Tuesday. The waiting is definitely the hardest part, but sounds like you're doing everything right with the weekly certifications!
This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I just checked my Claim Summary and it does show "Active" status which is so reassuring. I had no idea about that section - the interface isn't very intuitive for first-time users. It's great to know that after the initial wait, the weekly payments become predictable. Tuesday seems to be a common day people mention for receiving payments. I'm on day 5 now since my approval email, so based on everyone's experiences here, I should hopefully see something in the next few days. Really appreciate you taking the time to share those specific details about where to find the status info!
Just went through this exact same situation about 2 weeks ago! That "claim can now be paid" email definitely means you're approved - I know the wording is confusing because they don't just say "approved" directly. Mine took about 8 days to show up in my account after getting that email, so don't panic if it doesn't appear immediately. The key thing is to keep doing your weekly certifications religiously - that's what actually triggers the payments each week. Also, if you selected direct deposit, make sure to check that your bank account and routing numbers are correct in your online profile. A small typo can cause major delays. One more tip: you can check your payment status by logging into your NY.gov account and looking under "Payment History" - it will show as "Pending" until it actually gets sent to your bank. Congrats on getting through the approval process!
Thank you for sharing your experience! It's really reassuring to hear from someone who just went through this. I'm on day 3 since getting that email and was starting to get anxious, but 8 days sounds totally normal based on what everyone is saying. I definitely need to double-check my bank info - that's such a good point about typos causing delays. I just looked at the Payment History section you mentioned and mine shows "Pending" which is exactly what others have said to expect. Really appreciate the reminder about keeping up with weekly certifications - seems like that's the one thing everyone emphasizes as absolutely critical. Thanks for the detailed breakdown!
Lucas Parker
Just to be super clear - you earned these benefits through your work history. Your employer paid unemployment insurance taxes specifically for this purpose. Don't let anyone make you feel guilty about using a system you paid into!
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
Your coworker is definitely wrong - unemployment benefits are not a loan at all! I went through the same situation a few years ago and was worried about the same thing. The benefits are funded by employer contributions to the unemployment insurance system, so you've essentially already "paid" for them through your work history. The only time you'd need to pay anything back is if there was an error (like getting benefits you weren't entitled to), but that's not the normal situation. You're dealing with enough stress from being laid off - don't let misinformation add to your worries. Just focus on your job search and filing your weekly claims correctly.
0 coins